How AEW Has Actually Answered Its Biggest Complaint

Yes, this is sports(-centric) entertainment.

By Michael Sidgwick /

Twitter (@AEWrestling)

Several mutants who may have heard of UWFi, Battlarts and Bloodsport but have never, ever watched it - nor have the inclination to watch worked shoot style pro wrestling, hence why it remains a niche product and all but died as a mainstream concern years ago - prowl the hellscape that is online pro wrestling fandom.

Advertisement

They lick their thick, wart-ridden green lips and suck the pooling saliva into their mouths as they furiously type, just knowing that they have stumbled upon something. They have discovered The Take. The Take will make it seem like they are not trolling. They recite the deep magic, under the impression that they will nail that pesky All Elite Wrestling bang to f*cking rights. They crack their scaly fingers, eight on each hand, belch up some bile, and they log on:

"I'm so disappointed in AEW. I was expecting a sporting product!!!!"

Advertisement

It is, in fact, quite clear what they are attempting to do. The mutants are attempting to pretend that they really, truly want to like AEW, but alas, they simply cannot. It is not the sporting competition promised to them.

What's also irritating about this take, other than its transparent bad faith, is that it wasn't exactly nor definitively what was promised, despite what the self-designated "league" indicated in the press release that heralded its partnership with WarnerMedia. AEW EVP Cody is on record as stating "I want to be the sports-centric alternative in the pro wrestling world" - but he has also spoken at length that the company intended - and intends - to be a "buffet" of professional wrestling in a bid to differentiate AEW from WWE.

Advertisement

CONT'D...(1 of 6)

AEW

WWE is a company that, historically, patterns its matches to the point of near-total homogeneity and has very rarely offered undiluted genre offerings. There is a marked difference, to use just two examples of several, between the styles Shinsuke Nakamura and Ricochet worked in New Japan Pro Wrestling to their current promotions.

Advertisement

In AEW, Rey Fénix and Penta El Zero M do exceptional, authentic, unimpeded lucha things. Cody and Chris Jericho operate in the traditional U.S. TV wrestling vein. Jon Moxley is both gripping brawler and grappling strategist. Mr. Brodie Lee and Lance Archer work as modern monsters; capable of spectacular moments, they mostly use their size because what they can do with it hurts, not because it's cooler when they do cool stuff they should not, by rights, be able to do.

The idea is to attract several groups of fans drawn to several different disciplines. This something-for-everybody philosophy stands in complete contrast to WWE's everything-for-one-man vision.

Advertisement

In a bid to be the alternative.

What's also irritating about this bad take is that it is, simply, bad. AEW - easing away now from the breezy quasi-canon embraced in May to strike the immediate post-lockdown tone - has in fact created a sporting framework around which to book its product. Those aforementioned stylistic disciplines collide in AEW because that is what happens in - yes - real sports. How many times, in real sports, have you heard a manager have a right whinge when the opposing team plays in a way designed to suppress their opponent? Countless glamorous continental managers, proponents of sexy, free-flowing football, have complained when sides park 11 men behind the ball and hoof it to the big lad up top.

Advertisement

CONT'D...(2 of 6)

AEW

This is not too dissimilar to, say, MJF complaining that Jon Moxley is the lunkheaded brawler to his purist technician, even if it wasn't true. The difference being, of course, that Jon Moxley is an incredible strategist and Steve Bruce sets up with a five-man defence at home to minnows in the League Cup.

Advertisement

FTR, proponents of an old school style, seethe at the spectacular aerial fare of Private Party, the Young Bucks and the Lucha Bros. Kenny Omega had to prepare for Mox by testing himself in the hardcore domain in a Dark match against Joey Janela. So many AEW programmes are driven through style and indeed strategy; Cody, in particular, will take notes from his coach's strategy guide and even modify his weight to match his opponents. The point is that, in AEW, many of the wrestlers have perfected a certain discipline that they hold very dear. Their craft is emphasised as a storyline driver, thus creating the impression that they are sportspeople, athletes, more than they are performers. This is a "sports-centric" feature of the alternative, but it's not all of it.

In the competition, titles are either held by wrestlers who are afraid of wrestling matches (Bayley) or swapped between teams because the belts don't match the colour scheme of the brand (the Street Profits and the New Day). In the alternative, as in - yes! - real sports, the titles are built, very carefully, to mean something. AEW used the term sports-centric not as a promise not to do comedy skits but to create a promotion with a sporting purpose that trickles down everywhere.

Advertisement

Jon Moxley is over as the man because he wins often, he wins decisively, and he wins as a result of the sheer range of his skill. As a result, his AEW World Championship is a virtually unattainable symbol of dominance. It's not just the wins.

CONT'D...(3 of 6)

Advertisement
AEW

The losses are framed as seismic developments - by, for example, candid sit-down interviews that depict the loser as broken, or lost, to get over the idea that their life's work has just evaporated. Under this careful - yes - sporting approach, a near-loss means something. What these people fight for means so much that even a narrow, failed pursuit of it gets them over, and even, in the case of Ricky Starks and Eddie Kingston, signed.

Advertisement

Wins and losses matter like they do in - yes - real sports. The rankings system - abused though it is a bit too often - functions to further create the sporting atmosphere. The athletes in AEW strive to win titles, and their progress - made through invariable clean wins that register as meaningful through meticulous cause-and-effect booking not tarnished by the murky, drama-bereft carny pointlessness that is a traded or unacknowledged win - is visually mapped through it. Yes, this is sports entertainment, to an extent.

For your writer's tastes, AEW does too often succumb to the dreaded WWE tropes to its detriment - and more so in 2020 than 2019, which might be becoming a problem; nobody wants to see title contenders determined by a tumbler, nor images of heels Photoshopped in silly costumes projected on the tron.

Advertisement

But ultimately, the real message of AEW's launch is manifested in a product that operates almost entirely differently to WWE's. You can't possibly stack up a Jon Moxley promo against a Dean Ambrose one and think "Yep, same thing!"

But AEW can't, and should not, operate like a "league".

Advertisement

CONT'D...(4 of 6)

AEW/Lee South

Wrestling could only function as a direct emulation of a real "league" if each division was comprised of an even number of acts and a set fixture list. What happens if somebody gets injured? What happens if a hot new act becomes available? Sorry, person that could positively impact ratings and draw money, we need to hold off of your debut because there are nine weeks of fixtures to run through!

Advertisement

Nobody is seriously suggesting that this is the case, but a promotion that bases its matches entirely around the win/loss rankings sounds as niche as f*ck. And really, if that were the case, people would just complain that there are no storylines to invest in.

Just be fair, for Christ's sake. AEW is on national television. Reductively, pro wrestling is a medium built on people that hate each other beating the sh*t out of each other. It's difficult to engineer that which sells a product that needs to make money through a league system. AEW referred to itself as a "league" to convey the idea that it isn't sports entertainment. Don't be thick. Don't be so wilfully thick as to confuse marketing for what marketing is. It is absolutely pathetic.

Advertisement

"AEW is just like WWE!" is not a bad take just because your writer disagrees with it. It is *sh*t*, superficial analysis. Dynamite, virtually all of the time, works hard (for evidently scant reward) to create a sense of immersion. No matches happen on an impromptu basis. Every segment, interrupted to engineer conflict or otherwise, is scheduled as if Dynamite is an event to be broadcast and not a show to be filmed. Every contrivance - the hour-long title matches always seem to settle between 10 and 20 minutes, for example - is a necessary byproduct of producing a television show.

CONT'D...(5 of 6)

Advertisement
AEW

The camera isn't invisible, and several measures are taken to address that.

Advertisement

Most every promo segment is framed outwardly as a way to promote a match, not to set one up for later that night, which is crucial in deepening that sense of immersion; time, like so much else, is accounted for. Not once have AEW forced its audience to ask what would be happening, if Wrestler X didn't happen to interrupt Wrestler Y. Wrestling is showbiz, and the showbiz in AEW is coherent.

Orange Cassidy is emblematic of the "But I wanted real sports!" criticism, and he bats it away. Not once has he interfered with the fabric of traditional pro wrestling kayfabe in AEW; the magic of Orange Cassidy - and if you don't like it, fine, but to fail to understand him is your problem, not AEW's - is that he's among the most strategic and skilled pro wrestlers in the fiction of it. He out-wrestled Cody on the mat during last week's 20 minute draw - another facet, incidentally, of - yes! - AEW's sporting presentation. But ultimately, all of this was never about "sports". It was about creating a better pro wrestling company. For a growing number of people, that is all that matters.

Advertisement

As has been pointed out elsewhere, Ring Of Honor is currently promoting, free of charge, the strictest emulation of wrestling-as-sport through its Pure Title tournament - and it's very, very good.

It's everything these mutants claim to want to watch, and it's incredibly telling that they aren't doing so.

Advertisement