The One Problem EVERYONE Gets Wrong About WWE's Bloodline Saga
WWE is telling a tremendous - but flawed - story between Sami Zayn and Roman Reigns.
[The following editorial contains criticism of the ongoing, otherwise tremendous Bloodline storyline].
The problem with the ongoing Bloodline saga isn't that Sami Zayn isn't going to dethrone Roman Reigns. It isn't 2015 anymore; WWE fans, demonstrably, enjoy cheering on two distinct babyfaces at the same time.
One, Cody Rhodes, is destined to win the big one; the other, Sami, manipulated into a fake, one-sided bond, is destined to find the acceptance of real friendship that has eluded him since December 11, 2014. Two very different characters, two very different arcs, two very different triumphs. The days of pinning naive hope on one fan-cast workrate underdog are over. WWE's narrative palette has more range now than it has had in decades.
The real problem isn't hugely significant in and of itself, or at least it wasn't. This problem however is so glaring to those with an exacting (or pedantic) eye for logic that the saga cannot be considered the masterpiece that a lot of people insist it to be. The Bloodline angle is tremendous, but it's not a masterpiece. Under its storytelling model, WWE is unable to produce something that warrants such high praise - even if it is excellent on its own, deeply flawed terms. If you truly care about the craft of storytelling, and don't rate it on the WWE curve, the whole thing falls apart if you pull at it only slightly.
The invisible camera device is simply too dumb to ignore.
WWE actually corrected this goatse of a plot hole with the Trial of Sami Zayn, during which both Paul Heyman and Jey Uso pored over archive footage of the televised saga to determine whether or not Sami was an ally of the Bloodline.
A case of better late than never, the Trial was phenomenal - although the events that led to it could have been accelerated already, had the characters actually watched SmackDown as it progressed.
CONT'D...(1 of 5)
WWE television occupies a bizarre hinterland in which the characters are both aware and unaware that they are being watched simultaneously. In the ring, Roman Reigns demands that the fans acknowledge him.
Those same fans watch his clandestine plotting backstage, which is broadcast on international television. The characters have the ability to watch the show - they rally and taunt the people, who watch the show and with whom they share the same world - but they don't. It is easier for the writers if they don't, even if it makes a moron out of the characters; that way, the story is advanced.
On countless occasions, the tensions between Sami and Jey - which have driven the entire plot - could have been eased, had they taken just minutes out of their day to fire up YouTube. From those three minute-long clips, they would have seen that, ah yes, Sami was trying to help. That doesn't make for a twisting storyline, but it does make for dumb characters and a wholly illogical fictional universe that exists selectively at its own narrative convenience.
The thing is: nobody really cares. It's a stupid contrivance to which fans have been normalised over the course of years. WWE has in spite of the invisible camera told a compelling, unpredictable and massively, massively over storyline in which the promotion has united the base, made them feel the intended emotions for the first time in years and years, and spiked the numbers to a level not seen since early 2020. The success of it is so monstrous that WWE has no-sold wider trends in a TV industry that is slowly dying. Emotion trumps logic, particularly in a silly enterprise like wrestling, but that lack of logic is too pronounced to throw around the "masterpiece" label.
AEW does not utilise the invisible camera, a handful of lapses aside. Sometimes, they attempt to work around it so inelegantly that the result is equally as contrived.
Still, you could make the argument that any wrestler from any promotion could, as an example, watch the shows back and detect from the facial expressions of their tag team partner or stablemate that a betrayal is imminent. Perhaps all wrestling, a fictional universe watched live, is fundamentally flawed in that way.
CONT'D...(2 of 5)
Watch the aftermath to Kenny Omega and Hangman Page Vs. the Young Bucks at Revolution 2020; an integral chapter of the Elite saga which, while dormant for now, is the other contender for the best saga of modern times.
The match itself was seminal; pulsating evidence that storytelling doesn't require a microphone, much less an invisible camera, to connect emotionally. Wrestling itself is the story, and when Hangman Page used the One-Winged Angel, where Kenny Omega never used anything from Page's arsenal, the moves - that can actually be used as story beats in wrestling, because they are a vital component of a wrestling match - doubled as subtext. The exhilarating, outrageously athletic and physical 30-minute epic told a seminal story itself, but the post-match is what makes the argument.
In the end, Hangman Page struck Matt Jackson with the Buckshot lariat for the win. The Buckshot was more powerful than the One-Winged Angel, foreshadowing the events of Full Gear 2021, but that wasn't the genius moment. In the post-match, Omega commiserated his friends on their loss. The core Elite trio embraced as friends. The fight they had to have was over, but not for Page. Physically distanced from his partner, outside of the ring, he lingered by the ropes. He then held onto the top rope in the exact same position from which he launches into the Buckshot.
When Omega noticed, Page removed his hands and beckoned him over to celebrate. In that brief, small moment, the thought of betrayal ran through his mind. Crucially, it was as subtle as wrestling acting gets. It was an almost imperceptible moment.
Excalibur did a fantastic job of just approaching questioning what Page was doing before trailing off. Were Omega to have watched the footage back, he would not have noticed - or at least, he'd be forgiven for not noticing. Hangman's motives were ambiguous, and could only be inferred.
Because Hangman Page did not wear a hammy, sinister expression zoomed in on by a lingering camera he had to pretend was not there to make the story happen.
CONT'D...(3 of 5)
Wrestling is a hard game to get right. The Elite, invulnerable to this logic flaw in AEW canon, played it in God mode in collaboration with Tony Khan (and away from the contrived Being The Elite series).
It can be done.
It was done as industry standard before the late 1990s. The WWF itself told a story that could have been watched back by the characters as it unfolded with no resolution: the incredible Mega Powers Explode storyline. That tale - still the best WWE has ever told from beginning to definitive end - was informed not by "ambiguous" motivations clearly detected by the broadcast but by touching, platonic moments shared between Hulk Hogan and Miss Elizabeth that Randy Savage's paranoia interpreted as something more sinister. A character flaw, not a logic flaw, drove the plot forward. In the big heat angle, there was a reason for the camera to be situated backstage. It wasn't just there for no logical reason beyond facilitating the story. Similarly, the Owen Hart Vs. Bret Hart saga was more elegant than the Bloodline saga. The motivations of both characters were completely justified and were not made definitively clear via re-watch.
It should be done elsewhere.
On the last edition of SmackDown, Sami Zayn met up with Jey Uso in a secret backstage meeting, during which Sami acknowledged him.
Since all backstage meetings are filmed, "secret backstage meeting" is already an oxymoron. This was far worse than WWE's usual fare because, with an enormous camera set-up a few feet away from his face, Jey Uso, worried about prying eyes, craned his neck back and forth to make sure that nobody was watching. Paranoid, Jey said "Sami, you better get out of here with that, man," as if to say "Somebody might see us".
2,468,000 people watched the show on Fox - SmackDown is also broadcast in multiple countries - and one of those people was Roman Reigns, to which Paul Heyman alluded.
Even if you can accept the woeful contrivance that is the invisible camera, that was rendered impossible last week.
The already illogical device developed into something even dumber. WWE wrote themselves into a corner. It has now been established that the camera is not invisible (in this storyline, anyway). Jey Uso himself, by creating a video package as evidence of Sami's innocence during the trial, knows now that somebody could in fact see him.
So why did he pretend it wasn't there?
CONT'D...(4 of 5)
For the sake of a story that can't be a masterpiece because it is told in such a forced way.
At least somebody is even more of an idiot than usual here, and that's without picturing the actual camera positioned in front of their faces. Sami's plot, to appeal to Jey's good nature, was stupid. The babyface was an idiot. The idea that we all should just pretend that the camera isn't there is an insult to intelligence.
And again: nobody really cares in those buildings or in front of their TV set. Sami is too sympathetic, too endearing and too talented for this to matter. Every key in-ring segment might warrant the masterpiece label. The sight of Zayn, looking pitiful as Jey ripped the Bloodline t-shirt off him, was as scary as it was heartbreaking. Jey Uso literally leaping to Sami's defence during the Trial was the stuff of pure fist-pumping endorphins. The Royal Rumble angle balanced redemption and heartbreak to near-perfection.
As a wider story?
No.
The plot holes are too gaping (and frankly, the backstage acting is often the standard you'd expect from performers trained to do their acting in a wrestling ring). Masterpieces do not have plot holes; by definition, they are perfect.
A ****1/2 - ****3/4 story is still great, and that's what the Bloodline saga is: a tremendous, emotive, twisting saga undermined by poor plotting.
The idea, echoed everywhere online, that AEW must do something like the Bloodline saga is a load of b*llocks. They have to do something - the storytelling is nowhere near what it was between January 1, 2020 and Revolution 2022 across too much of the show - but the invisible camera need not exist.
Wrestling is more of a masterpiece without it.