7 WrestleMania Matches That Weren’t All Bad
It might not be obvious upon first glance, but these matches do have some redeeming features.
Since its debut at Madison Square Garden in New York City on March 31, 1985, WWEs annual WrestleMania extravaganza has brought us some of the greatest pro wrestling matches ever contested.
Randy Savage vs. Ricky Steamboat (1987), Savage vs. The Ultimate Warrior (1991), Shawn Michaels vs. Razor Ramon (1994), Bret Hart vs. Steve Austin (1997), Austin vs. The Rock (2001), Michaels vs. Kurt Angle (2005), Edge vs. The Undertaker (2008), Michaels vs. Undertaker (2009 and 2010) and others held at the show of shows are widely regarded as classics.
Along this epic journey, through 31 events on which there have collectively been more than 320 matches, Vince McMahons organisation has subjected us to oodles of painfully average and dismal confrontations, which are not remembered fondly or even remembered at all. Of course it has. And then there are those matches which fall into another category: bouts dismissed by pundits and wrestling devotees as absurd, tedious or dreadful which, upon further evaluation, are not entirely devoid of merit.
It might not be obvious upon first glance, but these matches do have some redeeming features.
Here are seven such WrestleMania scraps which, contrary to conventional wisdom, do deserve your attention. Misjudged, these matches are worth revisiting, for various reasons . . .
7. Hulk Hogan vs. Andre The Giant - WrestleMania III (1987)
Panned by many critics for its clumsy exchanges and glacial pace, the match between WWF heavyweight champion Hulk Hogan and Andre The Giant at WrestleMania III has been described as one of the shoddiest WrestleMania matches ever presented. However, if you can bring yourself to overlook its (admittedly glaring) technical flaws, you will discover a match which has much to savour: a simple yet effective story, dense crowd noise and a stunning outcome. This match deserves a repeat viewing.
To set the scene: Hogan was hellbent on revenge after Andre, his longtime friend and partner, had turned his back on him in January 1987, took the despised Bobby Heenan as his manager and challenged him to a heavyweight title match at WrestleMania. A bewildered Hogan refused to believe Andre could succumb to the dark side and consort with Heenan, until Andre tore off Hogans T-shirt and necklace. The symbolism was obvious: like Hogans chain, the friendship between Hogan and Andre was broken.
Tension mounted when Andre eliminated Hogan, with remarkable ease, from a battle royal broadcast on Saturday Nights Main Event on March 14, 1987. Fifteen days later, Hogan and Andre clashed one-on-one at WrestleMania from the Pontiac Silverdome in Pontiac, Michigan.
The sell out crowd of 78,000 (or 93,193, according to WWE lore) was a-buzz as Hogan made his entrance. This is the biggest match in the history of professional wrestling, said announcer Jesse Ventura. Based on the live attendance, then the largest in wrestling history, and combined closed-circuit and pay-per-view audiences, also record-breaking, he was right.
As a wild-eyed, shuddering Hogan approached a sneering Andre, Gorilla Monsoon remarked, The irresistible force meeting the immovable object. It was neither the first nor the last time Monsoon uttered those words. Never were they more apt.
The towering, massively muscled Hogan had reigned as WWF heavyweight champion since January 23, 1984. Andre, who was even larger, had been undefeated for 15 years, according to the pre-event hype.
Hogan struck with blows to Andres head and attempted a bodyslam. Failing to support Andres 500-pound frame, Hogan toppled backwards and hit the mat with Andres weight upon him. Hogan barely raised a shoulder before the referees count of three.
Hogans miscalculation pushed the drama levels up to maximum. WWF fans had seen Hogan absorb and recover from umpteen beatings from monsters. But Andre was in a league of his own in that department. How could Hogan rebound from this setback, just moments into his defence against the omnipotent, supposedly unbeaten-in-15-years Giant?
Andre worked over Hogans back, which the defending champion sold with conviction. From there, the match settled into a pattern of Hogan comebacks, which Andre thwarted. Crowd noise rose and fell accordingly.
Fittingly, the finale was the high point of their emotional roller coaster ride.
Hulking up, Hogan lifted spectators into a frenzy, which peaked when he successfully hoisted Andre for the slam he had earlier failed to complete and landed the customary legdrop for the three count. Hogan had done it again: he defeated the apparently unbeatable Giant.
Despite the spotlessly clean ending, the dispute between the mega-over Hogan and Andre continued well into 1988. So revered were these two titans of the ring, their quarterfinal match in the WWF heavyweight title tournament at WrestleMania IV was the main selling point of the show. The match lacked the intense atmosphere and drama of the historic Mania III collision. No need to watch this one again.
6. Vince McMahon vs. Shane McMahon - WrestleMania X-Seven (2001)
Lost on a stacked WrestleMania card was the street fight between tyrannical heel Vince McMahon and plucky babyface Shane McMahon who, six days earlier, had pulled off the coup to end all coups when he procured WCW from under his fathers nose. Of course, the acquisition of WCW ended very badly for Shane eight months later. But thats another story.
What Vince and Shane lacked in skill, they made up for in effort and wild abandon; these two went at it hammer and tongs. Shane suffered swelling near his right eye from Vinces punches, and Vince received a proper beating with a kendo stick, computer monitor and other props.
Vince gained the advantage when Stephanie McMahon, who had sided with her father, yanked him out of harms way as Shane performed his trademark flying elbow from the top rope onto the announce desk.
As Shane sold the impact of his crash and burn onto the table, the add-ons were activated to fill time. Trish Stratus, who had previously been humiliated by Vince and Stephanie, slapped Vince and attacked Stephanie, who appeared to be in genuine peril as she fled from Stratus. If only Steph had the courage to show such vulnerability in 2016. Vince flattened special referee Mick Foley with wicked chair shots at ringside, and then shoved wife Linda into the ring and placed her on a chair in the corner to more closely witness his continued destruction of their son.
To backtrack, Linda in the story line had suffered a nervous breakdown and been hospitalised, following Vinces request for a divorce. At Mania X-Seven, she was said to be under heavy sedation, and had been pushed to the ring in a wheelchair.
Her drug-induced state was a ruse. Linda had a surprise in store for her husband.
The roar from the crowd of nearly 68,000 inside the Houston Astrodome when Linda suddenly rose from the chair and kicked Vince in the testicles as he held a trash can above his head was titanic. It must have been the highlight of Lindas on-screen career in the company.
Vince sold the kick, Foley resurfaced and pummelled Vince and Shane made his heroic comeback, all in rapid succession. Saving the biggest stunt for last, Shane placed a trash can on Vinces knees and chest as he sat in the corner and executed Rob Van Dams Van Terminator the springboard corner-to-corner dropkick. It was the first time the move had been used in the WWF. It brought the house down. Shane covered Vince, and Foley counted three.
Weeks later, I spoke to Van Dam for Power Slam magazine in the United Kingdom. Inevitably, the topic of Shanes Van Terminator came up.
When I was watching, I knew what was trying to do, said Van Dam. And I thought, because he looked so hesitant, that he might not pull it off. But Shane did nail it. Great execution when he kicked that trash can into Vinces face I thought it was beautiful.
The street fight ticked all the entertainment boxes. There were no weak links: everyone came through on the night. That said, the award for performer of the match must go to Vince, who reaffirmed his commitment to embarrassing himself for the good of a match and a story line. He received his comeuppance for his dastardly deeds.
5. Roddy Piper vs. Mr. T - WrestleMania 2 (1986)
When it comes to combat sport exhibitions, the worked boxing encounter is usually comically bad. We all know what a legitimate fight between boxers looks like. It is extremely difficult to replicate this in a staged environment.
True to form, Roddy Piper and Mr. T failed to provide much in the way of realism when they donned the gloves for their boxing match at WrestleMania 2 on April 7, 1986.
Why, then, is this bout from the Uniondale, New York leg of the second WrestleMania on the list? For the effect it had on Pipers status and career.
Had this been a legitimate fight, Piper would have defeated T handily. That was evident from rounds one and two: Piper had superior technique, punching power and cardiovascular endurance. Frankly, it was no contest. By the time The A-Team and Rocky III actor received the signal to make his comeback in round three, he had been so humbled by his opponent and was so exhausted that spectators lining the Nassau Coliseum had sided with Piper, the so-called heel. Piper! Piper! Piper! they yelled.
It is probably worth noting, however, that many onlookers had defected to Team Piper before battle commenced at WM 2 because T had long outstayed his welcome in the World Wrestling Federation.
The worked fight was a stature-enhancer for Piper at the time. Silly as it reads now, many believed T was a genuine tough guy. Inside two rounds at WrestleMania 2, Piper dispelled that myth.
It mattered not that Piper lost via disqualification when he bodyslammed the actor in round four: he was the clear favourite on the night. The strength of this performance and the vocal support he received contributed to the success of Pipers babyface turn later that year.
4. Hulk Hogan vs. The Ultimate Warrior - WrestleMania VI (1990)
This bore similarities with the match between Hulk Hogan and Andre The Giant, which had headlined WrestleMania three years earlier.
By 1990, Hogan seemed more unbeatable than ever: he had not been cleanly pinned since he returned to the WWF in December 1983. Ultimate Warrior, meanwhile, had only one blemish on his WWF record. His loss of the Intercontinental championship to Rick Rude at WrestleMania V on April 2, 1989. However, that defeat was excusable: it had only occurred because Rudes manager Bobby Heenan had tripped Warrior from ringside and held his leg as Rude scored the three count. And Warrior had avenged that loss when he regained the title from Rude at SummerSlam 1989.
Prior to WM VI, both Hogan and Warrior seemed so invincible that it was virtually impossible to pick a winner of their match unless one had advance knowledge that Hogan was scheduled to take the summer off.
There were two notable differences between Hogan vs. Warrior and the WrestleMania III main event. The Ultimate Challenge, as Hogan vs. Warrior was billed, pitted babyface against babyface and champion against champion. Both Hogans heavyweight title and Warriors Intercontinental championship were at stake in the match. It was winner take all.
As was true of Hogan vs. Andre, the match was wafer-thin on action and finesse. Hogan and Warrior relied on their opponents to do the bulk of the work in their matches. On this night, it was their responsibility.
Whats more, the match degenerated into comedy when Hogan sold a knee injury, following a bump to the floor, from which he miraculously recovered moments later. He might have just temporarily dislocated the patella, observed Gorilla Monsoon. It was a transparent dig at WCWs star babyface Sting, who was recovering from surgery on his patella at the time.
However, the crowd heat was fierce for most of its 22:51 duration. Fans were gripped by what unfolded before them, even though it was predominantly tests of strength and rest holds. That Hogan and Warrior were able to engage the audience of 64,287 at the Toronto SkyDome for such a long period by doing so little was a remarkable achievement.
And despite those awkward, slothful moments, the all-important ending was well executed.
Hogan smashed Warrior with the big boot, but the IC champion evaded the legdrop. Capitalising, Warrior blasted the fallen Hogan with a splash to take the three count and the heavyweight title for the first time. Really, the sight of Hogans first clean pinfall loss in over six years was worth the price of admission alone. It was a true WrestleMania moment. History-in-the-making, as the late Gorilla might have said.
Warriors glory was short-lived, mind you. Hogan stole his thunder in the post-match scene, as he cheerfully admitted in his first autobiography, Hollywood Hulk Hogan, published in 2002.
3. Umaga vs. Bobby Lashley - WrestleMania 23 (2007)
Vince McMahon and Donald Trump had been acquainted long before the WWE juggernaut rolled into Ford Field in Detroit, Michigan for WrestleMania 23 on April 1, 2007.
Donalds Trump Plaza in Atlantic City had hosted WrestleManias IV and V in 1988 and 1989. Trump appeared in publicity photos with Hulk Hogan and Andre The Giant prior to Mania IV and in conjunction with the hype for WM V, made an on-camera appearance at WrestleMania VII in 1991, and was memorably interviewed from his ringside seat by Jesse Ventura at WrestleMania XX in 2004.
What does WrestleMania mean to a man like you? Ventura asked Trump in 2004.
Well, it means a lot, replied Trump. I was involved with Vince for a long time. Hes a great guy. Hes done, really, an unbelievable job.
After Trump agreed to appear on camera once more in 2004 and offered a glowing endorsement of McMahon, perhaps it wasnt that surprising the WWE supremo was able to persuade him to go one step further and participate in the featured match at WrestleMania three years later. Trump courted the limelight across all media platforms. The man famed for plastering his surname on his property empire harnessed this as another opportunity to promote the Trump brand.
Of course, McMahon and Trump did not lock horns in the ring in 2007: in the match, billed as the Battle Of The Billionaires, they were represented by Umaga and Bobby Lashley, respectively. At stake in the contest was not titles, money or property. It was something to which they were more closely attached: their hair.
From the moment the hair vs. hair match was announced, there was little doubt over whom would win. When McMahons longtime nemesis Steve Austin was appointed the special referee, McMahons fate was sealed. Nevertheless, this did not diminish the appeal of the match to the public: with the Battle Of The Billionaires as the key selling point, WM 23 attracted what was then a record pay-per-view number for the company (1.25 million buys).
In the presence of the charismatic McMahon, Austin and Trump, Lashley and Umaga were reduced to the role of stand-ins. Far from becoming larger stars by association, they were overshadowed by the verbal and physical interaction between McMahon and Trump at ringside (the Donald rocked Vince with a clothesline and ground and pound) and interplay between Austin and McMahon, which awakened memories of the feud that had dominated the company from 1998-1999.
Trumps rep Lashley won, naturally. Distraught, McMahon was on the brink of tears as the realisation dawned that he would soon be detached from his hair.
Vince attempted to flee, but Lashley caught him and carried him back to the ring, where the WWE boss tasted an Austin stunner and was placed in a barbers chair, which had conveniently been fitted with restraints. There would be no escape for the Chairman. Trump and Lashley whisked McMahons hair off with clippers and finished the job with razors and a mountain of shaving cream.
The sight of Trump, the leading candidate for the Republican nomination, shaving Vinces head bald in the middle of a wrestling ring was quite something, in hindsight. That Trump took a boot and Stone Cold stunner from Austin afterwards went above and beyond surreal.
Stone Cold just stunned The Donald! Good God almighty! What a WrestleMania! exclaimed commentator Jim Ross.
I bet Trumps ex-wives are doing cartwheels! Thats better than alimony! he added.
As a wrestling match, this was mediocre. As a spectacle, it was WWE at its finest.
2. 20-man Invitational Battle Royal - WrestleMania IV (1988)
The match, which seemed to function only to provide 20 otherwise redundant roster members with something to do on the March 27, 1988 event from Atlantic City, was notable for the performance of and reaction to the runner-up, in retrospect.
Among the 20 entered into the battle royal were Harley Race, George Steele, Sam Houston, Hillbilly Jim, Sika, The Junkyard Dog, The Hart Foundation and Bad News Brown.
Houston was eliminated at the 44-second mark. Sika followed him to ringside 12 seconds later. It was clear before the match had reached the one-minute mark that it would not be an epic confrontation.
Indeed. The field was whittled down rapidly. The final four were Brown, Paul Roma, The Junkyard Dog and Bret Hart of The Hart Foundation tag team.
Once Roma had been eliminated, heels Brown and Hart conspired against lone babyface JYD and were able to eliminate him, amazingly. Villains rarely prospered in matches like these in the WWF of 1988.
As Hart and Brown celebrated together, commentator Gorilla Monsoon said: I think maybe these guys have decided to split the purse money.
Honour among thieves? No chance in hell. As Harts back was turned, Brown floored him and whipped him into the corner: Bret absorbed his running chest-first collision with the turnbuckles. The difference here was the public was intended to sympathise with Hart. Bad News was framed as the villain.
Fans received the message.
Brown threw Hart over the top rope to win the match to the sound of boos. But Bad News didnt have the last laugh. In the end, the WWF adhered to its tried and trusted formula.
Hart returned to the ring and dropkicked the treacherous Brown to the floor. Seizing Browns winners trophy, Hart smashed it as spectators cheered. Though he had fallen at the final hurdle, the spotlight after the match was firmly on Hart, who was given the floor to interact with the audience in his official babyface turn.
This result also marked the separation of Brets Hart Foundation tag team with Jim Neidhart: Hart was promoted as a solo wrestler after Mania IV albeit temporarily.
The ever-fickle Vince McMahon reunited The Hart Foundation three months later. Hart had to wait until 1991 before he was the recipient of a prolonged singles push. Nonetheless, Harts performance in the battle royal and individual promos and matches in the spring and early summer provided a sneak peek of what was to come from The Hitman.
1. Daniel Bryan vs. Sheamus - WrestleMania XXVIII (2012)
Daniel Bryan lost the World title to Sheamus in just 18 seconds in the opening match of Mania XXVIII on April 1, 2012.
As soon as the bell rang, defending champion Bryan called a halt to the match and summoned girlfriend AJ Lee onto the ring apron for a good luck kiss. Miss Lee duly complied.
Turning around, post-kiss, Bryan walked straight into a Brogue kick from the challenger. Three seconds later, Sheamus was the new World champion.
That good luck kiss turned out to be a kiss goodnight, proclaimed Jerry Lawler on commentary.
This degrading treatment of Bryan on WWEs largest card of the year provoked an unexpected reaction from the WWE fan base: it galvanised support for the so-called Yes Movement.
Some spectators had mimicked Bryans cries of Yes! prior to his match with Sheamus at WrestleMania. The next night on Raw, the chanting increased tenfold: Yes! Yes! Yes! bellowed the crowd in unison. This continued throughout WWEs annual post-WrestleMania tour of Europe.
It was no three-week fad.
The fan rebellion against WWEs presentation of Bryan had staying power. Try as WWE did many times, it could not break the fans emotional bond with Bryan.
In late 2013, it only grew stronger. Public demand for Bryan to ascend to the top of the food chain was overwhelming. Finally conceding defeat, WWE made Bryan World heavyweight champion in the main event of WrestleMania XXX.