Ranking 6 Best John Cena Matches At WWE Extreme Rules

The event where Cena usually proves he's tough as nails.

By Mitch Nickelson /

On April 26th, 2015 John Cena will face off against Rusev for the way more coveted as of late U.S. Championship. The pair have both traded wins at the two previous Pay-Per-Views. This third and probably final match in their series will be settled in a Russian Chain Match. If Rusev wants to walk away from the event as U.S. Champion then it might serve him well to study Cena's efforts in previous Extreme Rules matches.

Advertisement

John Cena has an impressive history at the Extreme Rules event, both in regards to his win-loss record and to his body of work. With 6 years in existence and Cena wrestling a match each year, he has racked up 4 wins, 1 loss, and 1 no contest decision. That lone loss was due to a cage escape decision, one of the most protected ways to lose in the wrestling industry.

The workrate of all of these matches are superb. Only one really can be regarded as below average. Most critics would regard at least 4 of the other 5 matches as above average. And the top match on this list is a classic that was rated 4.5 out of 5 stars by Dave Meltzer.

The following are all 6 of Cena's Extreme Rules matches, ranked from worst to best...

6. Submission Match vs. Big Show (2009)

John Cena and The Big Show came into the inaguaral Extreme Rules Pay Per View after having a few meetings at the two previous big events.

Advertisement

Show interfered in Cena's match against Edge at Backlash and slammed him into a gigantic light. The following month Cena would defeat Big Show at Judgment Day. The two are now meeting in a Submission Match since Cena unsuccessfully put Show in his STF on three different occasions.

The match itself put Big Show in the typical role of the giant that he his. John would attempt a running bulldog on one occasion and would get thrown clear across and out of the ring. Cena would be on offense very little during this match.

The ending came after John was able to hook Big Show's leg in the ropes to aid him in his STF. That would prove too much for the giant as he tapped out.

The match was incredibly slow and never really felt like it took off. The polite New Orleans crowd simply chose to be silent throughout most of the middle of the match whereas a rowdier crowd would have made up creative chants to entertain themselves.

This wasn't blatantly terrible but it was John Cena's worst Extreme Rules match.

5. Cage Match vs. Bray Wyatt (2014)

John Cena and Bray Wyatt would face off in a series of three Pay-Per-View matches in early 2014 while Bray was seemingly at the beginning of a meteoric rise in his young career.

Advertisement

The two met up for their first encounter at the previous Pay-Per-View, WrestleMania 30, and Cena would go over. It seemed odd for Wyatt to lose on such a huge platform because a win over Cena, even a tainted one, could have solidified him as a main eventer.

Wyatt would face off against Cena for their second big match in a steel cage. The Extreme Rules match seemed to favor the cult leader as his two followers Luke Harper and Erick Rowan would prevent Cena from winning on multiple occasions. 

The crowd was loud as these two strong personalities beckoned a huge reaction. Cena appeared to have the Wyatt family single-handedly defeated as he made his way out of the cage. Then the arena would go black for a small boy to be singing "He's Got The Whole World In His Hands" with a creepy distortion on his voice. Wyatt attacked Cena from behind and walked out of the cage for the win.

This would be the most definitive victory that Wyatt would receive during his Cena rivalry, stalling his momentum and soured an otherwise good match.


4. Cage Match vs. The Miz & John Morrison (2011)

Thanks to help from The Rock at WrestleMania 27, The Miz came into this Extreme Rules main event with a WWE Championship win over John Cena. Mr. McMahon would later announce that Cena would get to challenge for the title at this event after Cena won a Raw battle royal. John Morrison would also be added to this match after defeating R-Truth for his #1 Contender shot.

Advertisement

Morrison's parkour style added a wealth of value to this match. His burst speed would add excitement as it looked like he could escape the cage with quickness and ease at any time. He would also do a variation of the Starship Pain off of the top of the cage for a fun highspot.

The Miz would even contribute to a big bump in the match when Cena and Morrison pulled him down from the top of the cage into a double suplex. He landed rather nasty as he impacted mostly at the top of his shoulders and neck. The few times it was replayed was slightly cringe-inducing.

R-Truth would interfere at the end of the match and cost John Morrison the victory. This allowed for Cena to do a top rope Attitude Adjustment onto The Miz and pin for the win. This was a fun and energetic match thanks to Cena's supporting characters.

3. Last Man Standing Match vs. Ryback (2013)

After defeating The Rock for the WWE Championship at WrestleMania 29, John Cena would issue an open challenge. This ultimately would lead to Ryback turning heel and challenging him because Cena never helped him whenever he was getting beat up against The Shield. Ryback was allowed to choose what match these guys were going to have at Extreme Rules so he chose a Last Man Standing match.

Advertisement

The match itself turned out to be above average. It was a little slow to start but crescendoed well thanks to a series of progressively more intense spots. The ending came after Ryback picked up Cena and ran him through the lights at the top of the ramp. It was an incredibly memorable spot that prompted the crowd to chant "Foley" in respect to how extreme the spot felt.

The match ended in a No Contest even though Cena clearly would not have gotten to his feet in time if the ref did his job after the match and counted him out. The announce team's excuse for why the match was stopped instead of counting Cena out was that the ending was "too extreme." Ryback should have thrown a bigger fit about that.

2. Last Man Standing Match vs. Batista (2010)

This rivalry between John Cena and Batista began after the two got involved with Bret Hart and Mr. McMahon's hostilities. Both guys would pass the WWE Championship around until Cena defeated Batista for it at WrestleMania 26. These circumstances lead to this Last Man Standing at Extreme Rules.

Advertisement

Batista showcased himself well during this match. He came across as progressively more ruthless as he tried to keep Cena down for the 10-count. An unintentionally funny moment came from Batista as he threw a monitor from the announce table at commentator Matt Striker while he was in the middle of proclaiming how much he liked The Animal.

Cena would be sent crashing through a barricade and Batista would get AA'd off of steel steps through an announce table. Carnage abounded in this excellent match but victory would be obtained by Cena when he cleverly duct taped Batista's legs around the corner ring post. 

John waved his hand mockingly for his "You Can't See Me" taunt as a frustrated Batista had to let the ref count to ten. Cena retained the WWE Championship.

With still one more match left that is better than this one in John Cena's Extreme Rules match history it is easy to see that he typically performs well at this event.

1. Extreme Rules Match vs. Brock Lesnar (2012)

Welcome back, Brock Lesnar. This was the former UFC Heavyweight Champion's first match in WWE since 2004 and boy did he make an impact. The build was that he was brought into the company to legitimize the WWE and he very much succeeded at that.

Advertisement

Give John Cena his credit as well because he sold for Lesnar in a memorable way. He would be busted open in the opening moments of the match and it seemed to only get more brutal from there. The match was almost stopped on a couple of occasions as the medical staff would tend to Cena's wounds and it was completely believable in every way.

The officials should also be credited for their work in this match. Charles Robinson took a couple of bumps, including being whacked by John Cena as he was being F-5'd by Lesnar. A replacement ref would then get clubbed by Brock for only getting to a 2-count during a pinfall.

Surprisingly, John Cena defeated Lesnar by delivering the AA to Lesnar on a set of steel steps that were in the middle of the ring. Lesnar's career definitely wasn't hurt by the loss and the match has high replay value so the booking is a minor gripe at this point.

This was also the event where Cena confusingly sort of retired after the match...but not really.

Advertisement