The Greatest Match From Every WWE SummerSlam Ever

12. 2008 - Undertaker Vs. Edge

The two former Ministry members capped off WrestleMania XXIV in style with a cleverly planned match. Their renewal of hostilities here is a totally different encounter, but reinforces their rare chemistry.

Advertisement

The booking going in is great: Edge, frightened of entering his first Hell In A Cell match against one of the stipulation’s heavyweights, has reached down deep inside himself to find the wild, risk taking performer he once was. The bug eyed intensity he brings to the match stays just on the right side of ludicrous, elevating things in contrast to the stoic, quietly fuming Undertaker.

The spots are brilliant, always used to advance the story. The middle section in particular is a pulse quickener; Edge rams ‘Taker through the wall of the cell, the runs along two announce tables to spear him through a third.

There are throwbacks to previous points in their feud, some gnarly table spots, and a dastardly looking con-chair-to delivered to a prone Edge. After Undertaker gets the win, he chokeslams Edge through the ring, with the hole then spewing flames. Over the top? Maybe. Still fun though.

11. 2009 - Jeff Hardy Vs. CM Punk

The best feud of 2009 came to a phenomenal conclusion in front of a packed out Staples Centre. Under TLC conditions, ideally suited for both Punk and Hardy, two sensational wrestlers and hardcore favourites were given the well earned opportunity to headline a major pay per view, and put on an absolute clinic.

Advertisement

Punk is in one of his deepest heel roles here and reflects that in his offence, hurling Hardy into various bits of steel weaponry and working his stiff martial arts strikes. Hardy is his usual high flying self, the highlight being a Swanton off a colossal ladder; we’ve seen him do it before, but it never gets old.

The two keep pace with each other so well, their familiarity having evolved into an easy chemistry. The match is based more around long term storytelling than traditional TLC high spots, which freshens up the proceedings significantly.

Punk gets the win and the Heavyweight championship in a dramatic finale, leading to a great post-match spot in which the lights dim, then come back on to reveal Undertaker in place of Hardy’s prone body. Both superstars would move onto the next story, but this remains a career highlight feud for both.

10. 2010 - Kane Vs. Rey Mysterio

It’s fair to say that 2010 is not a vintage SummerSlam. The back half of the show is dominated by the WWE vs. Nexus seven on seven match, which has its moments but goes on far too long and has an ill advised super Cena finish.

Advertisement

Kane vs. Rey Mysterio, meanwhile, is far better a match than it sounds on paper. There’s much of what you’d expect from the pairing - Mysterio the scrappy underdog using his pace to wear down a far larger opponent. Here Kane is as good as he’s been in many a year. He has scouted Rey’s counters, and meets these with counters of his own. It’s a dominant, destructive performance, a high point of his well deserved Heavyweight Championship run.

And then there’s the ending - Kane looks to place a defeated Mysterio in a casket, but when he opens the lid, who should be lying inside but the returning Undertaker. It’s a delightful magic trick by WWE, and with Kane getting the upper hand on his usually dominant brother, he has rarely been sold better as a monster.

9. 2011 - Randy Orton Vs. Christian

When you’re outshining Punk vs. Cena (in the summer of Punk, no less), you must be doing something right, and the second PPV clash between Christian and Orton does just about everything right. Christian was given a well deserved Heavyweight Championship after best friend Edge’s retirement, and while the run itself was disappointing, his clashes with Randy Orton were anything but.

Advertisement

This one is a masterpiece in storytelling. Christian won the gold in cowardly fashion a month prior, but after urging from Edge, had no choice but to prove his mettle against the Viper. The two work a perfectly paced match, playing off their immense chemistry with one another. Finishers are reversed and reversed again as the intensity ramps up. There are innovative weapons spots, including a truly surprising powerslam through a table, and in due course an RKO outta nowhere.

A lengthier championship run was the least Christian deserved, but at least he got to put on matches like this. As for Orton, he may not have better chemistry with any other wrestler. The feud could have gone on a lot longer, but at least it delivered this classic.

8. 2012 - Chris Jericho Vs. Dolph Ziggler

The build to this match revolved around whether or not Chris Jericho still had what it takes to perform at the highest level. Eight years and no shortage of reinventions later, the very idea that Y2J was past it seems more ridiculous than ever, but Ziggler was an ideal opponent for this particular angle.

Advertisement

The Show Off was holding the Money In The Bank briefcase here and was not far off his euphoric cash in, but he still had a lot to prove, and in locking up with an opponent of Jericho’s quality, he did just that.

The two are absolute workhorses, putting on a super slick match with some smart psychology - Jericho’s taped ribs (“soft and tender” per Michael Cole) are worked over throughout. The final few minutes especially are thrilling, with Jericho pulling off one of the finest late kickouts you’ll ever see.

Jericho gets the win with the lion tamer - a slightly questionable decision given Ziggler’s possession of the MITB contract. The notion that Y2J’s in ring career was coming to a close was laughable at the time, but this should have put a close to any doubts.

7. 2013 - John Cena Vs. Daniel Bryan

This may be the hardest choice of all, because CM Punk and Brock Lesnar’s bruising epic is one of the great SummerSlam matches. Cena and Bryan’s headliner, though, has all that and a huge dose of emotion to make it the worthy main event.

Advertisement

Bryan was nearing the peak of his ascendency here, and the indie darling vs. the face of WWE was the perfect match. The two bring out the best in each other, with Cena trying to overpower his smaller foe, but Bryan’s technical brilliance and heart keeping Big Match John on his toes.

The moment Bryan gets the win is glorious - no funny business, he just outwrestles Cena on the night. It’s undercut, of course, by guest referee Triple H nailing the new champ with the Pedigree, allowing Money In The Bank holder Randy Orton to cash in and end Bryan’s reign as soon as it started.

It was frustrating at the time, but of course led to the incredible climax of WrestleMania XXX. Taken on its own, this is one of the great WWE matches of either man’s career.

6. 2014 - Seth Rollins Vs. Dean Ambrose

The Shield is one of the few truly great achievements of modern WWE. The organisation created a dominant faction with the intention of creating three bonafide main eventers, and they achieved exactly that. When The Shield split, fans wanted nothing more than to see the treacherous Seth Rollins against the unstable Dean Ambrose, and at SummerSlam they got exactly that.

Advertisement

A lumberjack match (with the ring surrounded by superstars The Shield had wronged, in a nice touch) between two bitter rivals was never going to generate slick wrestling, but that wasn’t what the event called for. This was a blood feud, with Rollins and Ambrose tearing strips off each other from the opening bell.

It’s chaos, basically, and only gets crazier as they spill into the crowd. Rollins tries to flee, the lumberjacks carry him back to the ring, and Ambrose turns it up a notch with a colossal plunge into the mass of wrestlers.

The bout ends with heel shenanigans and a cheap win for Rollins after bashing Ambrose with a briefcase, but the match sets Dean up as a totally distinct character, capable of anything. Job done.

5. 2015 - Seth Rollins Vs. John Cena

Let’s get the finish out of the way quickly: having Jon Stewart insert himself into the ending of the match and deliver a (dreadful!) chair shot to Cena was a huge mistake. It was a poorly thought out gimmick that serves only to cheapen the title vs. title match.

Advertisement

It can only cheapen it so much, though, because this is otherwise a superb bout. Cena’s US and Rollins’ World Heavyweight belts are on the line, and the young gun, WWE’s heir apparent, brings the absolute best out of the veteran.

Cena is always at his best against faster, hungrier opponents, and he pulls out all the stops here. He and Rollins perform at a breathless pace throughout and only escalate the tempo as it goes on, with breathtaking counters and engrossing near falls bell to bell.

The two would have great clashes before and after, but this is their only one-on-one with a stage of this size, and they rise to the occasion with gusto. While Rollins has continued to be a stellar performer, it’s a crying shame he caught his injury not long after this - he was going nowhere but up, through sheer force of talent.

4. 2016 - John Cena Vs. AJ Styles

A lot of “dream matches” don’t live up to fan expectation when they finally happen. This one exceeds anything we could have imagined. Cena and Styles had locked up previously, but Styles’ pals Anderson and Gallows had made their presence felt in AJ’s win, and so the question of who was the greatest of the era remained unanswered.

Advertisement

There could be no doubt this time, as Cena puts the phenomenal one over completely clean, in one of the greatest matches of his career. It’s an elegant angle, two industry veterans with something to prove to the other, and willing to pull out every last move from their arsenal to get the win.

The high spots start early, with Cena kicking out of the Styles Clash, and while kicking out of finishers can be overused, it works perfectly here. Cena destroys Styles with an elevated Attitude Adjustment, but it’s not enough. Cena’s look of disbelief is perfect - he just doesn’t know what he can do to beat this guy.

As it transpires, he can’t. AJ downs Cena with a forearm, then leaves John in the ring to commiserate, and bask in an audience who haven’t enjoyed one of his matches so much in a long while.

3. 2017 - Brock Lesnar Vs. Roman Reigns Vs. Samoa Joe Vs. Braun Strowman

Truth in advertising from WWE: they promised us a chaotic battle of the big men, and delivered precisely what we wanted. There’s nothing flashy or complicated about this bout, just four of the company’s most fearsome and imposing figures tearing chunks off one another in a ridiculously fun, non stop 20 minute sprint.

Advertisement

There are bruising spots galore in this match. Strowman power slams Brock through a table, then does it again. Reigns spears Brock through the barricade, Joe stretches him out with one nasty submission hold after another - in general, everyone takes turns pounding on the dominant beast, whose Universal Championship and WWE career are on the line.

There’s no keeping Lesnar down, though. He’s stretchered out, ushering a mad scramble between the other three brutes, but returns for an all action finish, finally putting Reigns away with an F5 to retain.

Aside from the retirement stipulation, it really felt like anyone could win this one. A vulgar display of power from WWE that left all four big lads looking fantastic, but probably feeling awfully sore.

Advertisement