Impact's 'Who Shot John E. Bravo?' - Every Suspect Ranked

Who ruined the wedding of the century between John E. Bravo and Rosemary?

By Adam Morrison /

Two weeks ago marked the much-anticipated wedding between John E. Bravo and Rosemary on a special Halloween-themed edition of Impact Wrestling, a wedding that ended in controversy. It was a wrestling wedding, after all. It was never going to go according to plan.

Advertisement

However, no-one could have predicted what would have happened to the groom at the conclusion of the ceremony. The lights cut out, a bang was heard, and we came back to see Bravo laid out on the canvas, having been shot at his own wedding.

Madness.

Now, Impact are making a huge storyline out of it, as should always be the case when beginning a supernatural angle like this. Keep in mind, Impact are the promotion that made use of the Undead Realm in recent times, as we saw Allie literally killed off by the company when she signed with All Elite Wrestling last year. Who else can say they left a promotion through murder?

Detective Tommy Dreamer, in full Sherlock Holmes gear of course, is on the case to save Scott D'Amore the hassle of investigating it himself. 'The Innovator of Violence' has narrowed his case down to ten potential suspects, ranging from the wedding party to the minister to the bride herself.

Some have real reasons to have shot Bravo, others have minor issues with the groom, and some have no reason whatsoever...

10. Larry D

When the ten suspects Tommy Dreamer had narrowed his investigation down to were revealed, it was quite surprising to see Larry D in the bunch. Granted, he did very nearly steal Rosemary's heart away from Bravo in Wrestle House, but that was technically when he was under some sort of spell cast on him by 'The Demon Assassin' that saw him transform into Lawrence D.

Advertisement

In terms of the Larry D persona, all he's done to the former rogue referee is punch him in the jaw during the Call Your Shot Gauntlet Match. A simple punch. It didn't even knock him out.

Is that all Dreamer is using to justify Larry as a potential shooter?

If Bravo had been shot nearer the time of the whole Lawrence D schtick, then it would have certainly warranted the possibility of the XXXL member being included in the suspect lineup. Seeing as it's not the case, though, it's a safe bet he can be ruled out, and return to tag team competition with Acey Romero.

Chances of being guilty: Highly unlikely, unless Lawrence D makes a comeback

9. Cody Deaner

As with all the best weddings, John E. Bravo created a wedding party for the extravaganza, a party which Cody Deaner was a member of. Did the former Knockouts Champion (yes, really) take too kindly to his treatment from Bravo during this time?

Advertisement

Of course not. None of them did.

In fact, Cody noted at one point that he could have killed Bravo for the way he acted towards the Deaners member. Unlike Larry D, Cody has straight out said he would be willing to murder the former Impact official if need be.

Despite this, he still isn't a prime suspect. Cody Deaner is a country boy - he's not exactly going to back down from speaking his mind whenever and wherever he wants, and not everything he says should ever be taken literally.

If it has to be someone from the wedding party, why weren't Crazzy Steve and Alisha Edwards being investigated by Dreamer? Steve was yelled at by Bravo for failing to secure the correct wedding venue (keeping in mind the former Decay member is legally blind), while Edwards straight up didn't even want to help out with the wedding by the sounds of things.

Either of them would have made for viable suspects. Just not Cody Deaner.

Chances of being guilty: Unlikely, unless he had one too many Giv'Er beers

8. Brandon Tolle

It's not just members of the in-ring roster that are being investigated, as Impact's senior official Brandon Tolle has also been deemed a culprit by 'The Innovator of Violence'.

Advertisement

The man in stripes does technically have a reason to hold a grudge against John E. Bravo, seeing as Bravo called him out on his officiating skills during Fallah Bahh and Johnny Swinger's bout a few weeks ago. As a former referee himself - a rogue referee, but a referee nonetheless - Bravo knows poor officiating when he sees it.

Seeing as 'The Swing Man' only pinned Bahh after clocking him with Crazzy Steve's stuffed monkey, Bravo was right to call Tolle out on this and have the match restarted, even more so considering the match was to determine Bravo's best man for the wedding.

From this writer's perspective, you can sort of see a cold side to Brandon that would bring him to committing such an act. Keep in mind, though, he's a referee. Imagine if such an intense story that could very well create the next top Impact star culminated in a referee instead getting the rub.

Chances of being guilty: A possibility, although it would be a waste to have the culprit be a referee

7. Fallah Bahh

We're getting into the meat and potatoes of this ranking now, as Fallah Bahh seems to be the first here to properly have a genuine reason for why he would shoot John E. Bravo. He was fired from the position of Bravo's best man at the last minute, which came after the superheavyweight failed to present Bravo with the money he needed for the wedding.

Advertisement

Of course, Bahh was actually still in attendance at the wedding, sporting a Stay Puft marshmallow costume for no apparent reason.

Had Fallah not come out with the rest of the wedding guests, then he absolutely would have been higher up on this list. He hasn't always been one to hold grudges, but when you take into consideration the fact Bahh was confronted by Hernandez and Reno Scum before being fired, then you can completely understand why he would take it upon himself to take out John E. Bravo.

Then again, he's Fallah Bahh.

This is the guy who has forever been made a mockery. He's never been taken seriously, which, while it could make him far more guilty, actually adds together to make him less guilty than the following six entries on this list.

Chances of being guilty: A possibility, but don't bet your money on it

6. Johnny Swinger

Like Fallah Bahh, Johnny Swinger has never really been taken seriously since returning to Impact Wrestling, but for an entirely different reason. Simply put, 'The Swing Man' is a tad too full of himself to ever give a damn about anyone else's situation.

Advertisement

Just take a look at Wrestle House. Swinger spent the entire time in pursuit of his female roommates, namely Susie and Alisha Edwards. A Handicap Match against the pairing was the lowest of the low as it pertains to Wrestle House.

In terms of the wedding, though, Swinger very nearly became John E. Bravo's best man after it appeared as if he was victorious over Fallah Bahh after referee Brandon Tolle was blind to Swinger using nefarious means to secure victory. Even after Bahh was removed from that position next to Bravo, it was never made clear who had replaced him - it most certainly wouldn't have been Johnny Swinger, though.

Should Swinger be unveiled as the man behind the shooting, there's a higher chance of it being an accident as opposed to a planned out assassination attempt. The Locker Room Talk co-host has never been one to really think out a clever plan. His short-lived "partnerships" with Chris Bey and Willie Mack confirm this.

Chances of being guilty: A possibility, regardless of if it was intentional or accidental

5. Hernandez

We touched on it earlier, and now we dive into it properly.

Advertisement

Hernandez had his arm wrestling money stolen from him in order to help pay for the wedding. 'Supermex' was robbed by the then-best man Fallah Bahh whilst showering, a wad of cash that was then never actually presented to the groom in the end. Really, Hernandez's beef would be with Fallah Bahh, not with John E. Bravo. Up to this point, there isn't a single reason why the former LAX man would want to murder Bravo. Murdering Bahh on the other hand, possibly.

It's worth noting that out of everyone on this list, Hernandez is the only one who wasn't in attendance at the wedding, thus adding more fuel to the fire that is Hernandez being a murderer. But again, he's shown no intentions towards wanting to kill off Taya Valkyrie's former lackey.

The last we saw of Hernandez was when he was sent to John E. Bravo by Fallah Bahh. Fallah had admitted to stealing the money, but he only did so to lend a helping hand to Bravo. We saw Hernandez walk off-screen, presumably to find John E. Bravo, and that was that.

It's a possibility he went towards the wedding ceremony, but like with Brandon Tolle, it would be a tad boring to have Hernandez revealed as the culprit.

Chances of being guilty: Likely, even though he didn't need the money back

4. Father James Mitchell

Father James Mitchell doesn't technically have a reason as to why he would wish to take out John E. Bravo for good. However, it wouldn't be out of character whatsoever for him to do such a thing.

Advertisement

For as long as we've known him, Mitchell has been one of the most sadistic men to ever step foot inside an Impact ring. You don't exactly go about managing the likes of Abyss and Judas Mesias without being a sadist yourself. Going from accompanying 'The Monster' to playing a major role in the Undead Realm story arc the past few years was a natural leap for the former Sinister Minister.

That Mitchell was literally brought back from the dead in order to officiate the wedding ceremony is enough of a reason as any to put him up for investigation.

He'll be a tough cookie to crack, for sure. This is a man who just spent the majority of 2020 trapped in the Undead Realm. Why on earth would he then straight-up admit to attempting to murder John E. Bravo at the risk of spending another chunk of time behind bars?

Should Mitchell be involved in the story, it's far more likely he would have orchestrated the shooting for someone else to perform the actual shooting, but he remains a suspect regardless.

Chances of being guilty: Likely, simply because he's Father James Mitchell

3. Havok

Again, like Father James Mitchell, Havok doesn't necessarily have a strong reason as to why she would want to shoot John E. Bravo during his and Rosemary's wedding. But, the former Knockouts Champion could have easily taken him out in order to gain a bit of retribution (not that one) over 'The Demon Assassin'.

Advertisement

Keep in mind, Rosemary essentially pleaded for Havok to aid her in bringing Father James Mitchell back from the Undead Realm to oversee the wedding proceedings. Even though Havok had previously been aligned with Mitchell herself, she was visibly uneasy about bringing back one of Impact's most unpredictable personalities.

The thing is, Havok didn't have a choice. She lost to Rosemary cleanly, meaning she was forced to help turn her rival's wish into a reality.

It's entirely plausible that Havok would use such an event to get one back against the former Decay member. Throughout both of her stints in Impact Wrestling, she's never shied away from these big moments to get the fans talking about her. It's nowhere near on the same level, but this is the wrestler who gave Su Yung a top rope Tombstone Piledriver on to a pile of thumbtacks at last year's Slammiversary.

There are only a few steps between a super Tombstone and shooting someone, you know.

Chances of being guilty: Likely, mostly due to Father James Mitchell talking her into it

2. Rosemary

Why not?

Advertisement

During the entire relationship saga began between Rosemary and John E. Bravo, many, if not all, fans predicted that Bravo would come out the other end with his heart in pieces. After all, he's not really the man you would typically see someone like Rosemary dating and/or marrying.

Nonetheless, the two are now officially married, but that's not to say the former Knockouts Champion wouldn't still raise a gun to her husband's chest.

'The Demon Assassin' is more or less the entire reason for the Undead Realm story beginning in the first place. Allie, Su Yung, Father James Mitchell, Havok - they all came after Rosemary. It's been a tumultuous story arc, but perhaps we can now add John E. Bravo to that ensemble of characters.

It makes perfect sense for Rosemary to take out Bravo. Unlike John, Rosemary mostly wanted the wedding to go ahead simply so she could take a virgin soul. Granted, she seemed normal - as normal as a demon can be, anyway - at the actual wedding itself, but how is the audience supposed to know that this wasn't just a trick to throw us off course?

Out of everyone on this list, Rosemary and the following entry have the strongest reasons as to why they'd want to murder John E. Bravo.

Chances of being guilty: Very likely - all Rosemary ever wanted was Bravo's soul anyway

1. Taya Valkyrie

When John E. Bravo initially confessed his feelings for Rosemary, Taya Valkyrie was less than pleased. 'Wera Loca' had spent the past year or so using Bravo as her personal servant after the ex-referee had aligned himself with her and then-World Champion, Johnny Impact.

Advertisement

Now, add in the fact that, up to that point, Taya and Rosemary had never seen eye to eye with one another, and it makes the longest-reigning Knockouts Champion the prime suspect for attempting to murder John E. Bravo. If she can't have Bravo to herself (in a different way to Rosemary, mind you), then nobody can.

It must be noted that since Bravo proposed to Rosemary, Taya and Mrs. Bravo have been able to put their differences aside, and actually form an alliance, an alliance that could very well be in the running to capture the Knockouts Tag Team Championships this January. That's just not enough to rule Taya out as a suspect, however.

Prior to the wedding ceremony, Valkyrie made it crystal clear to Rosemary that John E. Bravo had become a complete lunatic since he proposed to 'The Demon Assassin'. Was this a clue from Taya before the shooting had even taken place?

Chances of being guilty: Almost certain. Babyface Taya Valkyrie is too good to be true after all

Advertisement