Ranking Every WWE Superstar Shake-Up Move From Worst To Best

Which movers and shakers on both Raw and SmackDown made the most sense?

By Jamie Kennedy /

WWE

WWE moved 31 superstars (if you consider tag-teams and wrestler/manager duos as individuals) across two nights on this week's Raw and SmackDown. In the process, the company split four tags and stables, and decided to shift the Intercontinental Title sideways to Tuesday nights. Now, it looks like Samoa Joe and his US belt could be going the other way to Raw, but that's yet to be confirmed.

Advertisement

There's a whole lotta' shaking going on.

Only time will tell how fruitful each move will prove to be; that's just the way it is, and it'd be unfair to analyse each properly for at least a few months. That, ladies and gents, doesn't mean we can't take a snapshot look at each roster move and inspect them at face value. There are positives to take from this Shake-Up, and there are (of course) some negatives.

Advertisement

WWE could never hope to please everybody with every single move they made though. That'd be unrealistic, and it was always going to be far more important to give the rosters on both major brands a fresh feel post-WrestleMania. Could they manage that, and vivify their product?

Yes and no...

Advertisement

26. Eric Young (Raw)

WWE.com

Eric Young and "vivify" don't fit in the same sentence right now.

Advertisement

At first glance, splitting Young from his SAnitY teammates and putting him on Raw solo is a mistake. EY has just replaced Apollo Crews as a lower-carder stuck in mid-card hell on the Monday night show, and it's hard to see him doing much as a singles. Let's hope we're wrong, but we don't think this'll do much to spruce up Young's career.

25. Apollo Crews (SmackDown)

WWE.com

Speak of the devil, it's Apollo Crews himself, a man who's already been on SmackDown before and must be crossing his fingers that things will be different this time. A move to Raw in April 2017 did nothing for the man's prospects. Aside from a brief stint in Titus Worldwide, he hasn't been given a chance to get over either, nor showcase his stunning aerial skills.

Advertisement

Don't get your hopes up.

24. Mickie James (SmackDown)

WWE

Hey, Mickie, you're so fine you blow my mind. As fine a talent as the veteran female is though, she's cannon fodder for a revamped women's division on Tuesday evenings after her shift from Raw. There's no more sidekick work alongside Alexa Bliss for James. She's on her own now, and that'll possibly mean a babyface run.

Advertisement

It'll most likely be a face run away from the SmackDown Women's Title.

23. Cedric Alexander (Raw)

WWE.com

WWE are hoping lightning will strike twice with the 205 Live lot and let Cedric Alexander bed onto the main roster like Ali has. The announcers even used that comparison on this week's Raw, suggesting that Alexander could be in for a mini-push on Mondays. The question is, how long will that honeymoon period last?

Advertisement

Cedric, a former Cruiserweight Champ, has the talent, but he needs to be put in situations that don't expose his lack of mic skills.

22. Naomi (Raw)

WWE.com

Naomi was overdue a change of scenery, and this year's Superstar Shake-Up was the perfect time to do it. At the same time, one can't shake (ahem) the thought that she was only put on Raw so she wouldn't be separated from her boys The Usos. Adding to that thought is the fact WWE haven't done anything with her for the longest time on SmackDown.

Advertisement

Her move is humdrum without being disastrous.

21. EC3 (Raw)

WWE.com

Despite being in the physical shape of his life and having showed how satisfyingly smug he can be on the mic in Impact for years, one EC3 hasn't had any breaks to speak of across two stints in WWE. His latest role appears to be as a mute prima donna, one who's only good for Braun Strowman squashes. If you're a Carter fan, it's time to be concerned.

Advertisement

Things do not look good.

20. Heavy Machinery (SmackDown)

WWE.com

A few gaps have started to open up in SmackDown's tag division. The Usos are no longer there, and the combo of Big E's injury and Kofi Kingston's WWE Title push mean The New Day are absent as well. That could well be Heavy Machinery's niche on the blue brand. They're a comedy duo, which is something Tuesdays lack right now.

Advertisement

Here's hoping WWE don't turn them into this generation's Jesse and Festus.

19. Lars Sullivan (SmackDown)

WWE.com

On Monday, it seemed like big Lars Sullivan had been posted to Raw. Then, 24 hours later he was beating the dance moves out of R-Truth and making Carmella quake in her boots. Definitively, Tom Phillips said the NXT nightmare was SmackDown-bound. That's that then, although it'll take more than Vladimir Kozlov-style squashing for Sullivan to get over.

Advertisement

If nothing else, he's away from Braun Strowman, a man who's a much more convincing monster on Raw.

18. Ember Moon (SmackDown)

WWE.com

Ember Moon talked a good game on her SmackDown debut by daring to throw her name in the hat as a future challenger for Becky Lynch. The big problem WWE will have is following up on Ronda Rousey and Charlotte Flair. In other words, it'll be a tall order to convince the fans that anyone, including Moon, is a real threat to 'The Man'.

Advertisement

This one is a thinly-veiled hit of the refresh button post-injury.