The Undertaker: 5 Awesome Matches & 5 That Sucked

From a Giant at WrestleMania to a Beast at SummerSlam....

By Kenny McIntosh /

For 25 years, he's been the one constant in WWE. While other wrestlers defected to WCW or retired, Mark Callaway has stuck around for a quarter of a century as The Undertaker. When the gimmick started out at the Survivor Series in 1990, it was thought it'd be a short term gig with a limited shelf life but it's a testament to the talent of Mark Calaway that he's been able to stick around for so long and remain an iconic character in the eyes of the fans. In the 20 plus years he's been in action, Undertaker has gone from the spectrum of having some classic matches that saved WrestleMania shows to having stinkers that were so awful he lived up to his gimmick by killing crowds. Vince McMahon's appetite for having Taker face giants, freaks and supernatural folk is seemingly insatiable and thus for every classic against Shawn Michaels, there's a head-scratching slug-fest with The Great Khali. Let's delve into the 5 best and 5 worst performances of Taker's career...

5 Awesome Performances....

Advertisement

5. Ladder Match: The Undertaker vs. Jeff Hardy (RAW, July 2002)

When The Undertaker turned heel in November 2001 during his American Bad Ass phase, he ended up revitalising what had become a stale character and the quality of his matches elevated to perhaps the most consistent period of his career. In 2002, Taker had a great WrestleMania match with Ric Flair and a thrilling triple threat match at Vengeance with Kurt Angle and The Rock but the match that sticks out from that era as Taker's most thrilling performance was his WWE Title defense to Jeff Hardy in a Latter match. Yes, a ladder match with The Undertaker. And boy did he live up to the gimmick. In this bout, Taker went out of his comfort zone and not only kept up with the young Hardy, but also put him over as a top superstar. The story of the veteran champion defending against the young rookie was a captivating one. There were numerous spots throughout the match where they had the audience believing that Jeff had a legitimate shot at becoming WWE Champion. In the end, Undertaker retained but he had made The Charismatic Enigma look like a million bucks in the process. It would take a while before Jeff Hardy would be seen by WWE management at main event level but in 2002, The Undertaker was ahead of the curve and visions of his 90s battles with Shawn Michaels could be seen in this contest.

4. The Undertaker vs. Kurt Angle (No Way Out 2006)

Kurt Angle has talked in various interviews about how close he came to facing off against the Undertaker at WrestleMania in 2006. For whatever reason, the match instead took place at No Way Out, the month before the Grandaddy of Them All. Undertaker had returned as The Deadman in 2004 and in his first year back wasn't having thrilling matches. He was competing against Kane, JBL and others in mediocre bouts. In 2005, he'd go on to have a great program with Randy Orton that proved the veteran could still go, so in February 2006 when he challenged Kurt Angle for the World Heavyweight Championship there was an anticipation for a classic. This was around the time when Taker started adopting a more submission based offence rather than just sitting up from the dead and doing a chokeslam and a tombstone. His bout with the Olympic Gold Medalist was outstanding and to this day is fondly remembered as one of the best PPV main events of the Ruthless Aggression era. In a tremendous closing sequence, Angle had the ankle lock applied until Taker countered into a triangle choke which seemed to be on course to win him the World title until Kurt reversed it into a surprise roll up to retain. If you have a spare twenty minutes, I cannot recommend enough that you go to the WWE Network and watch this brilliant match.

3. The Undertaker vs. Edge For World Heavyweight Championship (WrestleMania XXIV, 2008)

Edge got his first taste of being a main eventer in 2006 but by 2008, he had settled firmly as a top guy. In 2008, he was the World Heavyweight Champion and on the grandest stage of them all, he was set to defend against the man who he'd cashed in his Money In The Bank briefcase on just months before, The Undertaker. In front of over 70,000 fans, Edge and Undertaker had the dubious task of following Ric Flair's retirement match and Big Show's celebrity encounter with Floyd Mayweather. The two superstars took the challenge and knocked it out of the park. In a superb main event, Edge would come dangerously close to retaining his title and ending Undertaker's WrestleMania streak until in the end, a Hells Gate would seal his fate and Undertaker would again become World Heavyweight Champion. With Taker in his early 40's, he was like a fine wine, only getting better with age.

2. The Undertaker vs. Shawn Michaels (WrestleMania 25th Anniversary, 2009)

In my article about attending WrestleMania 25, I talked about not expecting the Undertaker and Shawn Michaels match to blow me away in any way. I knew the two superstars would have a good match, but I had no idea they'd provide me with the best wrestling match I'd ever seen in my life. The story was simple, Shawn Michaels claimed he was the best and wanted to end the undefeated streak of The Deadman. With both men born and raised in Texas, it was only fitting that the Reliant Stadium in Houston be their playground for this battle. This match was the beginning of the near falls and false finish type bouts that we've become accustomed to in WWE, and I would argue this is the best use of the concept. In one of the best moments in WWE history, Undertaker nails HBK with a Tombstone and when Michaels kicks out, the camera zooms in to The Dead Man's face to capture his look of utter shock at how Michaels managed to survive. For over 30 minutes, the two legends put on a clinic of storytelling where the fans though it could go either way. Each superkick or tombstone would provide a moment for the audience to be perched on the edge of their seat wondering if the streak would remain in tact or come to an end. It's the best WWE match I've ever seen and it still holds up 7 years later.

1. The Undertaker vs. Brock Lesnar (SummerSlam 2015)

After the streak ended at WrestleMania XXX, we didn't see much of The Undertaker anymore. He returned at WrestleMania 31 for an encounter with Bray Wyatt, but the match left a lot to be desired. Fans began to question if maybe Undertaker just didn't have it in him anymore to deliver a classic match. After all, he was approaching 50 years old, so it'd be understandable if he couldn't pull a great performance out of the bag anymore. Then at the Battleground PPV, Taker returned to cost Brock Lesnar a WWE title shot and the rematch was on for SummerSlam 2015. After an incredibly heated brawl on RAW with the great verbiage of Brock screaming at Taker "I'm gonna kill you" and in a rare moment of emotion, The Phenom responding "You're gonna have to" the expectation of something great began to grow. Could the half a century old Calaway and the part time Beast really main event a SummerSlam and follow a thrilling Cena/Rollins match? The answer is yes, yes they could. In a bout that was ALL about the story, it was special from the very beginning. Lesnar would attack Undertaker before he could even get his jacket off, and they would pull out all the stops to make it a memorable match. From them both sitting up and laughing in each others faces and trading punches, to an F5 on the announce table, this match was gripping from start to finish. In the end there was a screwy finish, but even that added to the drama that Undertaker tapped out and when the referee hadn't seen it, he took the cheating route, low blowed the Beast and made him pass out.

And 5 That Sucked....

5. The Undertaker vs. Giant Gonzalez (WrestleMania IX, 1993)

I was 8 years old when WrestleMania IX came on my TV on SKY Sports and even I remember how rubbish the Undertaker and Giant Gonzalez match was. Gonzalez was an Argentinian basketball player, who moved to the States to compete in the NBA but after injuries, ended up becoming a pro wrestler. After a sting in WCW, he came to the WWF in a furry body suit with drawn on muscles as Giant Gonzalez, managed by Harvey Wippleman. Poor Undertaker had to have his WrestleMania match with a 7 foot man who could barely move or execute a wrestling move. Apart from a bodyslam, a chop and a kick, Gonzalez couldn't do anything. On top of that, he was too big for Undertaker to perform and moves on. Taker couldn't pick him up, so he was left punching and kicking him for the whole match. To top off how hideous it was, the Giant would knock Undertaker out with chloroform causing a disqualification. As far as Undertaker matches go, this is one of the worst.

4. The Brothers Of Destruction vs. Kronik (Unforgiven 2001)

With Stevie Richards peculiarly by their side, Bryan Clark and Brian Adams came in late to the WWF vs Alliance feud as Kronik, to take on the Brothers of Destruction at Unforgiven 2001. Adams and Clark were so bad and sloppy, they could barely execute a move properly in the match, to the point you can see Taker and Kane getting pissed off because they know how horrible it was coming across to the crowd. In the end, The American Bad Ass and his Demon brother retained their WCW Tag Team Championships but it would spell the end of Kronik in the WWF. Apparently Taker and Kane were so unhappy with the amount of mistakes that Kronik made during the match that WWF officials opted to let Clark and Adams go after just two matches with the company.

3. The Undertaker vs. The Great Khali (Judgment Day 2006)

Vince McMahon loves gigantic wrestlers but sadly for The Undertaker, he always seemed to get stuck with having to do a program with them and try to make it work. By 2006, Taker was having great matches with talents like Kurt Angle and Randy Orton, until on an episode of SmackDown, The Great Khali debuted by attacking The Deadman. This led to their showdown at the Judgment Day pay per-view where Khali dominated most of the match because, like Gonzalez, he couldn't do much. Undertaker did manage to go old school on the Giant during the match, at least. In the end, in one of the worst finishing sequences to an Undertaker match I've ever seen, he tries to go for a chokeslam on Khali and once it fails, Khali hits The Phenom with a big boot and Taker is pinned 1-2-3. It's even worse than I'm making it sound. But hey, you gotta put over those Giants, right?

2. The Undertaker vs. Kane (Hell In A Cell 2010)

In one of the worst storylines of the year, Kane was responsible for putting his brother into a "vegetative state" which then brought Undertaker back at SummerSlam to get his revenge. What followed was a serious of matches that left a lot to be desired. It was cool to have Paul Bearer involved again, but it just felt like a poorer man's rehash of their previous programs. Kane was cutting some great promos on SmackDown as the World Heavyweight Champion but sadly the in-ring matches with his brother just weren't measuring up. The culmination of the feud was in a Hell in a Cell match at the pay per-view in October 2010. To sum it up, Dave Meltzer in that week's Wrestling Observer wrote: "Undertaker vs. Kane was one of the worst WWE PPV main events in years. It was really sad watching how limited Undertaker was, as age really caught up with him after his last absence." The pace of the match was slow, the execution of the moves were sloppy and it felt like the stars were just going through the motions, they weren't invested in what they were doing. In the end, Paul Bearer turned on Undertaker and joined Kane and Kane retained his Championship. If anyone ever suggests "Lets watch Hell in a Cell 2010" unfriend them immediately, it's not worth it.

1. The Undertaker vs. Brock Lesnar (WrestleMania XXX, 2014)

It's rare that an opponent will make it onto one of these lists on the good side and the bad side. While this match sucked, it largely suffered because Undertaker got a concussion several minutes into the match. Fans were excited for Brock Lesnar going up against The Undertaker with the Streak on the line. Once the match started, the fans didn't seem as interested as they had been in previous years during the Streak bout. After Taker's concussion, the match was kinda just there. Lesnar would hit an F5, Undertaker would hit a tombstone, but there was no connection to the moves or chemistry with the two wrestlers. In the end when Lesnar hit the third F5, it was all over for the Deadman. The streak was over. Even though the match was terrible, because it's where the Streak ended, as time goes on, all people will remember is the moment. The match becomes irrelevant because of the outcome. Even though it didn't live up to the hype, Undertaker deserves a hell of a lot of credit for putting on a match like that with a concussion. Luckily, we'd get the rematch at SummerSlam 18 months later to give us a classic match between the two.