How AEW Killed "Being The Elite"

The Superkick Party's Over.

By Michael Hamflett /

Twitter, @MattJackson13

“Farewell To Independent Wrestling” was the title of Episode 165 of Being The Elite. At time of writing it was the most recent edition of the weekly show, and was the most appropriate in recent memory. Its climactic moment featured The Young Bucks sharing their story with a House Of Glory crowd following a match with AEW signees Private Party, with a history lesson morphing into a plug for their television rematch on TNT in October.

Advertisement

This was peak Matt and Nick, operating - as they have been for nearly the full duration of the show - in self-promotion mode. For virtually all of the 165 weeks they've filmed their life and times as pro wrestlers, the pair have carefully curated a reputation as everymen whilst gradually becoming millionaires from their profession. Fierce capitalists that present themselves as people for the people, The Young Bucks' attitude has mirrored the remarkable story documented through the growth of the show.

Their emotional farewell was scripted for many more than those in the arena that night. Like much of their work in the past three years, it was valuable footage for BTE and its loyal audience. A loyal audience that once followed them to a WWE Raw Invasion, that multiple times followed them across multiple independent promotions and New Japan Pro Wrestling, followed them into a Chicago event started by a bet, and finally a fully-fledged billionaire-backed wrestling promotion.

Advertisement

Episode 1 of Being The Elite didn't have a title, nor really a format beyond The Bucks and Kenny Omega talking through their fascinating existences as pro wrestlers. The show that launched a million wrestling memes barely had anything of note to it, but it brought the future AEW megastars to life. As it would just about everybody that came near it in the years that followed - the angles were fake but the laughs, the love and the genuine midas touch was real. The foundations of AEW exist within that ethos, even if the BTE empire has crumbled in its shadow.

CONT'D...

Advertisement
Being The Elite

Cody’s cupped ear in the Being The Elite credits spoke to just how close to the ground his was. He’d joined up with the right folk at the right time whilst working through his fabled independent wrestling list since leaving WWE in 2016, but he was also the one with some of the biggest ideas for just how far a newfound friendship could be taken. The gang had smashed a glass ceiling with their YouTube hit, but YouTube wasn't the ceiling for the son of 'The American Dream'.

Advertisement

Joining the trio alongside fellow Bullet Club members Hangman Page, Marty Scurll and the rotating cast of characters the gang routinely worked with or against on the circuit, BTE quickly became the most vital watch of the week. It was cathartic in the face of sterile WWE output, it was a window into a thriving independent scene beyond head drops and endless flips on live streams and iPPVs, and it rewarded fans of the guys' actual Ring Of Honor/New Japan Pro Wrestling runs with easter egg add-ons. Eventually the script flipped - the real meat of their respective storylines was to be found on YouTube, with the group teasing or playing up to their traits on the actual wrestling shows. Crucially too, it was so so funny.

Few things relate fans to wrestlers than when they genuinely make them laugh. It's one of the key reasons The Rock and D-Generation X got over during a time of the anti-hero a*skicker Stone Cold Steve Austin, and why WWE have persisted with forcing the funnies on folk even if it doesn't remotely suit the gimmick. They tried it with the stoic Randy Orton in 2004. It only ever worked in Vince McMahon's mind with John Cena. It never worked with Roman Reigns a decade after that. It will continue not to work with Seth Rollins in 2019.

Advertisement

But it worked over and over again on Being The Elite. Host your own 'Try Not To Laugh' night with Flip Gordon and Matt Jackson paying homage to Terry Funk and Dennis Stamp on Beyond The Mat. Or Yujiro Takahashi giving The Elite four letters and both barrels. Or Juice Robinson's desperate search for "gossip for the boys". It wasn't just wrestling comedy done well, it was wrestling comedy perfected.

CONT'D...

Advertisement
Twitter (@ALL_IN_2018)

Episode 115 of Being The Elite (12 August 2018) is just one of numerous examples of the show reaching its critical and commercial apex in 2018. The former because it was hilarious on the reg and made inch-perfect and logical use of all its characters, the latter because it had convinced 10,000 fans to buy a ticket to see a historic live rendering of their wrestling adventures in Chicago later that month.

Advertisement

In this particular edition, the shoot portions are made up of all the usual cast members sharing their thoughts about ALL IN; hopes, fears, dreams, worries and other relatable traits that took them away from the spotlight of their regular stage and into the hearts of the regular audience. These moments of genuine humanity feed brilliantly into the worked and scripted content which is - without exception - sublime.

Kenny Omega expresses his dissatisfaction to The Young Bucks, Kota Ibushi, Marty Scurll and Chase Owens about them being booked against one another in a six man until Matt Jackson hilariously proposes that they "plan out, move for move, here in the back, what we're gonna do out there. We'll choreograph every single second of the match and - this is the best part - they're gonna think we're actually fighting." Omega, worried about forgetting the choreography is reassured by Matt's advice - "whisper into the confused individual's ear, the spot". Later in the episode, Hangman Page was called a "f*cking d*ckhead" by his own cowboy boots for attempting to murder the still-very-much-alive Joey Ryan. Wrestling, in case these skits weren't clear enough about reminding you, is not real - but none of this absurd silliness felt the tiniest bit fake. Not with a historic pay-per-view mere weeks away.

Advertisement

Long accused of "killing the business" by those from a very different corner of it, this was the group literally exposing the magic of it to an audience that have long known how the rabbit comes out of the hat. Nothing was lost or damaged or - god forbid - killed, by the segments, and it was aoo future-proof for any fans discovering the show later into their fandom of the group or pro wrestling at large. The Elite were being the change they wanted to see, filming it, and proving that others wanted to see it too.

September 2018's ALL IN was couched as the end destination for the content and banter to coalesce, but it proved far more than a final destination.

Advertisement

CONT'D...

FITE.tv/WWE

Just ahead of SummerSlam, a bizarre story hit the wrestling internet courtesy of Dave Meltzer noting that WWE were in talks to purchase Fite TV. Panic ensued - it was as though an end-of-days hole had opened up in the ground swallowing all hopes and dreams and things everybody loved, all until rumours were snuffed out as just that, and the story quietly went away.

Advertisement

The nature of the worry was tied mostly to the health of the wider wrestling world that had since come to rely on the service. Countless independent promotions as well as Impact Wrestling and - troublingly - All Elite Wrestling used it to carry pay-per-view and television events in the United States and internationally. Its sudden disappearance would damage every company it carried, not least with the mostly-functional WWE Network diversifying to include EVOLVE and ICW of late. More of the same is expected from the company in the coming months - their widening reach may look magnanimous but history has routinely informed us that the arm around the shoulder will always end with a knife in the back.

The AEW links to Fite TV were the most intriguing to consider, and it triggered conversation not just for their need to exist entirely on their own terms but also offer a service comparable with WWE, NJPW and even Ring Of Honor. Those organisations benefited from rich histories that could be pre-loaded alongside the brand spanking new content, but AEW’s own equivalent in this hypothetical arrangement would only really be able to exist as place to carry their newest - read: only - material.

Advertisement

Unless, of course, they lionise and weaponise the once-wonderful Being The Elite.

CONT'D...

Advertisement
WWE/AEW

Being The Elite is as good as dead because none of the AEW Executive Vice Presidents really have as much time to play at being pro wrestlers making towns anymore. Moreover, their best material is probably best saved for the upcoming weekly TV show or wealth of other outlets they're going to offer.

Advertisement

The "Road To..." series' ahead of ALL IN, Double Or Nothing, ALL OUT et al have been hit-and-miss from an entertainment standpoint, but as pay-per-view hype jobs, they've generally satisfied the brief. There's a controlled cohesion about All Elite's YouTube uploading frenzy, but little of it matches the magic of golden era BTE. There's subsequently never been a better time to finish it for good, then preserve it as a product worth paying for.

In Being The Elite, the group have 165 episodes (and counting) of a show to make up for the lack of a back catalogue if they set up their own version of the Network to host the pay-per-views and (eventually) archived weekly shows. Load the section with bloopers and outtakes, upscale production where/if necessary, split stories into chapters for ease of locating - the product is finished and already lends itself to giving fans something to do while they drop a nominal monthly fee for the benefit of an easy-to-access supershow.

Advertisement

For three years, Being The Elite was everything to those that took part in it as well as those that followed it. It must not be reduced to less than nothing just to ensure that AEW has all the quality content it needs to get off the ground in style in October. Preserving it with prestige in this matter would ensure that if and when it inevitably goes, it won't be forgotten. All Elite Wrestling wouldn't have existed - let alone set about attempting to "Change The Universe" - if Being The Elite hadn't gone about its business (and "this business") first.