Ranking 10 WCW Stars' First Major WWE Matches

After the WCW bubble burst, just how did these guys fare in WWE?

By Jamie Kennedy /

It's hard to put into words for the younger generation just how massive a moment it was when Vince McMahon was addressing fans on Raw in Cleveland, Ohio, also appearing on the big screen at WCW Monday Nitro in Panama City, Florida on March 26, 2001. That date was the final episode of World Championship Wrestling flagship telecast, and the show was notable for ending with a match between two men who perhaps personified the promotion more than any other, Ric Flair and Sting. McMahon announced on the show that he had bought WCW, and now held the fate of the company in his very hands - it was groundbreaking news, and history in the making. Finally, in 2015, it seems like Sting will have his first match in WWE. It's been a long time coming, many fans felt he'd surely make the jump once McMahon bought over his competition, but instead, The Stinger elected not to complete under the WWE banner. Over the next few years following 2001, many of his WCW peers did make the switch, some of whom had previously been WWE employees anyway. This list looks to explore 10 big WCW stars, and their first major singles matches in WWE, whether they were returning heroes, or wrestlers heading into the unknown.

10. DDP (vs. The Undertaker) - King Of The Ring 2001

When Diamond Dallas page was revealed as the mysterious character who had been stalking The Undertaker's then-wife, Sara, the wrestling world exploded. Page had been a huge name in WCW, and fans were thrilled at the prospect of seeing the hard-working future yoga master get the opportunity to tangle with one of WWE's top stars. Hindsight makes it easy to see that DDP wasn't perceived by company management as being on the same level as 'Taker, but at the time, this seemed like a great chance to kick-start the proposed 'Invasion' properly, with a top WCW star coming over and laying down a marker that the infiltrating wrestlers were a genuine threat. Of course, that would never happen, and DDP would instead get his butt kicked all over New Jersey at the 2001 iteration of the King Of The Ring. Inviting The Undertaker to face him like a man, the pair wouldn't even have an official match, simply a brawl, but it's largely considered Page's first in-ring foray with WWE, and one that's not exactly remembered fondly.

9. Booker T vs. Buff Bagwell - Raw 2001

The initial idea for WCW coming under the WWE banner was that Raw Is War would either be renamed Monday Nitro, or simply remain as Raw but feature WCW talent exclusively. Vince McMahon was at first interested in splitting up his two major shows, Raw and Smackdown, between WCW and WWE, running both completely separate. A sound strategy, for sure, but it didn't really work out that way, and fingers are often pointed at this match, taking place on the July 2, 2001 edition of Raw, as to why those plans were abolished. The brand extension in the Spring of 2002 was along the same lines that WWE had in mind for WCW, but nobody was impressed with this bout, contested for the WCW World Title. It was a landmark moment, but the match fell flat with the partisan WWE crowd, and Bagwell has since stated that he felt he and Booker had little chance of impressing anybody, stating the move to put a WCW main event on WWE's flagship program should never have been made. Seeing the resultant fallout, it's hard to argue.

8. Scott Hall (vs. Steve Austin) - WrestleMania 18

Once known as Razor Ramon, Scott Hall would depart the then-WWF in 1996, infamously forming the nWo faction with Hulk Hogan and his running buddy, Kevin Nash in WCW. A lot of success - and money - followed, but Hall was arguably never the same performer once he hung up the Razor schtick. Returning to the WWE fold in 2002, Hall was immediately thrust into a feud opposite one of the promotions biggest stars, 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin, and the pair would tussle at Wrestlemania X8, Hall's first 'Mania appearance since 1995. Rumour has it that Austin was none too thrilled about his mid-card placement against the incoming WCW grappler, and the match wasn't exactly a trademark performance from either man. It's a case of what might have been here - had it been Hall circa 1996 tangling with Austin, in-ring magic would surely have happened, but Hall was not the performer he had been just 6 years prior. As it stands, even though he left with his hand raised, this must surely rank as one of the poorest Wrestlemania memories Steve Austin has.

7. Kevin Nash (vs. Triple H) - Judgment Day 2003

Similarly to his pal, Scott Hall, Kevin Nash left WWE in 1996, going on to make history in WCW. Returning as part of the nWo in 2002, Nash would surprisingly play a minor part in storylines during that period, not really being featured in any huge singles matches of any note. Despite facing The Rock on an episode of Smackdown in '02, it wasn't until the following year that Nash would truly have something to sink his teeth into. Triple H would be his rival, and the pair would piece together a feud which fell during a weird time in WWE history - many fans were scratching their heads, wondering why the promotion hadn't stumped up the cash to bring in many of the WCW stars for the Invasion angle, only hiring them in after the story was scrapped. At the Judgment Day PPV in May, 2003, Nash would vie for HHH's World Heavyweight Championship, just coming up short after the latter whacked referee Earl Hebner with a sledgehammer. Better matches were to follow between the pair, most memorably a Hell In A Cell match at the following month's Badd Blood show.

6. Scott Steiner (vs. Triple H) - Royal Rumble 2003

Scott Steiner was another huge name in the dying days of WCW, one who fans would have loved to see make the switch when the company went under. WWE didn't want to pay off his contract with Time Warner however, so Steiner sat at home collecting a bumper paycheck. By late-2002, that contract had expired, and it was time for the former WCW World Champion to go back to work. Booked as a top star right from the get-go, Steiner was positioned against Triple H, entering into a power struggle over the World Heavyweight Championship. It was all a bit strange seeing guys like Steiner in WWE, fighting a Triple H who was accompanied by Ric Flair, over a belt which heavily-resembled the WCW World Title. Having their first big encounter at the Royal Rumble in 2003, both men would struggle to create anything memorable, going for close to 20 minutes but never really hitting their stride. It was an auspicious start for Steiner, and following another eerily-similar effort at No Way Out the following month, the ex-WCW star began falling down the card. Never again would he come close to the main event scene in WWE.

5. Goldberg (vs. The Rock) - Backlash 2003

Unquestionably, Bill Goldberg was the WCW star most wrestling fans wanted to see in WWE during the heyday of the Monday Night Wars. Entire articles in many magazines of the time were dedicated to fantasy booking scenarios, dreaming up the many matches and opponents Goldberg could have should he be under contract to WCW's competition. Steve Austin was routinely the most popular choice for these columns, but he was followed closely by The Rock. Fans would eventually get their wish in 2003, as Goldberg was brought in to combat The Rock's arrogant heel character. Wrestling enthusiasts badly just wanted to see big Bill tear through everything in his path, and it's hard to argue that his debut, spearing The Rock out of his boots on an episode of Raw, wasn't terrific TV. Sadly, even though the match between the pair at Backlash 2003 was decent, it could never live up to the hype. Even though he'd move on to a program against Triple H (who else) later in the year, WWE stupidly started moving away from what fans wanted to see with Goldberg, putting him in silly promo situations with characters like Goldust. One year later, in the Spring of 2004, Goldberg was gone, and it never seemed like he was truly into his WWE run, certainly not the same way he had been throughout his WCW tenure. At least he had a better debut match than DDP, Booker T or Scott Steiner!

4. Billy Kidman vs. Shane Helms - SmackDown 2001

On the July 5, 2001 episode of the show, WWE tried to showcase the WCW Cruiserweight division to their audience, and both Billy Kidman and Shane Helms would have a lot more success than their heavyweight counterparts, Bagwell and Booker T, had experienced just days earlier on Raw. Putting on a great little match, Kidman and Helms represented the WCW crew magnificently, and had the crowd hooked with their smooth transitions, memorable high spots (the crowd adored Kidman's Shooting Star Press) and generally great wrestling. It wouldn't be long before Helms donned the mask and cape to portray The Hurricane, and Billy Kidman himself would have a few runs with the Cruiserweight gold, but Kidman would never really top his debut, looking like the incendiary talent many had pin-pointed him as for years in WCW.

3. Ric Flair (vs. Vince McMahon) - Royal Rumble 2002

Being revealed as a majority shareholder in WWE the night after Survivor Series in November of 2001, fans were once again baffled why Ric Flair hadn't been part of the Invasion saga. Surely somebody who embodied WCW such as The Nature Boy would have perfect for the angle, adding significant weight to proceedings, and making the incomers seem like way more of a threat. Nonetheless, it was too late for all that, and Flair instead went up against Vince McMahon for control of the company, providing fans with many awesome verbal duels in the process. Surprisingly, Flair's big in-ring WWE comeback, against McMahon in a Street Fight at the 2002 Royal Rumble, was also a spectacle. The No Holds Barred stipulation helped both men, of course, but the bout was full of drama, and proved to many Flair doubters that he still had something to offer when the bell had rung. This match is often over-looked when people debate the better Vince McMahon rivalries, which is a shame, as there's some really weighty action to be found in McMahon vs. Flair, not least the incredible 'crimson mask' displayed by Ric.

2. Lance Storm (vs. Edge) - SummerSlam 2001

Being serious for a minute, Lance Storm was never going to break into the WWE main event scene. The fact that just a short while after his debut, the company handed him a storyline during which he was - on air - described as 'boring' by announcers and fellow wrestlers shows you where his chances stood on headlining Wrestlemania. Regardless, everyone has their place on the card, and Storm's position in WWE was to consistently produce excellent matches. Along with his partner, Mike Awesome, the guy had opened up the InVasion Pay-Per-View nicely, in a well-received tag match against Edge & Christian, but it wasn't until Summerslam that he really got to show what he could do. Having captured the Intercontinental Title from Albert a few weeks before the big event, Storm met Edge in the Summerslam opener, and the pair had a blinding match which set the tone for the rest of the show. Storm and Edge, both fellow Canadians, had been friends for years, and their natural chemistry and aptitude for putting on a great match showed here. Again, when fans discuss great Intercontinental Title bouts, this one often flies under the radar a little.

1. Hulk Hogan (vs. The Rock) - WrestleMania 18

On his first appearances back in WWE, Hulk Hogan was treated like a returning God, even though he was supposed to be a heel. The nWo weren't despised by audiences however, far from it, and it seemed only natural that Hogan would have to ditch the black and white colours of the faction at some point, once again embracing the red and yellow of his past. It may seem silly now, but fans demanded it - people desperately wanted to cheer Hogan, and that made for an interesting set of circumstances once the icon faced off against one of the most popular guys in the promotion, The Rock at Wrestlemania X8. The Toronto Skydome hadn't played host to a Hogan 'Mania match since the sixth edition of the event, where Hulkamania squared off with The Ultimate Warrior, and wrestling fans had been waiting years to heap adulation on Hogan. What followed was a strange match, with fans firmly in the corner of the heel, something which even The Rock had to acknowledge whilst the match was in progress. Nobody can call this a technical classic, but it wasn't necessarily about that. These men could have played poker in the middle of the ring, and the live crowd still would have went nuts - Hulk Hogan was back in WWE, and the political master was about to once again position himself as the top name in the company. The atmosphere, the aura and the buzz were mind-blowing during this match, and it stands proud as one of the biggest showdowns in Wrestlemania history, and surely the best example of a successful re-integration from WCW to WWE. Do you agree with the choices on this list? Which other former WCW stars do you feel had memorable debuts or reintroductions to WWF/WWE? Let us know in the comments below!