Should Demetrious Johnson Fight TJ Dillashaw

Demetrious Johnson vs. TJ Dillashaw is the UFC's goal, but is it the right call?

By Jody Jamieson /

Demetrious Johnson is on the verge of history. Tying Anderson Silva's record of ten successful title defences in April, he could face his biggest test to date in the record-breaker as TJ Dillashaw has offered to move down to flyweight to challenge for the title. Dana White is a man who likes money. He understands better than anyone this is the biggest money fight in the history of the flyweight division and is pushing hard for it.

Advertisement

There's just one problem. DJ wants to fight Ray Borg instead. Failing that, he'll take Sergio Pettis.

While there's no denying Johnson vs. Dillashaw is a much bigger fight than Johnson vs. Borg or Johnson vs. Pettis, DJ has very legitimate reasons for wanting nothing to do with the TJ Dillashaw fight. 'Mighty Mouse' has been very public with his dissatisfaction over the idea of Dillashaw dropping to 125 pounds for the first time ever and going straight into a title fight, even revealing that he called the promotion's bluff when they threatened to close the division if he didn't take the fight.

Should DJ take the TJ fight? We'll have a look at some of the key arguments.

11. Yes – It’s The Biggest Fight On DJ’s Radar Right Now

At UFC on Fox 24 back in April, Demetrious Johnson defeated Wilson Reis via third round armbar to tie the record with 10 successful title defences. A big deal right? In a fight sense certainly, but the viewing figures tell a different story. UFC on Fox 24 did the second lowest ratings of any fight card on national Fox in the US. The only Fox card lower was a Carlos Condit-Demian Maia card which was shown on tape delay in 15 American States as it was bumped for a pre-season NFL game. That's a bad look for the champion.

Advertisement

Would the numbers be better if the next challenger was Ray Borg? It's hard to make a convincing argument that they would be. You certainly couldn't main event a pay-per-view with it. But you could main event a pay-per-view with DJ vs. TJ and it would do good business.

Is it a super-fight? Not exactly, but flyweight has nothing close on its radar. With DJ being offered pay-per-view points for the Dillashaw fight, he'll make more money in this fight than any other in his career. Johnson vs. Borg makes pay-per-view as a co-main event at best, though probably stays on free TV. Money wise, DJ vs. TJ is an absolute no brainer.

10. No – We Don't Know If TJ Can Make Weight

TJ Dillashaw has never fought at flyweight before. A career bantamweight and also former UFC bantamweight champion, we just don’t know if he can make 125 pounds. He's confident he'll make the weight, but how many big fights do we lose with weight cutting issues? 125 could potentially put a massive strain on his body, and he’s far from a lock to make it.

Advertisement

While it is worth noting that he has looked good at weigh-ins when hitting 135, 10 pounds is nothing to shrug your shoulders at. Renan Barao, who Dillashaw took the bantamweight title from back at UFC 173, has looked great at weigh-ins in his run at featherweight.

There were times however where he looked ill at some of his bantamweight weigh-ins, and was pulled from his scheduled rematch with Dillashaw at UFC 177, being taken to hospital during his weight cut. You would hope a similar fate wouldn't befall Dillashaw cutting to 125.

9. Yes – Ray Borg's Record Of Making 125 Pounds Is Not Stellar

Ray Borg is an interesting prospect with a good wrestling base and a 5-2 record in the UFC. He’s also 5-2 against the UFC scale, missing twice in his last four outings. He tipped the scales at 129.5 for his fight with Louis Smolka at UFC 207.

Advertisement

One of Johnson's biggest arguments about not taking the fight is Dillashaw's ability to make weight. While Dillashaw is obviously not a slam dunk to hit championship weight, Borg is a safer bet, but far from a lock.

8. No – UFC Can't Promote A Fight They Might Scrap With 24 Hours Notice

In making his pitch for the DJ vs. TJ fight, Dana White revealed he'd book Ray Borg on the same card in the event if anything happened with Dillashaw's weight cut. That's a major promotional red flag. How can you justify selling tickets, selling pay-per-views, and generally advertising a fight you're transparently admitting might not happen? It screams of promotional malpractice to me.

Advertisement

Many people buy pay-per-views a few days in advance. Obviously almost everyone will have bought tickets weeks in advance. To scrap the fight with 24 hours notice is just a bad look. Not to mention it's a big middle finger to the champion to change his opponent with 24 hours notice. And what about whoever they book Ray Borg against? He does his training camp and weight cut and then loses his fight because someone he has nothing to do with misses weight?

Obviously any fight can drop at the last minute, and while openly preparing for it can look responsible, it's just openly admitting that what you're promoting comes with a potential caveat.

7. Yes – UFC Will Finally Promote DJ Properly

Not everyone is set for stardom. Demetrious Johnson is the consensus pound-for-pound #1 in MMA right now. He's just not the draw you'd hope a five year world champion who beats everyone would be. That being said, Johnson can be a bigger star than he currently is, and UFC can certainly do a better job in marketing both him and the division. UFC promote pay-per-view co-main events a million times better than they promoted Johnson vs. Reis back in April.

Advertisement

There is definitely a valid train of thought that "DJ can't draw" is at least partly a self-fulfilling prophecy. It's not that UFC doesn't want to promote him. It's just that they've done a pretty poor job overall in promoting a dominant world champion no-one can touch. Compare his push to the Ronda Rousey push and draw your own conclusion.

You can tell though by the enthusiasm in which they're pushing for this fight, and the fact it is targeted to main event UFC 215, that they'll finally go all on on Demetrious. DJ hasn't main evented a pay-per-view in a couple of years, and when he did main event, it was usually because another title fight fell out and he was promoted from co-main. Potentially setting the title defence record of 11 would be front and centre of all the promotional work. UFC would focus heavily on DJ for the first time ever, and it could be DJ's real breakthrough to the casual fan base.

6. No – DJ Is Promoting Himself Right Now Better Than Ever

UFC 212 was probably the most newsworthy show of 2017 so far. Yet 48 hours later, the topic on everyone’s lips was Demetrious Johnson and his open feud with the promotion. His appearance on the MMA Hour on Monday with Ariel Helwani went viral. For the first time ever, Demetrious Johnson is the most talked about fighter in mixed martial arts.

Advertisement

Max Holloway defeated Jose Aldo two days prior at UFC 212 in an amazing performance via third round TKO, but it’s on the back burner right now. DJ is the biggest news in MMA at present, and it's safe to say that's never been the case before. He didn't hold back either, revealing that UFC threatened to shut the entire division if he doesn't take this fight. The state of play right now is that DJ has called their bluff. It'll be very interesting to see what happens next. This story could go in a variety of different directions.

5. Yes – Let Ray Borg And Sergio Pettis Have A #1 Contender Fight

The story is that the promotion offered both Sergio Pettis and Ray Borg for the next title fight, before ultimately putting all their eggs in the Dillashaw basket before any agreements were signed. Borg and Pettis are both 23. Both on modest winning streaks, but in truth neither is likely to beat Johnson or even be much of a challenge and could do with more seasoning before fighting for the title. Why not match them up and see who rises to the top?

Advertisement

It's matchmaking 101. Book a title fight. Book a #1 contender's fight. Let two men rise to the top, and then they have the next title fight. Isn't match making easy? Well no, but sometimes the best solutions are the obvious solutions. If UFC see Borg and Pettis as ready for title fights, why not put that fight together, and let's go back to the meritocracy UFC always claims to be.

4. No – This Could Potentially Tie Up Two Divisions

When Cody Garbrandt returns from his back injury, his first bantamweight title defence will be against TJ Dillashaw. They filmed a whole series of The Ultimate Fighter with Garbrandt and Dillashaw as the coaches to build to this fight, and the beef is there for all to see.

Advertisement

If Dillashaw was to come down and win the flyweight title, it's champion versus champion, and it makes the fight just that little bit better. Great, right? TJ beats Cody and he's a two weight world champion. What's not to love?

Dillashaw was bantamweight champion for 20 months. He made three title defences. It isn't exactly a guarantee that he'll be active enough to keep both divisions rolling at once. Sure, this is a moot point if TJ loses one, if not both, of his title challenges, but shouldn't you prepare for all possible scenarios? UFC could potentially book themselves into the corner of essentially having a division on hold if Dillashaw went on a winning run.

3. Yes – As Champion, He Should Face Whoever The UFC Decide Is Next

As fun as Conor McGregor’s 2016 was, was it really fair that he ended 2015 by winning the featherweight title, fought three times in 2016, and didn’t defend his belt? Sure there were extenuating circumstances (Rafael dos Anjos pulling from UFC 196 on short notice created the Diaz rivalry) that dictated his schedule last year, but the fact he never defended his title sticks in many throats. As a champion you have a responsibility to your division and what’s best for it. If UFC decide TJ Dillashaw is the next challenger at 125, is it fair for DJ to say no?

Advertisement

Being champion comes with responsibilities. While it's absolutely fair to voice displeasure with the next challenger, in many ways the best way to make your point is to fight them and beat them. While it would be untrue to claim Johnson has nothing to lose in this fight, he has a lot to gain. There is in many ways no finer way for Johnson to end his current feud with the promotion by setting the record and defeating their hand picked guy to do it.

2. No – As Champion, He Should Have Some Say In His Career

On the flip side, if TJ loses to DJ, would he even consider fighting at flyweight again? It's extremely doubtful. He's likely back to bantamweight, never to be seen again at 125. On paper it can look like a very selfish move from Dillashaw. Only fighting at flyweight because he wants the belt, and then disappearing when it doesn't work out.

Advertisement

While Johnson shouldn’t have 100% say over who he fights, is it unreasonable to turn down a fight against a guy who’s never fought in your division? Probably not. Johnson has invited Dillashaw to come down, win a fight, and get in line. Whether you agree or not, you can see his point. DJ sees flyweight at his baby, he wants to protect it. Being the only flyweight champion in the promotion's history, he wants what's best for the division, and he wants TJ to want it as much as he does. Johnson believes Dillashaw is coming down on a whim because Cody Gardbrandt is injured. It's very reasonable and logical when you break it down.

1. Conclusion

When I started writing this article, I honestly hadn’t made up my mind, and you might weigh up the arguments and come to the opposite conclusion, and that’s fine! But should DJ fight TJ? My answer is yes. It would be Johnson’s biggest fight in years, if not ever. It’s a fight that could do more business than any fight he’s ever had before.

Advertisement

Johnson vs. Borg? It would be a good fight. Borg's wrestling base might cause Johnson some big problems. Johnson vs. Pettis? Pettis would be a massive underdog for good reason and in truth he's probably not ready for it. Johnson vs. Dillashaw? Under any circumstances, that's a really exciting fight. It's not a super-fight under traditional barometers, but it's as close as you're going to get at flyweight.

Sure there are reasons to be cautious. Dillashaw is likely the biggest threat to DJ's title out there, and Johnson's record against natural bantamweights isn't particularly stellar. Dillashaw would have a size advantage in the fight, which might nullify parts of Johnson's game, and while Mighty Mouse has added KO power to his game, Dillashaw has proven he can finish anyone.

It would be a really fun fight, and it's the best fight available in the division. Let's make it happen!

Advertisement