The Iron Claw Review: 6 Ups & 3 Downs
Fantastic biopic traces Von Erichs' tragic story... with some historic inaccuracies.
When a biopic starts out with the words, “Inspired by a true story,” it can go one of several ways, depending on your knowledge of the subject matter and your willingness to suspend a desire for accuracy in favor of “entertainment value.”
As a movie, The Iron Claw was a fantastically tragic retelling of the Von Erich family’s rise and dramatic fall. While not entirely historically accurate, the film mostly adhered to the major events that plagued the family.
But the sequencing of these events get jumbled about, with some details changed and others omitted entirely for the sake of the story. Fans – particularly those who didn’t follow these events firsthand in the 80s and 90s – who also can brush this aside and enjoy the movie will come away with a deeper connection to the Von Erich story.
Film reviewers will undoubtedly have different takes on The Iron Claw based on cinematography, plotting, pacing, camerawork and other qualities. From a wrestling perspective, the movie has to be viewed as a huge success, bringing this tragedy into the public eye for a larger audience while maintaining the spirit of the tale.
Perhaps the greatest strength of the movie is how it takes a pure wrestling story and molds it into a tragedy that non-wrestling fans can thoroughly enjoy and appreciate. It can suck a casual viewer in and leave them wanting to learn more about the Von Erich curse. Despite some truly dark material, the film manages to find a silver lining in it all, meager though it might seem.
Let’s get to it…
DOWNS…
3. The Missing Von Erich
As portrayed in the movie, the fate of the Von Erich brothers is tragic enough.
David dies while on tour in Japan, just months before his NWA World Title match against Ric Flair. Kerry loses his foot in a motorcycle accident and eventually commits suicide after a run in the WWF. Mike suffers brain damage from toxic shock syndrome and overdoses on pills. And young Jack Jr. dies years earlier in a terrible accident.
But The Iron Claw completely omits another Von Erich brother who met an untimely death. Chris Von Erich was Fritz and Doris’ youngest son, an undersized wrestler who never could achieve his brothers’ level of success due to his small stature and brittle bones. Chris would commit suicide in 1991, just four years after Mike’s death and two years before Kerry took his own life.
Including Chris’ death would have further magnified the family curse, but it also might have taken screentime from the other storylines. Still, deleting a Von Erich brother – whose story would have added to the overall tale – seems like a big transgression for a biopic.
Less offensive (except for AEW fans) was the minimizing of Lance Von Erich, the fictional cousin brought in to WCCW when Mike was out of action due to toxic shock syndrome. Played by Maxwell Jacob Friedman in the movie, Lance’s role as the Von Erich cousin was cut down to just a few short action sequences with no real screentime given to his backstory. Perhaps a director’s cut will restore MJF’s scenes.
2. ‘Ric Flair’
Iron Claw RIC FLAIR SCENE #wrestling #ironclaw #ricflair pic.twitter.com/qJNVjdeJtI
Advertisement— Bicks Flicks (@bicksflix) December 22, 2023
By now, most wrestling fans have seen and ridiculed the portrayal of then-NWA World Champion Ric Flair in the movie, easily one of the worst characterizations of a wrestling figure. And that includes some of the more egregious casting blunders on Young Rock.
Played by Aaron Dean Eisenberg, Claw’s Flair appears in the final third of the film to wrestle Kevin Von Erich while he is grieving the loss of yet another brother, Mike (more on that later). Eisenberg delivers some of Flair’s more famous promo lines in the most unconvincing way possible, even seemingly speaking in a southern drawl at one point. But perhaps his biggest sin is being unable to even “Woooo!” properly, screeching the Nature Boy’s battle cry.
Flair is onscreen for maybe a total of three minutes from promo to match to locker room afterward, but it’s easily one of the most jarring moments for even a casual wrestling fan. It’s an unforgivable crime that someone who is so widely known and impersonated was portrayed so horribly.
One has to believe that Eisenberg had never watched a single Flair promo and the filmmakers just let it all slide, which is just sad. As fans have noted, it would have been less offensive to have Jay Lethal play Flair as a spot-on impersonation, or have Will Ferrell do his Ashley Schaeffer character from Eastbound & Down (which was based on Flair himself).
1. Screwed-Up Timeline
Movies that follow real-life tales will often take creative license with the details, moving events around, omitting certain situations and sensationalizing parts to make for a more dramatic, compelling story.
But for all its successes, The Iron Claw plays a bit fast and loose with its sequencing of events in the Von Erichs’ story, compressing a series of tragedies befalling the brothers that took place over the course of several years into 20 minutes of film time. David’s death, Kerry’s motorcycle accident and Mike’s overdose happened during a three-year period but whisked by in less than a half-hour.
David is shown coughing up blood at Kevin’s wedding, just days before he leaves for his fateful 1984 tour of Japan, but Kevin was married in August 1980. The film suggests Kerry’s motorcycle accident happened the same night he won the NWA World Title in 1984, when that event didn’t happen until two years later. Mike’s shoulder injury that led to his toxic shock syndrome happened before Kerry’s accident, not after as the movie portrays.
Even Kevin’s wrestling career is subject to creative license. A major focal point early on is that Kevin lost to Harley Race in a non-title match and never got a rematch for the NWA World Title before Race dropped the championship to Ric Flair. In reality, Kevin wrestled Race for the NWA title eight times between 1979-83 and never faced him in a non-title singles bout.
Later, a distraught Kevin is shown fighting Ric Flair in 1986 after Mike’s death. Kevin actually wrestled Flair several times for the world title in 1984-85, but never after May 1985, nearly two years before Mike overdosed.
It wouldn’t have been that hard to keep a lot of these events in the proper order without sacrificing story and drama, which is what makes some of the decisions perplexing.
UPS…
6. Not Too Wrestling Heavy
A wrestling movie about a wrestling family is going to have to include some ring time, but there’s always a dual risk of overexposing the actors and filmmakers with unconvincing action and alienating non-wrestling fans with too much grappling.
The Iron Claw strikes a good balance by showing enough snippets of action, especially early on, to get across how popular the Von Erich brothers are in Texas without overdoing the wrestling. The scenes shown are well-worked and convincing enough, thanks to the consulting of Chavo Guerrero Jr. (who had a bit part as The Sheik) and the commitment of the actors themselves.
There is a decent peel-back-the curtain aspect to the film that viewers understand how the wrestling business works while still showing how physically demanding the industry can be. Kevin’s failed attempts to cut an effective promo and a pre-match strategy session between the Von Erichs and Bruiser Brody and Gino Hernandez provide an effective glimpse behind the scenes at what goes into producing the final product.
For any diehard wrestling fan, there is enough action to whet your appetite. And honestly, if someone wants to see longer clips of the Von Erichs wrestling, there are plenty of actual documentaries and footage out there to watch.
5. The Tragedy Of Mike
It’s impossible to watch the film and not feel the heartbreak of Mike Von Erich’s tragic story.
The only one of Fritz’s sons who had no interest in actually wrestling, Mike was more artistically inclined, an aspiring musician who was also shown as the odd brother out and often the recipient of Fritz’s scorn. He ultimately was pressured into the ring after David’s death, taking his brother’s place in a most unconvincing manner (the scenes with Kevin trying to train Mike depict this well).
Mike’s shoulder injury and toxic shock syndrome left him with brain damage, and the pressure of trying to be David finally got to him. Mike’s suicide was particularly harrowing in how he was pushed into the family business and it quickly consumed him.
His death is portrayed as the turning point for the Von Erich family, with Kevin consumed by the loss and even their stoic mother beginning to crack before everything falls apart with Kerry’s suicide.
For non-wrestling fans, Mike’s death is probably the most relatable, a young man trying to make his father proud and uphold the family legacy, but ultimately being crushed by the weight of it all.
4. Kevin’s Explainer Of Wrestling
Wrestling fans have long tried to explain professional wrestling adequately to their non-fan friends, describing it as an athletic soap opera, physical ballet, or choreographed fighting.
But Kevin Von Erich’s description of wrestling – and being a champion – in the movie is almost perfect. On a date with future wife Pam, Kevin compared wrestling to any other job, where success is based on performance and crowd reaction, and you’re promoted – read: moved up the card and made a champion – as a result of that success. Winning a world title, in Kevin’s telling, was a signal that you are trusted, reliable, over and deserving of leading your promotion.
Equating traditional job performance with in-ring acumen was a fantastic way of relating things for moviegoers who were non-fans, and it didn’t insult wrestling fans’ intelligence by dumbing it down to a level that made the industry look foolish.
3. Fritz The Heel
Every good movie needs tension, drama, or a villain to serve as the focal point for both.
The Iron Claw had a tailor-made villain in Fritz Von Erich, with his real-life pressuring of his sons serving as a perfect basis. Fritz spoke of bringing the NWA World Title into the Von Erich household as the only thing that mattered, going so far as to rank his sons and demean Mike for not being interested in the family business.
The movie wisely does not sugarcoat its portrayal of Fritz by giving him many – if any – redeeming characteristics. An understated scene near the end of the film reveals that he’s been stiffing his sons on their WCCW payouts through the years, a fact that astounds Kevin, who’s living in a tiny apartment with his wife and two sons.
Incredibly, the movie downplayed his role in pushing Mike into David’s spot, and by nixing the youngest Von Erich, Chris, they missed the opportunity to show how low Fritz would stoop and how little of a protector of a father he was.
Still, he’s the clear heel in this story, an easy character to despise.
2. An Imperfect Hero
As the last surviving Von Erich son, Kevin was very clearly the main protagonist of the film, but he was very clearly a flawed hero.
Kevin was a well-meaning, caring big brother who loved his siblings, wife and kids. On the exterior, he was the All-American hero. But beneath the surface was a man who couldn’t save any of his brothers from the excesses of professional wrestling or from Fritz’s relentless pressure. He’s scarred, damaged. Kevin’s burden was so great that at one point, he moved out of his home to prevent the Von Erich curse from “infecting” his sons.
Viewers can’t help but root for Kevin to come out of everything OK, but those who know the story know that it’s going to keep getting worse and the universe is going to continue beating him down. In the end, he’s left to sell his dad’s promotion and carry on without his brothers. It would be a tragic ending if not for the fact that Kevin has found peace and a normal life in the aftermath.
1. Emotional Rollercoaster
How else can one sum up the rise and fall of the Von Erich clan? Wrestling fans knew their story lent itself perfectly to the silver screen, with the emotional peaks and valleys that define a great drama.
Even with the exclusion of the Lance Von Erich fiasco and an entire Von Erich brother (Chris), The Iron Claw packed in enough heartache for two hours. Moviegoers saw the brothers being mobbed and treated like rockstars (though looking at actual footage, it seems like the movie undersold how popular the Von Erichs were), performing at the top of their industry and on the cusp of national superstardom.
And then it all fell apart in rapid-fire succession. David’s death was counterweighted by Kerry winning the NWA World Title, but that was immediately nullified by Kerry’s motorcycle accident and Mike’s injury and brain damage. Even Kerry’s run with the WWF was quickly darkened by his substance use and erratic behavior.
There’s no Hollywood happy ending or major redemption for the Von Erich family beyond Kevin finally finding peace after losing everything, the only silver lining in the film. The movie serves more as a cautionary tale about the dark underbelly of professional wrestling and how it can poison even the most All-American family in the business.
Wrestling diehards demanding a more historically accurate tale would do better to watch Dark Side of the Ring’s take on the Von Erichs. But Claw works exceptionally well for those looking for an entertaining, mostly faithful retelling of the Von Erichs’ story that a non-fan spouse or friend would enjoy.