How The Fiend Saved Bray Wyatt
Stepping outside the comfort zone has created WWE's best new character in years.
Six months ago, your writer filmed a video titled Bray Wyatt: What Went Wrong? for WhatCulture Wrestling's YouTube channel.
Based on this article by Michael Hamflett, it was a thorough, in-depth analysis of a character who'd gone from being touted as "the next Undertaker" in 2013 to a missing-in-action husk in 2019, and the factors causing his demise.
Wyatt had fallen apart long before our content was published. It began with a ghastly Ring of Fire match versus Kane at SummerSlam 2013. The ensuing years brought such horrors as the credibility-crushing John Cena feud, several pointless Wyatt Family splits/reunions, Kane and Big Show miserably dumping Bray over the top rope in the 2015 Royal Rumble, a WWE Championship reign years too late, the Randy Orton bug match, the House of Horrors, etc., etc., etc. The list goes on, and on, and on.
The character that left our screens for an extended hiatus in August 2018 was a babbling, broken joke, and a parody of his former self, despite a fun stint alongside Matt Hardy in the Deleters of Worlds. His situation was so dire that the average fan may have taken you for a troll had you told them that in a few months that Wyatt would be the hottest thing on WWE television by SummerSlam, and yet here we are.
It's August 2019, and Bray Wyatt has never been better.
CONT'd...
The Firefly Fun House was a roaring success.
Regularly described as one of Raw's few saving graces during one of the Monday flagship's regular creative lulls, its original eight-episode run not only gave us memes like the Muscle Man Dance, but also took the broken, defective Bray Wyatt character and immediately transformed him into something more compelling.
Dressed like a substitute geography teacher, Wyatt became a twisted, happy-go-lucky orator with a dark, sinister edge - The Fiend - lurking beneath. It was genuinely such good sh*t, pal. Something had damaged Bray's psyche in his time away, and as he laughed, waved, and joked through his Fun House skits, he felt more dangerous than he had in years. The playful, sweater-clad demeanour only enhanced The Fiend's menace.
WWE's presentation cannot be faulted here. They gave the former 'New Face of Fear' the perfect platform in these short, sharp bursts of mayhem, and while some bemoaned the Fun House's short eight-episode run, it kept things concise. Commissioning further episodes would have only increased the risk of overexposure.
But as brilliant as the Fun House's execution was, this resurgence was sparked by other, more important factors.
CONT'd...
Wyatt's hiatus was weird.
Removed from television when Hardy was injured, Bray's own absence was never explained. The following months were rife with speculation. Was he injured, holidaying, or in hot water? When would he return? Was he being repackaged? Reforming The Wyatt Family? Leaving wrestling, temporarily, to start a real-life family with JoJo Offerman?
Wrestling media was flooded with reports, but nobody had the answers. Nothing was concrete. Brief returns to the live event circuit in November and December brought further spikes in coverage, but eventually, inevitably, talk of what was going on with Wyatt died down.
The Firefly Fun House first aired in April 2019. The first time the new Bray was seen in the flesh was when he leapt from shadows to attack Finn Bálor in July. Given that his previous live televised appearance was in August 2018, that means almost a full year had passed.
As weird as it was, that the former Husky Harris went missing for so damn long is among the key reasons his return has gone so well. WWE gave us a chance to miss Wyatt by keeping him away from television between Aug '18 and Jul '19. Such a lengthy absence was necessary for the heart to grow fonder, given how diminished the character and, indeed, performer, had become. Whether this was by design or a happy accident doesn't matter: it worked.
So too did the decision to put the paintbrush back in the artist's hands.
CONT'd...
Scripted promos are a plague on modern WWE programming. A problem since Stephanie McMahon's promotion to the top of WWE's creative pile in 2002, they, amongst other factors, have contributed to a roster of stifled, clipped-winged wrestlers who share the same droning, flavourless voice. Sure, they're a popular target, but their role in WWE's artistic demise can't be understated.
It's no coincidence that WWE's most compelling talkers are those with greater freedom of expression - men and women like Becky Lynch and Samoa Joe. Bray and his Firefly Fun House fell into this category.
June brought news that Wyatt, not WWE's colossal crew of sitcom and reality TV writers, was writing the Fun House himself. The puppets, the call-backs to his old self, the not-so-subtle chainsaw/cardboard cutout allegory, The Fiend's mask: each had started as ideas in the performer's head. That's why it never lulled, and why the WWE locker-room emptied to watch each new Fun House segment as it aired.
It was a very un-WWE move from a control-obsessed company who rarely relinquish their iron grip. They should be applauded for it. Had the writers or - gasp - Vince himself taken control, history suggests that things might not have gone so well for Wyatt and his new alter ego, The Fiend, who'd probably be singing nursery rhymes to Kayla Braxton by now.
CONT'd...
Nailing the Firefly Fun House was the first part of the masterplan. As always, an effective follow-up was imperative and again, WWE and Wyatt knocked it out of the park, bridging the gap between pre-taped segments and live appearances with unexpected nuance.
The 8 July episode of Monday Night Raw brought the first puppet sighting. Ricochet was walking backstage when Huskus the Pig was caught lurking behind a shipping crate. Its appearance went unnoticed by the announcers but viral after the show, with hordes of eagle-eyed fans reporting the sighting on social media, and this continued over the coming weeks, with Abby the Witch and Mercy the Buzzard joining their porcine pal.
One might typically expect WWE to beat the audience over the head with such things, but not this time. In throwing the puppets onto Raw and SmackDown without acknowledgement, WWE, in a refreshing move, put trust in their audience. They wanted you to notice these things for yourself. The Subtlety Hammer was left in the toolbox and the new Wyatt's mystique was maintained through restraint, care, and faith.
Again, very un-WWE.
But this format always had a finite shelf-life. The true test of Bray and The Fiend's viability would come when he started making regular televised appearances and after downing Bálor in July, Wyatt's in-ring return was set...
CONT'd...
SummerSlam 2019 was a home run for The Fiend.
Everything worked. Everything. The new mask, attire, and entrance completed the act's unsettling new aesthetic. Coming courtesy of acclaimed metalcore noiseniks Code Orange, the discordant, squealing theme was recorded in hell's pit. That lantern, too, was a stroke of genius, with Wyatt's old, eyes-sewn-shut head literally lighting the new Fiend's way from his gaping maw.
This fusion of past and future is part of why The Fiend works so well. This is a character informed by the mistakes of old. Its presentation thus far suggests WWE and Bray himself have looked at why his original character failed, then applied them here.
It continued in the match itself, with Bray blending the familiar (Sister Abigail, teasing the spider walk) with new (the horror movie neck-snap, headbutting a charging Bálor's throat). He has evolved. The roots of 'The Eater of Worlds' remain, but, at this early stage, it looks like WWE have retained some of the better elements of the old Wyatt while shedding the b*llocks. This will go a long way towards destroying all memory of those big pay-per-view losses, babbling promos, and the bloody House Of Horrors.
This is a special, special act, and one that needs to be protected. Fortunately, WWE seem to agree.
CONT'd...
August saw Pro Wrestling Sheet's Ryan Satin break the news that WWE held off on having The Fiend appear on the post-SummerSlam Raw and SmackDown because they want the character to feel special. They want the audience to never know when he's going to strike.
This should be music to many a fan's ears. In today's WWE, gimmicks like Wyatt's always succumb to the grind and churn of weekly television. Overexposure is an aura-diminishing pox that makes even the most intriguing characters boring and mundane (see: Shinsuke Nakamura, Asuka, etc.). A performer can't feel "special" when you see them every single week, without fail, and the report suggests the promotion finally understand this.
Once more: very un-WWE.
And yet WWE's wild Sports Entertainment universe is the only place a character like this can exist.
The Fiend is the best kind of wrestling pantomime act and has more in common with a horror movie villain or a comic book character than a traditional wrestler. NJPW's sports-centric product can't produce content like this, and whether or not AEW's can remains to be seen. WWE have failed at this countless times before, of course, but perhaps using uncharacteristic traits to get The Fiend over will be a lesson to them.
Perhaps they'll now use the lessons learned in reviving Bray Wyatt's career and apply them elsewhere. His story shows that no matter how buried or diminished someone might be, there's always a way out. This was no accident, either. WWE didn't stumble upon this. In collaboration with Bray, they've plotted a meticulous path from the abyss to greatness, and while none of it is rocket science, credit is due.
Now think what the same approach could do for an Asuka, Nakamura, Drew McIntyre, or anyone else in WWE's undermined middle tier.