Ranking Every WWE Royal Rumble Since 2010
No surprise entrants in this list of the best Royal Rumble events of the past ten years.
The Royal Rumble pay-per-view is often regarded by WWE fans as the most exciting event in WWE's calendar, due to the shocks and surprises provided by the titular matches themselves, as well as the looming prospect of WrestleMania just around the corner.
The excitement of having the first 'Mania match of the year confirmed is enough to draw thousands of fans to the Royal Rumble each year and, since the addition of a Women's bout in 2018, the thrills that come thick and fast have been doubled. WWE don't often attempt to change the formula of the Rumble matches, as the typical format has worked for 30 years. However, there have been various occasions that the annual 30-man brawl has been negatively received, due to changes or poor booking decisions.
The last ten years of WWE have showcased some of the best (and worst) moments in Rumble history. Now the 2020 edition has rounded out the decade, it only makes sense to see how they all stack up.
11. 2014
The 2014 Royal Rumble was a hot mess of a show.
The WWE Universe was unapologetic in their opinions of this pay-per-view, with the climax being drowned in boos. After an unsuccessful bout against Bray Wyatt to open the show, Daniel Bryan was expected to be in the main event of the night, even potentially winning the whole thing. WWE fans across the world clamoured for the 'American Dragon' to be pushed throughout 2013 and it seemed as though there was no better opportunity to begin that than at the Royal Rumble. Much to the fan's dismay, that was not the case.
Bryan was not in the match. He did not appear as a late entrant, and as the number of remaining participants slowly dwindled down, fans became aware that their beloved superstar was not going to appear. This did not sit well with the WWE fans in attendance, with the Pittsburgh crowd booing usual fan favourite Rey Mysterio upon his entry at number 30.
This show seemed as though it was booked to upset fans across the board, with Bray dominating Bryan to open the show and Brock Lesnar and Big Show having a slow, methodical match. The main title bout of the evening - Randy Orton vs. John Cena for the WWE World Heavyweight Championship - was heavily disregarded by the live crowd, with chants of 'Y2J' and 'this is awful' ringing around the Consol Energy Center.
Thankfully, it appeared as though WWE saw the error of their ways when they decided to push Daniel Bryan to the main event scene not long after this show, with his triumph at WrestleMania XXX, but this event could have been salvaged somewhat had the company listened to their fans.
10. 2015
If there's one lesson that WWE failed to learn from the Royal Rumble just one year prior, it's that you should never mess with Pennsylvania.
A year removed from 2014's event and WWE had a new star in their sights: Roman Reigns. It was very clear that the company was not likely to give up on Reigns, which only made the WWE Universe reject him even more. Throughout 2014, it became obvious that Vince McMahon had taken a liking to 'The Big Dog' and saw him as the new face of the company. The only issue was that the WWE Universe did not agree.
2015's edition of the annual 30-man brawl saw Roman Reigns ascend to the top of the card after eliminating both Kane and Big Show at the same time, earning a shot at Brock Lesnar's WWE World Heavyweight Championship. However, the fans in attendance were left with a sour taste in their mouths from the moment that Daniel Bryan was mercilessly thrown over the top rope after a mere ten minutes. In a bout that saw the return of Diamond Dallas Page, the rise of Damien Mizdow and another fantastic Kofi Kingston escape spot, the finish was certainly a dampener on the night.
The saving grace of this event was the stellar triple threat competition between Brock Lesnar, John Cena and Seth Rollins. The three men put on an outstanding match and showed excellent chemistry, with the outcome seeming less predictable as the night wore on.
This Royal Rumble pay-per-view earns itself a place just above its predecessor due to that triple threat, as well as encouraging performances from Rusev and Kofi Kingston during the main event.
9. 2012
Three years before Roman Reigns was booed out of the Wells Fargo Center, the Royal Rumble was held in St Louis, Missouri and it was a night full of surprises.
During the main event, the Rumble match saw returns from Mick Foley, Kharma and the winner of the first-ever Royal Rumble match, Jim Duggan. Foley engaged with the 'Milan Miracle' Santino Marella, in a spot involving both of their signature moves - 'Mr Socko' and 'The Cobra'. Also, this event was the only time that the entire commentary desk has performed in a Royal Rumble, with surprise appearances from Michael Cole, Booker T and Jerry Lawler. It also saw Kofi Kingston survive elimination in an outrageous fashion yet again, this time landing on his hands and walking on them all the way back into the ring.
However, 2012's January pay-per-view event was not without its issues.
The eight-Diva tag team match was poorly received, the finish of Kane vs. John Cena was widely regarded as poor booking - as most matches ending with a double count-out usually are - and the inclusion of a blink-and-you'll-miss-it match between Brodus Clay and Drew McIntyre left fans scratching their heads while trying to find any reasoning behind it.
Thankfully, the arena did not ring with a chorus of boos when the eventual winner was revealed as the 'Celtic Warrior' Sheamus, with the WWE Universe in attendance being sent home happy - a trend which did not continue for future Royal Rumble pay-per-views.
8. 2013
Much like the year prior, the Royal Rumble was won by a superstar that fans actually supported - for the most part - in the form of John Cena. Cena found himself a two-time Royal Rumble victor (the first in 2008) when he eliminated Ryback last to earn himself a main event match at WrestleMania 29. However, the placement of the Rumble match on this card left little to the imagination. The 30-man brawl was placed one match before the WWE Championship match between CM Punk and The Rock, which meant that fans were able to predict the winner of that title bout before it even started.
The climax of the pay-per-view saw 'The Brahma Bull' overcome Punk and win the WWE Championship, leading to the blindingly obvious rematch of the 'Once In A Lifetime' match from WrestleMania just one year beforehand. Allowing The Rock to take the title away from Punk seemed an odd decision at the time, as Rocky was a part-time superstar and the WWE Universe believed that spots at the top of the card should be earned, rather than given.
The rest of the night had its ups and downs, particularly the return of Chris Jericho at the number two position, Kofi Kingston's miraculous escape on JBL's chair, and the appearance of NXT's Bo Dallas, to name a few. The annual January pay-per-view was not the worst effort that WWE have offered in recent years, with several positive moments and surprises - although some decisions were not well received - but this event earns its right to sit higher than its predecessor.
7. 2016
After the disappointment of both 2014 and 2015's Royal Rumble events, it seemed inevitable that 2016 would follow suit, with an underwhelming main event and a poorly-received winner. However, this event proved its worth over those two, with an improved Rumble match and the added thrill of the WWE Championship being on the line, it seemed as though WWE were trying to mix things up.
The show itself was opened with a stellar Last Man Standing match between Kevin Owens and Dean Ambrose for the Intercontinental Championship. Fans around the world widely describe this as one of the best opening matches on a pay-per-view and it certainly presented both men as stars in their own right. The added drama of both Ambrose and Owens entering the Rumble match later in the night provided a fantastic story, told through the excellent action in the ring.
However, the event seemed to lower in quality soon after that match. The triple threat Divas' Championship match was an invitation for superb spots, fantastic storytelling and engaging encounters between three of NXT's best female superstars - the memory of this match, however, is somewhat marred by the image of Ric Flair kissing Becky Lynch as a distraction technique. Reviews of the show unanimously agreed that this was a poor decision and an awful reminder of how women's wrestling was once treated.
Finally, the titular match of the evening brought about many of its own memorable moments. 2016 saw the debut of AJ Styles at number three - although it was hampered by a long display of Roman Reigns' face - and also the call-up of Sami Zayn. The main event saw superstars involved with their own ongoing storylines, with the Wyatt Family taking on Brock Lesnar and the League of Nations attacking Roman Reigns - per Vince McMahon's request.
The decisions to remove Reigns from the match for half an hour and then put the championship on the returning Triple H were not viewed very fondly at the time, as members of the WWE Universe were, again, not happy with seeing a 'part-timer' with the title heading into WrestleMania season and inevitably, another attempt at a Reigns coronation.
6. 2017
Evolution is a mystery, but their success is not.
Each of the members of Evolution has won at least one Royal Rumble in their career and in fitting fashion, Randy Orton captured his second in 2017. At the time, Orton was involved in a storyline with Bray Wyatt and Luke Harper as a member of the Wyatt Family. He would go on to turn on Wyatt and face him for the WWE Championship at WrestleMania 33, which was given negative reviews by many WWE fans.
Also, during the event, John Cena took on AJ Styles for the WWE Championship and defeated the 'Phenomenal One' to capture his record 16th world championship in WWE. This match is often regarded as the match of the night, with both Styles and Cena executing outstanding manoeuvres and creating an air of unpredictability around their match. The chemistry between both men is evident throughout the contest and the WWE Universe in San Antonio appeared to support Cena's victory.
As with every pay-per-view event, there were also some bad moments. Sending Roman Reigns into the Rumble at number 30 was definitely one of them. The fans in attendance were anticipating a big return or potential surprise as the final entrant - they were left reeling after the 'Big Dog' appeared - and the crowd began to turn on Reigns yet again. It appeared as though WWE didn't know how to handle Roman Reigns at the Royal Rumble, with this being the third consecutive year that he was booed, even while booked as a face.
The opening title bout between Reigns and Owens - which saw Chris Jericho suspended above the ring in a shark cage - was given a mild reaction, with 'Y2J' being the saving grace, due to his natural comedic ability. Also, Orton's victory in the main event was so well-received because the WWE Universe had decided that they would cheer anyone over Roman Reigns. Thankfully, from this point onwards, it seems as though WWE learnt their lesson when it came to the January pay-per-view.
5. 2010
The first Royal Rumble of the past decade was a very exciting one, with returns and memorable moments throughout the main event.
This event saw Rey Mysterio hold his own against The Undertaker, with a fantastic performance demonstrating how talented Mysterio is. Also, the seeds were sown for the eventual dissension of Legacy - Randy Orton, Cody Rhodes and Ted DiBiase Jr's faction - due to Rhodes' attack on Sheamus costing Orton his shot at the WWE Championship.
Impressive performances from established stars were not enough to save this entire pay-per-view, however, as a disturbing angle involving body-shaming between Mickie James and LayCool demonstrated a clear disinterest in the women's division at the time, as well as an underwhelming United States Championship match between MVP and The Miz.
Energy levels around the Philips Arena were beginning to drop until the Royal Rumble match began. After Dolph Ziggler and Evan Bourne entered the ring, the match began to pick up steam. At number three, CM Punk entered and eliminated both men, before proceeding to run down every member of the WWE roster and claim to be better than everyone in the arena. This demonstration of Punk's natural ability was a display of his charisma and potential that would carry him into the next three years as a top-level superstar.
As the match wore on, the WWE Universe had already seen their fair share of memorable moments: Beth Phoenix eliminated The Great Khali and D-Generation X wiped out everyone in their path, but no-one was prepared for the 29th entrant. The 'Rated-R Superstar' came out to a thundering roar of support from the WWE Universe, as his music hit and he returned after six months away from the ring.
Edge made a beeline for Chris Jericho - his former best friend - in order to make a statement and prove that he was one of the best in professional wrestling. The 'Ultimate Opportunist' stormed to the ring to a shower of cheers and proved that sometimes, WWE can send their fans home happy after a major pay-per-view.
4. 2011
Just when WWE had got things right with Edge's Rumble victory, they decided that it was time to mess with the formula.
In 2011, the Royal Rumble gained an extra ten men, with the first and only 40-man Rumble match taking place. As expected, this led to more surprises and open spots that allowed for memorable moments. This match saw the return of 'Big Daddy Cool' Diesel, as well as the surprise appearance of Booker T - both of these unexpected appearances drew huge pops from the WWE fans in Boston.
The WWE Universe was fully behind 'The Milan Miracle', Santino Marella during the build to the event, however, no-one genuinely believed that he might win the whole thing. This meant that his dramatic reveal as the last man alongside Alberto Del Rio received a hugely positive reaction - until he was unceremoniously thrown out of the ring by 'The Essence of Excellence'. Del Rio won the historic match and earned himself a title match at WrestleMania against Edge, in what would be Edge's final match.
Also during the pay-per-view, Dolph Ziggler tried (and failed) to capture the World Heavyweight Championship from 'The Rated-R Superstar', in what many consider to be the best match of the night. Both superstars put on an outstanding performance, as did The Miz and Randy Orton in their WWE Championship bout.
This show was an example of WWE changing the formula and making an improvement, which no-one expected after previous examples of poor decision making. Overall, this show was a success and the matches were all impressive, unfortunately, the Royal Rumble events started to go downhill from there - that is, until 2018.
3. 2018
The Royal Rumble rolled around at its usual time in 2018 and this year, it brought with it a second Rumble match - the female superstars were finally given their time to shine.
With two Rumble matches on offer, the number of surprises and memorable moments was likely to be doubled. The men's bout saw five surprise appearances, with NXT call-ups for both Andrade and Adam Cole, as well as returns from The Hurricane, John Cena and Rey Mysterio. The appearances from both Cena and Mysterio allowed for the famous 'The Old Guard vs. The New Guard' spot: Finn Bálor, Shinsuke Nakamura and Roman Reigns had a stand-off with Rey Mysterio, John Cena and Randy Orton. This visual was impactful as it demonstrated a metaphorical passing of the torch from the stars of the past to the stars of the future.
On the other hand, the inaugural Women's Royal Rumble was won by Asuka, after she eliminated Nikki Bella. Many surprise entrants were involved in this match, as the women's roster at the time was not quite dense enough to fill a Rumble contest. The returns of Lita, Torrie Wilson, Molly Holly, Michelle McCool, Vickie Guerrero, Kelly Kelly, Jacqueline, Brie Bella and Trish Stratus emphasised the important nature of this match, as several key female figures from the history of WWE appeared to endorse its creation. After the match, the long-anticipated appearance of Ronda Rousey highlighted her involvement at WrestleMania 34 and a brand new star in the women's division.
Elsewhere on the card, AJ Styles defended his WWE Championship in an engaging handicap match against Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn. Also, the SmackDown Tag Team Championships were defended in a 2-out-of-3-falls match between The Usos and Shelton Benjamin & Chad Gable, a contest regarded as one of the best of the night. On the other hand, the Raw Tag Team Championship match was underwhelming and the Universal Championship was defended in a dull Triple Threat match between Brock Lesnar, Kane and Braun Strowman.
As an entire pay-per-view, Royal Rumble 2018 was impressive and it showcased a lot of new talent, with NXT call-ups and returns, as well as outstanding matches and exciting crowd reactions. It did not seem that this event would be topped, with 2019's event expected to be a step-down. However, that was not the case.
2. 2019
2019's event saw the second Women's Rumble match and a much larger card on display for the WWE Universe.
The event was opened by Becky Lynch and Asuka, in a stellar bout for the SmackDown Women's Championship, which saw 'The Empress of Tomorrow' retain her title via submission over 'The Man'. Shortly after that match, Daniel Bryan retained his WWE Championship against AJ Styles, meaning that Bryan would have a target on his back after the Men's Rumble match. Another man with a target would be 'The Beast Incarnate' - Brock Lesnar defeated Finn Bálor in a fantastic match that displayed 'The Demon King's' amazing in-ring ability, as well as Lesnar's aptitude for working with smaller superstars.
The titular matches of the night saw Seth Rollins overcome the odds to win the Royal Rumble, as well as Becky Lynch taking over Lana's entry slot to surprise every woman in the ring and win the Rumble, setting her on a crash course with Ronda Rousey. Lynch and Rousey would go on to feud until WrestleMania 35, with Charlotte being added into the mix in order to carry out the first-ever women's 'Mania main event.
Rollins' victory also set him up for a groundbreaking match against Lesnar, one that the 'Beastslayer' managed to win and become Universal Champion for the first time in his career. The support that Rollins had from the WWE Universe was nuclear, as he was more over than he had ever been in his career. His victory to close out the show had the fans in Phoenix leaving the arena happy, which was a rare occurrence in the year beforehand.
Also, the Men's Rumble match saw a return for Jeff Jarrett after 20 years, as well as various appearances from NXT and NXT UK superstars. Johnny Gargano, Pete Dunne and Aleister Black all arrived on the main event scene to showcase the talent that NXT had in its ranks. The final entrant was scheduled to be R-Truth after he won the Mixed Match Challenge with Carmella. However, Nia Jax attacked him and took his spot, becoming the fourth woman to enter a Men's Royal Rumble match. She attacked - and eliminated - Mustafa Ali, but soon after that she received a superkick, a 619 and an RKO before being eliminated.
The 2019 Royal Rumble event initially had top spot on this list due to its consistent match quality and fan favourite ending, as well as the surprise returns and debuts for superstars that the WWE Universe admired - however, after the most recent pay-per-view, it had to be moved down a step, in order to allow for 2020's show to sit at the top.
1. 2020
This year's Royal Rumble rightfully earns its place at the top of this list, with many shocks and surprises as well as huge crowd reactions and excellent booking.
The show's opening affair saw Roman Reigns take on King Corbin in a falls-count-anywhere match that was a testament to its stipulation. The two competitors used all of the ground given to them, by exiting the ring and exploring all areas of the Minute Maid Park - there was no location off-limits for these men. Even with the interference of Corbin's associates, Dolph Ziggler and Robert Roode - as well as the arrival of The Usos - this match could not be slowed down. Eventually, both men ended up near the dugout of the baseball stadium, before 'The Big Dog' hit his trademark spear on Corbin to pick up the victory.
Next was the Women's Royal Rumble, which was kicked off by Alexa Bliss and Bianca Belair. This match featured a multitude of surprise appearances, from the amazing - Beth Phoenix and Shayna Baszler - to the underwhelming, such as Santina Marella. This Rumble match was more likely to feature surprise returns or debuts, due to the lack of confirmed superstars prior to the match. A fantastic match, which was well-balanced and efficiently booked, this bout saw the favourite to win, Shayna Baszler, thrown out last by Charlotte Flair.
The toughest spot of the night was always going to be in between the two Royal Rumble matches, and so it proved. Bayley vs. Lacey Evans was met with a worn-out crowd, regardless of the decent action in the ring from both women. Also, Daniel Bryan vs. The Fiend was filled with cringe-inducing spots, as both men used the strap as a weapon - with the welts on Bryan's back serving as a cruel reminder that wrestlers truly put their bodies on the line for the audiences every week. The penultimate match of the night saw Becky Lynch defend her RAW Women's Championship against Asuka, in an excellent spectacle of women's wrestling. However, the fantastic in-ring action was again, hampered by the exhausted crowd.
Finally came the Men's Royal Rumble match.
Brock Lesnar entered - as promised - at the number one position, and was shortly followed by 'The Drifter', Elias. This began Lesnar's reign of terror in the Rumble match, as he swiftly eliminated each entrant that followed, tallying up an extraordinary total of 13 eliminations. Removing names such as Kofi Kingston, Rey Mysterio and Keith Lee, Lesnar dominated the match until Drew McIntyre made himself known by hitting a Claymore Kick on 'The Beast Incarnate' and knocking him out.
The match also saw the return of MVP after ten years, although he was quickly fed to 'The Beast'. Also, this match brought 'The Rated-R Superstar' Edge back to our screens for the first time in nine years. His return brought the house down in Houston, with the emotion being evident on his face as he made his way to the ring. As his signature theme hit, the WWE Universe in attendance - and those watching around the world - rose to their feet to celebrate the return of one of the most beloved WWE superstars ever.
The match came down to its final four - Randy Orton, Roman Reigns, Edge and the eventual winner, Drew McIntyre. 'The Scottish Psychopath' waited until the perfect moment to strike, hitting Reigns with a Claymore and eliminating him to win the 2020 Men's Royal Rumble.
This pay-per-view deserves its place as the best Royal Rumble event of the last ten years, due to the shock factor in both Rumble matches, as well as the excellent story-telling and crowd-pleasing results. This Rumble event will go down in history as having one of the best Royal Rumble matches ever, as well as being a mostly outstanding show.