Ranking Every WWE Backlash Main Event Ever - From Worst To Best
Multi-man clashes, 'Mania rematches, and interference from your favourite beer-drinking brawler...
This month marks the triumphant return of WWE Backlash to
the company’s pay-per-view calendar. I say triumphant because historically its
been one of the better B-tier shows in the WWE’s arsenal.
That’s typically been a result of Backlash’s former spot as the post-WrestleMania PPV, meaning that we’ve seen a number of epic rematches and rivalries grace the event in years gone by. Then again, we’ve also seen some fresher feuds deliver the goods at Backlash.
This year the show will feature one such feud in the main event, as Dean Ambrose faces AJ Styles for the WWE World Championship for the first time ever. It’ll likely be a top match, but how does it compare with some of the headlining contests we’ve seen at previous Backlash PPVs?
Today we have a bash at answering that question, as we look back at some of the very best moments in Backlash history and rank each of the PPV’s main events to determine which was the greatest.
First though, time to address the other end of the scale…
11. 2002 – Triple H Vs. Hulk Hogan
On paper this may look like something of a dream match, but
in reality Triple H vs. Hulk Hogan for the Undisputed WWF Championship wasn’t
quite as good as it sounded.
While the use of Hulk Hogan in the title picture helped the show post a strong buy-rate, it didn’t do too many favours for the main event match itself. By this point, Hogan was fast-approaching 50 and little more than a nostalgia act. Plus, his limited mobility—not to mention his lack of selling—was increasingly proving to be a bit of an issue.
One moment in this match where those issues became apparent was when Triple H began sweeping out Hogan’s leg from underneath him; seeing the Hulkster clumsily amble to the ground in stages was likely more painful for the viewers than it was for Hogan himself.
Perhaps in a bid to compensate for the clunky action, we saw run-ins from Chris Jericho as well as the Undertaker, the latter of whom caused Hogan to "hulk up" before he’d hit the leg drop on Triple H to win his sixth WWF Championship.
A fun match for the Hulkamaniacs, but not a particularly great one all in all.
10. 2003 – Goldberg Vs. The Rock
Next we have another match that was made more in the hope of
creating a spectacle than a quality wrestling clinic.
Here, the appeal lay in the fact that this would be Goldberg’s first-ever match in the WWE—a scenario we thought we might never end up seeing. However, it didn’t quite go perfectly to plan. Having been unanimously cheered for much of his WCW run, at Backlash 2003, Goldberg was actually booed by half the crowd. Although that might have had something to do with the Rock being so charismatic and entertaining in his role as the villain.
Putting that odd dynamic aside though, we still got to see all the trademark power spots that we’d come to expect from Goldberg, including three separate Spears and an impressive one-armed Jackhammer which would eventually result in him securing the win.
It was a cool scene to see Goldberg finally in a WWE ring, and especially against a top star like the Rock, but that novelty alone wasn’t enough to make this one a classic contest.
9. 2005 – Batista Vs. Triple H
Batista vs. Triple H for the World Heavyweight Championship
at Backlash 2005 wasn’t necessarily a bad match, but I do think it suffered
from being sandwiched in between two much more exciting chapters in this
rivalry.
Four weeks prior to this Backlash meeting, Batista had celebrated his crowning moment as he defeated the Game at WrestleMania 21 to capture his maiden world championship. Obviously that changed the dynamic of this rematch, while it also meant that his eventual retention didn’t quite have the same impact as that dramatic title change at WrestleMania.
Plus, seven weeks later, these two foes would tear the house down in a brutal Hell in a Cell match at the June 26 Vengeance show.
With those highlights on either side, it’s easy for this Backlash encounter to pale in comparison. Also, the contest got a little messy towards the end, with multiples low-blows, a replacement referee, and of course the obligatory Ric Flair run-in.
Even so, this was by no means a terrible match; it just wasn’t quite the best work that these two would produce in their multiple meetings with one another.
8. 2001 – Two Man Power Trip Vs. Brothers Of Destruction
In terms of star-power, main events don’t come much bigger
than that of Backlash 2001. WWF Champion Stone Cold Steve Austin and
Intercontinental Champion Triple H faced off against WWF Tag Team Champions the
Undertaker and Kane—and all of the
belts were on the line.
Some have criticised the lengthiness of this one, but considering the talent that was on display, I'd say the longer the better.
Much of the match centred around Austin and Triple H looking to isolate Kane, with the duo adding a slightly comedic element by running scared anytime the Undertaker came after them. Eventually the Deadman looked to have secured the victory though, getting the hot tag, clearing house and hitting Triple H with the Last Ride. However, rather than counting the subsequent pin, the referee would instead inform ‘Taker that he never saw the tag to begin with.
Further shenanigans would then ensue as Vince and Stephanie McMahon got involved, before Triple H hit Kane with the sledgehammer to pick up the victory for his team.
This is a match that sometimes forgotten about, given the way the faction abruptly disbanded a few weeks later when Triple H tore his quad. Which, by the way, JR kind of predicted, ominously stating that “someone’s going to get hurt badly” as the Power Trip left the arena with all the gold in tow. Not sure he meant it in that way though...
7. 2008 – Randy Orton Vs. Triple H Vs. John Cena Vs. JBL
Backlash 2008 saw a similarly jam-packed main event, as
Randy Orton defended his WWE Championship in a Four-way Elimination match
against Triple H, John Cena and JBL.
It was naturally a fairly manic affair with all of your classic multi-man spots, including a tower of doom and double pin attempt, plus a cool moment in which JBL refrained from breaking up Cena’s STFU on Orton, goading the latter to tap, only for Triple H to spring up from behind and lock him in the crossface.
Shortly after, JBL and Cena would be eliminated in quick succession. JBL submitted to Cena’s STFU and in the aftermath Orton swooped in with a punt before covering Cena to take him out of contention. That paved the way for what was essentially a singles match between Orton and Triple H, which actually lasted twice as long as the preceding four-man action. Eventually Triple H would score the win, hitting the Pedigree after numerous reversals of one another’s finishers.
This wasn’t quite the best multi-man main event in Backlash history—as we’ll soon see—but it was still a solid showing nonetheless.
6. 2006 – John Cena Vs. Edge Vs. Triple H
Slightly better than that Four-way Elimination bout was the
Triple Threat that we saw at Backlash two years’ prior.
Here, WWE Champion John Cena and Triple H—fresh off their meeting at WrestleMania 22—were joined by Edge in the three-way, although you wouldn’t have known it from the opening exchanges. Living up to his Ultimate Opportunist moniker, Edge remained outside the ring as Cena and the Game went at it. Although it wasn’t long before they’d turn their attention to their ringside onlooker and welcome him to the contest.
This was another multi-man match that made good use of the stipulation, pulling out a nice spot in which Triple H would lock Edge in a sleeper, only for Cena to storm the ring and hoist both men up for an Attitude Adjustment. Edge, managing to wriggle free though, would then hit the ropes and unleash a Spear to knock both men to the ground.
The finish was also a rather novel one, with Cena winning via a jack-knife cover. Although, baying for revenge, a bloodied Triple H would seize his sledgehammer after the match, taking out Cena, Edge and the referee to make for an emphatic finale to the show.
5. 2009 – John Cena Vs. Edge
John Cena vs. Edge is one of the all-time classic WWE feuds.
So when they met at Backlash 2009 in Last Man Standing action, you just knew
we’d be in for a treat.
What started out as a typically stellar match between the two old foes would soon degenerate into a more extreme affair, which the steel steps playing a prominent role—as Edge would discover when they were hurled at his head as he stood by idly at ringside.
There was also a very cool Attitude Adjustment that sent Edge flying into the crowd, before the mayhem spread even further afield, making its way behind the curtain and eventually ending up on the stage.
Further hardcore moments would follow as Edge nailed Cena
with a DDT onto the steel, before pulling out a wicked one-man con-chair-to. And
there was still time for a late twist in the tale, as the Big Show emerged to
chokeslam Cena through a gigantic spotlight amidst a shower of sparks and a pretty spectacular explosion.
It may have been a little screwy, but the spectacle of it all atoned for the interference, in a match that would likely have ranked much higher were it not for some very stiff competition.
4. 2007 – John Cena Vs. Shawn Michaels Vs. Randy Orton Vs. Edge
Our second four-way match on this list, but easily the
better of the two. In fact, this may be one of the best Fatal 4-ways I’ve ever
seen on WWE programming.
First off, there was a ton of backstory to this one. WWE Champion John Cena and Shawn Michaels were in the midst of their epic rivalry that had recently included their near-60-minute match on Monday Night Raw, while Randy Orton and Edge were going through the messy break-up of their Rated-RKO tag team. Plus, they’d all met in tag action just a few months before, but this every-an-for-himself match would prove to be even better.
Understandably we saw various alliances come and go throughout the match, such as Edge and Orton simultaneously locking in single-leg crabs on an unlucky Michaels, plus Orton giving Edge a thumbs up before promptly being smashed in the head with a chair.
For me it was the finish that stole the show though. A flurry of reversals and finishing moves led to Michaels hitting Cena with Sweet Chin Music, causing him to fall on a prone Orton and unknowingly pick up the 1-2-3, with Michaels not realising until it was too late.
For the plentiful sub-plots and that brilliantly-orchestrated finish, this was so much more than your usual Fatal 4-way.
3. 1999 – Stone Cold Steve Austin Vs. The Rock
As you could probably have guessed by the names involved,
these two icons staged an absolutely brilliant match when they met at Backlash
1999, to the point that it probably eclipsed their WrestleMania clash from just
a few weeks’ prior.
After Mick Foley had refereed that WrestleMania meeting, this time it was Shane McMahon who’d officiate and he pretty much called it down the middle—until the very end, that is.
The preceding match saw both men take full advantage of the No Holds Barred stipulation, brawling their way throughout the arena and taking some pretty hard bumps along the way. There was also a more light-hearted element though, as the Rock paused mid-match to provide some commentary and take control of the camera to film a his opponent writhing on the floor.
Then in the closing moments, Austin inadvertently struck
Shane, who himself would inadvertently clatter the Rock. To atone for his error
though, Shane simply refrained from counting the three on Austin’s resultant
pin, instead giving the Rattlesnake the finger.
Escaping the scene, he was soon stopped by his father Vince, who laid him out on the entranceway and replaced him with Earl Hebner. Meanwhile in the ring, a cool spot saw Austin follow up a Stunner with an immediate title shot to the Rock’s forehead, allowing him to pick up the win with Hebner— the very ref that Vince had introduced to the mix—counting the pinfall.
Phew.
When a match manages to get a 4.25-star rating despite all those shenanigans in the finish, you know it must have been a good one.
2. 2000 – Triple H Vs. The Rock
I know I’ve criticised run-ins and screwy finishes
previously on this list, but when they’re executed as well as we saw with this
entry, it doesn’t detract from the match at all.
Here, with Triple H, Vince McMahon and his accompanying cronies seemingly screwing the Rock out of the WWF title, the Great One was in dire need of assistance. A chair shot from McMahon had left the Rock downed, to the point that Triple H could hardly lift his opponent to hit the Pedigree that would no doubt bring him victory.
Of course, what he and his buddies hadn’t accounted for was a certain Stone Cold Steve Austin.
With the situation hopeless, that trademark sound of smashing glass filled the arena and sent the fans into raptures. Austin, out of action at the time nursing a neck injury, soon came striding to the ring, chair in hand, before delivering rasping shots to Triple H, Pat Patterson and Gerald Briscoe in a whirlwind of steel on skull.
Upon reaching the ring, Vince and Shane were next to suffer the very same fate, before one final parting shot to Triple H for good measure had well and truly evened the playing field. The Rock would do the rest, recovering to hit the People’s Elbow and reclaim the WWF Championship.
Other main events may have seen better displays in terms of the actual wrestling portion, but for the drama and excitement caused by Austin’s emergence, this goes down as one of the greatest Backlash memories in history.
1. 2004 – Chris Benoit Vs. Shawn Michaels Vs. Triple H
In top spot we have the WrestleMania XX rematch between
Chris Benoit, Shawn Michaels and Triple H for the World Heavyweight
Championship—in a match that may even have outdone the original.
Here, we saw some brilliant storytelling throughout the contest. Benoit seemed to be far more in control in this match, as he should have since he was the champion. Not only was he holding the title up in the faces of his opponents before the match, but his masterful ability to pull a submission from out of nowhere made him seem almost unbeatable once the action was underway.
Our dose of drama arrived when Michaels locked Benoit in the Sharpshooter, prompting Earl Hebner to sprint to the ring to replace the downed referee. Naturally, the Canadian crowd recognised this scene from somewhere before and responded with deafening boos, as well as a resounding “You Screwed Bret” chant for the guilty parties in the ring.
This time though, there was to be no Screwjob. Benoit would hang on and later in the match lock Shawn in the same Sharpshooter to a thunderous ovation from the Alberta crowd. After a lengthy struggle, and with Triple H crawling back into the ring, Michaels could hold on no longer, submitting and allowing the champ to retain.
History may have since tainted the contest, but for the drama, storytelling, and the quality of the action in this 30-minute affair, it’s almost impossible not to regard this as the greatest Backlash main event in history.