NXT TakeOver: Philadelphia - Every Match Ranked From Worst To Best

The best NXT main event in a long time.

By Jack Pooley /

WWE.com

NXT once again set the bar high on a WWE pay-per-view weekend with another riveting TakeOver show, which delivered the incredible drama, storytelling and insane athleticism fans expect while setting up some hugely exciting matches for the New Orleans show before WrestleMania.

Advertisement

Though one title match fell more than a little short of the mark, the two most anticipated bouts met or exceeded expectations, with the NXT Title main event proving to be one of the brand's strongest matches from at least the last year, if not more.

It may not have been an all-timer NXT PPV overall, but it delivered above and beyond where it really mattered, and continues to cement NXT as a refreshing alternative to WWE's oft-infuriating booking and, well, the inevitably of Roman Reigns becoming the Most Powerful Wrestler Ever when he beats Brock clean for the strap at Mania.

Advertisement

Between this, NJPW's New Beginning in Sapporo and the Royal Rumble, it's one hell of a weekend to be a wrestling fan...

5. NXT Women's Title: Ember Moon (C) Vs. Shayna Baszler

WWE.com

Result: Ember rolls Shayna up to retain the strap (10:06).

Advertisement

Rating: Nothing in this match was better than Mauro referencing kids eating tide pods at the beginning. Any attempt to make a story out of Shayna working the arm fell flat after Ember nailed the Eclipse and didn't make the pin afterwards due to her arm injury...yet could withstand literally minutes of being locked in an armbar later on.

It just felt poorly thought-out and more like the nonsensical booking you'd expect to see on a WWE PPV. Ember's lucky win at least made Shayna look strong even in defeat, but honestly, they both deserved better; the match was too short, and the arm work went on way too long to be entertaining.

Advertisement

This was arguably one of the most disappointing TakeOver matches in years due to the dumdum booking. 5/10

4. Kassius Ohno Vs. Velveteen Dream

WWE.com

Result: Dream kills Ohno with the Purple Rainmaker for the win (10:45).

Advertisement

Rating: Velveteen Dream continues to prove why he's one of NXT's most promising and entertaining rising stars in a match that offered few surprises and lacked a little in the chemistry department, but was still a solid bout all the same.

It was never better than its red-hot start, and it's fair to say that the rest of the match could've been tidier given the number of botches. Things didn't gel quite how you might've hoped, but it was a decent see-saw match regardless, and did exactly what it needed to. 6/10

Advertisement

3. NXT Tag Titles: The Undisputed Era (C) Vs. The Authors Of Pain

WWE.com

Result: O'Reilly rolls up Akam to retain the titles (14:50).

Advertisement

Rating: This was a great showing from both teams, especially when it came to selling and ensuring each other looked as credible as possible. The Authors of Pain continue to show improvement and this was certainly one of their better NXT matches to date.

It was a physical, energetic opener that didn't outstay its welcome and had the crowd buzzing throughout, even if the final sequence was disappointingly sloppy.

Advertisement

Still, this could mean an imminent main roster call-up for the Authors, which on the basis of their work here they're more than ready for. 7/10

2. Extreme Rules: Aleister Black Vs. Adam Cole

WWE.com

Result: Black ends Cole with the Black Mass for the win (22:02).

Advertisement

Rating: The crowd were red hot from the outset for this fast-paced, brutal slugfest, so it's no surprise they called "bulls***" on having a medical stoppage in an Extreme Rules match, especially one taking place in Philly no less.

That tone-deaf moment aside, Black and Cole really brought everything they had here, with an intensity that sold the desperation to win throughout. It probably didn't need the run-in shenanigans from the Era and Sanity, but for the most part it did a great job delivering a savage car wreck match within the constraints of the PG Era. 8/10

Advertisement

1. NXT Title: Andrade "Cien" Almas (C) Vs. Johnny Gargano

WWE.com

Result: Almas nails a Draping Hammerlock DDT to retain the title (32:19).

Advertisement

Rating: NXT PPV main events have a tendency to fall a tad short of the mark, but this was absolutely fantastic and easily one of the best in a long, long time.

From the stiff work that kicked things off to the almost unbearably tense counters and kick-outs later on, not to mention Zelina's interference leading to the pay-off that was Candice LeRae getting involved, it was a dynamic, consistently thrilling bout.

Advertisement

The finish could've been stronger and many fans were clearly mad about the result, but at least they didn't go the most predictable route of having Ciampa show up to cost Gargano the win (they saved that for the post-match).

With an epic length and stellar physical showing from both men, it could've gone either way and still been a top-tier NXT main event. 9/10

Advertisement

-

How would you rate NXT TakeOver: Philadelphia? Shout it out in the comments!

Advertisement