The Disturbing Truth Behind WWE SmackDown On Fox
Are you ready for a good time?
Are you ready for a good time?
No?
Is that because Roman Reigns, King Corbin, dog costumes, noises and food have dominated the last segment and often first segments of every single episode after the brand warfare of the Survivor Series build? The programme has lasted forever in dog years, and it's built on prop comedy, obnoxious, purposefully grating, ceaseless heat, and hollow show-closing visuals that, if analysed, reveal that Roman Reigns has no friends. It's the quintessential modern Vince McMahon show, in that it is asinine, goofy (but improbably coherent) and between Corbin and Lacey Evans, is dominated by tall, telegenic performers limited in talent. The stories don't merely promote calculable ratings poison; they repeat the same beats ad nauseam.
The other major programme brewing centres around Bray Wyatt and Daniel Bryan. It isn't getting over; Bryan quite understandably looks disinterested, and isn't as hot as he was when he last adjusted his character. His heart doesn't seem in it. Bray, meanwhile, is Bray. Some believe the character is outstanding and creative, and is amid a character arc in which he darkens the mindset of those he comes into contact with; others believe the broad and goofy elements have ruined the early, promising presentation, and he can't be amid that character arc, unless he decided to "change" Braun Strowman into a dancer. He is divisive, but he isn't moving the needle.
CONT'D...(1 of 5)
Underneath, Braun dances, Otis romances (it's funny because he is fat and Mandy Rose is a bombshell), and The Miz pouts; he wanted to pose in front of the hard camera, so badly, but the Fiend photobombed him. Also, the Fiend terrorised his family, but that was a secondary concern. That is obviously a facetious point, but it's one that underscores a major, definitive problem with WWE's presentation: it's soulless, and very few of the acts resonate as actual human beings.
SmackDown on Fox is ostensibly every WWE show you've ever seen, produced at a time when WWE is at a very low point in fan engagement.
It's very, morbidly fitting that career con artist Bruce Prichard finds himself in the role of Executive Director of the show. It was built on a con. The promotion centred around the stars of yesteryear under the tagline 'We're all Superstars!': Steve Austin appeared in a restaurant as a waiter smashed some glasses in tribute; a surgeon performed John Cena's you-can't-see-me gesture as his patient passed away; said patient woke from the dead, à la the Undertaker: the message WWE seemed to send was 'The stars are back, and you're all going to watch them!'
Except the stars aren't back, and very few of the projected people are not watching them.
CONT'D...(2 of 5)
Yes, Kofi Kingston, Becky Lynch and Daniel Bryan were also featured, but this was flagrant false advertising on WWE's part - those stars only turned up at the premiere, and not all of them, incredibly - which hardly helped WWE's chronic brand trust issues. The tagline proudly told us that 'We're all Superstars!'. You're a Superstar: yes, you, in the crowd! The Legends are Superstars! Mustafa Ali, Dolph Ziggler, King Corbin, Shorty G, Bayley, Braun Strowman, Carmella, Cesaro, Elias, the Usos, Lacey Evans, Mandy Rose, Sami Zayn, Shinsuke Nakamura, Sasha Banks, the Revival, The Miz...sorry. You aren't Superstars.
None of the acts that appear every week were promoted. WWE promised a star-loaded show and delivered the precise opposite of it. The man framed as a punchline in the very first segment is dominating the final segment every week. The 'STD' is infecting the quality and integrity of the programme. Put yourself in the mind of the lapsed fan, piqued by a rare appearance from the Rock they grew up enraptured by: to them, this era of SmackDown is what would have happened, had Billy Gunn emerged from his 1999 humiliation to make a run as the top heel.
SmackDown on Fox represented WWE's best opportunity to conquer the mainstream in forever. The network offered the company an exposure it hasn't enjoyed in decades.That it didn't is troubling, looking ahead to the long-term future of the company.
Fox tasked SmackDown with scoring a 1.0 in the target 18-49 demo. It is only barely accomplishing that objective. After initial success with the premiere, which drew 3.9 million viewers, total viewership has stabilised at around 2.5 million. The numbers are at best solid, but post-WrestleMania season, they are more likely to sag than rise. That is precedent, not cynicism.
CONT'D...(3 of 5)
WWE has stumbled arse-backwards into an incredibly lucrative paradigm shift in market conditions.
The TV industry, threatened with extinction under the atomised wave of streaming services, considers pro wrestling a sport, in that it is DVR-proof. WWE successfully secured its biggest ever money deal on that basis. Merit has very little to do with it. WWE isn't a hot property, it's an established one, and it is simultaneously haemorrhaging its core audience and doing nothing new to draw new fans. Advertisers aim for that 18-49 demo, and only the boomers are watching in significant number.
If these numbers remain stable, and the TV industry continues to survive under this approach, WWE will maintain its negotiating hand. If they do not, WWE isn't as future-proof as it stands right now. TV revenue is pivotal to the future of a company that has ballooned in operational expense through fear and spite. NXT UK existed to thwart the rise of the BritWres scene, and is a money-loser by design. The domestic division cannot integrate its 108 contracted talents into the two hours of NXT on USA, and various reports from Squared Circle Sirens and Fightful allude to several of that number being unhappy at both the lack of opportunity and a level of pay that still isn't commensurate with the main roster. Triple H meanwhile referred to NXT as the main roster several times, on RAW and SmackDown, to market it as a legit third brand. This isn't reflected where it matters, and the old image of NXT - the haven from creative oppression and an arduous schedule - is fading.
CONT'D...(4 of 5)
Every fan-driven metric is down: merchandise, house show gates, TV ratings.
Looking at the sheer amount of content WWE pumps out, it is almost literally a house of cards stacked on the foundation of WWE's domestic TV deals. If that paradigm shifts, the business model changes drastically because WWE has increased its budget drastically in disharmony with how little fan-generated revenue it is currently drawing.
WWE's finances are preposterously robust, considering, but they are tenuous. The company is heavily reliant on an industry that is in a state of flux, and SmackDown on Fox is its foundation - SmackDown on Fox, with its stale tropes, ageing audience, perverse insistence on pushing heavily the man blamed just over a year ago as the harbinger of doom, silly horror that can only appeal to half of a fading, jaded base, its awful comedy, repetitive story beats, comparatively bang average in-ring...
SmackDown on Fox has comprehensively and objectively failed to bring about the hoped-for new mainstream boom. The disturbing truth behind the Vince N' Bruce yuk-yuk show is that it might, if anything, achieve the opposite of the intended effect.