The Problem With AEW That Nobody Wants To Talk About

AEW Dynamite has a creeping, nagging problem. And it has nothing to do with factions...

By Michael Sidgwick /

AEW

The discourse swung fairly dramatically from "Young Bucks melodrama descends into parody amid ratings crisis" to "Young Bucks draw second-highest Dynamite rating with all-time great TV match" over the last fortnight.

Advertisement

Matt Jackson, wearing a f*cking chandelier on his head, last week entered a fabulous full heel performance by parodying that for which he was criticised in an overblown, sh*t-eating sequence of a fire-up babyface spot. It's not so much that he listened to the criticism, as AEW tends to do to shape the product. He seemed to scream in the ears of those fans who didn't watch the product closely and patiently enough to recall that, more often than not, everything is OK in the end.

The brain rot fostered by WWE is a significant problem because so often, such a development is received through the lens of the monopoly's suffocating modern history and not a well thought-out wrestling promotion with a pristine record of peaking its various plot threads at the precipice of each and every pay-per-view, no matter how well or otherwise the show itself pays everything off. The market leader's modern sh*t-show of a record is so profound that, despite said record, AEW is so often analysed in the same tones as it, and not, for example, a prestige drama. Functionally, AEW occupies a middle ground. It is produced like WWE, in that it is a weekly endeavour, but exists, not unlike Game of Thrones, within a sprawling, intricate shared universe, the destination at the end of which is sometimes - in the case of Hangman Page's pioneering character arc - years and years away.

Advertisement

CONT'D...(1 of 6)

AEW

This is all magnified by the ceaseless nature of social media discourse. In the heightened online space, a misstep is a disaster, an upward trend a paradigm shift. The problems are only problems for a week. There are more. They aren't the real, worrying issue, however.

Advertisement

On the subject of Game of Thrones, incidentally, can you imagine a super-fan keeping a tally of how many characters appeared in certain episodes in a bid to explain why interest was down? Did anybody, when a scene didn't quite hit in the early seasons or a major character was killed off, think the whole deal was f*cked? No. Because they understood the show to be written well in advance, secure in the knowledge that it drew from existing source material. AEW isn't, obviously, but that aforementioned established record is too often ignored in the hot-take rush.

A lot of people are talking about AEW's bloated roster because AEW, unlike WWE, is actually worth analysing and debating. There's a deep-rooted feeling that wrestling fans are stupid, and unable to "keep track" of the product, but so much of this is white noise that quietens whenever, for example, the company generates a massive pay-per-view buy or an unexpected (relative) monster of a Nielsen rating.

Advertisement

That is not the real problem, and the imminent third hour of proper angle-driven television, all going well, will correct the feeling that certain developments could register with more gravity. The "too many stables" problem isn't worth discussing because the take is unleashed in such ignorance and or bad faith. The narrative framework, of using connections to create a sense of immersion and ultimately preserve the big marquee matches, isn't just a success as measured by the consistent pay-per-view buy numbers.

CONT'D...(2 of 6)

Advertisement
AEW

AEW's approach has illuminated to western fans the formulaic quality of New Japan Pro Wrestling's booking. The promotion has withered in relevance as a result. In NJPW, it's become apparent and predictable that Wrestler X beats Wrestler Y in a big match, Wrestler Y wins bigger match subsequently, and Wrestler X then challenges Wrestler Y with the previous victory hanging over their head. The combinations have become worn and uninspiring in contrast, even if the match quality remains exceptional.

Advertisement

AEW's stable-heavy approach works long-term, and people, funnily enough, have the capacity to remember the preceding two hours of their lives.

There are other, actual problems, none of which are institutional nor irreversible. AEW has long desensitised its fanbase to the visual peril of bloodshed. You'll never feel, at this rate, the same anxious sensation that you did watching Dustin Rhodes leak pints of blood at the inaugural Double Or Nothing. The winning thread of emerging upstart narrowly losing a big match is fraying somewhat, since there's so little space in which to ascend now. Jungle Boy's fans, for example, may have expected him to reach another level at this point. Allocation of TV time isn't ideal in 2021, a tremendous run of Dynamites notwithstanding. Ricky Starks and MJF haven't wrestled anywhere near enough given their drawing power and entertainment value, where others have dominated screens without proving themselves capable of being truly Elite nor undeniable.

Advertisement

And yes, this has much to do with the bloated roster, the management of which has caused the odd lapse in continuity.

CONT'D...(3 of 6)

Advertisement
AEW

With so much to balance, a lack of focus has become apparent. What happened to the animosity between PAC and Lance Archer? If Jon Moxley aligned with Death Triangle to build his Revolution main event with Kenny Omega under the stable-heavy mentality, where were Fénix et al. when Mox was getting beaten down for several minutes before that dud of an explosion?

Advertisement

But the real problem is the explanation AEW has provided in canon for this uneven distribution of TV time. If this recent trend becomes an established storyline driver, the ramifications are not remotely ideal.

Recently, Lance Archer, Scorpio Sky and Ethan Page - who only joined the company in March - have expressed frustrations with AEW in storyline. Lance Archer complained that he will be presented as a main event-level talent one week before being vanished the next. Scorpio Sky opined that he has been overlooked for the last year of his career, and is joined in this crusade by his new tag team partner, who feels that he wasn't awarded with sufficient pomp and ceremony after an unsuccessful debut. The recently-formed Factory have emerged with a similar mentality, though the "blame" in storyline has been deflected onto Cody at least. That he's a management figure in real life doesn't help, however.

Advertisement

There are two implications to consider. Neither are great. In a predetermined business that holds the power to get everybody and everything over to some extent - and if that scans as hyperbole, remember the top-to-bottom white-hot brilliance that was the month of February 2020, a euphoric celebration of the best of the industry - something or somebody always sucks in this scenario.

CONT'D...(4 of 6)

Advertisement
AEW

Either the talent sucks, for their inability to get booked regularly, or the promotion sucks for their inability to recognise the talent. Somebody is telling on themselves. It's thin, damning pretext with which to turn heel, but it's invariably a failure of a move. Pissing and moaning is not effective heat. Beating the sh*t out of babyfaces as a credible threat is effective heat. Nobody ever gets over by complaining about how they are used. This counterproductive, WWE-specific development is dog sh*t. WWE has descended into a strange meta landscape - a sort of onscreen anti-promotion that acts as the barrier to stardom when it is meant to function as the precise opposite. AEW can't ever be this. More than anything - the tiresome debates of "sport" and the like - what puts AEW over as the alternative is that it's the good promotion that rewards worthy talent.

Advertisement

In the case of Lance Archer, a tremendous talent, it should not go without mention, AEW has stumbled onto the problem of booking a monster in one weekly episodic territory. They don't want him to win all the time, but his aura suffers more than most when he doesn't. He's become a directionless and agitated tweener as a result. Perhaps this is another case of writing AEW off too early. This mysterious storyline with Sting might result in Archer dethroning Darby Allin and mounting a monster of a run with the TNT Championship. Or perhaps this very week, he'll target Ethan Page and Scorpio Sky - as teased on last week's Dynamite - for pissing and moaning about their spot. But it's a bad, indirect indictment of the company that Archer is saying the things that he is saying, because the subtext - subtext that some wrestling fans are in fact smart enough to pick up - is that AEW doesn't know how to book the monster.

CONT'D...(5 of 6)

Advertisement
AEW

It is imperative that AEW does not present itself as anything less than a background meritocracy that quietly develops a sense of prestige and trust.

Advertisement

A great wrestling promotion is only great because it promotes the biggest stars and the hottest action. It shouldn't act as a vehicle to tell stories, but simply a stage on which to tell them. This tactic has worked once, but only for a while. The nWo preyed on the lowly WCW, and the fans, for a while, were willing to rally behind "their" guys. Look at what remained of WCW when it all went to sh*t.

The idea that the company is in any way bad at this is toxic. It's far better for AEW to simply not use the talents that aren't connecting. It's a problem because, insidiously, it gnaws at the idea that AEW is the true wrestling promotion making the great comeback against sports entertainment. In his career-best promo, Cody Rhodes said that AEW was the "Ellis Island" of professional wrestling. The reverence that AEW developed almost instantly can't be sullied. A monster can be reheated.

Advertisement

But that feeling can never be replicated.