John Cena's 10 Most Shocking WWE Defeats

He's known for always overcoming the odds...but what about when he didn't?

By Chris Foale /

There€™s a key reason why John Cena is often referred to these days as €˜Big Match John€™. When the pressure is on, and expectations are at their highest, Cena usually delivers. Not only that, we know the Cenation leader lives and dies by his €˜Never Give Up€™ mantra. He has an entire legion of dedicated, young fans who adorn themselves with his t-shirt, hat and wristband uniform, who count on him to always defeat the latest evil that threatens his philosophy of Hustle, Loyalty and Respect. Whether it be battling factions, toppling giants or even taking on the entire roster, Cena always finds a way to dig deeper, fight harder and, no matter how high the odds are stacked against him, win. Except when he doesn€™t. Over his fourteen year WWE career, John Cena€™s phenomenal win/loss record has been lightly dashed with some rare defeats that have left us astonished, bewildered and in some cases, appalled. In a time where most other superstars are constantly trading victories, Cena has been heavily protected for over a decade. This makes him one of the few people who can still evoke a raw, stunned reaction from the crowd when he goes down and the referee's hand hits three. These are John Cena's ten most shocking losses...

Advertisement

10. Vs. John Laurinaitis - Over The Limit 2012

€œPeople Power!€ - Whilst John Laurinaitis€™ awkward microphone work and misguided sense of popularity were occasionally entertaining, by June 2012 the fans had grown truly tired of his presence on TV, and it was time for him to go. After Laurinaitis survived many previous close shaves with almost getting the chop, the stage was finally set at Over The Limit €“ John Cena vs. John Laurinaitis and if Laurinaitus loses, he would be fired on the spot. After Cena tormented him with trash cans, water bottles and fire extinguishers, Laurinaitis would try to escape the arena, only for Big Show (previously fired by Laurinaitis) to drag him back to the ring to receive his final comeuppance. However, once in the ring, Big Show would turn heel for what feels like the 327th time in his career and hit Cena with a K.O. punch. A full 1 minute 19 seconds later, Laurinaitis would cover Cena and get the three count. Fans left bewildered as to why Cena couldn€™t kick out after so long, and would have to wait a whole month before Laurinaitis would finally meet his end.

9. Vs. The Great Khali - Saturday Night's Main Event 2007

Before The Great Khali became the loveable €˜Punjabi Playboy€™ we know and love(?) today, WWE were intent on pushing him to the very top of the card as an unstoppable monster. He already held pinfall victories over the likes of Kane and even The Undertaker, and was now due to take on John Cena for the WWE Title at One Night Stand. Before then however, they would first meet one on one at Saturday Night€™s Event. Although Cena would try everything he could to topple the giant, Khali used continuous chops, clotheslines, chops and€more chops to beat Cena down, before easily putting him away using the two handed Chokeslam. Shockingly, Khali managed to pin Cena with nothing more than a single foot on his chest, making this almost the most one-sided loss of Cena€™s career.

8. Vs. Daniel Bryan - SummerSlam 2013

A top contender for Match of the Year 2013, this clash arrived with heavy anticipation. The incredibly popular Daniel Bryan was finally getting a main event opportunity after months of unrelenting support from fans - in the main event of the 26th annual SummerSlam no less, against the company€™s top star for the WWE Championship. For Bryan to even be placed in this position was thrilling for the fans, but the idea of him actually defeating Cena was still a long way off, even with reports circulating of Cena possibly needing time off for an elbow injury. The ensuing match was a spectacular fight, including a slap battle taken straight from the books of traditional Japanese contests and heart-stopping near-falls. The idea of Daniel Bryan actually pulling off the victory was becoming real. Perhaps he would score a lucky roll-up or reverse the STF, trapping Cena in a pin? In the end, Daniel Bryan flattened Cena with a running knee, a finisher he hadn€™t used until then, and pinned him in the middle of the ring. The fact that not only did Daniel Bryan do the unthinkable by defeating John Cena, but to do it in such decisive fashion was flabbergasting. The crowd reflected this with their stunned silence, before jubilance took over. Although what happened next often eclipses this match, Bryan€™s victory here remains a rare clean loss for Cena.

7. Vs. Kevin Federline - Monday Night Raw 2007

Who?!? Back in 2007, Kevin Federline was a notorious rapper (kind of), dancer (sort of) and husband to Britney Spears (not for long). Not a wrestler. However, with a reputation for being particularly arrogant and self entitled, deserved or not, WWE saw a great business opportunity and brought him in as a special guest on Raw one week, receiving an AA from John Cena at the end of the show. This created headlines all over America, and so €˜K-Fed€™ was invited back for a heavily promoted no disqualification match against Cena on the first Raw of 2007. With Cena being twice the size of Federline, many expected this to be a 30 second squash. However, various shenanigans including interference from Johnny Nitro and Umaga left Cena on the ground long enough for the non-wrestling, nine and a half stone rapper Kevin Federline to steal the three count, to the utter disdain of the crowd.

6. Vs. The Miz - WrestleMania XXVII 2011

The year was 2011, CM Punk was yet to drop his infamous pipe-bomb, The Rock had just returned from a seven-year absence and The Miz was our WWE Champion. Since October the year prior, it seemed The Miz was on borrowed time until John Cena (who was undefeated in one on one singles action at WrestleMania) would inevitably take the championship from him on the grandest stage of them all. Not the case. In one of the flattest main events in WrestleMania history, which involved The Miz getting concussed and ending in a double count out, The Rock would restart the match only to confusingly Rock Bottom Cena, allowing Miz to gain the pinfall straight after, costing Cena the title he€™d already failed to win. The Rock would then pose for the bewildered crowd who had just seen the mid-card-at-best heel Miz defeat the top babyface John Cena in the MAIN EVENT of WrestleMania. Wow.

5. Vs. Kevin Owens - Elimination Chamber 2015

Kevin Owens and John Cena had been exchanging words for weeks beforehand, with Owens debuting on Raw and interrupting Cena€™s U.S. Title Open Challenge, only to refuse to fight him until the Elimination Chamber pay-per-view. Many regard the resulting match as a top contender for match of the year. Owens hung with Cena throughout the entire 20+ minute contest, each trading signature moves with Owens even hitting the AA on Cena himself. It would be Kevin€™s own Pop-Up Powerbomb though that would ultimately defeat Cena cleanly. An NXT star arriving on the main roster and beating the top star in their first match was unprecedented, and although Owens would end up losing the other two of their PPV matches, it firmly put him on the map.

4. Vs. Edge - New Year's Revolution 2006

John Cena€™s very first WWE title reign in 2005 was long. So long in fact, that by January the following the year, the fans had revolted entirely against him, audibly booing him at every show and actively cheering all those he faced, heel or not. The Elimination Chamber match at New Year€™s Revolution was no exception, with the entire crowd relentlessly booing Cena throughout the entire match, going into overdrive when Cena inevitably won the match with an underwhelming roll up on Carlito. Then it happened. Directly after the match, Edge would cash in the first ever Money In The Bank contract won the year before and stole the title from Cena after two consecutive Spears. This strategy has been replicated a dozen times since, but none have captured the sheer shock and unpredictability factor that Edge successfully pulled off ten years ago.

3. Vs. CM Punk - Money In The Bank 2011

The championship match between John Cena and CM Punk in Chicago is possibly the most controversial title match in WWE history not involving a certain Canadian in pink tights. In front of a mercilessly hostile crowd, Cena was to defend his title against the hometown hero and if he were to lose, not only would he be fired, CM Punk would leave the whole company with championship in hand, as his contract would be expiring that night. Life was imitating art here €“ Punk really WAS set to leave the company at midnight, and had cut a historic, scathing promo a few weeks prior where he aired his grievances and reasons for leaving the company live on RAW. No one knew for sure what was going to happen on this night. The two fought for over half an hour and rocked the house, with fans never giving up hope that Punk would somehow pull the heist off. After interference from Vince McMahon backfired, Punk did the unthinkable and got the three count on Cena, following a GTS. He escaped through the crowd, dodging a Money in the Bank cash in attempt and blowing Vince a kiss along the way, leaving everyone with one question - what next??

2. Vs. Sheamus - Tables, Ladders And Chairs 2009

In late 2009, John Cena had just come off from a five month long rivalry with Randy Orton, surviving with the WWE Title throughout Hell in a Cell, I Quit and Iron Man matches. Sheamus on the other hand, a relative unknown at the time, had just been recently drafted from ECW to Raw and was hungry to prove himself. After winning a battle royal to become number one contender for the WWE title to many's surprise, he went on to face Cena in a Tables match for the title at TLC. After such a gruelling feud with Orton, everyone dismissed this match as a simple palette-cleanser before Cena would be launched into his next title programme for WrestleMania. However, during the match, after a top-rope-tussle which didn€™t go in Cena€™s favour, he crashed straight through a table in the middle of the ring. Following a few seconds of confusion, Sheamus was announced as the new WWE Champion and his music began playing. For a wrestler to win the world title after just a few weeks on the main roster, despite the circumstances, was completely unheard of, especially against the face of the company. This however, still wouldn€™t be Cena€™s most shocking title defeat..

1. Vs. Brock Lesnar - SummerSlam 2014

Brock Lesnar. The Beast Incarnate. The Conqueror. Introduced as The Authority€™s €œdangerous and uncomfortable Plan C€, the main event for SummerSlam was set: John Cena vs Brock Lesnar for the WWE World Heavyweight Championship. The last time these two met, Cena took a bloody and brutal beating - but ultimately got the victory. We all knew Cena was in for the fight of his life again this time, however nobody could have predicted what would happen that night. Yes, Brock won, and whilst Lesnar defeating Cena may not be too surprising in of itself, the way in which Lesnar relentlessly man-handled and disposed of Cena was utterly astonishing. Countless punches. Two F-5€™s. Sixteen German suplexes. With no trademark comeback from Cena in return, no overcoming of odds and no answer to Lesnar€™s brutality, this was the most shocking defeat in John Cena€™s historic career.