The Day AEW Rampage Died

How Tony Khan busted your trust in a show once considered better than Dynamite.

By Michael Sidgwick /

AEW.com

When AEW Rampage premiered, on August 13, 2021, the praise was glowing.

Advertisement

Tony Khan is used to critical acclaim at this point, but even he must have been astonished by the takes. Many fans thought it was even better than his Dynamite flagship: the most revered North American episodic wrestling show since the halcyon days of WCW Nitro or the Chris Kreski-penned Raw product of 2000. One phenomenal hour of momentous, superb and emotive action and storytelling, with not one solitary second wasted, it was up there with the very best of AEW's output. Christian Cage defeated Kenny Omega for the Impact World Title in a superbly built match in which their arsenals complemented one another perfectly for counter-driven drama; Fuego Del Sol won an AEW contract following a dramatic and gutsy noble effort before Miro killed him; Dr. Britt Baker sent her home city fans home deliriously happy after she beat Red Velvet in one of her best in-ring offerings. The show was so white-hot that even killed an enduring narrative dead: Pittsburgh isn't a sh*tty crowd when they are offered exceptional pro wrestling worth shouting about.

Rampage started strong and maintained form. The First Dance was the site of CM Punk's return to wrestling, one of if not the loudest ever pops recorded, and a beautiful, moving moment in his candid promo. It was iconic. Unforgettable. For a while, Rampage was ostensibly a third hour of Dynamite in terms of match quality and narrative importance, only not on a Wednesday.

Advertisement

The audience wasn't exhausted by third hour but rather thrilled by it as, in parallel, the hype before and after All Out promised a bumper-sized golden age.

CONT'D...(1 of 6)

Advertisement
AEW

Eddie Kingston sold his Full Gear match with CM Punk using his eyes in a legendary face-to-face confrontation. His mood shifted from combustible to seething to sarcastic to sarcasm's close relative - unbridled rage - in one of the best angles of the modern era. Kingston was sensational in the ring on Fridays too; his World Title Eliminator match opposite Bryan Danielson was so incredible that they summoned a standing ovation seconds before the finish. That's what a finish should f*cking do: peak at the perfect time.

Advertisement

PAC and Andrade worked a fantastic series, as physical as it was spectacular, in which they worked over one another's brain tissue. Minoru Suzuki Vs. Bryan Danielson. A series of very good and very over CM Punk matches (versus Daniel Garcia, versus Matt Sydal). It has faded so badly now that the very idea that CM Punk made his impossible return to wrestling after seven years on the show feels surreal. It's almost like if Steve Austin worked Kevin Owens on Velocity, and not WrestleMania 38. That's probably hyberbole, but the last slew of episodes have felt inessential in the extreme in the grim, final phase of development that took root in 2022.

As the year started to settle, Rampage started to feel like the baggy middle of the less good episodes of Dynamite. Angles were scarce. Promos were filmed backstage and often interrupted. Nothing climactic was settled on Rampage, only gently advanced. For example, Adam Cole Vs. Trent, a very good match, functioned to set up the Lights Out match between Cole and Cassidy a couple of weeks later at Beach Break. That is a standard Khan booking device - a way of building interest in a bigger match without being must-see in and of itself - but that device is often used alongside more bold booking moves.

Advertisement

Increasingly, as 2022 unfolded, Rampage became the exclusive home of such hardcore completionist fare.

CONT'D...(2 of 6)

Advertisement
AEW

Some of the matches were very good and well thought-out - Darby Allin Vs. The Butcher from March 16 boasted a unique finish, rich continuity, some creative limb work and a wonderful, gnarly mauling - but it wasn't so massive or great as to be appointment viewing.

Advertisement

The trend continued as, all the while, Bryan Danielson, CM Punk, and MJF rarely if ever featured on what was increasingly becoming the B-show. Every week followed a certain pattern that inspired apathy. Sometimes it's all too easy to sour on something if it isn't amazing for a few weeks - the best match of the year, Jon Moxley subverting his entire act to put Wheeler YUTA over, took place on Rampage - but Rampage became a 7/10 show every single week. It's always a joy watching the Blackpool Combat Club, but Matt Sydal and Dante Martin stood absolutely zero chance against them. Eventually, every last match was entirely predictable, even if they were good to very good, and with fewer and fewer people watching, nothing of true narrative significance actually happened. Vince Russo is the single dumbest f*ck to have ever been involved with wrestling and his approach to the form should never again be emulated, but being able to put a fortune on every winner, and never once being stunned by a story beat, is the opposite end of his extreme - and that's no place to be, either.

The third hour of Dynamite now feels closer to Dark: Elevation. It's the home of bizarre and unwanted experimental fare, like the Trust Busters. It's the home of the least essential chapter in the Blackpool Combat Club Vs. Jericho Appreciation Society saga, which is becoming passé, and Rampage is such an inessential show that they're actually running Sammy Guevara and Tay Melo Vs. Ortiz and Ruby Soho back.

Advertisement

AEW Rampage died on a day that no episode of Rampage was broadcast.

CONT'D...(3 of 6)

Advertisement
AEW

The idea that nobody would have missed it is an accurate enough tombstone etching, but that's not the point: AEW Rampage died on August 13, 2022, because Tony Khan didn't think enough of the show to promote an anniversary edition on the closest Friday.

Advertisement

This is a man who will suffix every Dynamite in five to create the illusion of a special event in a cheeky bid to pop a rating: Homecoming, Road Rager, Fyter Fest, Fight For The Fallen, Winter Is Coming, Quake By The Lake, Beach Break, St. Patrick's Day Slam...it's a bit much, in truth, but that's the nature of the television wrestling business. Even when he takes a patient route to his destinations, Khan will fabricate a major show. It's a trick, but it's one he didn't play as Rampage approached its first year on TNT. The show could have really done with the boost, too; despite performing well in a poor time slot, often winning it across all of cable, the show has declined badly. Khan didn't celebrate the anniversary of Rampage because it would have brought into focus how everything significant or seminal happened around six months ago.

If those on social media discussed their favourite moments in the show's history, as tends to happen when a milestone draws near, not a soul would write "The best moment in Rampage history would have to be Shawn Spears Vs. Bear Boulder". Also: he quite clearly doesn't care that much about it.

Advertisement

Why?

CONT'D...(4 of 6)

Advertisement
AEW

He has given up on the time slot.

Advertisement

It's clear that Rampage has developed the dreaded skippable stigma, and Khan appears to feel that wasting valuable Dynamite-calibre matches on it is a waste. The trend has formed for several months now; if Khan were that concerned, he'd have done something drastic like, for example, switching around the Trios title tournament brackets. He hasn't. The death of Rampage is affecting AEW on the other six days of the week, too, which is...suboptimal. Remember when the Young Bucks proclaimed, during the Double Or Nothing 2019 press rally, that they were intent on bringing back tag team action as a hugely important fixture of North American mainstream wrestling?

You'd be forgiven for forgetting, on recent evidence; Rampage in 2022 has acted as a dumping ground for the doubles division, on which Jurassic Express and Swerve In Our Glory have defended the gold in - yes - good if predictable matches. Belts that are defended mostly on the less prestigious show now feel less prestigious. It's a self-fulfilling prophecy.

Advertisement

The show has sparked into life on occasion in recent months - Eddie Kingston Vs. Konosuke Takeshita was an excellent war, the Young Bucks Vs. Lucha Bros. mind-blowing aerial warfare - but Rampage still carries connotations of solid TV...if you can make time for it.

CONT'D...(5 of 6)

Advertisement
WWE.com

It's especially bleak because AEW debuted under the promise of premium content.

Advertisement

Two hours of weekly TV, quarterly PPVs, no house shows: the model was a direct and much-needed response to WWE's greedy "super-serve" content era, and Rampage just feels like an obligation now. Is there any way of fixing it? In its current form, not really. The very name of the show is synonymous with apathy. If Khan wanted to do something in the time slot, he'd probably have to opt for a complete rebrand: new name, new aesthetic, new theme, new everything - a promise to actually build something of significance.

Ring Of Honor and All Elite Women are two potential options. Honestly, and this is very conspiratorial, it almost feels like Khan is allowing Rampage to bleed out knowing that plans for such a revamp are in place.

Advertisement

The performer is talented, but that isn't the point: how else do you explain Ari Daivari headlining two consecutive episodes?