The WrestleMania 33 Awards!
Who were the biggest winners and losers at the 'Show of Shows'?
WrestleMania. You wait all year for it, and then just seven short hours later its all over for another twelve months. It's like Christmas, if you ignore the details beyond Chris Jericho's festive scarf.
Still, the event may have been and gone, but the fallout will last for the next month or so, as every wrestling writer on the planet scrambles to deconstruct the show's best moments, where it went wrong, and what it all means for the future. It's never about living in the present.
But for every serious assessment of WWE's supershow, there's a two-bit hack like myself who favours frivolity over, er, 'fought'-fulness. Hey, wrestling's supposed to be entertaining! Let's not get all bogged down in whether Roman Reigns should have won (he should have) - it honestly doesn't matter.
What we should get bogged down in is handing out imaginary awards, some earnest, some less so, to the performers on wrestling's greatest jamboree. What was the best match? Who had the best outfit? Was Triple-H's Tom of Finland inspired entrance the best of all time? (Look him up.)
So roll out a mile-long red-carpet for... the WrestleMania 33 awards!
15. Best Entrance: Naomi
Every self-respecting wrestling fan (an oxymoron?) knows that the most important part of WrestleMania isn't what goes on between the ropes, but the aisle-way action. And with a ramp-way the length of Italy, WrestleMania 33 had few excuses not to deliver on its entrances.
Ultimately, the avenue of lights' mammoth size had the opposite effect; most entrances were broken up with a vignette, and those that weren't took bloody ages. The less drawn-out ones featured superstars on vehicles, though it is hard to decide if a leather clad Triple H riding to ringside on a trike surrounded by police officers was totally cool or totally camp. Bit of both.
However, there was one entrance which shone. Or rather, glowed. There are many who think blacklights are kitschy relics of the '70s, and whilst they aren't strictly wrong, Naomi's ingress was nevertheless clearly amazing. As an added bonus - as if the Floridan sun wasn't enough - all that UV flying about was bound to top up your tan. Science.
Runner-up: Bray Wyatt
A spectacular light-show the envy of Lyon's Lumiere - but really more the function of an eager crowd than any production magic on WWE's part.
14. Best Outfit: Goldust
In the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal, buried amid a sea of jobbers, tag teams, and Braun Strowman, was our old pal Goldust, doing his utmost to uphold 1995-chic. The face-paint wasn't perfect, and the black boots were right out, but man, that New Generation jump-suit was golden (quite literally).
The correct and proper sartorial attitude for WrestleMania is to wear your normal outfit, but in white. Shawn Michaels did it. Randy Savage did it. Er, Beth Phoenix did it. But if you're a veteran who very well may be retiring immediately after the show, the only option is an exact replica of your original attire, no matter how ludicrous.
Goldust knows the score. Pity he didn't tell The Undertaker.
Runner-up: Chris Jericho
Sure, he looked like a walking Christmas tree, but who doesn't love Christmas?
13. Worst Outfit: Seth Rollins
Whereas Goldust's golden garb grabs the gong for best outfit, Seth Rollins' similarly aureate attire paradoxically claims the counterpart accolade, despite the two costumes being fundamentally identical. Doesn't seem fair does it?
And it isn't fair, but I'm sure Seth will be content with the somewhat more prestigious award he's going to win later in the article (but don't tell him).
Unfortunately, his aesthetic was a bit all over the place. Given the fire and the scales, I think he was supposed to be some sort of dragon, but it came across more like a crap fish. Wearing a shield, for no apparent reason. All in all, a bit of a shambles.
Runner-up: Mickie James
I appreciate James' Native American background, and can only presume she was trying to pay homage to her heritage, but this was less Tatanka and more Gobbledy Gooker.
12. The 'Life's Too Short' Award For Most Flagrant Waste Of Time: Pitbull's Impromptu Concert
If somehow I was able to unlock the secret of everlasting life, and blessed with the rest of eternity to sample the entire gamut of human experience, I still think I'd give this Pitbull concert a miss.
I could read everything, see everything, and do everything - and yet the boredom produced by having extinguished life's seemingly illimitable possibilities wouldn't be enough to make me want to watch this utter dross. Frankly, infinity isn't time enough to waste on it.
Which bright spark thought the middle of a four-day show needed an interlude of a two-hour concert? It was utterly interminable: three 'artists' I'd literally never heard of, dancers dressed like chess boards, and a song about traffic. Still, Pitbull is at the height of his cultural releva... oh.
Runner-up: The entire pre-show.
I can't knock it as a means to keep the insufferable Dean Ambrose off the main show, but the whole thing was entirely unnecessary, and a bit of a slap in the face to the performers relegated to it.
11. The Boogeyman Award For Creepiest Tactic: Bray Wyatt's Menagerie
Bit of a one-man contest this, but it was worth mentioning, as I can't recall the last time a wrestling show forced a member of my family to hide behind the sofa. Three times, no less.
In truth, it's actually ludicrous - it's more the production truck being weird than Bray Wyatt - but hey, this is theatre, and it's always entertaining when your sister-in-law squirms like the worms she can't bare to look at. Papa Shango eat your heart out.
Runner-up: Triple-H
There was one other eerie moment on the show, and that was Triple-H's eye being magnetised to a sledgehammer like some sort of muscular magpie. The irresistible allure of the tool to our Trips was sinister, to say the least. Don't take the guy to B&Q.
10. The Amelia Earhart Award For Unexplained Absence: Samoa Joe
As one of the primary components in Seth Rollins' barney with Triple H - and the man who crocked the 'Architect' - Samoa Joe seemed a certainty for WrestleMania involvement just a few months back. Yet he was conspicuously absent from everything over the weekend.
I guess it makes sense. WWE clearly wanted to focusing on settling Rollins and Triple-H's tiff mano-a-mano without muddying the waters with too much external involvement, but it seems a bit strange to have Joe in the build-up and then forget about him completely. It's fairly certain the Samoan destroyer will be entering a feud with Rollins in the immediate aftermath of WrestleMania so its not a terrible snub, but maybe a little hint wouldn't have gone amiss to keep the idea ticking over in fans' minds?
Runner-up: Shinsuke Nakamura
Yes, yes, he headlined the TakeOver show, but there's little question the 'King of Strong Style' should have been kneeing the main roster in the face long before now. Here's hoping his big WrestleMania opportunity hasn't passed him by.
9. Mick Foley Award For Needless Risk Taking: Jeff Hardy
Most aging superstars making a long-awaited return have to do little more than go through their best-loved spots and pose a bit to draw rapturous approval from an excited crowd. Jeff Hardy is no different. Unfortunately for him, his most best-loved spots are suicidal.
It's hard to decide where the greatest point of tension lied. Was it the worry that Jeff might not complete his rotation in time? Was it the eminent possibility of the over-sized, imbalanced ladder toppling over before he performed the move? Or maybe it was just the concept of a near forty-year old performing a somersault through metal.
Whatever it was, many kittens were had. It was totally unnecessary, totally reckless, but also, totally great.
Runner-up: The Undertaker
There were quite a few old chaps taking rather hefty bumps on this show, each of them inducing some worried winces in this author, but the sight of a 52-year old in dire need of hip replacement surgery being smashed through a table was the most cringey. Still, if you're going to get a new one, suppose it doesn't really matter too much.
8. Most Underwhelming Finish: Bayley Beats Charlotte
The Raw women's fatal-four way was moving along entertainingly enough in a manner typical of its contestants, methodically plotted and featuring many an eye-catching, high-risk spot, and then, after only a dozen minutes, it just sort of... ended. One Savage elbow drop, and it was all over, with little in the way of a dramatic climax.
Perhaps the tension would have been present had the build to the match not been such a farce. Instead, we had a champion retaining to little fanfare, and a PPV record which had already been shattered suffering another blow. Not a terrible match, but not the showpiece spectacle for the women's division it could have been.
Runner-up: Randy Orton vs. Bray Wyatt
Given the show was about 19 hours in by the time the WWE title was defended, a short match wasn't exactly unwelcome. But as ever, Bray's WrestleMania weekend ended with a whimper - a single RKO and that was enough to end his too-short title reign. Tosh.
7. Biggest Overperformer: Nia Jax
It may sound a little harsh, but I don't think it's especially unfair to say our Nia is the least technically able of the quartet who competed for the Raw women's title at WrestleMania. Yet bizarrely, the match actually suffered for her elimination.
It's a very obvious tactic to play to somebody's strengths, and thankfully that's exactly what WWE have been doing with the Samoan powerhouse. Jax is clearly of a different breed to her waify contemporaries, and the way she was booked as a brutish threat enhanced the match massively. It may have been something of an overstatement on commentary to suggest she is the most dominant WWE superstar of all time, but her performance at WrestleMania certainly transformed her into a legitimate monster.
Runner-up: Shane McMahon
Shane O'Mac's performance opposite AJ Styles had no right to be anything beyond utter gash, yet the fact this match came off relatively smoothly - albeit a bit tediously - is a credit to the middle-aged non-wrestler. Let's make this the last though, eh?
6. The Droz Award For Modern Emetics: John Cena's Proposal
I don't know if it was really necessary to bury a super-over Miz in order to set this angle up. Judging by the reactions, few in attendance gave two hoots save Nikki Bella herself; it was utterly self-indulgent and sappier than a tree.
It's hard not to feel a bit sorry for John; it doesn't seem like he had much choice in this proposal. Did he really wait all this time just so he could pop the question in front of 73,000 people following a low-key mixed-tag match? Is this the sort of situation that presages a long and happy marriage?
Either way, it was nauseatingly saccharine, and totally unnecessary. A 'WrestleMania' moment forced down our throats like a couple of fingers. Having said that, all the best to the happy couple.
Runner-up: None
5. Most Entertaining Spot: Stephanie Through A Table
Oh come on, who didn't love this? Stephanie - undoubtedly the company's number one heel (except when she's suddenly a babyface) - gets a lot of criticism for her egomania undermining the rest of the roster throughout the year, but to give her credit, come WrestleMania she usually gets her comeuppance.
This year's variation on Roman's spear was thankfully a little less violent (it makes one dreadfully uncomfortable being expected to cheer a man laying out a woman), but no less satisfying. Chekhov's tables dictated that as soon as the unstable bit of furniture was set up at ringside somebody was going to crash through it, but most would have suspected something a little more mundane. Instead, we got an inventive finish, and the perfect conclusion to Steph's arc which should see her written off TV for at least a few months.
Yeh, right.
Runner-up: Jeff Hardy's ladder jump.
See award number 9. A bit too buttock-clenchy to take top spot, but spectacular nonetheless.
4. Most Shocking Moment: The Hardy Boyz Return
This was great for two reasons. 1) whilst the Hardyz' did seem imminent, an immediate return to action on WrestleMania itself seemed pure fantasy. 2) it prevented the tag team ladder match from being, well, a bit sh*t.
In fact, it was one of the most thrilling bouts on the card, the excitement of the Hardyz' unexpected return energising the crowd to a level rarely reached throughout the rest of the night. The difference actual heat makes to a match is alarming, and when a decidedly non-Broken Matt unhooked the titles from their little coat-hanger thing, the whole place went not just bananas, but pineapples too. It was as strikingly shocking as that streak of white hair on his head.
Runner-up: Mojo Rawley wins the Andre Memorial Trophy.
WrestleMania 33 was otherwise thin on the ground for surprises. Mojo claiming victory in the battle royal wasn't exactly seismic in its shock, but it was obviously loopy, so takes the silver medal here.
3. Match Of The Night: Triple H Vs. Seth Rollins
It feels like something of a betrayal writing this. In advance of the show, I predicted Seth and Trip's showdown would be a protracted snooze-fest in a very similar mould to The Game's previous WrestleMania efforts, and even suggested Mr. Helmsley might claim the victory on account of the injured knee angle.
When did us wrestling analysts become so cynical?
As it transpired, I was half-right; the match was long (indeed, the longest on the show). But it was far from boring. OK, admittedly, the opening ten minutes or so seemed a bit laboured, but in the context of the match's story, it made perfect sense, as Triple H methodically worked over Rollin's knee in anticipation of his eventual gutsy comeback.
And the closing stormed barns, as they say. What wasn't to like? A scintillating series of Pedigree reversals, teased sledgehammer blows narrowly avoided, and Stephanie McMahon going through a table. The match did everything to create the sort of tension lacking elsewhere on the night, and in the end - only just - the right man won. Sterling work.
Runner-up: Brock Lesnar vs. Bill Goldberg
Everything it needed to be: decisive, dramatic, and crucially, short.
2. WrestleMania 'Moment' Of The Night: The Undertaker's Retirement
The match which preceded it may have been a heatless mess, largely due to an exhausted arena impatiently waiting for the inevitable, but the drama which followed was true pathos.
Obviously we all knew this coming into WrestleMania, and there was no way The Undertaker was going to call it a day with a victory, so let's just forget the result and appreciate its role in setting up this most deserved of send-offs.
After about seven hours of action, watching a man slowly undress in the ring was a tad laborious - especially when it seemed he might not stop at the hat - but ignoring the tiredness, the raw emotion on display was palpable. WWE desperately try to manufacture 'WrestleMania moments' each year since they decided those are a 'thing', but none of them can compare to something as genuine as this. Not just a WrestleMania moment, but a soon-to-be defining image in the history of the industry.
Runner-up: The Hardy Boyz win tag gold.
Not much explanation needed here really. Legendary tag-team returns unexpectedly, win titles, everybody happy.
1. WrestleMania MVP: Jim Ross
Taking into account the terrible, senseless tragedy which has recently beset his life, that Good 'Ol JR was even present at all for WrestleMania showed remarkable courage in the face of unspeakably awful personal anguish.
The show's commentary had been flat throughout, and though Ross was a little muted himself - understandable given the circumstances - his voice immediately lifted the occasion, lending the closer a sense of gravitas Michael Cole has simply never managed to muster.
Quite frankly, Cole should have stepped aside for the legendary broadcaster, though again asking Ross to anchor the show's ending might have been a little too much. However, having the pair commentate in tandem highlighted the immense gulf in quality between the two. As JR offered insightful analysis to Roman's methodical actions, his timbre authoritative and genuine, Cole swiveled in his chair reading his notes, a gormless smirk plastered across his face. Like cheese and sh*te.