Ranking WWE Judgment Day PPVs - From Worst To Best

Judging 'Judgment Day'...the bitter irony.

By Lewis Howse /

Man, WWE pay-per-views used to have such badass names. Come on, who doesn't want to watch a show called Armageddon or Judgement Day? Hell, the big guy in the sky might even make an appearance. Oh, wait. That was Backlash 2006, wasn't it? Never mind...

Advertisement

The fact is that WWE PPVs, even the 'B' level events, used to have a much stronger identity. Maybe it had something to do with WWE not using the same set every single time, or the fact that the brand split created two distinct types of supercard, but it's true.

One pay-per-view that I always looked forward to was Judgement Day. I'm not entirely sure why, since WWE notably dipped in quality in the spring as they experienced the post-WrestleMania slump. I think a lot of it had to do with great matches like The Rock versus Triple H in their incredible Iron Match, Eddie Guerrero and JBL's blood-soaked epic and Orlando Jordan versus Heidenreich...

Okay, maybe not that last one, but Judgement Day was host to some truly remarkable during its existence between 1998 and 2009. Great matches, maybe, but the shows themselves could be hit and miss at the best of times.

Since we're now in May (a month now host to two PPVs/specials), let's take a trip down memory lane and look at the month's former designated pay-per-view - Judgement Day.

The end is near, ladies and gentleman...

11. 2003

The Good

Advertisement

Match of the night honours went to the Eddie Guerrero & Tajiri Vs. World's Greatest Tag Team ladder match. The Japanese Buzzsaw was an eleventh hour replacement for Eddie's nephew, Chavo, who tore his bicep days before the event. Tajiri slotted in fine and the bout was very good indeed.

That was about it, as far as good matches go. The Big Show versus Brock Lesnar Stretcher Match was fun in a goofy way, but it wasn't anything you need to watch twice. Brock looked really good and was very over as a babyface champ here, which was encouraging at the time.

The Bad

Scott Steiner & Test's clash with La Resistance was good, old-fashioned xenophobic wrestling fun. See, the Genetic Freak and his partner hated La Resistance because they were french and had to beat them up because AMERICAN GOD DAMMIT. It was not good. No, it was not.

Even worse was Mr. America versus Roddy Piper. Honestly, watching this in 2003 was just really, really sad. It lasted just shy of five minutes and featured run-ins from Sean O'Haire, Zach Gowen and Vince McMahon. 2003 was a really, really weird year for WWE, guys.

The Intercontinental Title was brought back after being shelved for seven months and was won by Christian in a completely unremarkable battle royal. Really, there should have been a major tournament over this, especially since there was no King of the Ring that year.

Triple H and Kevin Nash had a positively rotten World Heavyweight Title match, which lasted a paltry seven-and-a-half minutes and had a lame DQ finish.

The Rest

WWE put most of their efforts into promoting and presenting the bikini contest between Torrie Wilson and Sable. Priorities.

10. 2004

The Good

Advertisement

I might be in the minority here, but I absolutely loved the Eddie Guerrero versus JBL top-liner. This was the former Bradshaw's first major match since turning heel, going solo and reinventing himself as a JR Ewing style character.

The match was bloody, brutal and quite epic. Of course, everyone remembers it for the truly ridiculous amount of blood the champion spilled, but it was chugging along nicely before that gory blade job went down, too. JBL won via DQ, setting up another grudge match the next month at the Great American Bash.

The only other half decent thing on the show was the opener, which pitter high-flying babyfaces Rob Van Dam and Rey Mysterio against the Dudley Boys.

The Bad

Just about everything else. Judgment Day 2004 was one of the poorest PPV undercards you're likely to see, with such classics as Torrie Wilson Vs. Dawn Marie No. 2,565, Mordecai Vs. Scotty Too Hotty, Chavo Guerrero Vs. Jacqueline and Charlie Haas & Rico Vs. Hardcore Holly & Billy Gunn.

The matches that should have delivered (Undertaker Vs. Booker T and Rene Dupree Vs. John Cena), really didn't, meaning that the show was bookended by two decent matches but the rest was skippable.

The Rest

Latino Heat lost so much blood in the main event that he went into shock backstage after the event and had to be taken to hospital. He refused a blood transfusion (against doctor's orders) but did let them stitch up his mammoth wound. It required sixteen stitches to close and the whole episode left Guerrero weakened for days.

9. 2002

The Good

Advertisement

Judgment Day 2002 belonged to Kurt Angle and Edge, who positively tore it up in their Hair versus Hair encounter. The two men, who had been Smackdown MVPs for some time, had an absolute stunner filled with believable nearfalls and great wrestling.

Speaking of great wrestling, Eddie Guerrero and Rob Van Dam had another good entry in their Intercontinental Title feud in the show's opener. Eddie got the rope-assisted win after ten minutes of exciting action.

And Triple H and Chris Jericho might not have had a classic, but they delivered the drama and the brutality expected of the Hell in a Cell stipulation. This pairing worked far better when the roles were reversed, though, with Trips as the heel and Jericho as the face.

The Bad

The Undertaker and Hulk Hogan had an absolute shocker of a main event. The Hulkster's brief, nostalgia-fuelled WWE Title run came to a screeching halt following one awful, sanbagged chokeslam courtesy of The Deadman. Thankfully, Hogan's role would change after this and he began working on the undercard.

Steve Austin's handicap match victory over Big Show and Ric Flair wasn't very inspiring and should give you some clues as to why Stone Cold was so pissed off with WWE creative around this time. Stacy versus Trish was just an excuse to get the recently split Dudley Boys out there and Rikishi & Rico versus Billy & Chuck was a sorry indictment of the Tag Team Title scene at the time.

The Rest

This was not a happy show for referee Tim White, who injured his shoulder when taking a bump into the side of the Cell so badly that he has to retire soon afterwards.

8. 1998

The Good

Advertisement

The midcard delivered some good matches, if nothing else. Christian, in his very first televised match, won the Light-heavyweight Title from TAKA Michinoku in a good match. He'd lose it a month later to Gillberg, true, but it's the thought that counts.

Following that match were two really good ones. First, Goldust beat Val Venis in a match that was being foguht over Terri Runnels. Then D-Lo Brown (one of the unsung heroes of the Attitude Era) and X-Pac had a belter over the European Championship.

Following those were a halfway decent New Age Outlaws versus Headbangers match and an IC Title match between Mankind and Ken Shamrock, which had a very creative finish.

The Bad

The Undertaker versus Kane headliner - with Steve Austin as the guest referee - was the pits. It was just slow and plodding and not very good at all. These two had little chemistry with each other, actually, outside of their WrestleMania XIV match. To top it all off, Austin declared himself the winner when both men were counted down. Dumb, dumb, dumb...

The start of the show had useless filler like Marc Mero (whose WWE career was quite clearly nearing its end) taking on Al Snow and LOD 2000 & Droz versus the DOA.

The Rest

The event drew 18,153 to the Rosemont Horizon in Illinois. WWE sure could pack them in during this particular era.

7. 2007

The Good

Advertisement

The was nothing exceptional on the Judgment Day 2007 pay-per-view. In fact, the best match of the night was probably Chris Benoit and MVP's 2/3 Falls match over the United States Title, which MVP won by beating The Rabid Wolverine in two straight falls.

The Hardy Boys and Lance Cade & Trevor Murdoch had a good World Tag Team Title match, too, but the Redneck Wrecking Crew's tweener status seemed to confuse the crowd and the reaction wasn't really there, despite the work itself being pretty damn good.

And Batista and Edge had an alright World Heavyweight Title match built around The Animal's leg injury. They'd have better PPV matches against each other in 2007, but this one was OK.

The Bad

Any supercard that has The Great Khali headlining can't be good. The punjabi giant's match with John Cena was smartly worked, yes, but didn't create the requisite excitement a PPV main event should. At eight minutes in length, at least it was kept short.

Umaga, Shane and Vince McMahon versus Bobby Lashley was ridiculously short, whereas CM Punk versus Elijah Burke felt way, way too long. Shawn Michaels versus Randy Orton, meanwhile, was more of an angle than an actual match, necessitated due to HBK's knee injury.

The Rest

This was Chris Benoit's last ever PPV match. The Benoit family tragedy would happen a month afterwards.

6. 2009

The Good

Advertisement

The eleventh and final Judgment Day PPV was just kind of...there. There was nothing exceptional on the show, really, but nothing outwardly terrible, either.

Chris Jericho was Judgment Day MVP (again), as he produced another cracking match with Rey Mysterio. Like the Michaels match in 2008, this would be the first in a long series of them.

On top, Jeff Hardy and Edge had a mildly disappointing match. It was still good - those two would hardly put on a trainwreck - but watching it it's hard to shake the feeling that they were perhaps holding back a little and had another gear to kick into.

Other matches that fell under the 'perfectly acceptable wrestling banner' were the Umaga Vs. CM Punk opener, John Morrison Vs. Shelton Benjamin and Jack Swagger Vs. Christian (ECW Champion). All were fine and had some good wrestling, but there was just something missing.

The Bad

Big Show Vs. John Cena was pretty bad, guys, and Randy Orton Vs. Batista wasn't that much better. Both dragged on longer than they should and had weird finishes. The Batista/Orton match is pretty good, though, if you're a chinlock enthusiast.

The Rest

Joey Styles took a unique approach towards promoting the PPV by tweeting 'Even those misled Americans who voted for the Marxist Barack Hussein Obama are invited to join the Judgment Day Live Chat on WWEUNIVERSE.com.'

What a nice fella.

5. 2008

The Good

Advertisement

Judgment Day 2008 was Chris Jericho and Shawn Michaels' night. The two talented veterans stole the show with their match, the third on the card, which helped kick off the best rivalry of the year. It was only meant to be a one time thing, but WWE were so impressed with their storytelling and chemistry that they booked them to have a longer dispute. Definitely check this one out if you get the chance.

Other good matches came courtesy of Edge and The Undertaker and Randy Orton and Batista. But then, given their talent level and how many times they'd clash previously, you'd expect them to, wouldn't you?

The Bad

Nothing offensive on here, but a lot of average. Cena and JBL once again demonstrated that they have little chemistry with one another in the opener (they had one great match together, of which we'll get to in due course). Watching their matches was almost always a tough ask.

The Mickie James/Beth Phoenix/Melina Women's Title match was alright for what it was, but seriously rushed. MVP versus Jeff Hardy, meanwhile, was just a match between two guys. It had no reason to exist on this card, and the two men wrestled like it had just been thrown together.

The Rest

Hardcore Holly & Cody Rhode retained their Tag Team Titles against the positively wacky pairing of Carlito & Santino Marella in the dark match. I'm bet you're glad you know that piece of information, aren't you?

4. 2006

The Good

Advertisement

Another great wrestling show during a good era for the blue brand. The Smackdown-exclusive show kicked off with a surprising Tag Team Title switch, as the team of Paul London and Brian Kendrick upset MNM to bag the gold in a good match.

That was followed up by a wonderful old-school wrestling match between Chris Benoit and Fit Finlay. The two men took their time, worked every hold and had the crowd's attention for the full twenty minutes that they were out there. This one should be required viewing for anyone currently training at the Performance Center.

Kurt Angle and Mark Henry had a much better match than they did in the main event of the Royal Rumble (which was dire). Angle looked seriously motivated here and was made out to be an absolute beast when he demolished Mizark after the bell had rung.

Booker T and Bobby Lashley had a good King of the Ring final, which was won by the five-time WCW Champion, setting off his highly entertaining run as King Booker. Lashley, while not an incredible worker, was clearly starting to get a lot better at this point.

And finally Rey Mysterio - the man who was booked about as poorly as any World Champion ever - defeated JBL in a great main event. Big bully Bradshaw is great when he's 'on' and a guy like Mysterio is a perfect opponent for him so this was just fine, thank you very much.

The Bad

Melina versus Jillian was nothing to write home about and Gregory Helms and his 1,000 neckbreaker variations against Super Crazy was so-so.

The Rest

Turned out that MNM dropping the tag titles and then breaking up wasn't such a shocker after all, at least not to the locker room: Mercury needed to go to rehab to fight substance abuse issues while Nitro and Melina had garnered so much heat that management were desperate to send them to Raw in order to keep the peace.

3. 2005

The Good

Advertisement

This was, from top to bottom, quite the wrestling show, capped off by two fantastic matches at the top of the card. First, Rey Mysterio and Eddie Guerrero had their first big match since Eddie officially turned heel. It was wonderful, with Eddie masterfully controlling the pace and using some great psychology to really get fans invested. They'd have other great matches over the spring and summer months, but this one might have been their best of that year.

John Cena and JBL had a barnstorming I Quit match in the main event. While their other matches together were tepid at best, this one was truly great thanks to the stipulation and both men's willingness to go all-out and put their wellbeing on the line.

On the undercard, Hardcore Holly & Charlie Haas had a good Tag Team Title opener with MNM, Paul London and Chavo Guerrero had a tight Cruiserweight Title collision and Kurt Angle and Booker T had a decent match, even if the storyline (the whole 'Kurt Angle wants to have his way with Booker's wife' thing) was ludicrous and in poor taste.

The Bad

Carlito versus Big Show and Orlando Jordan versus Heidenreich were about as good as you'd imagine i.e. not very.

The Rest

In the Show/Carlito match, the cool one's stuttering bodyguard Matt Morgan came in the ring and dropped Show with an F5. This was right about the time Lesnar was suing WWE over his no-compete clause, in case you were wondering...

2. 2001

The Good

Advertisement

Not a bad show at all, this. The best match of the night was Chris Benoit and Kurt Angle's 2/3 falls match (first fall regular match, second fall submission rules and third fall ladder) which, at almost half an hour in length, never felt like it outstayed its welcome, such was the talent of both men.

Benoit returned later in the evening, putting in another shift alongside Chris Jericho in the WWE Tag Team Title Tag Team Turmoil match. The Calgary Kids got the surprise win after beating Edge and Christian in the best match of the series.

In the main event, a resurgent Steve Austin had a good brawl with The Undertaker, which was replete with all the Attitude Era shenanigans you'd expect (liberal amounts of interference, fighting in the crowd etc.). The other half of the Two Man Power Trip, Triple H, lost to Kane in an entertaining Chain Match earlier in the show. The Big Red Machine received a sizeable pop when he pinned the dastardly Cerebral Assassin.

The Big Show Vs. Rhyno Vs. Test for the Hardcore Title was also a lot of fun. The Man Beast really did wonders for that belt, but his larger opponents were game here as well.

The Bad

Nothing really terrible, but Lita should have been given more in her Women's Title challenge of Chyna. The Ninth Wonder of the World would be gone from the company soon after, as WWE could never convince her to compete regularly with the women.

The Rest

Jerry Lynn cut one of the lamest 'shoot' promos ever on this show. Speaking live from WWF New York, the Light-heavyweight Champion expressed his bitterness with not being featured and seemed to blame commentator/head of talent relations JR for his plight.

It was going OK before he signed off with an unintentionally hilarious death metal grunt...

1. 2000

The Good

Advertisement

Pretty much all of this was good stuff, as Judgment Day 2000 was one of WWE's finest PPVs during their hottest period. The characters were over, the storylines well thought out and the wrestling great. What's not to love here?

Credit must first go to the main event and Triple H and The Rock, who busted their backsides for sixty minutes in a hugely enjoyable Iron Man match. The great in-ring work was capped off by the return of The Undertaker, now in his American Badass phase.

The night got off to a great start with a red-hot six-man pitting Too Cool & Rikishi against Edge, Christian & Kurt Angle. As far as openers go, this one was pretty much perfect. It was followed up with a technically sound triple threat match pitting European Champion Eddie Guerrero against his Radicalz brethren Dean Malenko and Perry Saturn.

The other radical, Chris Benoit, retained his Intercontinental Title against Chris Jericho in a phenomenal and very stiff Submission Match. These two clashed many times on PPV around this time, but it was always welcome because they always delivered the goods.

Although they weren't quite on the same level as the aforementioned contests, Shane McMahon versus Big Show (Falls Count Anywhere) and the Dudley Boys versus Road Dogg & X-Pac (Table Match) were a lot of fun and served their purpose.

The Bad

Nothing. The show wasn't perfect but it was remarkably consistent.

The Rest

Throughout the night new WWF Hardcore Champion Gerald Brisco tried to escape the show with the title around his waist and was so paranoid that he ended up running away from referees and attacking concession vendors.

Hey, it's funnier than it sounds...

Advertisement