The Problem With Daniel Bryan That No One Wants To Talk About

Like CM Punk, AEW signing Daniel Bryan is a no-brainer, BUT...

By Andy H Murray /

AEW/WWE

How many times in history has a startup wrestling promotion had the opportunity to sign one of the greatest performers of all time before age has taken too heavy a toll on their capabilities?

Advertisement

Some may argue that All Elite Wrestling accomplished this twice before its first show. Chris Jericho is a contentious G.O.A.T. candidate hurt by middling runs and downswings between his peak periods. Kenny Omega, meanwhile, is an even more contentious pick for the frothing vitriol he inspires within members of a certain Kentuckian cult, though both have enhanced their cases since becoming All Elite. Jericho, still the biggest name AEW has signed to date, finally has a run as a legitimate franchise player in American wrestling to his name, while Omega has proven he can draw in the United States and Japan, emerged as a star on weekly television star, and padded his in-ing résumé with two years of state of the art insta-hits.

Less contentious is Daniel Bryan, who now appears to be on his way to AEW where once it looked like he would re-sign with WWE following a quiet summer vacation.

Advertisement

If the G.O.A.T. argument could be settled (it can't), Bryan's broad resume, longevity, adaptability, stunning peaks, relative lack of lows, and ability to create magic from even the smallest of opportunities makes him the strongest candidate still working today. At least between the ropes, Daniel Bryan is flawless.

But would he be a flawless signing for AEW?

Advertisement

CONT'd...

WWE

If All Elite Wrestling pulls off the coup of all coups by inking CM Punk and Daniel Bryan within a few weeks (or days) of each other, the wrestling world will, for at least a brief period, be turned on its head.

Advertisement

The mere notion that two of the century's most iconic and impactful wrestlers were on their way to Jacksonville ensured America's second-biggest promotion dominated the news cycle in a week that saw WWE bring John Cena and Goldberg back into the fold. If Bryan and Punk sign, Vince McMahon may as well take a week off, hit the Bahamas, and leave booking Raw and SmackDown to an algorithm. Even Brock Lesnar showing up or a Becky Lynch comeback would be drowned out from the noise emanating from northeastern Florida.

Punk would admittedly contribute more to this than Bryan. This isn't a comment on their respective skills, but their differing circumstances. One was on television three months ago while the other hasn't been around since January 2014. Punk has been gone so long that many fans, this writer included, had forgotten how much they missed him.

Advertisement

But Bryan is Bryan. A multi-time WWE Champion he may be, but he represents something similar to Punk in that he is rightly perceived as somebody Vince McMahon rarely (if ever) put everything behind, even with the belt. While Bryan was doing great work in wrestling's most restrictive system up to his final day within it, he was never The Guy. He was never going to be The Guy.

An S-tier talent to many but a B+ player in the only mind that matters in Stamford.

Advertisement

Thinking of what he could accomplish with a promotion's full support, unhindered by McMahonism, is tantalising, particularly as so many of Bryan's best matches happened before he joined WWE anyway.

So yes. There will be a pop, there will be a boost, and there will be a buzz.

Advertisement

But beyond that initial flurry is where Bryan's run really erupts.

CONT'd...

Advertisement
WWE.com

There's nothing Daniel Bryan can't do between the ropes and nothing a good booker can't do with him.

Advertisement

A natural babyface he may be (and really, it'd be impossible for AEW to push him as anything but a hero for at least his first half-year), but the 40-year-old's Planet's Champion run proved he is still elite on the other side of the alignment scale. Give him 5 minutes and he'll cram in more detail than most can muster in 25; give him 25 and he'll deliver you an epic. You can use him as a card-topping headliner or on the undercard, elevating less experienced talents to the next level. He can work whatever pae you require, be it brisk, methodical or anything in between, and can brawl, trade holds, fly when required, assert dominance, play the underdog, and complement any opponent's style.

Really - and this is the highest possible compliment in this regard - Bryan is comparable to Terry Funk in his versatility.

Advertisement

AEW will rightly debut Bryan as a big deal, because he is a big deal. Beyond the first year or so, they can slot him in wherever they want. He has ascended to the status of the most talented utility player in wrestling history and fans can expect Tony Khan to exploit the full range of his capabilities and, crucially, his star power.

Bryan may not pop initial numbers like CM Punk will but the guy headlined WrestleMania three months ago. Vince McMahon called on him to save a dying Edge vs. Roman Reigns program and save it he did, immediately making the Universal Title program more interesting. In AEW, he won't be the backup option, but a go-to guy, and his appeal to this more wrestling-centric fanbase is clear and obvious. He'll draw.

Advertisement

Intermittently.

CONT'd...

Advertisement
WWE.com

Daniel Bryan wants to work with New Japan Pro Wrestling and New Japan Pro Wrestling almost certainly want to work with Daniel Bryan.

Advertisement

Dave Meltzer wrote the following in the 26 July 2021 edition of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter:-

"But that was always the key, the ability at this stage to work New Japan and other dates, similar to what Moxley has where he can work selected independent dates of his choosing although the dates do have to be approved by AEW. My belief is that if it was not for the pandemic, Danielson would have already been wrestling in New Japan by now unless a deal was made with WWE or AEW where he promised them the first appearance and match back since the AEW or WWE money offers would be so much higher and thus it was a virtual lock he was ending up in one place or the other."

If he has signed with AEW, the company's existing working relationship with NJPW was critical. Wrestlers travel through the Forbidden Door almost every week and when the COVID-19 pandemic eases off and international travel becomes less of a hindrance, it's reasonable to assume that things will get even busier.

Advertisement

Bryan, Meltzer wrote, will likely enjoy a similar level of freedom as Jon Moxley. We don't currently know what that means, though, as 17 months of COVID restrictions have prevented Mox from leaving the country. What his combined AEW/NJPW schedule will end up looking like is a mystery.

This is speculative, but the NJPW deal being critical to where Bryan signed after leaving WWE gives the impression that he would have gone back to the market leaders had Nick Khan not failed in his negotiations to strike a working relationship. And if New Japan is where Bryan's heart really lies, what does this mean for AEW?

Advertisement

CONT'd...

WWE.com

The problem with Daniel Bryan that no one wants to talk about is two-fold.

Advertisement

1. If Daniel's priority is NJPW, not AEW, then Tony Khan's company may not necessarily get the best of him. This would depend on the terms of his contract (and which side gets the first refusal on bookings), but particularly during G1 season, Bryan is going to hop across the Pacific and go missing from Dynamite and Rampage for weeks on end. We've seen recently how detrimental PAC's constant movement between the United States and his UK home has been for his booking patterns. While Bryan admittedly outstrips the Brit as an attraction, their situations are similar.

2. NJPW isn't NJPW anymore. Shingo Takagi, Will Ospreay, and others will feature on many a Match of the Year list in 2021, as they should, but the decline in Gedo's booking over the past couple of years is well-documented. The pandemic has amplified issues like the abundance of tired western tropes, which existed long before COVID took hold. EVIL's ascension was as unforgivable as this year's cannibalisation of the IWGP Heavyweight Title's legacy. The golden era is long dead.

Advertisement

It sounds like a dream scenario, Bryan buzzing back and forth between AEW and NJPW, but it isn't as utopian as it first seems. While this deal would almost certainly yield more high-level matches than renewing with WWE, Bryan taking time off from AEW to work for a promotion three years removed from its vintage.

CONT'd...

Advertisement
WWE Network

Scheduling conflicts are a spanner in the cogs of AEW's long-term booking machine. In this case, they may end up preventing all the wonderful six-month yarns fans have spent the past few weeks building in their heads from ever coming to life.

Advertisement

The sad reality of it all is that Bryan may end up being booked in AEW like he was in WWE: a potential top guy, but only in a pinch.

Or perhaps it'll end up being the best thing that ever happened to Tony Khan's company.

Advertisement

That second scenario is likelier than the first because we're talking about Bryan bloody Danielson. Even if he does end up taking more satisfaction from working for NJPW than AEW, it isn't in his nature to dog it. He's a pro wrestling craftsman brimming with creativity, who happens to be exciting the most stifling promotion there has ever been. Bryan's head must be swimming with ideas he never pitched to Vince McMahon, knowing they'd get shot down. Watching them manifesting should be a delight. There's no way he won't want to work with Kenny Omega, PAC, Jon Moxley, and dozens more and given how giving he is, he'll relish taking on a Ricky Starks as much as fighting for the World Title.

This should be incredible. Here's hoping the concerns outlined earlier aren't a factor.

Advertisement