Every WWE Backlash PPV Ranked From Worst To Best
Featuring dream matches, thumbtacks, and one of the biggest run-ins of all time.
Let me preface this list by saying that there has never been a real stinker of a Backlash. Some years have seen a weaker incarnation of the traditional post-'Mania PPV, sure, but there's no SummerSlam 1995 or King of the Ring 1995 equivalent (apparently 1995 was a slog).
Backlash has almost always landed somewhere around the average-to-great range, thanks in part to the natural surge of momentum WWE receives after its annual April bonanza. Over the course of its history, fans have been treated to highly-anticipated rematches, brand new feuds featuring red hot debutants, and all manner of springtime chaos.
If the Road to WrestleMania represents the most predictable part of WWE's calendar year, Backlash could be seen as the very opposite. Nobody's quite sure what to expect in the post-'Mania reshuffle, and SummerSlam is too far off to see many programmes set in stone.
This slightly chaotic position means that Backlash has often provided some of the most exciting shows in recent memory - although naturally, one or two didn't quite hit the mark.
From 1999 to 2009 - as well as last year's impressive return to the yearly schedule - we've ranked each Backlash pay per view from worst to best. Let's hope 2017's show is a worthy addition!
12. Backlash 2003
Of all the Backlash PPVs, 2003's edition is probably the most disappointing. On paper, the dream main event match-up of The Rock and Goldberg seems gigantic - but it didn't really resonate with a crowd unwilling to say goodbye to the Brahma Bull (especially in his Hollywood heel role). Goldberg steamrolled his opponent to the disappointment of many.
Elsewhere on the card, Brock Lesnar and John Cena clashed in a rather disjointed affair, while a messy six man tag involving Triple H, Chris Jericho, Ric Flair, Booker T, Kevin Nash and Shawn Michaels attempted to mash several separate feuds together.
The best match on the card was undoubtedly its opener, a fun tag team affair between Los Guerreros and Team Angle - but nothing else on the show managed to reach the bar it set early on.
11. Backlash 2005
Backlash 2005 was by no means a terrible show, saved by a decent WrestleMania rematch between Triple H and Batista and an intense Last Man Standing bout pitting the dastardly Edge against Chris Benoit. However, the less impressive aspects of the show were pretty rotten indeed.
A jingoistic tag match saw Hulk Hogan and Shawn Michales make comedy jobbers out of Muhammad Hassan and Shawn Daivari, and while the latter certainly shouldn't have gotten any offence in, it served as yet another nail in the coffin for his promising charge.
Elsewhere, Kane and Viscera put on one of the worst PPV matches of the year, while a drawn-out tag team turmoil match showcased Raw's lack of tag team depth. The Heart Throbs were involved, as were Simon Dean and Maven.
'Unspectacular' is probably the appropriate word.
10. Backlash 2002
A common theme on this list is a strong main event, even in most of the weaker shows in Backlash's history. Unfortunately, 2002 bucked this trend in a big way, as Hulk Hogan defeated Triple H to scoop the WWF Undisputed Championship.
The face vs. face encounter was understandably plodding, despite The Game's best efforts, and certainly wasn't helped by the separate interferences of Chris Jericho and The Undertaker.
Further down the card, Austin and 'Taker went almost 30 minutes in a chore of a no. 1 contender's match - ending with a deflating Undertaker win despite Stone Cold's foot being on the ropes.
The show was saved from being arguably the worst in the history of the event by a pair of entertaining undercard bouts: Kurt Angle vs. Edge and Eddie Guerrero vs. Rob Van Dam. Fans also saw the terrifying in-ring debut of Brock Lesnar, who defeated Jeff Hardy by referee stoppage in about five minutes.
9. Backlash 2007
In fairness to Backlash 2007, it made the most of a potentially tricky main event. John Cena, Randy Orton, Edge and Shawn Michaels did battle for the WWE Championship - and while the sight of Cena retaining his title threatened to deflate the Atlanta crowd, it incorporated a satisfyingly creative finish. A desperate Sweet Chin Music sent the champion tumbling onto a prone Orton, where he accidentally retained his belt. A risky booking decision for sure, but one which seemed to pay off.
Unfortunately, the rest of the card was largely a disappointment - particularly the infamous handicap match pitting Umaga, Vince and Shane McMahon against ECW Champion Bobby Lashley. Yes, Vince booked himself to win the belt, a purely inflammatory piece of booking which garnered exactly the wrong type of heat.
The show's longest match saw Undertaker and Batista clash in a Last Man Standing bout - and the pair largely ignored the stipulation. Yes, 10-counts were administered and answered to, but the only unique spot in the match saw both men crash off the stage. The rest could easily have been standard singles affair, and the finish (a draw) didn't satisfy the fans a jot.
8. Backlash 2008
2008 saw a pretty stacked line-up, and all of the big matches delivered to some degree. A big elimination main event saw Triple H outlast Orton, Cena and JBL to win the WWE Championship, while Undertaker and Edge put on an enjoyable rematch of their WrestleMania 24 classic.
Further down the card, HBK defeated Batista with Chris Jericho as special guest referee - a bout which sowed the seeds for Y2J and Michaels' epic feud later on the same year.
Had the rest of the undercard been more impressive, this event would probably find itself much higher on this list - but low points such as Big Show vs. Great Khali and a crowded 12-woman tag match prevented it from picking up any real momentum.
7. Backlash 2009
It's unfair to judge a pay per view based entirely on its main event, but without John Cena and Edge's Last Man Standing war, Backlash 2009 would probably be remembered as one of the worst in event history. Thankfully, the main eventers helped propel it into middle-of-the-road territory.
Their bout was an incredibly intense one, displaying the natural chemistry that the pair shared throughout their rivalry. The ending - which saw Big Show interfere and chokeslam Cena into a spotlight - divides opinion, but it at least helped play into Edge's opportunist persona (as he undeservingly made off with the World Heavyweight Championship).
The undercard, however, was almost entirely disappointing. A very uninspiring six-man tag bout saw Legacy defeat the mish-mash team of Triple H, Batista and Shane McMahon, while the Hardy Boyz were sadly unable to get the best out of an 'I Quit' stipulation laden with potential.
Special mention must be given, however, to Chris Jericho's 12-minute victory over Ricky 'The Dragon' Steamboat - in which the old-timer proved that true class is permanent.
6. Backlash 2006
2006's show benefitted from one of the best main events in the history of Backlash, a well-structured, well-executed triple threat match between John Cena, Triple H and Edge.
On paper, Cena retaining and Triple H laying out everybody seems a finish guaranteed to cause anger - but The Game teased a DX reunion during his post-match antics, putting an exciting cap on an already-dramatic climax to the show.
Shelton Benjamin and Rob Van Dam were the stars of the undercard, displaying their astonishing athleticism in a bout pitting RVD's Money in the Bank contract against Benjamin's Intercontinental Championship.
However, not everything on the show was a success - particularly the controversial tag match pitting Vince and Shane McMahon against the team of Shawn Michaels and 'God'. The less said about that the better (even if the in-ring action was actually quite good...).
5. Backlash 2001
What Backlash 2001 lacked in sheer quality it made up for in variety. One of the most well-balanced pay per views in the event's history saw Austin, Triple H, Kane and Undertaker do battle in a mammoth main event with a number of titles on the line.
That bout certainly divides opinion, many viewing it as drawn-out and lacking in quality, while others argue in favour of its pure Attitude Era chaos.
In the undercard, Angle and Benoit took one another to the limit in an inventive Ultimate Submission match, while Rhyno and Raven revelled in hardcore anarchy.
The event also saw one of Shane McMahon's less-remembered bumps, a leap of faith from the side of the Backlash structure onto a prone Big Show.
It's certainly one of the wilder Backlash PPVs ever, but is thankfully anchored by that Benoit/Angle clash in the middle of the show. Without that, it could well have spiralled out of control.
4. Backlash: In Your House (1999)
Speaking of anarchic Backlash pay per views, the inaugural 1999 event was perhaps the wildest of all.
As with much of WWE's output in that year, it somehow managed to keep itself together enough to deliver a compelling show - but always seemed to be on the brink of disaster. The main event (Austin vs. Rock under a No Holds Barred stipulation) was undiluted Attitude Era madness at its best, and knocked spots off their more famous WrestleMania XV encounter.
A hefty undercard saw Undertaker defeat Ken Shamrock in a very unique encounter (give it a chance), while Al Snow and Hardcore Holly went 15 minutes in a surprisingly entertaining Hardcore Championship clash.
Of course, the best-remembered moment of the show came after the final bell, as Undertaker hilariously abducted Stephanie McMahon by posing as her limousine driver.
Car crash wrestling? Yes. Entertaining? Absolutely.
3. Backlash 2016
Backlash made a triumphant return to WWE's pay per view calendar after seven years on the shelf, giving SmackDown the immediate edge in the renewed brand war.
The show is best remembered for AJ Styles capturing the WWE Championship, a previously unthinkable occurrence until his amazing January debut and consistently stellar performances.
The undercard was full of similarly significant moments. Becky Lynch became the inaugural SmackDown Women's Champion, last eliminating Carmella, while popular underdogs Heath Slater and Rhyno won the tag titles to a raucous reception.
The Miz and Dolph Ziggler also added to the show's overall quality, taking one another to the limit over the Intercontinental Championship (although their best encounter wouldn't occur until No Mercy the following month).
2. Backlash 2004
Backlash 2004 featured two of the very best matches in the event's history, and as such, was always going to be somewhere near the top of this list. The most famous of the two actually wasn't the main event bout, but rather the grisly war between Mick Foley and Randy Orton.
This is rightly seen as a landmark moment in Orton's career, as well as one of the most entertaining matches in Foley's action-packed back catalogue. The young upstart was able to defeat the legend, but not before being put through the wringer. Tables, barbed wire and thumbtacks (so many thumbtacks) were inflicted upon the Evolution member, but he emerged a bona fide star as a result.
The main event was similarly fantastic, but for different reasons. Triple H, Shawn Michaels and Chris Benoit were never going to live up to their WrestleMania XX masterclass - but boy did they come close. A screwy HBK finish was teased, sparking fury in the Canadian crowd, but Benoit survived to retain his World Heavyweight Championship.
1. Backlash 2000
If any one pay per view perfectly encapsulates the energy of the Attitude Era, it could well be Backlash 2000. The main event is, quite simply, one of the most joyous occasions in WWE history, and the archetypal babyface return angle to boot.
Although many claim that The Rock should have won the main event of WrestleMania 2000, if he had done so, we wouldn't have been able to enjoy this amazing moment for what it was. With the Brahma Bull struggling against desperate odds (ultra-heel champion Triple H; various McMahon family members; Patterson and Brisco), the return of Stone Cold Steve Austin shook the MCI Center - and the wrestling world in general - to its very core.
The event had not only a sports entertainment finish done right; it had the sports entertainment finish done right, but the undercard was also punctuated by several workrate classics.
Scotty 2 Hotty and Dean Malenko provided a sleeper hit of an opener, while Eddie Guerrero and Essa Rios did their best to top it later in the night. Just prior to the main, Jericho and Benoit - two men with some of the best chemistry ever seen in WWE - went 15 minutes in a worthy high point of their rivalry.
Backlash 2000 was a brilliant show from top to bottom, and its very hard to argue against its status as the best show in the (pretty damn impressive) history of the event.