That Time Vince McMahon ACTUALLY Stopped Booking WWE
He wanted it to be a Cowboy, baby.
Vince McMahon is going to continue to book WWE until there is no Vince McMahon, and that's as safe a take as there is.
He's still booking it now, at 74, and it's more difficult to assess than the first impulse suggests. The events of the last two editions of RAW have felt removed from Paul Heyman's altogether more solid approach, in that the continuity errors and inexplicable results are glaring, even by modern WWE standards. The Viking Raiders were made to look like a comedy act at the precise moment Bianca Belair told the Street Profits to take them more seriously. Liv Morgan was built up carefully purely to take a barely promoted loss on RAW to NXT Champion Charlotte Flair. A dwelling for horses tragically set ablaze would still make for a better stable than Zelina Vega and her useless associates; it was as if the second they formed, Vince got bored of them. Three weeks had become three seconds.
They have the numbers advantage. There is a champion in their ranks. And yet, they are hopeless. To put it as sensitively as possible: the last two episodes of RAW appear to have been written by a person not operating at optimum mental capacity.
The XFL has folded, leaving Vince with more free time than was becoming a pattern late last year. These things cannot be unrelated.
Vince McMahon is going to continue to book WWE. Nobody will look the fool for committing it to record. Vince McMahon voluntarily stepping down is the never in wrestling's never say never rule. Except, it isn't.
CONT'D...(1 of 6)
Almost.
Bill Watts - think Gran Torino, except he lives next door to all of the ethnicities - wasn't just a booking genius. He was a booking pioneer; at the helm of Mid-South Wrestling, he created the model for episodic wrestling television to which AEW's Tony Khan is indebted. 10 lashes of the whip was a fate shared by both Cody and Magnum TA (and Terry Taylor, whose earnest, loyal babyface courage is another trope borrowed by Khan).
WWE remains unmatched in its ability to craft video packages precision-calibrated to sell you on a match, even if the build towards it faltered at times, or was mid to begin with. That was a Watts innovation; with his finger on the pulse of fashion, his groundbreaking use of the music video fleshed out the personalities of his talent. His own training montage, set to 'Eye of the Tiger', edited to incorporate his glory days and create a striking tone of pathos and drama, was incredibly rousing stuff ahead of his 'Last Stampede' - an angle, incidentally, that has heavily inspired Dustin Rhodes' AEW run. 'One Last Ride', as his slogan goes.
That was the magic of Watts; more so than marketing and schlock, he was incredibly careful and savvy to emphasise relatable human characteristics and the connections forged across his roster, the effect of which created entry points to endless purposeful matches within a universe that proved immersive and realistic. These foundations, once established, enabled the deftest of quick manoeuvres - that being the legendary Ted DiBiase babyface turn, the overnight nature of which was made viable through his connection with Dick Murdoch. It is not at all unlike - yes - Khan's AEW, in which virtually every match is informed by that which came before.
CONT'D...(2 of 6)
That the cool new league of 2020 is borrowing liberally from early to mid '80s Mid-South is evidence of its timeless genius. Its genius, not his; Watts lost his touch as the '80s receded, getting in the way of himself and the younger talent by 1992 in WCW, implementing draconian rules that felt removed from the pulse he was once in sync with. He left under a racism furore in 1993, and resurfaced in the World Wrestling Federation in 1995 as head booker. Per the October 9, 1995 Wrestling Observer Newsletter, a meeting was held prior to In Your House: Triple Header that Watts was to assume a level of creative control unprecedented before or since. In a fantastic time capsule of a paragraph, Meltzer wrote the following in the same issue, which in no small part was the motive behind the unthinkable:
"At the meeting, McMahon blasted WCW saying their (sic) going on Monday nights wasn't good business. He said they could have put their show on Wednesday or Thursday and had the night to themselves and said by going on Mondays, they showed that it's more important to them to hurt the Raw ratings then draw big numbers themselves which he called stupid business."
It was a necessary change.
The tremendous storyboarding of 1994 - and the overarching emphasis on the vibrant athleticism of the New Generation youth movement - A) didn't work and B) had plunged to hokey fare overwhelmed by a cast of goofy characters and headlined by the gigantic and not particularly dynamic Diesel and Mabel. Business was dire, buzz nonexistent. This was less bad, and more of a dangerous predicament for the WWF; the abject failure to create new superstars had been compounded by the rising tide down south.
CONT'D...(3 of 6)
Watts' tenure was short and unpopular - an echo of his WCW downfall, rather than his Mid-South genius, or maybe a flash hybrid of both.
Gauging by the October 16 WON, it would appear that one of Meltzer's sources was unhappy. Watts, ostensibly pre-internet, implemented a policy as antiquated as those with which he had pissed everybody off in WCW: talent on the big shows were not told of the finish until the day of, which undermined their ability to work. Talents were more meticulous in preparation than in Watts' era, which he imposed on them for the apparent sake of secrecy, though there was always the sense that the man couldn't much stomach what had happened to the game. There was perhaps as much defiance as protection in his thinking.
Watts resigned, almost immediately, after a disagreement with Vince over what constituted his role. The reality is that Vince was unable to relinquish full control despite the promise made in Saginaw. He continued to overrule Watts despite claiming to further withdraw into his executive role.
This battle was fought on the grounds of the October 9, 1995 Monday Night RAW.
CONT'D...(4 of 6)
In the opener, the Undertaker, Diesel and Shawn Michaels were defeated by the Camp Cornette trio of Owen Hart, the British Bulldog and Yokozuna. Watching it back will, incidentally, make New Gen geeks mourn a nonexistent high-profile Michaels Vs. Yoko pay-per-view singles match. In the post-match, Mabel and Dean Douglas joined a brutal attack - Michaels took a particularly gruesome bump on the stairs - divorced from the WWF's in-house style. Seeing the '95 iteration of the Undertaker selling such a big heat angle to unconsciousness is particularly striking, watched back through a 2020 lens.
Watts envisaged this as the main event, consistent with Vince's own edict to counter WCW with a more modest budget and taped schedule. Each show, explained Vince at the talent meeting, would end in the style of 'Melrose Place'; a tantalising morsel footage of next week's show would air in a bid to hook the audience. To Watts, this was not the opener.
This was the episodic cliffhanger, the moving parts of which created scope for several match-ups further down the road, the dramatic tension of which was designed to create anxiety within the audience. Vince overruled him; the match and angle started the show, and later in the broadcast, Dok Hendrix provided a medical update that, equipped with this knowledge, is quite amusing.
CONT'D...(5 of 6)
He tried at once to sell the plight of Shawn Michaels and reassure the audience that their hero wasn't on death's door, or anything: he had collapsed, but Hendrix reckoned he'd probably be OK later! As for Big Daddy Cool Diesel, he had lost his cool, he was that angry! The Undertaker, however, seemed to have taken the "worst of the brunt of the blows". This sounded serious.
"Quite frankly," said Hendrix, "it looks like the wind's been taken out of his sails!"
Not the wind!
They were OK, folks, and that big heat angle, resistant to an old Vince edict, was not allowed to register, to provoke dread and anguish, to mean anything.
What's stunning to consider is that, despite the very much substantiated notion that he books for an audience of one, Vince McMahon does actually want to put smiles on people's faces, irrespective of whether he is any good at it or not.
Watts harboured no ill will. He empathised with Vince's innate need for control, and left amicably. It was never something could let go, and that was for the best, as it turned out.
In a crazed sentence that is suitably pro wrestling, the WWF fared better three years on, through that control, with the man who would become the worst booker ever than they would have with the man once considered the best.