Every Major Wrestling Debut TV Show Ranked From Worst To Best

10. WWE ECW

An undead monstrosity shuffled back to a bastardisation of life, and it was acknowledged by what was either an inspired meta in-joke, or network mandate, in the form of the 'Zombie'.

Advertisement

The Zombie was killed again by the Sandman, who made his entrance to unfamiliar, underwhelming stock music. One of two things happened: WWE told us not to worry about the rumoured SciFi Network intervention, we'll have fun with it, wink, or WWE begrudgingly appeased its new master. Both felt like a compromise, and that's what WWECW felt like from the jump.

The debut wasn't a terrible episode of TV - this version of Kurt Angle, sadistic choke-out artist, had real potential - but it was unshakeably 'wrong'. The fans in the arena reacted with mild enthusiasm; the arena itself was distant and corporate, where the ECW of old was intimate and familial.

The feature-not-a-bug complexion of the old roster did not work in this jarring, unflattering context. It was akin to filtering a ramshackle, incendiary punk act through ProTools. The Extreme Battle Royal main event was a nothing, witless exchange of weapons shots, and really, the only re-watch fascination lies in Paul Heyman's eyes.

He lasted until December, but it was over before it began.

Advertisement