THIS Is The One Man Who Can Save WWE
Who should REALLY take over WWE creative.
Vince McMahon is no longer fit for the purpose of running WWE's creative arm.
This is so patently obvious that it shouldn't require an explanation, but that wouldn't make for an article, so consider the following. At Super Showdown, Vince clipped the wings of a performer who was generating real buzz and optimism when operating on a creative tear. The in-ring reeked, and perhaps it was always going to reek, but the supernatural horror of the Fiend was pushed heavily as WWE's top heel before falling to a sh*tty suplex delivered by a 53 year-old gassed-up part-timer. On principle, this was pathetically short-term in its thinking, and made zero sense in storylines. Nobody could put the Fiend away for longer than a few moments. Goldberg smashed through him in three poorly-executed minutes. This betrayed every last brick of world-building in a brazen quest for WrestleMania numbers that would not have been necessary, had Vince not patched his broken machine with over and over and over again with this exact same BS.
Vince McMahon barely rated Goldberg at the time of his first run in 2003. He was an ex-WCW guy he hired for his star power and drawing ability, but was told how to work in his harebrained, stubborn, arrogant way. Booking him to go over in an in-house creation - a third-generation superstar - is almost comparable to Vince booking a sneeze to go over Roman Reigns.
Even the contrarian Goldberg apologists (hi) could not defend his performance. This marked a radical and perversely hilarious paradigm shift for McMahon, who is laughably out of ideas and incapable of creating new stars, or indeed preserving those who got over literally everywhere else they have worked. He is no longer fit for the purpose of running WWE's creative arm.
Is Triple H...?
CONT'D...(1 of 5)
NXT showcases excellent professional wrestling on what isn't necessarily an excellent TV show on an episodic basis that proves compelling week to week. Those that don't have an undying love for the programme - which despite its huge push on RAW pulls in less than a third of Monday's not-great audience - lack that connection because the storytelling is basic and there is a synthetic, over-produced in-house quality to the show, not too dissimilar to that of the main roster, that replaces silliness and bad jokes with serious, operatic business. This isn't (just) a subjective opinion. NXT only generates serious buzz on TakeOver shows, and even then, the increasing, excessive melodrama influenced by Producer Shawn Michaels is beginning to invite scorn. The ratings reflect the idea that NXT is no longer the future.
If you are in investor in WWE, you are looking at those Nielsen ratings with a certain apprehension over the company's long-term future under Triple H's vision, and that does not factor in his big, failing, money-losing quest of NXT localisation. NXT UK is a ghost town of a brand rejected or ignored by its target audience, while NXT Japan in its embryonic stage is even less tenable.
NXT had the currency, and so (too) much of the talent, and it hasn't transitioned to TV success, which is troubling. It is precision-engineered as a response and alternative to what fans of the main roster have bemoaned, and it is it outdrawn by the main roster to a significant extent.
Is Paul Heyman equipped to take over the creative side?
CONT'D...(2 of 5)
The prospect of Heyman usurping Triple H as successor isn't at all remote. The level of trust placed in him is quite extraordinary, even if he is still operating within certain, debilitating confines you'd expect he'd dispense with in an alternate timeline. Heyman has an eye for and is patient with talent, has for years created an incredible aura around Brock Lesnar, has conspired to sequence three hours of RAW in such a way that it doesn't feel quite as long, and books with a knack for the big angle and the episodic story beat alike.
There's too much in the way of big picture thinking and passé shock value, though; that Lesnar aura rarely benefits anybody, and the cuckold and wedding angles are short-term ratings grabs that don't reverse WWE's perception as the goofy, lame monolith. The darkened rooms and spiders imposed on Aleister Black and Erick Rowan give the impression that his brain is still wired in the worst of the '90s, and there's a real carny element to his bait-and-switch tactics that masquerade as cute. That carny complaint extends to his quite weird and desperate stipulations. Fist Fights? Mosh Pit Mixed Tag?
Heyman is a product of his time. As vastly improved as RAW is, it's still a very WWE show, and ratings have only barely improved under his quasi-stewardship.
If Vince McMahon isn't the present, and neither Triple H nor Paul Heyman are the future...who is?
CONT'D...(3 of 5)
WWE has the resources and the requirement to offer Daniel Bryan a lifetime contract in an influential management capacity. They should do this. They should pinpoint Daniel Bryan as the greatest wrestling mind in the entire system and entrust him to shape the future vision of the company.
Daniel Bryan is a master wrestling technician and all-time great sports entertainer. His matches get over to everybody; the discerning hardcore set and the young children in the audience alike. He has the carefree confidence and genius political and creative ability to do his own work and get that work over. He is so fantastic at laying out matches that he convinced the world that Kofi Kingston was true World Champion material and the Fiend's in-ring work was even remotely plausible. He can do mandatory broad scripted WWE comedy, very well, and is a master at the old, timeless essence of the wrestling promo: he balances the credentials of both himself and his opponent so deftly that it never feels contrived. His big matches feel like real events.
He has a keen eye for a story and the talent that will get over by its last chapter; it is no coincidence that WWE's most critically acclaimed development of modern times - KofiMania - was very much shaped his creative control. Bryan has worked within the WWE system for a decade, but is impervious to its bubble.
CONT'D...(4 of 5)
He watches and loves pro wrestling beyond WWE, having conceded that Zack Sabre, Jr. has eclipsed his technical accomplishments. He is well-liked and profoundly respected amongst his peers. Hell, his run on Talking Smack alongside Renee Young is the closest we have ever come to the funny, wholesome chemistry shared between Bobby Heenan and Gorilla Monsoon.
In Daniel Bryan, WWE has its best future road agent, scout, and booker. He is a true master-of-all polymath.
Even in a scenario much like that which exists now - with Vince still in effective unilateral control, relinquishing it in painstakingly slow fashion, if at all - Bryan knows how to navigate and star in a broken system, and has the know-how and compassionate nature to guide those underneath him over the eggshells.
He is perfect for the role, but whether Bryan would it is another matter. He isn't materially motivated, and the image of greying Bryan in a suit is incongruous. It's a hopeless fantasy scenario, but one that speaks to another, harsh truth. The WWE system is not built to be changed by a man of Bryan's values or disposition.
But Bryan is the one. In another harsh truth, it's not as if the staff writers are remotely capable of the promotion, which begs the question: why are they there?