Ranking Every SmackDown WWE Superstar Shakeup Move From Worst To Best

"Miz Is Awesome" or "Let's Go Joe"?

By Jamie Kennedy /

WWE.com

The Superstar Shake-up is complete and WWE have moved a total of 19 workers to Raw and 17 to SmackDown over the past two days.

Advertisement

Looking at the lay of the land on both shows, it seems SmackDown got the better deal; Kevin Owens, Sami Zayn and Drew McIntyre were huge for Raw, but Samoa Joe, Jeff Hardy, Andrade Almas, Asuka and The Bar blew them out of the water 24 hours later. Though he was traded on Monday, add The Miz to that list too.

As with any draft, there were a few stinkers in there that happened just for the sake of it. It was the same on Raw. For all the names like The Ascension, Mike Kanellis and Chad Gable making up the numbers on Monday, SmackDown received its own fair-share of filler that are nothing more than head-scratchers.

Advertisement

Things are looking bright on Tuesdays though. SmackDown got rid of some dead wood and is well-placed to become the definite wrestling-centric show on WWE's weekly schedule. Bring it on...

11. R-Truth

WWE.com

Comedy relief is fine if booked well and used sparingly.

Advertisement

It's all R-Truth has at this point anyway, and his immediate flub upon debuting on SmackDown (saying he was glad everyone was together on Raw) did raise a giggle. It's very one-dimensional though, and therein lies the core problem with Truth's purpose in WWE these days.

He's a peripheral figure, not one fans will take seriously again in a no-nonsense role and was blatantly only involved in the Shakeup so WWE could balance the books across Raw and SmackDown in terms of numbers. Truth, for lack of a better description, is SmackDown's version of The Ascension in this Shake-up.

Advertisement

Still, if his silliness is kept to a minimum, Truth could be fun for the odd segment or two sprinkled here and there. That's provided SmackDown's writers don't book weekly segments during which he acts like a 10-year old boy.

Leave that to Nicholas.

Advertisement

10. Mandy Rose & Sonya Deville

WWE.com

Once the Riott Squad appeared on Raw to attack Bayley and Sasha Banks, it was obvious that Mandy Rose and Sonya Deville would join their old leader Paige on SmackDown. On Raw, they were on the fringes, but who's to say that'll magically change now they're working Tuesdays?

Advertisement

There's been a woeful lack of character development for both. WWE barely even attempted to explain why Rose and Deville remained pals once Paige bolted to SmackDown and filled the vacant GM role.

Just giving a group a name isn't enough in an era when NXT call-ups are abundant, so if Rose and Deville want to be successful on SmackDown they're going to need a little context. Or, they might be better off splitting and carving their own respective paths.

Advertisement

One thing's for sure: Paige, as a babyface character in the GM role, doesn't need their backup any longer.

9. Big Cass

WWE.com

Overshadowed by Braun Strowman in the entertaining big man role and sucking hard as a menacing heel, poor Big Cass looked like a lost soul on Raw before he was injured last summer. That injury, as painful as it surely was, may end up being a blessing in disguise for Cass.

Advertisement

After interrupting the main event tag match on SmackDown and pasting Daniel Bryan, Cass finally has some heat.

The key thing here is going to be how SmackDown's creative team follow up on that return beating he gave Bryan and maintain his momentum. It's unlikely people will clamour to see Cass vs. Bryan in anything more than a short TV match, so finding a feud Cass can sink his teeth into seems crucial.

Advertisement

Let's just hope, for his sake, that Cass worked on his heel promos at home. He'll need to find the same fire Samoa Joe has to convince anybody he's worth caring about.

8. Luke Gallows & Karl Anderson

WWE.com

The brief alliance they enjoyed with real-life pal Finn Bálor is over and both Luke Gallows and Karl Anderson have been shifted sideways to help shore up SmackDown's tag-team division in coming months. Although it's disappointing WWE didn't make more of the Bálor Club idea, there's still hope for The Good Brothers.

Advertisement

Don't forget AJ Styles is a top name on SmackDown, and there's no reason why he can't eventually join up with Gallows/Anderson to rework The Club angle they did a few years ago. A refreshing twist would be turning the team babyface to meet AJ's popularity with fans; a heel turn for Styles seems out of the question right now.

It'd be nice to see WWE give Gallows and Anderson a run against teams like The Bludgeon Brothers long term too. Both are veterans, and they'd really help Harper and Rowan get their dominating big man gimmick over properly.

Advertisement

Failing that, reprise some Gallows/Anderson/Styles action again.

7. SAnitY

WWE.com

There's the threat of a really good tag-team division on SmackDown now teams like The Good Brothers and SAnitY have joined the ranks. Killian Dain, Alexander Wolfe and Eric Young have the potential to challenge The Bludgeon Brothers perhaps more credibly than anyone else, and the kooky 'Weirdos vs. Weirdos' vibe they'd work would be fun.

Advertisement

It'd also be a total departure from the done-and-dusted growing respect story between The Usos and New Day that pinned down SmackDown's tag division for months.

Why Nikki Cross wasn't called up alongside her stablemates is anyone's guess, but that shouldn't hold SAnitY back from becoming a sweet addition to the main roster. Besides, there's time for WWE to iron out whatever kinks they feel Cross has and call her up later.

Advertisement

SAnitY might have been higher had the full complement come up.

6. Jeff Hardy

WWE.com

WWE have always been a little higher on Jeff Hardy than his brother Matt, and that's been shown once again by his standing in this Superstar Shakeup. Since returning from injury, Jeff has become United States Champion, moved away from his sibling's wacky characterisation and become a singles star on SmackDown.

Advertisement

One quick note: Jeff is the fourth different United States Champ this year. It'd be cool if WWE could give the title some stability like they have the Intercontinental belt.

There's every chance Hardy will be the man to rebuild the title and get it back to the level it was at last summer when AJ Styles and Kevin Owens feuded over the strap. To do so, he'll need the backing of SmackDown's writers and (most of all) to be left alone when it comes to working out the basics of his feuds/matches.

Advertisement

There are so many great workers on SmackDown for Jeff to work with. AJ Styles, Samoa Joe, Shinsuke Nakamura and Daniel Bryan come to mind immediately.

5. Andrade Almas & Zelina Vega

WWE.com

The days of Andrade Almas dancing around in braces and a little white hat are a distant memory. With the (slightly) under-rated Zelina Vega by his side, Almas has developed into one of the most exciting acts in all of WWE. Together, the pair are dynamite.

Advertisement

Vega's similarities to Lita in 1999-2000 are there for all to see, and the reign Almas had as NXT Champion will only stand him in good stead. Having already been the top heel in NXT, he'll be better prepared for working his way up the SmackDown ladder.

We can't wait to see him do it.

Advertisement

Almas is in the envious position of joining a roster bursting with world-class talent. AJ Styles, Samoa Joe, Shinsuke Nakamura, Daniel Bryan, Cesaro/Sheamus, Jeff Hardy, The Miz, Randy Orton, Chris Jericho (when he's around) and Rusev can all give Andrade top matches, which will introduce those who don't watch NXT to his skills.

4. Asuka

WWE.com

Whether she'd been booked to lose her long-running unbeaten streak or not at WrestleMania, it was wise to move Asuka over to SmackDown in the Superstar Shakeup. The main reason? It keeps her away from Ronda Rousey for the remainder of 2018.

Advertisement

That's one match WWE must be interested in booking at some point. For now though, Asuka needs a little rebuild job after dropping to Charlotte Flair at 'Mania 34, and there's no better way to do that than by booking her revenge later this year.

Other options open to Asuka include Becky Lynch, Naomi, The IIconics and current SmackDown Women's Champion Carmella. It's only a matter of time before Asuka supplants the Princess of Staten Island as titleholder. That's why 'Mella was given the title in the first place: She's a buffer between Flair and Asuka.

Advertisement

3. The Bar

WWE.com

Seeing The Bar lose to Braun Strowman and a kid at WrestleMania 34 then stare at the lights for Breezango on Raw this past Monday was weird. Akin to the territorial days of pro wrestling, it was almost like WWE had chewed up The Bar's usefulness and were readying Sheamus and Cesaro to leave for another region.

Advertisement

In a slightly skewed sense, that's exactly what has happened. The Bar have traded ruling Raw for freshness on SmackDown, and they're now well-poised to continue their run as WWE's most valuable tag-team.

If WWE are thinking of splitting the pair, they shouldn't. Sheamus and Cesaro have mileage yet, and they're ideal for lengthy feuds against The Usos, SAnitY and Rusev/Aiden English. It wouldn't even be a problem if WWE rebooked The Bar vs. The New Day either.

Advertisement

Enough time has passed that old feuds would feel relatively fresh again.

2. Samoa Joe

WWE.com

All hail Samoa Joe.

Advertisement

If Joe can keep up the level of mic work he's shown recently against Roman Reigns, then he'll be pushing AJ Styles for the spot of best all-rounder in WWE. Joe has been superb on the stick over the past few weeks, and it's great to see him join a roster that suits him better than Raw's did.

Matches against AJ Styles, Daniel Bryan, Shinsuke Nakamura and Jeff Hardy seem like no-brainers for Joe. Beyond those names, he'd smash it against Randy Orton, The Miz or Chris Jericho. Those matches might have a different feel to ones against the likes of AJ and Bryan, but they'd be no less valid.

Advertisement

Joe is a modern-day super worker who can work against anybody. The main challenge he's going to find on SmackDown is satisfying his thirst for competitive matches and being able to push a match with Reigns at Backlash (despite being on a different show) at the same time.

1. The Miz

WWE.com

Another challenging AJ Styles for the best all-rounder tag is The Miz, and that's not something anyone thought would be the case four/five years ago when he was toiling in the lower card.

Advertisement

The most outstanding heel in the company right now, Miz is arguably the top draft pick across both legs of the Superstar Shakeup. He carried the Intercontinental Title torch proudly, is Teflon in terms of bouncing back from losses, can cut promos better than most, and has the potential to turn babyface this year to boot.

There's also the not-so-small matter of seeing Miz vs. Daniel Bryan thanks to his switch.

Advertisement

That one match is must-see, and it's been years in the making. Once he's done there, Miz can either pull the trigger on a face turn or repeat the formula against AJ Styles. If only he'd brought the Miztourage with him, things would be perfect.

-

Advertisement

Do you agree with these rankings? Let us know your thoughts about the Superstar Shakeup down in the comments section below!