Ranking 15 Four Horsemen - From Worst To Best
The Four Horsemen defined what it meant to be a wrestling stable.
Whenever the debate about greatest wrestling stables comes up, one group tends to dominate discussion, the Four Horsemen.
For almost 15 years they dominated the landscape of the National Wrestling Alliance (NWA) and World Championship Wrestling (WCW), winning titles, breaking bones and leaving a trail of destruction not seen since the biblical incarnation of their oft-imitated but never replicated moniker.
Coming together in November 1985, the original incarnation included Ric Flair, Arn and Ole Anderson and Tully Blanchard (with JJ Dillion as manager). Over the course of the next 14 years some 15 in-ring competitors would officially be Horsemen, with a number of managers and associates along the way.
Who was the best Horseman? The worst? The ninth best? Finally, here is a list to end the discussion. For the sake of argument, this list will only rank the in-ring Horsemen. As such, JJ Dillion isn’t included but Sid Vicious is. If this riles anyone, I’m terribly sorry.
Not many groups command as much respect to this very day as the Four Horsemen, and for good reason. Without them, there would have been no Degeneration-X, no Evolution, no Corre...
15. Sid Vicious
This might seem like a somewhat unfair ranking for ol’ Sid, but I stand by it. The big man just doesn’t fit the Horseman bill. Almost always including technically sound wrestlers of middling size and steely-charisma as opposed to wild-eyed madness, Sid is almost the antithesis of this. He joined the group on May 11th 1990 as the muscle of the Horsemen, brought in specifically to counteract the strength of Robocop, which is a sentence I still wish wasn’t true.
His time with the group was fairly uneventful, and his membership eventually fizzled out. The only positive of his time with the group is that he was billed as being from ‘wherever he damn well pleases’, which is an excellent location that needs to be reprised.
Sid (pictured above, far left) is the worst Horseman because he doesn’t fit the Horseman ethos and was brought in for ridiculous reasons. I mean, come on, Robocop?
14. Steve 'Mongo' McMichael
Okay, so Sid wasn’t what the Horsemen should be but at least he was a damn wrestler. Steve ‘Mongo’ McMichael was an American Football player who won a Superbowl with Chicago Bears, which is as far as my research into American Football will go. After a brief stint as a commentator (along with his dog, Pepe), Mongo got involved in a feud with the Horsemen over Ric Flair’s advances on his wife, Debra. This all led to a match at the Great American Bash in 1996 between the team of Arn Anderson and Ric Flair and the team of Mongo and fellow NFL-person Kevin Greene. Of course, this is WCW, which meant that Mongo turned on Greene to join the Horsemen.
Mongo wasn’t always terrible, and would even go on to have a run with the United States title. It was his general uselessness however that would lead to the Horsemen being disbanded (something that seemed to happen every few years or so) in 1997. This would last barely a year, and Mongo was a Horsemen a second time round in 1998. Another year later, he was gone.
The only thing that stops Mongo being bottom of this list is te fact that he was Horseman when I watched WCW, so there’s an element of nostalgia to this.
13. Sting
The Horsemen as faces just never seemed to work anywhere near as well as the Horsemen as heels, so any time they decided to put on the white hats (with the exception of the nWo times) something didn’t feel right. The Horsemen were at their finest when acting as violent antagonists to the top babyfaces in the company. Who was WCW’s biggest all time babyface? Sting of course.
What business did Sting have being a Horseman? Whilst he may fit the bill being a top-tier worker with impeccable reputation, he was exactly the top of character who should only ever have opposed to the Horsmen, not on their side.
Sting was a Horseman for less than six months, between the end of 1989 and the beginning of 1990.
12. Paul Roma
Whenever discussion comes up about who was the worst Horseman, Paul Roma (pictured centre)’s name inevitably tops the list. Why is this? Well, Roma wasn’t exactly Horsemen-level at any point in his career, not as a worker, not as a character, not as anything. He joined in early 1993 and didn’t last a year, leaving the group to join Paul Orndorff and continue his career or middling tag-team success. Paul Roma should never have been a Horseman.
So why does he rank higher than such names as Sting and Sid then? Well, Paul Roma did kind of fit the Horsemen in a variety of ways. Miscast as a face for sure, Roma as a heel Horseman would have made sense. He was the smarmy self-obsessed heel look down pat. His in-ring ability certainly wasn’t elite-level, but above the likes of Sid, Mongo and Luger.
Paul Roma is the definition of a failed Horseman, but at the same time he doesn’t deserve the vitriol that was thrown his way. It’s just a case of wrong person, wrong time.
11. Lex Luger
In many ways you could merely copy and paste the entry for Sting into this entry, in that Luger was often a major babyface for WCW and should have generally been on the opposite of the ring to the Horsemen. However, Lex Luger’s generally renowned as one of the least-trustworthy characters in wrestling history, so maybe he’s a better fit for the group than the Stinger.
Luger joined the group in 1987, replacing original member Ole Anderson. His tenure with the stable was highlighted by his United States title run, which started when he defeated Nikita Koloff in shady fashion and ended with a loss to perennial Horsemen rival, Dusty Rhodes.
If anything Luger’s greatest contribution to the Horsemen would come in 1988 after he left the group, Luger teamed with Barry Windham and would win the NWA World Tag Team Championship, only to lose the straps when Windham turned on Luger. Who did Windham join after this act? The Four Horsemen.
10. Jeff Jarrett
Why is Jeff Jarrett in every stable ever?
9. Curt Hennig
The man known as ‘Mr Perfect’ in WWF would have a rather underwhelming run as a Horseman, but come on, it’s Curt Hennig. After his almost 10-year run in the World Wrestling Federation came to an end, Hennig found himself in WCW as the war between the New World Order and the Horsemen raged on. Both stables wanted to recruit Hennig, and he ended up choosing the Horsemen. He may have done this because he saw Vincent and Bagwell in the nWo ranks.
He entered as Arn Anderson’s replacement, but this being WCW in the mid to late 90s he wouldn’t last long before turning on the group to join the damn New World Order. I’m pretty sure every WCW-rostered wrestler joined a variation of the nWo at some point. Curt Hennig was a Horseman for only two months, but I’m not putting him behind Paul Roma and Mongo on any list, unless that list is ‘Worst Horsemen’.
8. Brian Pillman
Brian Pillman is something of a wrestling enigma. Many often refer to him as a wrestling genius, but looking back at his career there’s for sure an element of unfulfilled promise. He is remembered for a number of angles that started hot but never really went anywhere. If I think of Pillman, I think of ‘I respect you, booker man’ and a slightly wacky dude on crutches.
Brian Pillman was also a Horseman. He joined the group in 1995 (after attacking Sting, of course) and by 1996 he was gone. His time with the group is best remembered for the evolution of his ‘Loose Cannon’ gimmick, but much like his career it is almost something of a lost opportunity.
Still, it’s Brian Pillman. He was a top-level worker with exceptional charisma and the sort of respect that being a Horseman demanded. It is testament to the quality of the following seven performers that he only spots eighth on this list.
7. Dean Malenko
Before starting this I should make something clear; Dean Malenko is my all-time favourite professional wrestler. Even now as I go back and watch old Malenko matches, there is something different in each one, something unique. Sure, he wasn’t overflowing with the charisma and entertainment factors that many of his peers had, but if I was on a desert island with only one wrestler’s catalogue of matches to watch, with no hesitation I would want that catalogue to be Dean Malenko’s.
My overly nostalgic mind remembers Malenko as a Horseman, but it turns out he was only involved from September 1998 until May 1999. Still, Malenko fits the Horsemen bill perfectly. If anyone was a spiritual successor to one (or two) of the names upcoming on this list, it was Dean Malenko.
6. Chris Benoit
For obvious reasons, it is impossible to look back at Chris Benoit’s career without bringing up the awful tragedy that ended his life and his crimes. I’m certainly not intelligent enough to do so objectively, so let’s keep this one brief.
Chris Benoit was a Horseman from 1995 until 1999 (in two incarnations). These were the years I discovered WCW properly, so it is difficult for me to think of the Horsemen without Benoit popping in.
An all-time elite worker with intensity that couldn’t be matched, Benoit the worker deserves this spot. Let’s leave it at that.
5. Ole Anderson
They say the originals are the best, and this is almost true with the Four Horsemen. The original group was three of the four names to follow, and Ole Anderson (far left, above) along with manager James J. Dillon.
It was during Ole’s time with the group that they set in stone what would make the Horsemen so important going forward, the pack-like viciousness and the domination. I know less about Ole than the three other originals, but he deserves a high spot in this list.
4. Barry Windham
Ole might be an original, but who is the fourth Horseman when it comes to the WWE Hall of Fame? None other than ‘The Stalker’ Barry Windham. Windham joined the group by turning on Lex Luger in 1988 in what was something of a shock, losing the NWA Tag Titles in the process to Horsemen Arn Anderson and Tully Blanchard. It is this incarnation of the group that is generally considered the definitive Four Horsemen, running riot in the company from 1988 until Flair’s departure to WWF in 1991 (with a short break for Windham in the middle).
As a Horseman Windham won the NWA United States strap, holding it for a good nine months and defending against a whole host of challengers. His time with the Horseman (his second run at least) sort of fizzled out somewhat when Flair was fired and headed to WWF, but it is difficult to argue with the WWE Hall of Fame when it comes to the four definitive Horseman.
The Stalker gimmick was dumb as bricks though.
3. Tully Blanchard
Who is the most underrated professional wrestler of the last 40 years? You could throw a whole host of names into that bucket, and I’m adding Tully Blanchard’s name to that list. One of the original Horsemen, Blanchard was already a bona-fide star in the National Wrestling Alliance when winter 1995 rolled around after high profile feuds with NWA legends Dusty Rhodes and Magnum TA. If you’re looking to go back and check up on these feuds be aware; there is a lot of blood.
Tully’s time as a Horseman was mostly spent in the tag team division, winning the NWA titles on a couple of occasions with Arn Anderson in the late 1980s before heading to the World Wrestling Federation in 1988. Anderson and Blanchard would taste brief success in the WWF in the tag division, but they weren’t long for that world.
2. Arn Anderson
Is there a more universally respected professional wrestler than Arn Anderson? If the man that tops this list is one of the most recognisable faces in all of wrestling, Double A was the glue who managed to hold that particularly erratic and excitable man in check during his glory years. Anderson was a part of the original group that formed in 1985, and was subsequently a part of every single collection of Horsemen until his retirement in 1997.
Every team or group needs a straight man, and Arn Anderson was that for the Four Horsemen. This isn’t to say he was completely void of charisma, the man could cut one hell of a promo when given the chance, but he wasn’t considered the Enforcer for no good reason.
It is difficult to deny the influence Arn Anderson has had on modern-day wrestling, and if this was any other list there is a strong chance he would rank number one. But how can anyone deny the list topper here?
1. Ric Flair
Over the many years that the Horsemen were active, there were two permanent members but only one true leader. Arn Anderson was there all of the time, but he was one of three (or more) members of the group whose sole purpose was to ensure Ric Flair remained at the top of the NWA and subsequently WCW. It is Flair’s position that really set the stall out for almost every stable to come. With a main event talent on top, a number of midcard performers would rally around with the aim to ensure the number one keeps their title, elevating themselves through association and subsequent story.
This was pretty much invented by Flair and the Horsemen. Sure, they weren’t the first stable in the history of professional wrestling, but it’s difficult to argue against them being the most important. As a Horseman, Flair won 14 of his 16 World Championships along with one United States Championship.
The Four Horsemen basically existed for the benefit of Ric Flair, so of course he is number one on this list.