Exposing The Myth: TNA Was A WWE Rival
Examining whether the current day IMPACT Wrestling was ever a genuine rival to WWE.
For nearly two decades, WWE dominated the pro wrestling business as Vince McMahon's sports entertainment juggernaut essentially turned the business into a one-horse race.
While McMahon's WWE did its best to monopolise the industry, one plucky upstart promotion to rear its head was what is now known as IMPACT Wrestling. Initially NWA-TNA, then just TNA, and now IMPACT, there was always that hope early in the promotion's formation that this was a company that could rise up to somehow compete with the glitz, glamour, and finances of Vinny Mac's WWE.
To some, TNA was at one stage a genuine rival to WWE. To others, TNA never got even close to laying a glove on WWE.
You can make your own mind up on where you stand on that topic, but there's no question that TNA certainly had its fair shares of highs and lows - and those highs were ridiculously high, and those lows were likewise devastatingly low.
In the latest edition of our semi-regular Exposing the Myth series, let's take a look at whether TNA ever really was a true and genuine rival to WWE.
10. The Humble Beginnings
After WWE had beaten down WCW to the point that Vince McMahon was able to pick up Ted Turner’s rasslin’ company for a relatively modest fee, the wrestling world – at least in the North American sense – seemed destined to become a monopoly.
That WCW buyout happened in early 2001, but a year later came the rumblings of a new kid on the block. That new kid, of course, would be what was initially known as NWA: Total Nonstop Action, aka NWA-TNA.
Created by the father and son duo of Jerry and Jeff Jarrett, NWA-TNA was hoping to rise up to fill the void left by WCW’s demise. The promotion was able to use the National Wrestling Alliance branding and even NWA championships thanks to a licensing deal that was in place, and the plan was clearly to tap into the audience left stranded after WCW closed its doors.
Leaning on the three letters of the NWA brand of yesteryear, TNA had set its stall out when it came to the approach the promotion was going to take. Could that possibly ever get anywhere even close to matching WWE, though? That was the big question.
9. The Initial Plan Of Attack
It was clear that the fledgling NWA-TNA couldn't match WWE in terms of a TV presence, and so the early plan of attack for the Jarretts was to deliver a weekly PPV product.
Originally held from Huntsville, Alabama's Von Braun Center and then the Nashville Municipal Auditorium, the sixth of these weekly PPV offerings saw TNA move to Nashville's Tennessee State Fairground Sports Arena - better known as the TNA Asylum, and a venue that would house TNA shows for the next two years.
Where the talent was concerned, TNA looked to utilise stars - such as Ken Shamrock, Jeff Jarrett, Scott Hall, and Jerry Lynn - with pre-existing name value from their time in other promotions, while also putting a spotlight on younger, lesser-known names.
You just know that Jeff Jarrett was dying to make himself the company's inaugural World Champion, but it would be Shamrock who was crowned the first ever NWA World Heavyweight Champion of the TNA era after defeating Malice, aka the former Wall of latter-day WCW, in the finals of a Gauntlet for the Gold tournament.
Still, it would only be five months until Jarrett did get his hands on the Ten Pounds of Gold - with Double J defeating Ron Killings to become the third person to hold NWA-TNA's greatest prize.
8. Introducing The X-Division
For the very first weekly PPV, NWA-TNA introduced the concept of the X Division.
Pulling inspiration from WCW's success with the cruiserweight division and WWE's subsequent adaptation of that division, the X Division took what was being seen by WWE's lighter grapplers of the time and amped it up to 11.
Rather than simply being focused on the supposed smaller wrestlers, the X Division changed things up by being more about a person's in-ring style rather their size - or, as the tagline read, "it is not about weight limits, it is about no limits".
It was AJ Styles who would be crowned the first ever NWA-TNA X Division Champion, with the Phenomenal One defeating Jerry Lynn, Low Ki, and Psicosis on the second of the company's weekly PPV events.
At this time in 2002, the cruiserweights of WWE were putting on good matches - with Shane Helms, Jamie Noble, and Billy Kidman all taking centre-stage - but the X Division was a different beast altogether, which in turn gave NWA-TNA a one-up on WWE in that regard.
Going from strength-to-strength, the Ultimate X concept was introduced the following year and only served to further up the ante for the X Division talent. And when there are performers such as Styles, Lynn, Low Ki, Christopher Daniels, Amazing Red, Chris Sabin, Petey Williams, and the badass presence of Samoa Joe competing within the ranks of the X Division, it instantly made for must-see TV.
7. The First Step Towards Being A Major Player
If TNA was ever to be a true rival to Vince McMahon's WWE, the Nashville promotion needed to find itself a weekly TV slot in place of merely operating under a weekly pay-per-view model.
That meant that it was a huge deal when 2004 saw TNA begin to air its Impact! show on Fox Sports Net each week. With that move, TNA decided to introduce a six-sided ring in order to stand out from the pack - even if the focus of the in-ring product was to showcase a more traditional, sports-like feel.
Unfortunately, that deal with Fox Sports wasn't renewed upon expiring in May 2005, yet that didn't stop TNA from branching out further later that year by serving up the company's first line of action figures. In the meantime, weekly programming aired online, while TNA had by this point moved to a standard monthly PPV.
By the end of 2005, TNA's Impact! show was once more available on a major platform - this time in the shape of Spike TV. And with this move came a new influx of familiar faces for TNA, with Team 3D debuting on the first Impact! on Spike, and then the next few months seeing the likes of Sting, Kurt Angle, Kevin Nash, Scott Steiner, Booker T, and Mick Foley join the fold.
Slowly but surely, TNA had positioned itself as having the potential to maybe, just maybe provide some form of genuine competition to WWE.
6. The Varied Roster
At times, it could be argued that TNA had the best overall, most varied roster in professional wrestling.
That in itself is obviously an extremely bold statement, but the wrestlers involved with the company in the late 2000s back up that claim.
In Sting, there was a genuine icon of years gone by who could still go. In Kurt Angle, there was one of the absolute best in the world. In the Knockouts ranks, performers like Gail Kim and Awesome Kong were allowed to show why women's wrestling could be just as good as men's wrestling when afforded the chance. In AJ Styles, Christian, Christopher Daniels, Samoa Joe, and Frankie Kazarian, there were talents who could have a great match with anyone. In Abyss, there was a legitimately great, violent monster. In teams like Team 3D, Beer Money, LAX, and the Motor City Machine Guns, TNA had a tag team division to rival anybody. And veterans like Mick Foley, Booker T, Scott Steiner, and Kevin Nash had name value with more casual wrestling fans.
Of course, the big test of whether TNA really could legitimately compete with WWE was waiting just around the corner.
5. The Big Push
When looking at the key point in time when TNA went all-out to try and match WWE, it's impossible not to hone in on the period of late 2009 through until the middle of 2010.
It was in October '09 that TNA President Dixie Carter aimed for the moon by signing Hulk Hogan and Eric Bischoff in the hope of increasing the status of TNA. These acquisitions not only brought star power and served as quite the attention-grabber in a more mainstream sense, but Hogan and Bischoff were also to help on the creative side of things in addition to being on-air talent.
With other big-name stars like Rob Van Dam, a returning Jeff Hardy, and a totally-not-really-retired Ric Flair also added to the TNA ranks, the hope of Dixie was that she'd finally assembled a dream team capable of giving a WWE a run for its money.
By 'run for its money', that meant that the call was made for TNA to move its Impact! programming to a Monday night in order to go head-to-head with Raw and attempt to create a new Monday Night Wars scenario.
4. Was It Really A War, Though?
To be blunt, no, no it wasn't.
When TNA and Spike TV decided to move Impact! from a Thursday to a Monday, there was always going to be an element of risk. What if the show completely tanked in the ratings? What if TNA came off looking bush league? What if Spike TV completely soured on TNA should this move backfire?
Airing Impact! on a Monday had been tested out previously, with 4 January 2010 seeing TNA's flagship going up against WWE Raw.
That episode of Impact! actually drew an impressive 2.2 million viewers, with a first-hour viewership of 2.5 million viewers. To put that into perspective, the 22 September 2020 edition of Raw averaged 1.67 million viewers - which is a scary indicator of just how horrendous WWE's ratings have regularly been in the last few years.
So happy were both TNA and Spike at that 2.2 million average, 8 March 2010 saw Impact! permanently moved to a Monday night. The first week of this permanent move resulted in Impact! bringing in 1.4 million viewers and a 0.98 rating, while WWE easily surpassed those numbers with 5.1 million viewers and a 3.4 rating.
The following week would see Impact! draw its lowest rating for two years, but Spike TV and TNA were determined to make this move work.
3. The Move Back To Thursdays
Despite certain TNA higher-ups playing up how a war was on the horizon and how TNA was going to become a true rival of WWE's, that move to Monday nights proved to be a mistake.
There were some decent numbers for certain segments or certain matches on Monday nights, but never anything close to matching the numbers that WWE was bringing in. As such, it came as no real surprise to see TNA move Impact! back to Thursdays barely two months after that initial call to switch the company's flagship to a Monday night.
Spike TV and TNA initially tried having TNA air an hour earlier than Raw, yet that didn't make all that much difference and so Impact! officially moved back to its Thursday slot on 13 May 2010. For the record, the final Monday night Impact! had a 0.8 rating and an average 1.15 million viewers in comparison to WWE's 3.05 rating and 4.15 million viewers.
You can see how TNA clearly wanted to imitate WCW's bold decision to run Nitro up against Raw back in 1996, but the big difference there was that WCW already had viewership numbers close to rivalling the programming of the then-WWF. For Impact!, the move to Mondays was done on the hope of improving ratings rather than because of ratings.
2. The Winds Of Change
The switch back to a Thursday night for Impact! was one that was necessary as it soon became apparent that TNA, at that point of time in 2010, could never rely on averaging over 1.5 million viewers each and every week. Since taking themselves out of direct competition with WWE, TNA - now known as IMPACT Wrestling - has had its fair share of ups and downs.
While Hogan and Bischoff would depart the promotion as 2013 rolled into 2014 - with both of them later throwing plentiful shade TNA's way - Dixie Carter's company had to deal with ownership issues with Jeff Jarrett, a potential merger with Jarrett's Global Force Wrestling, major talent departures, failed ventures like Ring Ka King, Billy Corgan's attempted takeover, and Anthem eventually taking 85% ownership of TNA in 2017.
As for those talent departures, AJ Styles, Samoa Joe, Sting, Bobby Roode, Eric Young, Jeff Hardy, Matt Hardy, EC III, Bobby Lashley, Kurt Angle, Drew McIntyre, Bully Ray, and Nick Aldis are just a selection of former World Champions who headed for the TNA exit door to compete elsewhere before the Anthem buyout.
1. The Lay Of The Land Today
After a rough few years, the former TNA is these days known as IMPACT Wrestling and has slowly gathered a reputation for putting on a good professional wrestling product.
In an industry shared with WWE and AEW, it's always going to be hard for IMPACT Wrestling to compete on a financial level - yet that hasn't stopped them from quietly making itself one of the most engaging wrestling promotions in the game right now.
Nowadays owned by Anthem and steered by the stewardship of Don Callis, Scott D'Amore, and Ed Nordholm, the former TNA has managed to shake off so much of the stink that it has been associated with it over the past 18 years.
Did TNA ever live up to the hype of some in regards to being a legitimate rival to WWE? Of course not, but that's not to say that the TNA years didn't have some great moments from some great talents and provided a spotlight for so many people to make a name for themselves.
Here in 2020, the current IMPACT Wrestling product is an impressive one, with the creative and storytelling usually way above what's seen in WWE. It may not be the biggest dog in the yard, but IMPACT Wrestling should be a welcome part of any wrestling fan's weekly viewing habits - even if this wasn't quite the great rival to WWE that some had hoped the company would become.