How The Wednesday Night War Was Won On The Very First Night

AEW Dynamite and NXT each showed their hand in just 15 minutes...

By Michael Sidgwick /

AEW

The Wednesday Night War is over.

Advertisement

Sure, there are some weeks like this one, in which you're reminded that AEW Dynamite isn't quite perfect. And yes, NXT presents good-to-very-good bell-to-bell action and might win a rare week in which it revives an old WCW pay-per-view brand and literally plasters it on the show.

But it's over. NXT has bested Dynamite just once in the key demo, and has scored what amounts to a few consolation goals in terms of overall viewership. AEW is even tripling NXT in the demo when not merely battering it. Where AEW has become the epicentre of pro wrestling conversation, there is no buzz on the back-and-yellow brand. The second Fight Pit didn't draw as well as the original, but that can be classed as a noble failure. NXT did the work. But in what can be classed as an indictment, NXT b*llocksed up Rhea Ripley's push despite her building the audience like no other performer.

Advertisement

The real war is now being fought between Dynamite and WWE Monday Night RAW. AEW is gunning for those demos and has even fired off some shots in 18-49: the fallout from Winter Is Coming scored better ratings than WWE's flagship managed the week prior. The Wrestling Observer's Dave Meltzer calculated that Dynamite, should viewing trends continue, is on course to defeat RAW regularly by November/December 2022.

The Wednesday Night War was over, in fact, on the very first night.

Advertisement

CONT'D...(1 of 6)

WWE.com

Both shows entered head-to-head competition on October 2, 2019.

Advertisement

In a desperate, short-term bid to undermine the premiere on TNT, Triple H booked an NXT Championship match between Adam Cole and Matt Riddle. This was the biggest - or at least one of the biggest matches - NXT had in its locker. This wasn't informed by any great, well-crafted grudge story. Riddle defeated Killian Dain in their second Street Fight in as many weeks - wildly, total gimmick over-saturation happened before head-to-head competition did - and was confronted by Adam Cole in the post-match. To put over the idea that a title switch was imminent, Riddle trapped Cole in an armbar. The Champion tapped. Cole's Undisputed Era stablemates arrived on the scene to bail their man out. Riddle didn't take the beating, he ran, and wasn't assisted by any of his fellow babyfaces. NXT missed the trick that won the war.

The actual match was great, tainted though it is now - they worked a super-dramatic sprint around Riddle's striking legitimacy and Cole's defensive acumen - but then, it was always going to be. The incredible in-ring standard had long been normalised. The principle behind episodic television is to create intrigue and ramp up the anticipation.

Advertisement

In an infamous Wrestling Twitter moment, Dave Meltzer analysed early Nielsen data by proclaiming "Riddle huge for teenage boys". Translated from the sort of quirk you can never tell is oblivious or not, the venerable Wrestling Observer chief revealed that Riddle had drawn the demographic TV advertisers want shows to draw - the same demo that WWE has struggled to dent for several years now.

And they pinned him virtually clean in the middle within 15 minutes of night one.

Advertisement

CONT'D...(2 of 6)

Scott Lesh

Over on TNT, AEW was one plot hole away from booking the perfect angle.

Advertisement

In the main event, Chris Jericho and hired guns Santana and Ortiz defeated the Elite stable of Kenny Omega and the Young Bucks. In one chaotic and thrilling and amazingly productive segment, AEW mapped out the short, medium and long-term future of its Dynamite flagship and the next pay-per-view on the calendar. Midway through a match that really should have been fought under a No Disqualification stipulation, to allow AEW to eat the cake, Jon Moxley lurked behind Kenny Omega in an iconic visual. He drew away him from the action, the memory of the Fyter Fest assault informing this gruesome receipt, and smashed him head-first through a glass table to set up their Lights Out match at Full Gear. Jericho's team used the numbers advantage to win, and they beat down the Bucks in the post-match. Cody made the save. In a shocking development, the good dude helped out his friends.

This drew out Sammy Guevara, who had earlier refused Cody's handshake after losing their opener. He kicked Cody in the balls. This was all sequenced so brilliantly, particularly since it built both a faction war and two pay-per-view main events in parallel. In removing Omega from the fray, the heels always held the advantage. Dustin Rhodes came out to help his brother, before, in the big shocking headline moment, the debuting Jake Hager decked him. He looked so shredded, and the beat-down looked so good, that any TNA comparisons made in the aftermath felt contrarian.

Advertisement

If it was a move from the Dixie Carter playbook, it was executed brilliantly.

CONT'D...(3 of 6)

Advertisement
AEW

The Inner Circle was formed. The Elite had competition in their quest to dominate the wrestling landscape.

Advertisement

This faction war spawned so many matches because this form of storytelling allows for so many dovetailing permutations. Hangman Page defeated Sammy Guevara ahead of his Full Gear match opposite PAC, building a midcard attraction while maintaining the overarching thread. Santana and Ortiz's victory on October 2 landed them in a big match opposite the division's flagship players at Full Gear. Cody's connection with his brother allowed for the indirect heat angle that saw Hager break Dustin's arm, intensifying Cody's resolve to win the big one on November 9. The Chris Jericho & Sammy Guevara Vs. Kenny Omega & Hangman Page Full Gear go-home match created a logical foundation for yet another sensational retread of the all hell breaks loose brawl.

Seeping into the title picture while creating an enormous canvas all of its own, the Elite Vs. Inner Circle war was all meant to culminate in Blood & Guts, a match nailed-on to rival the 1.4 million number generated by the premiere. That's how - and why - you book. The pandemic f*cked up the plans for that WarGames-inspired battle (Stadium Stampede was wonderful, context-dependent consolation), but the narrative blueprint won the war.

Advertisement

NXT gave away its biggest theoretical ratings draw of a programme in a quarter of an hour; AEW storyboarded the next six months of the main event scene in the same timeframe.

These weren't just flashpoint moments that drove the first battle. They each embodied the respective philosophies of both shows.

Advertisement

CONT'D...(4 of 6)

WWE.com

The method by which NXT booked numbed people on the prospect of the most critically-acclaimed series of matches held in North America in 2018. Tommaso Ciampa, after failing in his pursuit of "Goldie" - in what was a very basic programme marked by lazy, gravitas-reaching stare-downs more than any real narrative development - found himself feuding yet again with Johnny Gargano.

Advertisement

The excess of it all was as uninspiring as it was, in the end, laughable.

The method by which AEW booked meanwhile put you on the hook for Goldust Vs. Jack Swagger. The match at Revolution epitomised the gentleman's three, in that it was so well-built and presented so early that the strictly quite good action was received very politely. And in truth, Hager was a bust as a singles guy, though his subtle character work and tag team displays are sorely underrated. But the point is that AEW's booking was so good that it made a WWE Main Event match from 2013 must-see.

Advertisement

Of course, NXT did run with their own overarching storyline premised on the dominance of a heel faction: the Undisputed Era's Golden Prophesy. But the issue is that they never built up a team of babyfaces, outside of a WarGames unit that relied on a one-off main roster for the sake of a one-night pop, to go at them.

CONT'D...(5 of 6)

Advertisement
Impact Wrestling

Keith Lee was the man who toppled what felt like a thin excuse to get all the belts in the same frame, but it didn't really work.

Advertisement

He defeated Roderick Strong when he felt above the North American Title, and, with the momentum he generated at Survivor Series lost, he defeated Adam Cole too suddenly for it to resonate as this great achievement on the back of a richly earned story. NXT simply wanted to counter-programme Fyter Fest with a big match. Nor did NXT explore the end of the Prophesy with any real intrigue. It feels like it should have been bigger, like losing every title should have held major narrative ramifications. The pandemic didn't help, and while we've seen hints of friction, the Undisputed Era just sort of exist on Wednesday nights now.

To this day, AEW uses faction-based storytelling to deftly map journeys that preserve and build anticipation ahead of the ultimate destination: Sting and Darby Allin Vs. Team Taz; Kenny Omega's new Elite Vs. Jon Moxley and Death Triangle; Hangman Page finding his confidence with the help of the Dark Order. NXT meanwhile by tossing off workrate matches as one-week hooks finds itself in the same illogical, meh loops it has since February 2020. How is Pete Dunne a credible #1 contender to Finn Bálor's NXT Championship? He just lost clean in the middle to Kyle O'Reilly.

Advertisement

For the same reason Adam Cole wrestled Matt Riddle all that time ago: because the match will probably get ****1/4 irrespective of how poorly it has been built in the Observer Newsletter.

It's quite ironic: NXT has lost, past tense, for chasing the acclaim that led to AEW's formation in the first place.

Advertisement