How WWE Has FINALLY Solved Its Babyface Problem
How a deliberately uncool Riddle is better than an accidentally lame Seth Rollins.
WWE has failed emphatically to build a top-level babyface to replace John Cena.
WWE has failed emphatically to build a top-level babyface to replace John Cena because Vince McMahon is under the impression that they should all be John Cena, whether they possess his generational charisma or not.
John Cena played the master of ceremonies and the host of the show. He buried his opponents with scathing "fine speech" missives and jabbed them with weak, child-friendly insults. He riffed on Star Wars and internet culture and had a troubling habit of comparing his foes to women years after the PG Era prohibited his virulent homophobia. He didn't take anything seriously. The Miz, rising midcard star? Barely even made it halfway through his cut-off. Roman Reigns, fiercely protected top heel? Lifeless detriment to a company in decline. Bray Wyatt, formidable psychological manipulator? Fat bloke who'd look even uglier, if you stuck him in a dress!
Cena's material was rancid, but the kids loved his schtick and his sheer megastar personality punted it over the line, insofar as drawing a booming reaction at least. Cena's successors don't possess his generational charisma, because it's generational.
And so one arrives at Roman Reigns reading winking fairytales to the kiddies. At Seth Rollins impersonating a caveman to mock Brock Lesnar. At Drew McIntyre regaling the crowd for minutes on end, cutting the de rigueur tron gags and recapping in slow painful detail the sh*t you've literally just seen. At every last one of his successors welcoming you all to Monday Night RAW!
CONT'D...(1 of 6)
Damian Priest, a man who hucks fresh produce at the baddies because everybody with the ability to access this article unsupervised is far too old for this sh*t, was the latest to do precisely that. He said, like most do, that he "always wanted to say that," as if combat athletes dream not of winning fights and making millions of dollars but rather becoming brand ambassadors for WWE.
The Rock's easy-going charm is also a template, except it was phenomenally hard-going when Seth Rollins did stand-up comedy in 2019. His cringe-worthy attempts to own the room were so embarrassing that his face role was untenable despite going over Brock Lesnar twice. Remember when that was the ticket to babyface stardom, incidentally? It was never that easy. A WWE babyface could tap out Cthulhu, and they'd still have to mock the tentacled sky-scraping behemoth up in bandages and stink lines on the f*cking titantron.
Oh, and of course, Steve Austin. Seth Rollins played the 2000 vintage of the character during that very same programme. He didn't trust anybody and assaulted several wrestlers backstage with a steel chair. His characterisation was all over the place. He played everybody but Seth Rollins.
All WWE babyfaces must fit within an established archetype that they are woefully unsuited to. For years - decades - virtually every WWE babyface has been presented, accidentally, as a total dork. It is impossible to take a WWE babyface seriously as a cool, likeable guy. They beat people up when they haven't even been beaten down, they tell sh*tty jokes, they have no friends out to save them. They, by definition, are geeks.
Have WWE finally realised and embraced this?
CONT'D...(2 of 6)
Two babyfaces on Monday Night RAW are getting over, and this reaction is pronounced against a backdrop of almost blanket silence elsewhere. The amplified reactions afforded to Riddle and John Morrison must be noted as a result.
Putting aside the not ideal optics of actually presenting Riddle as a babyface, Riddle is getting over - big - as a babyface to those untroubled by his reputation. And Riddle is a total dork by design. His character is a brainless nitwit with dire patter who annoys the f*ck out of everybody. He is therefore no different to any WWE babyface with one crucial difference: this is a deliberate move. Riddle is not somebody that Vince McMahon thinks of as cool, and is thus objectively uncool by default. The audience is asked to sympathise with this blithering f*cking idiot because he sees the best in everybody. He is a naive, well-meaning fellow who would rather help out somebody who he thinks is a friend than serve his own individual ambitions. "Randy," he'll wail, imploring the sociopathic bully to be his mate.
At his core, which is what counts, Riddle is a phenomenal professional wrestler. His explosive striking game is among the most legitimate in the entire industry, which of course is all the more effective in the methodical context of WWE. His real knowledge of what pain actually feels like informs his stunning selling ability. A character like this does not get over if he can't go. But Riddle is an otherwise rubbish pro wrestling babyface. He's prone to distraction, he isn't remotely smart, and nobody aspires to be anything like him. People rather enjoy being able to tie their shoelaces together.
But that modern, WWE audience, who just seem happy enough to be there, has no aspirations to get behind the proper pro wrestling babyface.
CONT'D...(3 of 6)
They don't want a whip-smart ass-kicker with the cool, dry wit of an action hero. They don't want pro wrestling. They enjoy the stories WWE tell, and Riddle's pitiful attempts to befriend Randy Orton are working for them.
It's a masterstroke, it really is. That, or Riddle has simply got over in spite of the booking, which is true of every star act not named the Tribal Chief in the post-Super Cena wilderness. But he gets more over with every stupid thing he says. This is a total subversion of the fates of Seth Rollins and Drew McIntyre, in whom fans lost interest the more they said stupid sh*t that no real human being would say. WWE has abandoned any dreaded pretence of promoting Riddle as a traditional babyface that once got over, and because they are so f*cking useless at the old babyface devices, it's working. This article is only half-facetious. WWE has stumbled onto something.
Consider John Morrison.
Morrison is not unlike Riddle. He is a nonsensical if well-meaning human being. He was a pleasant, oblivious presence by the side of The Miz. When Miz would say something flagrantly untrue, Morrison would deadpan his disbelief. He is also fond of sh*te patter that makes him sound like an utter doofus. Like Riddle, he too carries a prop to the ring; a "dripstick" as opposed to a scooter.
And he too is over.
CONT'D...(4 of 6)
Morrison received a monster of a reaction at Money In The Bank, and Miz's betrayal of him on RAW the other week drew, by WWE standards, a massively sympathetic reaction. Both Riddle and Morrison draw "Awwww" noises from an audience that has forgotten what a pop feels like or doesn't care for what a pop sounds like. This article was pitched before Morrison was obliterated by Omos in two minutes on RAW, but wins and losses do not matter. In WWE, daft patter matters.
This is an audience that has been conditioned for years to receive the WWE babyface as a geek. When this is performed on purpose, it actually gets over. WWE has for years insisted on removing itself from the energy, soul and archetypes of traditional professional wrestling. Is this the final, improbably successful metamorphosis from professional wrestling to sports entertainment?
Do fans identify and sympathise with hapless nice guy geeks because WWE has embraced that which it can actually do? Seriously, no facetiousness here whatsoever this time: is this mode of storytelling, no matter how whacky, actually resonating with the audience because the audience can sense it's an earnest and organic expression of something that the creator can actually get on board with?
None of this is subjectively great, just to make that clear. But it's working, and it's preferable to that with which WWE was running off its audience.
CONT'D...(5 of 6)
WWE has struggled for years to connect with its base because its half-hearted obligation to push a bastardised version of indie wrestling was just so loveless. The hilarious, multifarious incompetence also did not help, of course, but WWE presented bad wrestling that it did not give a sh*t about for years. The outwardly silly pushes of Riddle and Morrison at least feel lovingly crafted. That goes exponentially further than reluctantly pushing a lad in kick pads for three weeks because they had a bit of buzz that a sighing Vince McMahon acknowledged before saying "Actually, f*ck this, I don't have to acknowledge a f*cking thing!"
This is the beginning of a shift away from the 2010s, throughout which Vince was confronted with various trends that he was not predisposed to understanding. AEW has subsumed virtually all of them, and Vince McMahon is happy about it. He's doubling down now on his own, full-throated bullsh*t.
Bright colours. Colossal new recruits. Spooky bullsh*t. Silly, silly wrestlers.
And because it feels like he isn't hating his f*cking life, the mad awld despot might actually be onto something. Really, this new vision for WWE can't be any worse; it's better Vince do something he wants to do than something he doesn't.
A well-made ketchup burrito probably tastes better than an organic fish taco thrown against the wall after a conniption fit.