The Impossible End Of Wrestling’s Worst Era

A long-read covering the real reason why the cursed WWE monopoly ended.

By Michael Sidgwick /

WWE.com

In March 2001, the WWF purchased WCW. It was the very definition of a pyrrhic victory, but Vince McMahon was still dumb, arrogant and reckless enough to celebrate it regardless.

Advertisement

The resulting Invasion angle was never going to work. Hulk Hogan, Goldberg et al. elected to do nothing for free by sitting out their contracts, as well they should have. It was the correct decision for a worker who bumps for a living well before it became obvious, through the mishandling of Diamond Dallas Page and Booker T, that the WWF held no interest in positioning the former WCW wrestlers on the same level as the top WWF stars. The case of DDP was particularly, morbidly hilarious. He rose to fame as a creative workhorse of a babyface in WCW. In the WWF, as a heel, despite being married to Kimberly Page at the time, he stalked the Undertaker’s then-wife Sara. His motivation?

Diamond Dallas Page - whose segments invariably thrashed the Undertaker’s in the ratings throughout 1997 - wanted ‘Taker to make him famous. If that’s how Vince McMahon perceived very large and very known men, the breakout prospects from the ECWA Super 8 tournament stood absolutely no chance.

Advertisement

The Invasion was a doomed non-starter even with the best of intentions. The star power simply did not exist. The WWF’s arrogance didn’t help, obviously, but there was no real demand, either. The WWF fanbase had been conditioned over the years to receive WCW as the lesser knock-off outfit: a message that was reinforced through the booking every single week. The WWF could have waited, heavily teased the formation of a new WCW, signed Hogan et al., appointed a different showrunner to book a relaunched Nitro using the third and fourth hours of television, and created a very different feel to that old SmackDown slot to develop two audiences. That was never going to happen. Vince won with his vision. The intent to rebuild WCW as a brand was not there. Vince would have sooner rebooted ECW, and in fact did five years later. By Survivor Series, the ordeal was over.

The monopoly was a definitionally awful framework with which to promote pro wrestling: the story that never ends. No other promotion of renown existed on the cable stage. A wrestler couldn’t jump over to WWE to create a shocking, iconic moment and refresh company storylines. The same old stars felt overexposed as, in parallel - years after WWE had ruined the territory system - new, super-green acts were shoved under the bright lights to fail.

Advertisement

Even if WWE was booked really rather well and was willing to patiently embrace pro wrestlers who didn’t move like robotic, über-juiced freaks, it would not have functioned correctly. Wrestling, which never ends, can get tedious or skippable enough with competition. Without competition, WWE floundered. Drastically.

WWE was not booked well at all.

Advertisement

It would be reductive to state that WWE bought WCW and was dismal for the next two decades of its existence. WWE at least recognised that they’d broken the mechanisms of how wrestling should function. To correct this, the brand extension era was launched in 2002, which was quite funny conceptually, given what hadn’t happened the prior year. People don’t want WCW.

They want two WWEs, if anything!

Advertisement

The rosters were split between Raw and SmackDown. For a while, each brand promoted their own pay-per-views. In theory, this was an astute idea. In theory, it made WWE feel less homogenised and more appealing to a wider audience.

They got it right twice, like the broken clock WWE was.

Advertisement

The Kurt Angle Vs. Shawn Michaels programme of 2005 was magnificent. Despite both being contracted to WWE, because neither had been drafted to the other show in the near three years that preceded it - and because Angle debuted during Shawn’s four-year hiatus - it felt weirdly impossible. WWE’s early, disciplined approach worked. This was the closest WWE had come to harnessing the wonderful possibilities of old. Angle Vs. Michaels somehow felt like an inter-promotional dream match in the context of the time period.

The premise and development of the feud was incredible. After he was quickly, shockingly eliminated from the 2005 Royal Rumble match by Shawn, Kurt became obsessed. He insisted that he was a better wrestler than Shawn. In fact, everything Shawn could do, Kurt could do better. As part of this campaign, Kurt infamously “covered”, complete with new lyrics, Shawn’s ‘Sexy Boy’ theme song, after which, in a really well done heat angle, he made Sensational Sherri’s ankle hurt. In another inspired idea, Angle defeated Shawn’s old Rocker partner Marty Jannetty on the March 15 SmackDown. It probably went too long, at 17:44, but what a commendable showing and great idea for a subplot. WWE felt interesting again on the road to WrestleMania 21. Two new megastars, in John Cena and Batista, were set to be anointed. The Money In The Bank match was the most original and promising new gimmick concept in years. As random and brief as it was, Jannetty’s cameo signified that anybody could show up, and not just some oafish developmental greenhorn who’d take months and months to get over, if they ever did.

Advertisement

Angle Vs. Michaels was incredible. It clicked as beautifully as the wider storyline did. In a great twist, while it was a familiar beat in Angle’s matches, the thread of Michaels outclassing him on the mat with some atypical amateur exchanges drew the intense killer from the humiliated wrestling machine. Between January and April, WWE fans were treated to both the composite brilliance of Kurt Angle and a cruel glimpse of the old creative paradigm.

This programme, as exceptional as it was, followed the death of the actual idea of the brand extension.

Advertisement

The consensus opinion that Monday Night Raw was the dismal sports entertainment show and SmackDown some workrate utopia is overstated. On SmackDown, to list just three events that unfolded during Heyman’s time as lead writer, Dawn Marie screwed Al Wilson to death, Billy refused to marry Chuck because he wasn’t “gay or nothin’”, and Torrie Wilson defeated Nidia in a bikini contest. On a fundamental core level, Raw and SmackDown were very similar shows, which was always going to happen when they were each overseen and approved by the same person: Vince McMahon.

Still, there’s something to it. Which memory persists as a fond one to this day: the ‘SmackDown Six’, or Bubba Ray Dudley’s singles run?

Advertisement

On his own WWE Bio DVD ‘’Ladies And Gentleman, My Name Is Paul Heyman’, Heyman expressed his belief that he was removed from the position as SmackDown lead writer because those above him in WWE resented that “his” show performed better than the Raw flagship - which starred Triple H - that was WWE’s priority. This wasn’t Heyman’s trademark brand of hyperbole. In January 2002, before the rosters were split, Raw handily out-drew SmackDown, as it always had done.

In February and March, it often did so by a full ratings point. However, by the time Heyman’s vision for the show materialised, a shift happened. SmackDown started to equalise or outright defeat Raw nearly half the time. In September, it was a clean sweep for the entire month in SmackDown’s favour. This didn’t just happen; Raw was entrenched as the big show of the week. SmackDown, historically, was stigmatised as the B-show. Across that month of September 2002, the ‘SmackDown Six’ was pushed heavily. On September 10, Chavo Guerrero and Eddie Guerrero, Chris Benoit and Kurt Angle all won matches (the latter over Rey Mysterio in a blinding SummerSlam sequel). On September 24, Edge went over Eddie in a superb No Disqualification WWE Match of the Year contender. In the main event, in a match almost as good, Rey went over Angle and Benoit in a breathless Triple Threat sprint.

Advertisement

In the WWE of 2024, the paradigm has since shifted from kick pads to “cinema”, but 22 years ago, a portion of the fanbase, reeling from the endless stunts and over-the-top angles and terrible carny finishes of the Attitude Era, were wildly enthusiastic about the direction of SmackDown. For all of eight months, beyond the mandatory schlock booked to appease Vince McMahon, SmackDown was the hotbed of in-ring action and intra-match storytelling. There was a TV-sized audience for professional wrestling in the United States, and Paul Heyman captured them. For eight months. When he wasn’t as horny as the rest of them.

Out of the writer’s room door by February 2003, the other side of the story puts it that Heyman was impossible to deal with and would not “play the game”.

Advertisement

So what?

He was actually winning a game that was far more important, but that wouldn’t stand. Vince McMahon, who encouraged the competition, threw a temper tantrum, and - isn’t this ironic? - took his ball and ran home from the challenge. SmackDown was Raw and Raw was SmackDown and the Attitude Era never really ended. ‘Ruthless Aggression’, in tone, format, and spirit, was simply an extension of a grotesquely ugly and grabby time.

Advertisement

To a not inconsiderable number of fans, who hadn’t learned the lesson imparted by the Invasion angle, this was the first sign that WWE was no longer for them. You put your money where your mouth was, but WWE - inexplicably, until you learned of the childish psyche that Vince McMahon calls his thoughts and feelings - didn’t want it like that.

Vince McMahon didn’t learn the lesson, either. Why would he have? His grand vision for “sports entertainment” had defeated wrasslin’. He didn’t have to worry about it anymore - or at least, he didn’t think he had to worry about it.

Advertisement

At several points, Vince McMahon had the opportunity to get ahead of the trend that would one day undermine his monopoly.

Mick Foley in 2004 made a few appearances for Ring Of Honor. It was hardly a memorable chapter in a vaunted time for the promotion - it seemed as much an excuse on Foley’s part to rant about Ric Flair as to endorse the next generation of talent - but he was genuinely impressed by Samoa Joe and CM Punk. He was so impressed that he personally recommended both to Vince McMahon. That was a mistake. Vince’s contrarian childlike demeanour compelled him to brush off the suggestion; he never did like it when somebody else thought they had the inside track. Also working against Samoa Joe: he was “fat”.

Advertisement

Yes, according to an old episode of Something To Wrestle, Bruce Prichard confirmed that Vince looked upon Joe not as the best wrestler in North America but rather a “big fat Samoan”. Between Prichard’s trademark embellishment and Vince’s physique bias, it’s difficult to tell whether that was a verbatim quote, but regardless, Joe did not turn up on the WWE main roster until 2017, years into a physical decline.

Samoa Joe was so fantastic in 2005 that he wrestled Kenta Kobashi and the ROH fans received him as an equal to one of the most revered babyfaces in professional wrestling history. Joe was an intense, cool, killer, the very definition of aura. He also boasted so much in the way of substance. In many ways, if not every single last one of them, he was the ideal professional wrestler. The issue is that the only game in town didn’t want pro wrestlers, much less fat ones.

Advertisement

Joe was the first sign of an invisible enemy encroaching - a new way of doing things that would one day become a cable hit - but, because he was years away from that shift in his prime, he instead attempted to make his fortune in Total Non-Stop Action.

TNA was a joke of a promotion. It was actually a tragicomedy; people needed it to be good, it so often was good in spite of itself, but it was ultimately too stupid to ever compete with the WWE juggernaut. Booked by Vince Russo, it was an outfit so dumb that it was actually worse - significantly so - than the general public’s perception of the medium. These people - whose perception of you makes advertisers uneasy about selling their wares in the commercial breaks of a pro wrestling TV show - think wrestling is a pathetic interest in and of itself. They couldn’t even conceive of something as harebrained as the Reverse Battle Royal, in which the wrestlers had to enter rather than exit the ring (!). Logically, the match should have been a running race, but they chose to brawl for a while first. Wrestlers were so moronic under Vince Russo’s direction that they in effect couldn’t even walk through an open door.

Advertisement

CM Punk did sign with WWE, but only because they’d heard some distant chatter about his promo skills and because Paul Heyman was adamant that they had to recruit him. Sometimes it was easier to simply shut him up and let him get his own way - and it was only the rebooted ECW. The stakes were low, and the brand needed bodies.

ECW was the latest phase of the recurring, cruel trend. WWE would convince the ‘Universe’ that they were doing the proper wrestling thing, and decide shortly thereafter that they could not be bothered. Stunned by the huge sales of the ‘Rise And Fall Of ECW’ DVD, WWE promoted the One Night Stand tribute nostalgia show in 2005. That was another roaring success, and so WWE decided to reboot the brand and turn it into a weekly TV show. The weekly TV show was dire, a soulless thing indistinguishable from the main roster after a matter of weeks beyond the odd curio, like Big Show Vs. Ric Flair in a Hardcore match. After the ECW faithful very vocally rejected Batista Vs. Show in the Hammerstein Ballroom, ECW was taped on the same night as SmackDown. The underground brand had made it mainstream, sort of, as the monkey’s paw curled and the Sandman defeated Matt Striker via count-out in the land of “extreme” in front of a bunch of disinterested people who actually wanted to watch Batista. This should have underscored to Vince McMahon - who heard volleying chants of “Let’s go Cena/Cena sucks!” every single Monday - that there were in fact two audiences.

Advertisement

CONT'D...

AEW

In retrospect, it was remarkable that Punk was permitted to retain his own gimmick. It took him years to reach a level below John Cena’s pinnacle. He was not blameless - his endless would-be breakthrough programme with John Morrison was plagued with multiple nothing matches - but it was primarily the fault of WWE that he was made to get over on his own accord. He was a superstar in 2009, but he wasn’t meant to be. Across 2010, as the leader of the Straight Edge Society, Punk starred as the generational heel he was before he even worked a WWE dark match. In 2011, he cut the infamous Pipe Bomb promo. In it, he articulated that which many fans felt after this constant stream of halfhearted flirtations with good, productive fan-forward wrestling. And through it, Punk widened the chasm between WWE and the audience to what, ultimately, was an irreconcilable extent. There were two WWEs.

Advertisement

There was the WWE that appealed to the young children it targeted through the push of John Cena, and there was the WWE that millennial fans suffered because they believed in CM Punk and wanted to watch something that was big time. WWE could have enjoyed the benefits of these two audiences and, for a few years, they almost did - but not before a short decade of an abysmal philosophy of talent recruitment.

WWE did not sign Samoa Joe from Ring Of Honor because they had created their own pool of talent from which to recruit.

Advertisement

The developmental system was a joke that was much too successful too early.

The vaunted Ohio Valley Wrestling Class of 2002 was an impossible aberration. Brock Lesnar was a once-in-a-lifetime athlete so freakish that he later dominated the UFC with relatively minimal training because he was such an eye-catching beast of a human being. John Cena was simply a megastar who happened to choose wrestling as his profession and was one of the rare few who was able to move past it. He later joined Batista, who was a more understated but no less effective badass, in Hollywood. Randy Orton was never a needle-mover - would wrestling look any different had he not entered it? - but was a super-reliable and gifted natural who ultimately showed his star and staying power as much as WWE insisted upon it.

Advertisement

WWE must have thought this developing greenhorns lark was easy, hence why they essentially just expected it to happen all over again. That would explain why they treated OVW and its creative force Jim Cornette with contempt - and then, when Cornette was fired for slapping Santino Marella, why WWE thought it was as easy as setting up regional throwback territories in Atlanta and Tampa. The latter was far more productive than the former - Deep South Wrestling was more a small man’s outlet for torture than a wrestling school - but Florida Championship Wrestling, helmed by the overlooked, brilliant wrestling mind Tom Prichard, was hardly fit for purpose. Roman Reigns and Big E, amongst others, learned the trade in a facility that for months had no running water, but while they eventually ascended to the top of the card, neither entered the WWE system as an experienced, good-to-go game-changer.

OVW, DSW, FCW: over-delivery, laughable dumpster fire, very modest success. Fundamentally, wherever it was located, the satellite feeder system did not work. WWE preferred to recruit mostly very large men - and telegenic female models - with zero or minimal experience. Chris Jericho, back when he was sharper, once remarked on his podcast that Vince believes “If you came from another company, it didn’t count” and that Vince does not like it when he is not in control of a performer’s success. Thus, appalled by the idea that there was such a thing as ‘Ring Of Honor’ in which wrestlers outside of the WWE system were received in niche circles as demigods, he essentially signed camera-friendly lumps of clay, to draw on Minoru Suzuki’s infamous analogy of the WWE system. Even the best trainers - and Tom Prichard was that - could not prevent the inevitable. The same coaching philosophy and the same drills and the same curriculum will result in the same wrestlers.

Advertisement

Forget the Undertaker’s parlour tricks. Forget Kota Ibushi entering, with eerily blank eyes, a sort of fugue state in which he can’t feel pain and thrusts sickening jabs into the throats of his opponents. Forget the bone-chilling, quiet delivery of Jake ‘The Snake’ Roberts. Forget New Jack taking leave of his senses and mauling a hapless, terrified opponent for real.

The most horrifying sight in pro wrestling history is that of the WWE HD logo appearing in the top-right corner of your screen as a midcard TV match happened between 2008-2011. At that point, the folly of the developmental system had fully materialised. WWE was in the cookie cutter era. So many bland matches, featuring mechanically identical talents scared of doing something to get themselves over, simply…happened.

Advertisement

The developmental era of WWE was atrocious, almost comically so. For much of the 2000s, the biggest worm of all-time, John Laurinaitis, oversaw the programme. When he wasn’t signing synthetic, wildly unqualified wrestlers on a physique-first basis, John Laurinaitis, infamously, was signing the wrong one-legged wrestler. WWE was a joke so outrageous that an animated sitcom writer wouldn’t get away with pitching it. Nobody is that stupid.

In the wake of Chris Benoit killing his wife Nancy, child Daniel and himself in 2007, WWE cynically abandoned, at long last, the grim pursuit of controversy-baiting schlock. In its place, in order to position itself as clean sponsor-friendly family fun - a savvy move launched by Stephanie McMahon, who probably drew more money to WWE than most - the promotion’s storylines became unfunny, trivial, cringe-worthy. PG WWE, led by John Cena, was a level significantly below the best children’s television. To that jaded millennial audience, Cena was an insufferable gurning clown. Vince always wanted his sports entertainers to be living action figures; John Cena, clunky and unable to convey genuine emotion, was the closest he ever came to that ideal.

Advertisement

WWE was not wall-to-wall diabolical as the 2000s receded from view. Certain top-level programmes peaked at outstanding: the well-plotted blood feud between Chris Jericho and Shawn Michaels; the Undertaker’s Streak and the ‘End of an Era’ story-within-a-story; CM Punk rising to superstardom as Jeff Hardy proved to be the ideal vehicle with which to reboot his sanctimonious better-than-you persona…

This actually good storytelling was the absolute least fans could reasonably expect from what, by that point, was the most comfortably moneyed pro wrestling outfit in history. More often than not - statistically - those fans watched Cena, Orton and Triple H wrestle one another in various combinations for two full years.

Advertisement

Developmental, post-OVW, even at its most productive, was just a glorified wrestling school. These talents could have trained anywhere else. WWE, in the meantime, rarely recruited from what, towards the end of the 2010s, had become a bonafide scene: the super-indie circuit.

In the early-to-mid 2000s, Ring Of Honor captured a comparatively tiny but influential share of the wrestling market. Aghast at the bland and puerile state of the monopoly, those few who held an interest in great in-ring wrestling followed ROH through its DVD releases. ROH was AEW before AEW: with its puroresu-inspired narrative framework, it was the antidote to WWE’s trite, frivolous “entertainment”.

Advertisement

The early stars of Ring Of Honor became legends. CM Punk, a loathsome, pious megalomaniac, was so effective at drawing heat, with his punchy, venomous, cocksure delivery, that he was in effect a time traveller. He generated reactions thought lost in a more knowing, detached modern era. Joe, as mentioned, was revered on the level of the ‘90s All Japan gods. Bryan Danielson was the greatest wrestler alive, a man so incredible at pacing the struggle of a violent wrestling match that it was practically impossible not to rate him. At a stretch, you could argue that he was a bit indulgent on occasion. Otherwise, the American Dragon was the objectively great genius in a subjective medium. AJ Styles continued to redefine the athletic standard - tighter, more ambitious, more exhilarating than the WCW cruiserweights who forged the path through which he sprinted. Backed by wrestlers who reintroduced a degree of authenticity not witnessed since the pomp of ECW (Homicide) and great stooge heels without whom it would have all been too much (Jimmy Rave), ROH was the Best In The World.

As with everything else, particularly the ceaseless pro wrestling churn, ROH eventually did become too much. Davey Richards epitomised this descent into parody; his matches would have been dumb, stiff, intense fun, had he not been in there for what felt like an eternity.

Advertisement

Over on the west coast, Pro Wrestling Guerrilla supplanted ROH as the preeminent hipster league. As co-founder Scott Lost put it, PWG wanted to be ROH - “without the stick in its ass”. Much of the promotion’s early output, with its awful edgelord racism, has dated horrendously, but peak PWG was an exhilarating, irreverent battleground - an intense competition in which the goal was to get over and appease the discerning tastemakers that crammed inside the sweltering dump that was the American Legion Hall in Reseda, California.

PWG was the place in which the crowd, after ironically taking to their hand-slapping Hardy Boyz update and Hanson theme song initially, roared in approval as the Young Bucks were mutilated by Bryan Danielson and Roderick Strong in 2009. Booker Super Dragon wanted the beating to feel so awful that the crowd eventually sympathised with the Bucks. It didn’t happen. Strong and Danielson intensified the rampage. At one point, Danielson accidentally kicked Matt Jackson square in the face. Matt had just eaten a forearm to the jaw so vicious that he involuntarily slumped out of position.

Advertisement

If anything, the crowd was so unforgiving that Strong and Danielson turned babyface several times over. When the Bucks won, following an unconvincing and anticlimactic closing stretch, they were booed out of the building.

It was only when the Bucks learned this painful lesson and pissed the crowd off in response months later - brilliantly, by redoing the exact same spot when met with chants of “Same old s**8!” - that the bloodlust was quenched amongst the crowd. Contrary to the daft idea that the PWG crowd would pop at any old high spot, the opposite was true.

Advertisement

A few years removed from that match, the Bucks, in the process of mastering that craft, wrestled the Super Smash Bros. and Adam Cole and Kyle O’Reilly at Threemendous III on July 21, 2012 in a three-way ladder match. It was one of the most insane spectacles ever promoted in a North American wrestling ring. In it, Nick Jackson tweaked a genre standard spot. He climbed the ladder in a bid to retrieve the Tag Team titles. Evil Uno threatened to topple him over. Nick feigned a dramatic tumble to the outside, but, in a magnificent twist, a moment of crazed inspiration, used the top rope as a springboard to launch a senton that flattened the field of wrestlers below. The Reseda crow lost their goddamn minds. Contrast that with WWE developmental wrestlers grabbing holds and executing a standard, imposed layout in accordance with the in-house style. It’s little wonder that one generation of wrestlers truly learned how to get over.

(In a notable irony, given that the Young Bucks didn’t know how to work and WWE don’t do spot-fests, Sin Cara replicated that spot during the Money In The Bank Ladder match at WrestleMania 32. Ricochet also executed the exact same sequence nine full years later at WWE Money In The Bank 2021.)

Advertisement

Unlike Florida Championship Wrestling, real, discerning fans filed into the Legion. If those fans didn’t give the Bucks such a hard time, Nick Jackson might not have thought to do that spot. He was determined to prove that he was one step ahead of the smug know-it-alls in attendance.

On a broader level, he might not have been driven to impress through a level of creative expression that was encouraged by the promoter. And, since every other trendy import was intent on getting over and making their name, a sense of cutthroat competition emerged. A wrestler had to earn that spot. They didn’t get it just because they had a certain look and were groomed for it.

Advertisement

In PWG, the wrestlers often performed guest commentary. It was mostly daft, knockabout fun in the vein of the promotion’s culture - but it served a dual purpose. If a wrestler popped at something, it meant more. Conversely, and wrestlers improved on the back of this, if one of their peers messed up in some way, the guest commentator would bury them mercilessly. In a PWG classic, Matt Sydal, Ricochet and Will Ospreay defeated Adam Cole and the Young Bucks. In it, after wowing the crowd with a high spot, Ospreay sat on the mat and for some reason gave them a thumbs up with a deeply regrettable goofy expression on his face. Giddy with adulation, Ospreay sort of crossed his eyes and stuck his tongue out. Chuck Taylor was on commentary and said that Ospreay looked “like a d*ckhead”. Ospreay remains very theatrical with his facial expressions, but he was never quite so cringe-worthy after that harsh (but thoroughly justified) burial. Bad habits were either bullied or literally stamped out of the wrestlers.

Yes, the infamous invisible grenade spot was also very stupid, but PWG was lawless terrain. The wrestlers were encouraged to piss about and determine what worked, what worked but wasn’t worth doing again, what didn’t work whatsoever. PWG was the rough demo every artist must record before nailing their sound; FCW was WWE’s soulless attempt to ghost-write something manufactured.

Advertisement

PWG was the last true territory. Wrestlers got over there. Wrestlers were made there. Not funded by WWE, it became, in effect and alongside ROH, its most effective developmental territory.

In one of the endless incredible gags in the peak era of ‘The Simpsons’, the titular family, tormented by villain Sideshow Bob, is forced into the Witness Protection programme in season five episode ‘Cape Feare’. As part of the programme, they must naturally change their surnames. Homer, a perfect idiot, is unable to grasp this. He maintains that he understands. The FBI agents tell him that his new name is Mr. Thompson, but when they address him as ‘Mr. Thompson’, he doesn’t respond. His name is Homer Simpson. In the final punchline, one of the exasperated agents, his tie loosened to convey the frustration and the long passing of time, says “Now, when I say “Hello Mr. Thompson” and press down on your foot, you smile and nod”. He stamps on Homer’s foot and says “Hello, Mr. Thompson”. Homer doesn’t get it. Who’s Mr Thompson? He’s Homer Simpson. Homer whispers to the other agent “I think he’s talking to you”.

Advertisement

This scene, designed to portray the dumbest human being on the planet, is almost precisely analogous to the relationship between Vince McMahon and the more cynical “vocal minority” of the WWE fanbase. They told Vince - time and time again, by jeering John Cena or chanting for CM Punk or simply tuning out of the product - that they wanted to see a wrestling-forward product featuring state-of-the-art wrestlers that they liked no matter how relatively small or pale they were. They in effect stamped on Vince’s foot over and over again. “I think they want large sports entertainers,” Vince said, before, to draw on one of countless examples, handing Daniel Bryan’s “Yes!” chant to the Big Show under the belief that Show was bigger and thus automatically better.

Vince was slightly less stupid than Homer Simpson. He at least knew that many of you really rather liked Daniel Bryan; he just couldn't care less. Moreover, Vince also knew that nobody else could monetise this demand on a financially viable scale. That would change - but it might not have, had Vince responded to karma’s call.

Advertisement

He was kicked in the foot yet again on the road to WrestleMania XXX. He tried to sideline Daniel Bryan in place of Batista, who was by that point just the latest part-time star who had understood that they could return for a less intensive January to April schedule (a trend that only lowered the ceiling on the hapless full-time main roster). Bryan of course got over, and how, through his expert in-ring work and his ability to rig the system with his simple, ingenious use of crowd interaction; before there was “Yeet”, there was “Yes!”

CONT'D...

Advertisement
WWE.com

Bryan capitalised on his newfound popularity by reinventing himself as an incandescent babyface sports entertainer. He simplified his work, but it was beautifully potent - pro wrestling’s version of the major label debut. He was so over that fans jeered a returning Batista at the 2014 Royal Rumble. They could not sanction that WWE was not a meritocracy, in spite of so much evidence to the contrary, and the threatened revolt was so embarrassing that WWE had to pivot. Bryan defeated Triple H, and then Randy Orton and Batista, to walk out of WrestleMania XXX with the WWE World Heavyweight title. Vince McMahon was dragged, after much resistance, into placating the second audience.

Advertisement

On the week of WrestleMania XXX, Vince told Bryan that he wanted Roman Reigns, not him, to be the next John Cena. Were Bryan to have stayed healthy, he was scheduled to take the John Cena squash at Brock Lesnar’s hands at SummerSlam 2014. The answer to the revolt was only a temporary measure.

Virtually everything WWE did in this era was a reaction to its various, arrogant blunders.

Advertisement

If they could just get ahead of it, and not treat positive fan-friendly moves as if flustered with an almighty sigh and passive aggressive “OK, fine,” WWE could have changed the timeline.

In yet another continuation of the same pattern, the ‘Women’s Revolution’ only happened because it was a reactive measure to dismal PR. The candid AJ Lee ripped apart WWE’s approach to women’s wrestling by pointing out a certain hypocrisy on Stephanie McMahon’s part. Stephanie had tweeted her support of Patricia Arquette, who at the 2015 Academy Awards ceremony had campaigned for wage equality in the United States. AJ pointed out that WWE was vastly behind that curve as, on the very same night, the hashtag #GiveDivasAChance trended on Twitter in response to Paige and Emma Vs. the Bella Twins being allocated just 30 seconds on Monday Night Raw. The message was again shouted, unmistakably, in WWE’s ignorant face.

Advertisement

The ‘Revolution’ took root in NXT. Paige and Emma instigated it by wrestling a comparatively lengthy and well-received match (13:01) at NXT ArRIVAL on February 27, 2014. It hasn’t aged spectacularly well, in truth, but the match signified that WWE - not that they deserve much praise for not treating women like sex objects for once - might start taking women’s wrestling seriously. This wasn’t entirely benevolent. Paul Levesque had identified the success of the UFC women’s division and the drawing power of Ronda Rousey as something to replicate in WWE. Even the moderately more progressive approach to women’s wrestling in NXT was, ultimately, another reaction.

Lapsed fans, by the mid-2010s, felt they had been saved. Paul Leveque’s peak NXT run was a special, vital time. NXT and the main roster oscillated wildly in quality, so much so that the bond between fans and the former intensified. ‘Papa H’, as he came to be known, was received as a saviour figure. The Reddit community extended their gratitude by gifting him a fruit basket. Levesque didn’t get to where he was by being an idiot. Even though he enjoyed burying them in the same breath, he was very much aware of the second audience and built his product around appeasing them. He was on the campaign trail for the throne.

Advertisement

NXT was at its best when it was plain nice. It wasn’t merely more on the pulse. It wasn’t just a place in which a wrestler like Sami Zayn could be a babyface without you being told that he was some uppity geek who was actually terrible and the only people who like him are internet nerds. (That isn’t a snarky joke; Michael Cole said almost precisely that, and worse, about Daniel Bryan in 2010). It wasn’t just the place in which Zayn could unleash some of the most heart-pounding state-of-the-art offence that WWE fans had ever seen. It was nice.

NXT at its best was near-perfect. Through the unique purpose that it served, for a while anyway, the show and brand solved the problem that befalls every major outfit. Wrestling never ends. There is no off-season. While tinged with a degree of guilt, there’s no escaping the fact that even your favourite wrestlers become boring. Overexposed. AEW fans didn’t expect to want Jon Moxley to take an extended vacation in 2023 when he was the hero they needed in 2020. Becky Lynch was The Man at WrestleMania 35; at WrestleMania 40, despite having already played heel in the interim, she as a babyface was booed by over half of the stadium.

Advertisement

WWF fans were a bit bored of Steve Austin by late 2000!

NXT circumvented the issue because it was designed for wrestlers to eventually graduate from the system. Consider the rise of American Alpha. Neither Jason Jordan nor Chad Gable had made a name for themselves on the independent circuit. Both were box-fresh. Fans weren’t bored of them; quite the opposite. They developed near-instant chemistry as a unit. A faster and more wholesome update on the Steiner Brothers fused with a more earnest babyface vulnerability, the team was a total joy, and watching them capture the NXT Tag Team titles at NXT TakeOver: Dallas was a strangely paternal experience no matter your age.

Advertisement

After years and years of two flawed extremes - to be reductive about it, most wrestlers who didn’t break big or flame out fell under two archetypes and were either a multi-gimmicked nightmare like pre-fame Cody Rhodes or a tedious ever-present like Dolph Ziggler - NXT crafted actual, complete character arcs.

American Alpha really were “able”. Bayley was the wrestler who spoke to your inner child but was hardened enough to repeatedly crush the bones in your hand to jelly if you wronged her and her fans. The Revival proved that you could actually invest in tag team wrestling all over again, and were two wrestlers honed on the unfashionable reaches of the indie circuit. Before Levesque opted for the hot free agent shortcut deeper into his run as booker, Scott Dawson and Dash Wilder completed their own arc from virtual nobodies to a unit that made fans believe in an art that should never have been lost.

Advertisement

NXT was the place in which a megastar could finally arrive in WWE as a megastar - Shinsuke Nakamura was presented as nothing short of a game-changing living legend - and a meritocracy in which less-fancied signees, like Johnny Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa, could ascend to the top of the card and define the entire brand in their image because you, the audience, wanted them to.

The problem, of course, was that Vince McMahon didn’t push these gift-wrapped, demonstrable stars on the main roster. He treated his new young talents like Saturn Devouring His Son. It’s no shock whatsoever that Vince resolutely failed to grasp the feel-good NXT vibe. Levesque built a second audience that actually “belonged” to WWE, and Vince still told them to hit the bricks!

Advertisement

NXT, ultimately, was a failure - and Vince wasn’t solely to blame. In retrospect, it was not sufficient enough an alternative to draw the lapsed fans back. The brand was the very definition of too little, too late.

The television was largely solid. It was easier to ruffle its hair for a job well done than to feel spellbound by it. The plotting made sense. Wrestlers who needed a push won often enough. Only on very rare occasions would something with a true creative spark to it play out - for example, the brilliant use of Dan Matha as a subverted bait-and-switch sacrificed to portray Samoa Joe as the true monster of the brand.

Advertisement

The promos were scripted, just never in the deeply embarrassing “WWE way”. Consider this: how many NXT promos make it into the grand pantheon of classics? Which NXT promo would you rank up there with Dusty Rhodes raging against “hard times”, Eddie Kingston vowing to crawl on his hands and knees to CHIKARA High Noon, Jon Moxley demanding the ball?

Very few, if any. The promos were solid enough, but in that modern WWE tradition, they existed to build towards a soundbite inserted into the video package just before the chorus or the breakdown in the accompanying song. There was synthetic quality to NXT. It was great sports entertainment, but sports entertainment all the same. There was a polished lack of authenticity to the product. It was pedestrian in a way that wrestling shouldn’t be, formal, stilted. You could hardly fault it. It made sense. The “right” things happened - but was NXT ever a true alternative?

Advertisement

Paul Levesque is not blameless. Whether he was permitted to book entirely of his own volition or not, there was no blood. No fire. No spittle flecked at the camera.

Even the best patterns eventually begin to feel patterned. Drew McIntyre is currently a smash hit on the main roster as the paranoid “hater” troll, but in 2017, he was just the latest shortcut.

Advertisement

Sign hot free agent > strap up hot free agent > NXT champion drops title > main roster debut was the pattern, and that version of Drew McIntyre wasn’t quite Shinsuke Nakamura, despite the opposite being true now.

As NXT was exposed as a sporadically incredible but hardly must-see or distinct pro wrestling brand, in parallel, the true King of Pro Wrestling made inroads into the United States.

Advertisement

CONT'D...

AEW

The modern era of New Japan Pro Wrestling - this isn’t a strict consensus, there never is - peaked between 2012 and 2019. Great as NXT was, it wasn’t great enough to thwart the rise of the resurgence era.

Advertisement

Hiroshi Tanahashi was a genius who could get more out of a well-timed dragon screw - he did it in every match and it would always make perfect sense and you’d still never, ever expect it - than a thousand other wrestlers would get out of a more spectacular move. Kazuchika Okada, the Ace who supplanted him, was the best-ever version of the invincible champion. He paced his matches to make his opponent’s comeback feel earned better than any of his contemporaries and predecessors. Tetsuya Naito was a sick, cool, aloof freak who was incredible at revealing that he did have heart after all (he also perfected the exhilarating danger inherent to pro wrestling). Shinsuke Nakamura was almost the perfect wrestler at his peak. He boasted megastar charisma and a super-credible, unique strike-based arsenal. He was a deranged composite of everything that was ever great. Underneath, Tomohiro Ishii was a man who every single time could convince you that he was about to die or could never die, often, somehow, in the space of a minute.

The level of quality, combined with the easy access to it in a borderless digital age, saw NJPW become the #2 promotion in the United States. The second audience loved NXT, but it just wasn’t enough anymore.

Advertisement

Everything changed on January 4, 2017.

Kenny Omega lost to Kazuchika Okada at the Tokyo Dome, but, as a pro wrestling genius, he got over to a seismic extent in defeat. The match was incredible, quite possibly the greatest ever held. It was so unbelievable that, on commentary, Steve Corino could only make bewildered jock noises as he couldn’t believe he hadn’t just seen the finish. Before the insane closing stretch, so close that every mere strike felt like the finish, Omega transformed into the next best in the world to an even loftier designation. His physical timing was so supernaturally precise that he was probably a centimetre from doing himself significant damage when taking a deranged back body drop bump over the ropes and through a famously sturdy Japanese table. The sound of the Tokyo Dome crowd, when Omega performed a springboard moonsault to the outside, clearing the guardrail, was a rare thing. They reacted like they’d seen some natural wonder. It was the aurora borealis of wrestling spots.

Advertisement

The emotion and drama of that fatigued shoot-out at 40 minutes broke another new barrier of sound. Every fan sounded like they were in a different, very personal state of disbelief. The atmosphere felt overdubbed; it was the total antithesis of the loud but performative, chant-heavy heat you almost invariably hear everywhere else. The first 15 minutes of Okada Vs. Omega 1 planted the idea that wrestling, for the first time since 1998, could be as big and better than WWE. By the time the closing bell sounded, that idea had already bloomed.

Omega Vs. Okada I changed everything in wrestling, even the vernacular. A WWE wrestler would get six stars if their matches took place in the Tokyo Dome.

Advertisement

This match increased the second audience, measurably so; NJPW World subscriptions doubled ahead of it. With Kenny Omega as the top foreign star, a bridge was erected over the pacific ocean. NJPW appealed further to the North American fanbase. NJPW held shows in the States and introduced the United States title to deepen its tendrils into the western market.

NJPW somehow surpassed that unscaled peak over the next two years, commercially and artistically. Okada Vs. Omega IV was the next greatest match of all time. Alpha Vs. Omega - Chris Jericho Vs. Kenny Omega at Wrestle Kingdom 12 - again doubled World subscriptions. That Jericho, a top WWE star, would work for NJPW - where he would never seriously entertain the idea of working for TNA/Impact Wrestling - was another indication that something massive, unthinkable, was sparking into life.

Advertisement

Lapsed WWE fans as much as anything hated the WWE creative process. They resented John Cena, were unmoved by the in-house style, and were exhausted by the constant retconning of vaguely promising storylines - but the stilted writing and the idea that these people were artificial and reading from awful scripts could not be shaken.

Being The Elite hasn’t aged particularly well and was wildly uneven at the time. Certain gags were inspired - Cody Rhodes wildly celebrating his win over Kenny Omega at ROH Supercard of Honor 2018 as his wife required urgent medical attention in the very next room, for one - but there was a lot of snark and corniness. The show nonetheless embarrassed WWE’s writing at its peak, not that that was altogether difficult; by the mid-2010s, WWE did a stunningly effective job of humiliating itself.

Advertisement

As silly as much of BTE was, it obviously connected with a great deal of people. The second audience had known for a long time that other companies could promote better in-ring action than WWE (or action that was better suited to their tastes). Storylines, though?

That idea was nothing new. The ROH Vs. Combat Zone Wrestling feud was the hydrogen bomb to the Invasion’s coughing baby. Still, that BTE’s success could drive a 10,000+ attended show was the tipping point.

Advertisement

That a do-it-yourself YouTube show could better engage its (smaller) audience than WWE’s creative process wasn’t just shocking: it was exhilarating. The lapsed second audience knew that WWE’s way of doing things was wrong - certainly, not the only things could be done. All In was proof. All In instilled in those fans a sense of righteous defiance. To be told you were a “mark” who couldn’t grasp what was best for business outside of your niche little forums - only to discover you were in fact correct - was a physical high of validation. The AEW “tribe” existed before AEW.

It’s easy to rubbish Being The Elite in hindsight. Some of it was awful, and at least two cast members have been rightfully scrubbed from the pro wrestling consciousness. But the series told many popular stories, and whether you hated them or can’t bear to watch them back now, on September 1, 2018, the cast of BTE did that which WWE could not or would not do. They sent the fans home happy that they had invested in something with an actual payoff.

Advertisement

BTE drove the resurgence of Ring Of Honor. The aforementioned 2012 Supercard drew a company record of 6,100. Cody Rhodes was a huge draw there, and his rhetoric and conviction was instrumental in the “movement” breaking big.

The landscape was in a state of transformation by 2018. The second audience no longer had to naively dream of, for example, Johnny Gargano headlining WrestleMania. It was never going to happen. If they wanted to see that style on the big stage, they could simply pay to watch Kenny Omega headline Wrestle Kingdom 13.

Advertisement

In 2018, a millennial fan, one of the many that comprised the second audience, took an interest in this new scene. He attended one of the shows NJPW promoted in their bid to expand into the west. His sense that a wrestling alternative could be a viable major cable proposition actually predated All In (although All In did act as proof of concept to the TV industry). That millennial fan was the son of a billionaire named Tony Khan.

As NXT strived for a movement that was organically materialising elsewhere, the main roster plummeted to hitherto unexplored depths of awfulness. Many lapsed fans have their own personal goodbye. It wasn’t just the second audience that Vince McMahon treated with contempt in the late 2010s.

Advertisement

As expertly tracked by Brandon Thurston of Wrestlenomics, the dismal events of the 2015 Royal Rumble accelerated WWE’s decline in viewership. Several internet darlings were ejected from the match, in order to portray the unpopular office favourite Roman Reigns as the lesser of evils, by tedious antiques Kane and the Big Show. Dolph Ziggler et al., hoisted out by the back of their trunks, resembled sentient bags of trash. One picture. One thousand words.

As NJPW courted the second audience in 2017, with Omega hunting down the most well-booked World champion in wrestling, WWE pissed off the primary audience by crowning Jinder Mahal as WWE Heavyweight champion. This was a disastrous, insulting move. This booking decision underscored how utterly meaningless WWE had become. It was one thing, to watch Roman Reigns suffer in the babyface role when he was surely better suited to play heel. WWE barely even attempted to get Jinder over. Mahal was a completely generic in-ring worker with no charisma nor presence. He was a spiritual successor to the infamous late 2000s bore Vladimir Kozlov, but WWE at least tried to legitimise Kozlov with a steady, committed push. Jinder, as low as jobbers get in WWE, simply won the chance to defeat WWE Champion Randy Orton and did so in just over a month. Before winning that Six-Pack Challenge on SmackDown, Jinder lost in three minutes to the lowly Mojo Rawley on April 11, 2017. 40 days later, at Backlash on May 21, he was WWE Champion. At no point throughout this period did his perception change amongst the public. WWE fans viewed this all with a sense of bemusement. They had never mattered less. The WWE Champion was neither good nor over when the absolute minimum requirement was to be both of those things.

Advertisement

NXT fans received yet another reminder of this when they watched Bayley’s main roster run with utter disbelief. Bayley - a superfan who must have missed every other show with a plunder match on it - refused to use a kendo stick against Alexa Bliss at Extreme Rules 2017. This was the wrestler, again, who once crushed the hand of Sasha Banks to exact her revenge.

By 2017, WWE fans had entered a bargaining process with WWE. They were no longer hopeful of watching a smaller, more athletic wrestler in kick pads ascend to the top of the card. That was hopelessly naive - but what about Braun Strowman?

Advertisement

CONT'D...

WWE.com

This was the primary audience telling Vince McMahon that they’d at long last gravitated towards a star built in his preferred image. Braun was a gigantic truck of a wrestler. His best matches were fun and explosive, but the character wasn’t necessarily a success as a result of his in-ring exploits. WWE held no interest in allowing state-of-the-art, fashionable pro wrestlers work to the intense degree of a Kenny Omega. Strowman worked precisely because he wasn’t doing an impression of Omega. He was WWE through and through. He was what they were looking for, and on that basis, WWE fans thought they had found a realistic attraction worth the investment.

Advertisement

Strowman had an attitude on him at the time, granted, but it’s not as if any top star was ever a goody-two-shoes. He was decisively beaten by Brock Lesnar at No Mercy and was never as hot again. It was all about Roman Reigns.

Fans however revolted at the idea of Roman Reigns challenging for Brock Lesnar’s Universal championship at WrestleMania 34. The indelible image of that main event is not the blood-splattered babyface bravely fighting the monster; it is that of several beach balls being thrown around a stadium that could not have cared less.

Advertisement

Those fans who hadn’t lost faith - those who hadn’t migrated to ROH and New Japan - still fought. Becky Lynch was cast as the heel at SummerSlam 2018, but fans once again refused to go along with the script. Lynch became ‘The Man’, though the original idea was for WWE to hand Charlotte Flair her umpteenth babyface push ahead of WrestleMania 35.

CM Punk.

Advertisement

Daniel Bryan.

Becky Lynch.

Advertisement

All three wrestlers were forced into the main event bracket in response to a toxic fan backlash.

In December 2018, the product was so poorly-received that the McMahons had to apologise for it onscreen and vow to do better. The product did not improve; if anything, the opposite was true.

Advertisement

You had to eat your slop even when you were told it was slop that you were eating. Who else was going to fund this freak show called pro wrestling?

Dave Meltzer of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter once wrote, and he was absolutely dead-on: “The negative stigma pro wrestling faces in television is largely something that has plagued the business on a grand scale from the beginning of time.”

Advertisement

By 2018, things had changed. The relatively inexpensive ad-free streaming model had long since hastened the very slow death of cable television. TV executives panicked. Streaming was winning the war at a price point level, and Netflix, with its acclaimed and engrossing viral documentaries a particular selling point, lured yet more subscribers with its original content. This development compounded the issue that had affected cable TV years earlier: the rise of DVR. Through this, viewers could circumvent those pesky commercials - the commercials that funded cable television. Networks responded by throwing everything at live sport under the belief that it was ‘DVR-proof”. A game is only worth watching live. The drama is entirely driven by the live experience and, unlike a sitcom that will make you laugh forever, a game is done when it’s done.

Ironically, given McMahon’s long-held insistence that wrestling was “entertainment”, it was tolerated by networks because it was considered a DVR-proof property with no off-season: a sport.

Advertisement

At the exact same time in which Vince McMahon pissed the second audience off, the TV industry begrudgingly acknowledged it. To them, you were still poor and unintelligent. They were still unconvinced that you could actually afford the products and services offered in those premium advertising slots. But very few other people were watching television.

This is hardly a romantic interpretation of the AEW origin story - some seminal, uplifting pro wrestling brilliance drove it all forward, and it’s not as if a major network was desperately throwing money at Impact - but it’s not untrue. To underscore that point, Tony Khan had to persuade Kevin Reilly - the former Warner executive without whom AEW would not exist - over a long, protracted period.

Advertisement

All Elite Wrestling was and remains a unicorn of a wrestling promotion. So many factors, many of them thought impossible, converged to make it happen and, in the process, bring an end to the dismal WWE monopoly era.

The death of the TV industry. The rise of New Japan Pro Wrestling and the advances in digital technology that allowed people to more easily access it. The rise of social media as a free tool with which to build brands and tell stories. A collection of intensely acclaimed and gifted free agents whose contracts all expired at the same time. And, of course, a billionaire who could have done literally anything with his young life, but chose to watch Extreme Championship Wrestling and sign up to the DVDVR forum.

Advertisement

And, above all else, the appetite of a public who were simply - in yet another irony - “tired of having their intelligence insulted”. It was only because WWE was so bad for so long that AEW was allowed to be so radically different, and if that scans as hyperbole, WWE isn’t letting Nick Gage slice Chris Jericho up with glass on national television.

AEW was an impossible triumph against the odds - fittingly enough, the exact opposite of WWE’s Jinder Mahal story.

Advertisement

Levesque, who always wins in the end - just ask Sting, Booker T, Goldberg… - actually did become the saviour. Much like his WrestleMania matches, however, it took him rather too long to maintain the monopoly. By the time his NXT TakeOver: New York card featured 11 out of 14 former PWG wrestlers, AEW was already in motion.