Lucha Underground's 34 Wrestlers - Ranked From Worst To Best

By Matt O'Connell /

5. Prince Puma

Pros: - Inaugural Lucha Underground champion - Defeated all comers for the better part of a year - Can throw a 630° splash Cons: - Has taken a number of non-title losses - Has had trouble tempering his unbridled athleticism with experience and skill - Relied heavily on Konnan Prince Puma is the inaugural, reigning and defending champion of Lucha Underground, and he's functionally the face of the company. He won the title in January and has been turning away challengers ever since, putting away Johnny Mundo, Fénix, Drago, Hernandez and about a dozen others. Through all his defenses, he's proven exemplary at forging a connection with the audience, despite the fact that he's yet to speak a single word. Under the mask is indy standout Ricochet, possibly the flippiest wrestler on the planet. He throws 450° splashes as transitional moves, because he's reached some heretofore unknown level of high-flying skill and can throw in an additional 180°. While that maneuver proved absolutely bulletproof for his entire championship reign, it was not enough to put away Mil Muertes, and Puma ended Ultima Lucha as the first-ever former Lucha Underground champion. Final Rating: ****3/4

4. Johnny Mundo

Pros: - Winner of Tough Enough season one - Former intercontinental, ECW and tag team champion in WWE - Doing the best heel work of his career Cons: - Still hasn't won a promotion's major championship - Still struggles with promos - Somewhat overshadowed by the arrival of Alberto El Patrón Johnny Mundo, AKA WWE's John Morrison, has been quietly doing the best work of his career within the Temple's walls. In WWE, Mundo's work always seemed disjointed, but in retrospect that probably had more to do with the standard of competition he faced there. Mundo's a complete one-off when it comes to movement, whereas guys like the Miz are trained to wrestle a second, hypothetical Miz. When Mundo doesn't have to slow down every twenty seconds so Ted DiBiase can grab a chinlock and suck wind, he's an absolute marvel. Over the course of season one, Johnny's also embrace his long-neglected dark side. He came in to LU as a babyface, because that's how he left WWE, but come on. He's this ridiculous Adonis with rock star hair and a chinchilla coat that stars in straight-to-DVD films about wrestling dogs. At this point, he's the best possible version of himself, and also the best possible version of the Miz. Final Rating: ****3/4

3. Mil Muertes

Pros: - Twenty years of experience wrestling in Puerto Rico, Mexico and the U.S. - Most AAA Mega championship reigns in history - Current Lucha Underground champion Cons: - Has been defeated in several big match situations - Defeatead by Fenix in Grave Consequences - Already 40 years old Mil Muertes is an inspired throwback, an extinct species brought back to life because BD Wong extracted 1960€™s luchador DNA trapped within amber. In a promotion full of insanely athletic young luchadors, Mil Muertes stands out by lumbering around menacingly and countering corkscrew planchas with measured haymakers. Under the mask is longtime journeyman grappler Ricky Banderas, perhaps best known in the U.S. as Abyss' disappointing brother, Judas Mesias. As Muertes, however, he's magnetic. It's as if the first two decades of his career were a protracted Husky Harris period, and he's Bray Wyatt out of nowhere. He's still no technical wizard, but Lucha Underground doesn't ask him to work a breathless reversal sequence, it asks him to loom menacingly out of the shadows like he's Orson Welles in Othello. After nearly a year of being the most impressive figure on the show, Mil Muertes finally captured the Lucha Underground championship in the main event of Ultima Lucha. Final Rating: *****

2. Fénix

Pros: - Won LU's undisputed match of the year - Current Gift of the Gods champion - Only 24 years old Cons: - Missed much of the late season - Seems trapped in an unending duel with Mil Muertes - Wait, that's not a bad thing, those matches were all amazing Basically ever since Rey Mysterio began to seem less like superhero than a tired dad, much ink has been spilled on the topic of who, if anyone, can be the next Rey Mysterio. We know now that is sure wasn't Sin Cara, and WWE is banking on it being Kalisto, but I'll let you in on a little secret: it's Fénix. It's Fénix, and the people who disagree with that sentiment are split neatly into two categories: people who haven't seen Fénix work, and Kalisto's mom. It's not just his aerial skill, though he is an astonishing athlete; although LU boasts guys that can jump higher or tuck more rotations into a plancha, no one brings all of those elements together with the heart and fighting spirit Fénix has. In that sense, Fénix has as much in common with guys like Sami Zayn and Daniel Bryan as he does with his fellow luchadors, and the uncanny sympathy he commands from an audience is what makes him a worthy successor to Mysterio. Fénix is also the inaugural Gift of the Gods champion, a title he won by uniting the seven Aztec medallions that he and others had been compiling for months. Now, he seems destined for yet another collision with Mil Muertes, now the Lucha Underground champion. Life and death. Lucha libre sure does paint with broad strokes. Final Rating: *****

1. Pentagón, Jr.

Pros: - Possibly the best active heel in pro wrestling - Breaks suckas' arms as part of a karate voodoo sacrifice - Has zero fear. ¡CERO MIEDO! Cons: - Had a fairly weak early season - Surprisingly, has never challenged for the LU championship - Slightly disappointing reveal of his master The story of Pentagón, Jr. in Lucha Underground has been that of a man driven to excellence by cruel purpose. In the early weeks, Pentagón suffered the worst indignities of any luchador not named "Son of Havoc," but soon found terrifying new purpose under the tutelage of an unseen dark master. Since his dark apprenticeship began, Pentagón has been an absolute beast, breaking the arms of five different opponents, enjoying a months-long undefeated streak, and trying to set Vampiro on fire at ringside. He's like Kevin Owens, Brock Lesnar, and Mortal Kombat's Scorpion rolled into one wonderful, wonderful skeleton ninja. At Ultima Lucha, he added classic hardcore violence to his arsenal of deadly competencies, alongside gnarly submissions, killer strikes, and vicious suplexes. He utterly destroyed Vampiro and broke his arm, with the slightly disappointing reveal that Vampiro had been his master all along. Even so, Pentagón stood revealed as a man who works in violence the way other artists might use oils. He's simply incredible. Final Rating: *****