NXT TakeOver: Chicago II - Every Match Ranked From Worst To Best
Gargano and Ciampa steal the show (duh).
NXT TakeOver: Chicago II is proof perfect of the fact that even when NXT doesn't serve up an absolute home-run of a show packed with four-star bangers, the quality of the wrestling across-the-board is still shockingly consistent, especially in comparison to WWE's main roster events.
Aside from the spectacular final match, this was a good-to-great show for the most part, hampered somewhat by the overwhelming predictability of practically every single result. Ultimately, however, satisfying storytelling and electric in-ring action trumps shock value for the mere sake of it (take note, WWE).
Fans will obviously be talking about and dissecting that Johnny Gargano-Tommaso Ciampa main event for months to come, though the rest of the card also ensured that Chicago II was a worthwhile sit, with most of the featured talents bolstering their skills in front of a crowd that couldn't have been more into it.
Again, not quite a classic NXT show, but still unlikely to be bested by what Money in the Bank serves up...
5. NXT Women's Title: Shayna Baszler (C) Vs. Nikki Cross
Result: Baszler chokes Cross out to retain the strap (9:25).
Rating: This was a solid, physical title match bolstered by strong psychology, even if Baszler's in-ring style ultimately isn't that interesting. Still, they sensibly kept things brief, allowing both competitors to get in, do their thing and get out.
The ending definitely threatened to be silly with Cross smiling before passing out, but it basically worked and added yet another layer to her character.
The real story here, of course, is that Cross is most likely due to be imminently called up to the main roster, and if so, this was a fine way to play her out. 6/10
4. NXT Title: Aleister Black (C) Vs. Lars Sullivan
Result: Black retains the title after nailing Sullivan with the Black Mass several times (14:07).
Rating: Not a classic NXT Title match by any means, but it basically delivered on expectations, with Sullivan playing the big-man part superbly while Black once again convinced as the tenacious, unstoppable champ.
Like almost the entire card there wasn't much to be surprised by, but the pacing was great, it was hard-hitting and the selling throughout was terrific (especially from Black).
That final moment made Sullivan look like an absolute monster even in defeat, so both men managed to come out of this looking fantastic even if it wasn't all that memorable as a title match. 7/10
3. Ricochet Vs. Velveteen Dream
Result: Ricochet kills Dream with the 630 for the win (22:10).
Rating: This match was strangely laid out, with a surprisingly slow and grounded opening, but built to be a highly entertaining, fast-paced fight where either man could've satisfactorily won.
Ricochet continues to prove himself to be one of the world's best at what he does, while Dream again cements that he's one of NXT's most intriguing personalities (and a damn fine wrestler to boot).
The match ran far longer than expected, perhaps a tad too long ultimately. It mercifully wasn't the quick sprint many were expecting, but it felt a bit long in the tooth by the end, and Dream's knees-up counter in the final stretch was embarrassingly telegraphed.
Still, a ton of fun, though proof that sometimes less is more. 7/10
2. NXT Tag Titles: The Undisputed Era (C) Vs. Oney Lorcan & Danny Burch
Result: Strong pins Lorcan after Strong and O'Reilly nail him with a devastating high-low to retain the titles (16:00).
Rating: While it wasn't ever particularly convincing that Era could lose this match, both teams did a remarkable job creating a sense of desperation regardless.
Lorcan and Burch proved themselves more than deserving of a prime-time title match and quickly won the crowd over, even if Era were always going to be the stars of the show.
It was just a superbly contested match throughout: Lorcan landing on the apron was especially nasty, and that double submission was so good it almost convinced the crowd the challengers could win. A red-hot opener if there ever was one. 8/10
1. Chicago Street Fight: Johnny Gargano Vs. Tommaso Ciampa
Result: Ciampa drills Gargano with a DDT onto the ring's exposed wood for the win (35:29).
Rating: This was pretty much exactly what fans were expecting and hoping for, somehow fully living up to the enormousness of their New Orleans match while elevating the physicality with the added stipulation.
This match was savage, full of wince-inducing spots, and while it fell short of being a technical classic, was anyone really expecting that? The long run-time only added to the epic feel of the bout, and that murderous final stretch was absolutely fantastic.
The Ciampa win may have been predictable even as things got increasingly dicey for him at the very end, but his means of victory was great for his character, and it was the right story to tell regardless of it being fairly obvious.
Quite how this pair are going to manage to top this in the future is anyone's guess. Good luck, guys. 9/10
-
What did you think of NXT TakeOver: Chicago II? Shout it out in the comments!