Lucha Underground's 34 Wrestlers - Ranked From Worst To Best

By Matt O'Connell /

25. Killshot

Pros: - Taller than the other luchadors (according to Matt Striker) - Worked well with Big Ryck and the Mack - Has a boat-load of gun taunts to fall back on Cons: - Looks like a living Rob Liefeld character - It's not 1992 - Rob Liefeld sucked even in 1992 Killshot came to the Temple as part of Big Ryck's tríos team along with the Mack, and the latter's combination of personality and athleticism quickly made him the breakout star of the team. Since then, Killshot has struggled to find a niche for himself, with somewhat limited success. He's clearly not on the aerial level of the AAA imports, and he doesn't have the freakshow athleticism of U.S. indy guys like Cage or the Mack. Trouble is, there isn't anything superlative about Killshot. He's not the fastest, or the strongest, or the best flyer. He's not the meanest, smartest, or most cunning, either. So far the only thing the announcers have consistently pointed out is that he normally enjoys a height and reach advantage, and main, that's just not enough to hang your mask on. Final Rating: ***

24. Jack Evans

Pros: - Is apparently lighter than air - Sells every move done to him like death - Medallion winner Cons: - Very late season one arrival - Not teamed with Angelico for some reason - They still wear matching pants Jack Evans is kind of the perfect lucha libre heel: a smarmy, self-aggrandizing white dude who rubs everyone the wrong way by saying he's the best at lucha libre, while simultaneously being kind of the best at lucha libre. The physical aspects, at least; he could probably do a triple rotation moonsault inside an airplane bathroom, but he couldn't care less about the really important stuff, like respect and tradition and whatever dude, do you see what Evans just did? In AAA, he's been a championship tag team partner with Angelico, but that tandem hasn't been seen yet inside the temple. That's likely for the best, at least for now; Angelico's firmly established as a major babyface, while Evans is absolutely KILLING it as an ur-athletic gringo scumbag. Final Rating: ***1/4

23. Ivelisse

Pros: - 1/3 of the inaugural tríos champions - Appeared on Tough Enough and NXT - Trained by Carlos Colón and Savio Vega Cons: - Owner of the shrillest voice this side of Vickie Guerrero - Spent much of the season with a leg injury - Still abrasive as a babyface Ivelisse is the self-proclaimed "baddest b*tch in the building", and at first that sounded like an empty boast. She spent most of her time brow-beating a sullen Son of Havoc and looking terrible in sexual harassment-themed matches with Angelico. Since the three of them found themselves forced into teaming, however, Ivelisse has blossomed into an incredibly competent team captain, a position which utilizes her extreme bossiness and shrill voice to their maximum potential. She's also shown extreme heart, defending her tríos championship alongside her partners despite a shattered ankle. I mean, the lady won a ladder match for her team despite having a big damn cast around one of her legs. She eventually took the fall in the match that cost her team their titles, but not before fighting one-legged for several minutes and trying to brain the opponent's manager with a mystical death rock. So, "baddest b*tch in the building?" Yeah, maybe. Final Rating: ***1/4

22. Blue Démon, Jr.

Pros: - Heir to one of the greatest lucha libre legacies of all time - Former NWA and AAA champion - Currently heading up some kind of lucha mafia with Chavo Guerrero Cons: - Has only appeared a few times - Nearing 50 - Cannot compete with the younger talent Blue Démon, Jr. is the most traditional luchador on the LU roster, the adopted son and namesake of the original Leyenda Azúl. He's also the Original Rudo; his father was originally a blood rival of El Santo, Mexico's biggest wrestling hero of all time, and that evil is a part of him as well. He's spent the majority of season one entangled with the affairs of Chavo Guerrero, defeating him in episode one, being nearly murdered by him in episode two, and returning to attack him for revenge during Aztec Warfare. He was supposedly pulling the strings behind the scenes during Chavo's exile from Mexico, but as of the season finale the two have patched up their differences and aligned with the Crew to form some kind of lucha mafia, maybe? It's super unclear, but that's the best possible use of Blue Démon at this point. The guy is almost 50, and he's realistically no match for LU's younger stars. Casting him as the Mexican HHH with his own personal Authority is a smart move. Final Rating: ***1/2

21. Pimpinela Escarlata

Pros: - Really good at armdrags - You might even call him a drag queen - DID YOU SEE WHAT I DID THERE Cons: - Seriously, 90% of his offense is armdrags - The other 10% is kissing you and hoping you panic - To recap: his moveset is 90% armdrags and 10% sexual assault Did you know that lucha libre has a character type called the exótico? They dress in women's clothing, especially old-timey showgirly stuff, and flirt with their opponents. There's often discussion about whether their behavior is genuine or psychological warfare, designed to put homophobic opponents off their game. That's right, it's an entire division of Goldusts, and Pimpi is their queen. Though he's one of the more successful exóticos of all time, Pimpinela Escarlata doesn't have a lot to fall back on in terms of in-ring maneuvers. He's got a heck of an armdrag, though, and his apparently uniformly homophobic opponents can be counted on to hurl themselves bodily from the ring to avoid being kissed by him. He even kissed a Disciple of Death, and the guy took a bump like he got shot in the chest by a cannonball. Final Rating: ***1/2

20. Aerostar

Pros: - Next-level springboard and tope ability - Medallion winner - Perhaps the world's most impressive trust-faller Cons: - Owner of wrestling's least specific hometown - Is he an astronaut or an alien? - Struggled against high-level opponents The Man from the Cosmos is an astronaut, maybe, which he illustrates primarily by having a mask that vaguely resembles a space helmet, and also springboarding opponents to death like he ain't even care. The guy doesn't go in for any of the more Byzantine aerial acrobatics favored by his peers. Instead, he just blasts off wayyyy into the ether without looking and somehow always finds his mark. It's incredible. Aerostar was also part of Lucha Underground's most storied rivalries in season one, a best-of-five series with the reptilian wrestler known as Drago. Although Aerostar ultimately came up short in that rivalry, it gave him the time and exposure to establish a foothold with the Temple faithful, and he has been a fan favorite since then. He's battles rudos like Jack Evans and Johnny Mundo with varying degrees of success, but he did capture one of Dario Cueto's seven medallions in the home stretch of season one. He also seems to have made some sort of alliance with former rival Drago. Final Rating: ***3/4

19. Hernandez

Pros: - Multiple tag team championship reigns in the past - Great mainstream exposure from TNA - Perfect LU heel Cons: - May or may not be PLAYING a heel - Notoriously sloppy and lazy - Doesn't believe in dragons Hernandez inadvertently became the biggest heel in Lucha Underground by playing his standard babyface character in a promotion where good guys try hard and care about things. Because the writers of the show also try hard and care about things, he was quickly repackaged as the worst person in the world, a self-centered goon who disrespected lucha tradition and said dragons aren't real. Whether or not the actual worker felt he was too good for Lucha Underground and determined to mail it in is anyone's guess, but the guy got nuclear heat when that became his official character. From whining to Dario Cueto about not getting immediate championship matches to his constant pimp-strutting, he was the absolute perfect heel for the LU universe. Fittingly, he was sent packing by Drago -- whose traditional lucha libre silliness and Cinderella Man narrative marked him as Hernandez' foil -- and the Temple denizens themselves in a combination leather strap/lumberjack match. He got belted so hard in the face that it looked like he was wearing a damn red headband, and shipped off to TNA, who shipped him off to who knows where. Sometimes a guy is perfect for a role, and Hernandez was perfect for this. Final Rating: ***3/4

18. Chavo Guerrero, Jr.

Pros: - Last scion of the Guerrero dynasty - Championship runs in WCW, WWE and TNA - Twenty years of pro experience Cons: - Very few appearances throughout the season - Poor win/loss record - Injured his leg in his biggest LU match If you want a good idea of how much of a disappointment pre-Lucha Chavo was, consider this: when Eddie Guerrero died, Chavo couldn't even claim to be the most prominent, charismatic member of the family because of Eddie's widow was too good at yelling. Outside the temple, he's the blandest possible luchador with nothing but a famous last name to his credit, hoping you don't notice he's terrified of failure and ignominity. Inside the Temple, he's that same thing, but on purpose. He came to cement his legacy, but he€™s Chavo Guerrero and so he doesn€™t have one. He lost to Blue Démon in the promotion€™s very first match, and Dario Cueto straight up told him he€™s a miserable failure and a disappointment to his family. In response, Chavo went nuts and nearly killed Sexy Star and Blue Démon with a chair, laughing all the while. He spent much of the rest of the season terrified of retribution from the lucha libre community, and confused about why his heel turn didn't make him feared and respected. Even after a literal lifetime in wrestling, Chavo still has no sense of personal identity. Even after this latest attempt at violent self-actualization, he€™s still playing a role and he can only understand himself in terms of wrestling storyline tropes. I don't know about you, but that's certainly the most genuine enjoyment I've ever gotten out of Chavito. Final Rating: ***3/4

17. The Crenshaw Crew

Pros: - The most consistent heel threat on the show - Extremely good team chemistry - Much more effective and brutal than most villainous henchmen Cons: - Often get distracted by their own cruelty - They get passed around a lot - One of them was literally killed onscreen Cortez Castro, Mr. Cisco and Bael have been the most consistent threat to the babyfaces of Lucha Underground since episode one, and they're not afraid to switch allegiances when it benefits them. They originally backed Big Ryck before switching to Dario Cueto, who subsequently bequeathed them to Chavo Guerrero. And, uh, Blue Démon. They get around is my point. It's refreshing to see heel enforcers that can actually -- if only occasionally -- defeat our heroes. Compared with Jamie Noble and Joey Mercury they're the Steiner Brothers, but they've lost to the faces exactly as much as they've won, which is why Bael got his face smashed in by Dario Cueto's deformed cage monster brother and died. Lucha Underground is kind of an intense show, if you hadn't noticed. Final Rating: ****

16. Angélico

Pros: - Trained by Booker T - Capable of daredevil leaps that make Jeff Hardy look like Duane Gill - 1/3 of the inaugural tríos champions Cons: - Kind of the worst actor of all time - Goes to the well too often with his unreal leaps - The whole weird sexual harassment match thing Angélico is a legitimate international superstar and maybe the best pure athlete in the promotion, but he's also a petulant teen trapped in the body of a gangly, sexually aggressive super soldier. You take the good with the bad with Angélico. He started out as victim #3 in a four-way match also involving Cage, but first really became notable during a program with Son of Havoc and Ivelisse where he refused to take her seriously and kept grinding up on her. He was ostensibly the babyface, and it was terrible. As soon as he found himself teaming with his former enemies, though, he suddenly became a SUPER FACE who will leap off of anything and everything to protect his friends. He's still an obnoxious twerp dressed in motocross pants for no reason, but his actual flight powers (and his exemplary striking skills) have made him an irreversible fan favorite. Final Rating: ****