How WWE Ruined The One Thing That Made It Great
Googoo Gaga 3:16.
WWE is useless at booking babyfaces.
That’s not fair.
WWE is worse than useless at booking babyfaces because anybody tasked with the top babyface role is systemically reduced to villain status. It’s really quite incredible, how WWE conspires to do this, and it no longer matters who it is done to—“it” being a total hatchet job.
It was once thought that Roman Reigns got WWE’d because his ring style was unfashionable. He was a powerhouse in an era of the technically gifted, as the organic rise of Daniel Bryan brought into focus—another John Cena when the first John Cena was chronically over-exposed.
Turns out WWE simply cannot book babyfaces. At all. The babyfaces in WWE are hapless dorks. WWE took a talent most fans wished was booked like Roman Reigns—Seth Rollins—and turned him into the new Roman Reigns. WWE is playing 4D Bullsh*t Chess and calling it “creative”.
Seth Rollins is an inconsistent but excellent pro wrestler on his day, but he isn’t a compelling sports entertainer. WWE has effectively killed his babyface character via thousand-cut death, so it wouldn’t much matter if he was. If WWE signed Kenny Omega, they’d have him spamming the One-Winged Angel and looking shocked when it couldn’t put away Drew McIntyre.
Rollins does impressions of Brock Lesnar like a giant dork, which he punctuates with a witty zinger. Rollins says “Burn it down!” like he is Michael Cole. Rollins performs maudlin soliloquies as if he is sympathetic and beloved—like if we just got behind him, the Beastslayer who slayed the Beast at WrestleMania could slay the Beast at SummerSlam.
CONT'D...(1 of 5)
Rollins attacks guys with steel chairs backstage and says cool sh*t afterwards. Why, with a dry cool wit like that, Seth Rollins could be an action hero! Vince McMahon thinks, not realising it’s a f*cking Simpsons gag. Seth Rollins is reduced to a pathetic simpering wreck when confronted by The Fiend. He’s so scary! He does a pro wrestling hold that doesn’t actually kill people! Time to cry!
Seth Rollins cries. The man cries because he is scared. He’s a baby, all right, Jesus wept. The great, fearless babyface, who would rather get the sh*t beaten out of him than show cowardice, literally cowered in fear. Seth Rollins is the WWE 2K20 version of 2K15 Roman Reigns, and it is an outrageously awful bit of business. The fans wanted to cheer Seth Rollins. WWE pushed Seth Rollins. WWE turned Seth Rollins into a lamentable geek. He aims for Jon Snow, but he’s Theon Greyjoy, and Vince McMahon laughs with lis lopped-off c*ck in his hand. We’ll find that c*ck of yours in the next town, pal, he says, using that notorious Jedi mind trick.
??????
Profit.
And it’s not just Seth Rollins, and it’s not just the top babyface role. It’s every WWE babyface, and helpfully, Becky Lynch is the rule-proving exception.
CONT'D...(2 of 5)
Kevin Owens went from the next Stone Cold Steve Austin to a member of the PG Kiss My Ass club real quick. He didn’t pucker up and actually kiss Shane McMahon’s ass, but he did effectively beg for forgiveness. Shane “considered” the offer, and the storyline ultimately materialised in tedious lawsuit bullsh*t and another “firing” angle, which was of course reversed, because nobody ever got “fired” from WWE. It’s a recycled load of old !*$% that is even less believable in the wake of AEW. Kevin Owens is significantly colder than he was in July.
WWE wouldn’t fire Tamina in 2019, for f*ck’s sake, and we’re meant to believe that WWE would allow Kevin Owens to draw for another promotion?
WWE doesn’t merely ruin babyfaces throughout the course of its putrid, ineffective weekly television. There is no gravity to any of this: Kofi Kingston happily played with pancakes one week after the most profound humiliation of his career. WWE is an actual cartoon, in which the events of the previous week have no bearing on the next.
Ricochet is a superhero: 50/50 Man! Do you know that he is a superhero, only, one that exists in a real life? He is a real-life superhero. Hey kids, you like that Marvellous? Well, here’s a superhero, in the flesh!
Ali should watch his own vignettes. He could do with the inspiration. Rusev is going to get over on the strength of his *checks notes* tiny lil’ c*ck, which seems incongruous with the whole “larger than life” deal that tends to draw the public to stars. Braun Strowman? His throat gets those hands, because he’s a Championship match choke artist.
Chad—where are my manners—Shorty Gable is the latest victim of this malpractice.
CONT'D...(3 of 5)
He’s a tiny lil’ guy, but he’s got a big heart! is the premise of this storyline. It is also the premise of several sh*tty kid’s TV shows. This man is an Olympian athlete. His lack of height could be subtly sold in the context of commentary, to put over his sublime technical skill as all the more impressive. But no: Vince loves broad dumbass comedy, and you must like it too.
Daniel Bryan is our last hope, but what happened the last time he was a babyface? Hopes were high for Kevin Owens, and look what happened there. This company cannot book babyfaces.
Shorty ‘F*cking’ Gable, man. What next?
Fat Kev? Dork Rollins? It’s a wonder they didn’t call him Fúnn Bálor, because with that big beaming smile, he just loves to have fun out there!
Again, everything circles back to the same arguments because the company is in need of a complete systemic creative overhaul. WWE doesn’t book babyfaces. It writes for babyfaces. That is the problem.
WWE’s team of über-hack TV writers—if they were any good, they wouldn’t subject themselves to ungodly working hours and a 74 year-old lunatic blowing gaskets in their faces—attempt to apply inspirational TV narratives to the context of pro wrestling and it doesn’t work. At all. The plotting is all over the place and is scrawled everywhere except “the point”: Rollins is pathetic, not sympathetic. He’s lame; he isn’t cool. His eventual retribution always come off as petulant and detestable. He’s as much a dork as Michael Scott was, and he shares the same gift for ruining any currency he may have built by being a total d*ck.
WWE used to be good at this.
CONT'D...(4 of 5)
WWE used to be incredible at this. WWE built itself with this. Consider the obstacles placed in front of Hulk Hogan and Steve Austin: the twin referee shenanigans of Main Event and the convoluted scheme of Deadly Games were so devious and complex that Hogan and Austin weren’t remotely foolish for buying them. WWE—WWF—babyfaces used to be savvy. They used to be heroic. Badass. And now they are completely inept and uncool goobers.
How did WWE ruin its very core appeal?
Dave Meltzer put it best, when lamenting the grand failure to get Lars Sullivan over as a monster at Super ShowDown: Vince McMahon has forgotten how to ride a bike.
It is as stark and simple and troubling as that. This isn’t Vince being out of touch with modern trends. This is Vince totally losing it to an unrecoverable extent, powered by probable CTE and a loathing of his millennial roster, who he deems unambitious, but he also doesn’t allow for the agency of ambition.
And this isn’t default “cynicism” or “bias”, either. NWA Powerrr didn’t work for your writer—it rendered Jim Cornette’s “cosplay” rants deeply ironic—but it works for a sizeable, impressive audience. It is accomplishing something, and that is to be commended and praised objectively.
WWE crowds are dead. They are stone dead. They sit, with their arms folded, waiting for the bullsh*t. And then the bullsh*t happens, and they boo the bullsh*t. They’re holding out for a hero, a saviour, but that saviour is Steve Erkel.
Vince is wearin’ you down, baby! He’s wearin’ you down!