TNA: Hulk Hogan - Boom Or Bust, Brother!

By Col Rothwell /

October 27th 2009 was a day that I imagine very few people saw coming. This was the day that TNA Wrestling, a company that has long been a very distant number two wrestling promotion who are very much in the background compared to the monolith that is WWE - announced they had signed THE biggest professional wrestler in the business, Hulk Hogan. Now of course Hogan was way beyond actually wrestling anything aside from maybe a very rare match with very few bumps taken, but his presence clearly would attract a whole new audience to the TNA product wouldn't it? See TNA had been trying to raise awareness for their product for many years. Usually they seemed to try and accomplish this by trying to attract former WWE wrestlers and hoping they would help them get over the 1.0 ratings hump that they'd been stuck with seemingly forever. They tried with Christian, they tried with Kurt Angle and also various other names had passed through or joined the company on a long-term basis, usually to minimal or no real ratings increase on the whole. But Hogan, well Hogan was arguably the biggest name in the business you could get, and personally I was both surprised and a little excited to see where this could potentially take TNA in the future. Would this finally push them up towards the big time? TNA have had a great roster of talented athletes for many years and also had certain things that separated them from the WWE product, namely the X-Division where wrestlers would compete in fantastic fast paced cruiserweight style matches and original battles such as the Ultimate X match where four wrestlers usually compete trying to grab an X (or at times the X-Division title belt itself) hanging fifteen foot above the ring from two cables attached to a structure around it. Also the Knockouts Division thrived for TNA, where the women competing seemed much better booked and taken a lot more seriously than WWE's Divas ever have. TNA just seemed to need more promotion to help them gain more of the viewers wrestling lost when WCW closed its doors in the 90's and to attempt to hook in more of the casual viewer that is only aware of the WWE when anyone mentions wrestling. Hogan had to be that guy who would create a whole new interest in the product. But would TNA get what they wanted and needed from Hogan, or was he simply here for another huge payday with little to nothing changing? Now with close to four years gone by and Hogan's contract nearing expiration any day now, I look at what's happened and where all parties have ended up.

January 4th 2010 was the day Hogan actually debuted on television and the episode of Impact was literally full of suprises. As many had predicted, Hogan brought in many of his own personal friends with him such as Eric Bischoff, The Nasty Boys, Sean Waltman, Scott Hall, even the terrible Bubba The Love Sponge along with more. In better news, TNA fans were also treated to Ric Flair and Jeff Hardy appearing in the Impact Zone that evening at least. Things didn't exactly start too well since the commentary team had been hyping up Hogan's imminent arrival for most of the episode along with several video shots of a limo on the way to the arena, only for Hogan in his first promo to tell everyone he'd been in the back all day.

Advertisement

Unfortunately this wouldn't be a rare occasion of stumbling on the microphone for Hogan in his TNA career either. Nevertheless many changes were planned and undertaken once Hogan and Bischoff got their feet under the table. For one, come the next Pay-Per-View show Genesis, TNA ditched the six sided ring that was pretty original for a wrestling company in the United States and went with the regular four sides. The fans didn't seem to approve of the change. Typically those mentioned such as The Nasty Boys and Bubba The Love Sponge also went down about as well as a fart in church and it didn't take too long for both to be ditched by the company.

Other experiments that were meant to take TNA to new levels according to Hogan were to go live on Monday nights up against WWE's flagship show Monday Night Raw. This began in February 2010 and failed so miserably that by May Impact was back to being taped for Thursday nights. More names came into the company such as Brian Kendrick, who looked completely uninspired for the majority of his TNA run and only half the wrestler he'd displayed himself to be in WWE and on the independent scene, Mr. Anderson who had been on the verge of a big push in WWE until one too many botches, injuries and complaints led to his release and Rob Van Dam, who despite being awarded the TNA Heavyweight Championship in an admittedly very good TV match with TNA original and probably the biggest face the company has had in AJ Styles, went on to seem more and more disinterested and sloppy as time went by. Not only this but many of the TNA originals who had shined in the past and were actually on a bit of a good run just before Hogan and friends arrived, either got pushed into the background or left altogether.

Advertisement

Was Hogan really the golden goose that TNA expected him to be?

In truth the people that had worked hard for TNA got a pretty raw deal once Hogan turned up. AJ Styles for example, despite holding the TNA Heavyweight Championship at the time and primarily suited to being a face character was aligned with Ric Flair and saddled with a terrible Nature Boy 2.0 gimmick that didn't gel with him at all. Desmond Wolfe who had been on a huge roll with the company just before Hogan arrived and having several fantastic matches with Kurt Angle, was suddenly reduced to nothing much more than a jobber. Infact when TNA ran a poll to determine who would be the number one contender for the Heavyweight Championship and Wolfe won by a landslide, TNA showed us how much they were behind him when they had him lose his match in quick fashion. Not long later Wolfe was taken off TV for an extended period of time due to health issues only to eventually be released altogether. Likewise other TNA names such as Christopher Daniels, Jay Lethal, Homicide and Low-Ki were either let go or requested their release and had it granted. Daniels would eventually come back and become hotter than ever but was this a realisation backstage of a mistake letting him go in the first place? On the whole for a long period of time it seemed as if TNA really had no clue which way to go, constantly applying changes then backtracking, changing again or simply dropping ideas and hoping nobody noticed. One name who seemed to fare much better was Abyss, who Hogan referred to in interviews as someone who could be TNA's John Cena. Despite this the fans never really saw Abyss as that type of guy and no matter how much they tried to force him into being the main event guy that Hogan constantly gave the rub to, nobody bought it. Throughout 2010 and 2011 TNA seemed to be stuck in a constant cycle of throwing stuff at the wall and desperately hoping some of it stuck. Vince Russo, who was head booker at the time and someone whose reputation in the industry is pretty shaky thanks to his WCW days, didn't last long once the new regime arrived. Although in fairness despite how poor relations were meant to be with Hogan and Bischoff, he did last longer than people probably expected. I wasn't at all unhappy to see Russo go as for every good idea the guy has he seems to have at least ten terrible ones. TNA itself was much better before Russo returned late 2006 and I originally thought Bischoff taking more power and Russo being gone would be a good thing. Unfortunately that wasn't really the case.
As much as Bischoff did certain things well, he's also seemingly trapped in time when the NWO was the biggest thing going in professional wrestling. See it was Bischoff and his supergroup that put WCW through the roof all those years ago but unfortunately someone needs to tell him that keep re-hashing it isn't going to have the same effect today. Bound For Glory 2010 was meant to be the shocking moment that someone who has never really been a heel turns suddenly, just like Hogan did back in the day. And so in the main event we got the shock turn of Jeff Hardy, claiming the Heavyweight Title after attacking both Kurt Angle and Mr. Anderson with a crutch and immediately aligning himself with Bischoff's new creation, Immortal. Immortal was yet another NWO rip-off which never really took off like anyone had hoped. Hardy himself would become derailed by the Victory Road 2011 Pay-Per-View where for some completely unknown reason, TNA allowed him to come out to the ring and wrestle Sting in the main event despite being in no condition to perform. At this time Hardy had fallen off the wagon once again and was clearly under the influence of something and after an incredibly short 'match' where Sting visibly pinned Hardy despite the latter being totally unaware and trying to kick out, Hardy would be gone for an extended period of time. Who in the world thought that rather than reschedule the match they should send Hardy out in that state where he could possibly injure himself or Sting? Keeping the card intact was one thing but fans didn't exactly benefit from having the advertised match as the Pay-Per-View closed with them loudly chanting Bulls**t amongst other things, Sting himself even agreeing audibly on his way up the ramp. It's safe to say that 2010 and 2011 were not good years for TNA on the whole, but not all was lost. Come the end of 2011 there was a pretty good Destination X Pay-Per-View which focused everything back on those X-Division guys I mentioned and a lot of new and past names were around for the show. One bright spot especially was Austin Aries who for years has been a huge part of independent wrestling and a talent that I'm surprised has never been picked up by a major company before. Aries would win a contract with TNA at Destination X and go on to surpass what anyone expected of him in the company, now being one of the most entertaining guys to watch both on the microphone and in the ring. Also 2011 began one of the better TNA creative ideas, the Bound For Glory Series, where a group of selected wrestlers would face off against each other on Impact shows, house shows and Pay-Per-Views accruing points for wins by pin or submission etc. The winner of the overall series would get a Heavyweight Title shot at Bound For Glory in the main event which was a perfect way to elevate someone into the main event picture on a permanent basis. This was achieved well in the first year of the series with Bobby Roode coming out on top, only for him to go on and lose his title match at the big show with an already injured Kurt Angle. At the time this was a debatable move again as Hogan had come out in the media as saying that Roode was not 'THE' guy which came off pretty badly considering how they'd built him up. TNA would then go on to have Angle drop the belt on Impact the week after to Roode's tag team partner James Storm instead. Now despite the bizarre circumstances it was nice to see Storm get the shock win and when the storyline eventually turned to Roode going back heel on his tag partner and cheating him out of the title it seemed that the long term booking was better all along. In truth at the time both Roode and Storm were elevated to the top and Roode went on to have a great title run that lasted well into 2012....which just so happened to be one of the better years in TNA's history. Indeed not all has been bad during Hogan's time in the company. 2012 became a pretty big year for them with several good to great Pay-Per-View shows and finally the spotlight seeming to fall on the right people. Bobby Roode was an excellent champion that the company really got behind whether Hogan meant what he said or not. Roode shined as the arrogant heel champ who would do anything to stay on top and he had some excellent matches along the way. Despite TNA dropping the ball in keeping Storm at the top of the tree with him losing to Roode one too many times when it mattered and eventually falling off into the background, they did get it spot on with Roode and many other guys like Styles, Daniels, Angle and Aries delivering some classic matches. Jeff Hardy had also been given another chance to redeem himself in late 2011, coming back as a fan favourite who had changed his ways. Thankfully so far Jeff seems to have taken full advantage of this opportunity and he has seemingly stayed clean and at the top of his game since. Likewise the Bound For Glory series delivered even better this time around, having a more clearly defined format and more top-tier matches. Austin Aries would come out of nowhere to dethrone Roode at the Destination X Pay-Per-View in a real feelgood moment that was totally unexpected, using another new idea where the X-Division champ could cash-in that belt come Destination X for a shot at the Heavyweight Title. Roode and Aries had a great match and Aries becoming champ really changed the landscape from what wrestling fans expect on television these days. Aries would likely never have the same chance in WWE where he would be seen as too small, something which no doubt helped them decide not to even let him onto Tough Enough before his TNA stint. Towards the end of the year Jeff Hardy would win the Bound For Glory Series and ultimately beat Aries for the belt at TNA's biggest show in another great match which the fans lapped up. Hardy has always been a massively popular character in wrestling who is naturally very charismatic and can seemingly do no wrong in the eyes of the fans. Despite his past issues and how many chances he's been given the fans seem to be more behind him than ever in his quest to finally overcome his demons. Bischoff and Hogan were also no doubt behind the idea of new segment Gut Check which debuted in April 2012 but came to an end in July 2013. At the time it seemed a relatively good concept, using a similar format to WWE's Tough Enough although with a wrestler having a match one week on Impact and having his fate at getting a contract decided the week after by three TNA staff judges. The flaws in the idea were the questionable decisions on who got through and at times putting people on live television who simply weren't ready and came off very badly. To make matters worse most of the people that were hired and spent time training in OVW to one day be called up to TNA are already gone from the company, but I do give them credit for a more original idea on weekly TV. It seems now this along with the themed Impact episodes like Open Fight Night and the Television title belt which had already changed names and rules to compete for it many times, are more of those ideas that they hope people don't remember as all have vanished with no mention of why. On the whole though 2012 gave reason to believe that TNA were on a roll and finally were starting to gain some traction with good booking and the focus in the right places. Could it stick? 2013 has been the typical year for TNA. One step forward, two steps back. Since the year began the company has taken some twists and turns that have left fans wondering if TNA is in worse shape than it has been for some time. The next big idea from camp Hogan was that taking Impact on the road would be what would put them over the top and boost those ratings and finances. Unfortunately whilst this came across great on television with way more enthusiastic crowds and much better visuals than the very small Impact Zone, it hasn't brought the company anything other than larger bills to pay. This has contributed in TNA letting go of a lot of names this year, which when you think about how the Knockouts Division is practically non-existent now, the X-Division is a shadow of its former self and even major names like Mickie James, Tara, Mr. Anderson and more have gone whilst Hogan sits on a presumably astronomical contract, is pretty ridiculous. As it stands now Bischoff has yet another faction the (not at all a rip-off of Sons of Anarchy, honest) Aces & Eights that has done nothing for anyone outside of the fantastic Bully Ray who could have done the same on his own. The Bound For Glory Series became more convoluted again and seemed to chop and change rules as they saw fit towards the end just so they could come out with who they wanted in the top spots after not planning properly to begin with. AJ Styles has gone it alone and become a sort of tweener character whose contract is up in real life and worryingly has still not committed to staying beyond the end of the year. He's now playing off an angle about winning the belt at Bound For Glory after winning the series and potentially leaving the company with it like CM Punk did in the WWE a couple of years ago. Whilst Styles is not Punk and the angle is coming off as a copy of sorts, it does work to some degree with Styles words on the names that have been let go and the people in Dixie Carter's ear that have changed the company for the worse being very close to what he probably feels for real. Bellator fighters Rampage Jackson and Tito Ortiz have for some reason been brought in taking up television time and done nothing much aside from integrate into the Aces & Eights and Main Event Mafia feud (oh yeah, they're back too) and promote Bellator far more than TNA have benefited from the situation. Chris Sabin also had a very short run as Heavyweight Champion thanks to the Destination X cash-in situation and shenanigans which did nothing at all for Sabin except make him look weak. Hogan himself continues to trot out and flub his lines whilst attempting to put over TNA guys with alarming insincerity. The good news in all this? Hogan (and presumably Bischoff) is coming to the end of his contract in the next week or so and reports say he isn't so sure to re-sign this time. I guess that leads me to my conclusion... Despite the fact that I'm sure TNA has gained some more attention through Hogan since he came along, the experiment has clearly failed when it comes to the company making so many cuts in talent whilst Hogan and friends sit there on their big money deals. Hogan is incapable of wrestling any sort of decent match with all his surgeries and does not come across as at all sincere or believable when attempting to build up TNA or any of its employees. Recent reports say that Hogan and Dixie Carter are not on great terms anymore and there's no word that Hogan is staying this time around. Whilst TNA have recently filmed an exit for Hogan if he doesn't stay, it remains to be seen whether it's all a work and Hogan will sign once more. No doubt Hogan is doing what he usually does and looking out for himself first and foremost by seeing if Vince comes calling for a Wrestlemania 30 appearance next year. It's also no coincidence that this is at least the second time Hogan's contract comes to an end just before the biggest show of the year for TNA, which potentially gives him leverage in contract negotiations and forces them to keep him around for any angle that's been building up long term. Personally I think it's time TNA rebooted the whole company once more and remembered what sets them apart from the WWE. That means building up the X-Division again, building up the Knockouts again and expanding the tag team division with a few more established teams to go with the outstanding E.G.O stable (consisting of Roode, Daniels and Kazarian) who are possibly the most entertaining part of Impact every week at this point. It means convincing Styles to stay and continuing to build people like Magnus who has a bright future. Bring back some of the names that made this company so exciting like Jay Lethal, Low-Ki and Alex Shelley. Hell bring back Jeff Jarrett too. You could argue that TNA are more visible to casual fans than ever right now and maybe Hogan has helped that, but now is the time to stop trying to mimic WWE. No company will ever come close to toppling Vince McMahon and his empire so trying to copy them only makes you look like a poor mans WWE-Lite. What TNA needs is to stand out as a viable alternative and they certainly have the capabilities to do that if they do the right thing now and use the money they've been putting in Hogan's pocket to hire several wrestlers and do what they used to do best. Also TNA needs to start relying on youth more, push Magnus into the main event, keep Samoa Joe in there too and let's cut back on Sting and Angle. Don't get me wrong Sting and Kurt Angle are legends of the sport and do have a place in the company but they shouldn't be in main event positions and title feuds at this stage of their careers. Also Angle really needs extended time off from the ring considering his own alcohol issues and wealth of bad injuries that have taken a toll on his body. For me it's time now to revolve the company around the safe hands that know this company inside out, Samoa Joe, Frankie Kazarian, AJ Styles, Christopher Daniels, Bobby Roode, James Storm, even the smaller Chris Sabin who is great when utilised right and of course Austin Aries who has shown his ability to make waves in the company and looks like he belongs in the main event. By adding a few names of old and a few new to the company and going back to what they do best TNA could thrive as an alternative to WWE. They've already done something which I fully support by cutting back from monthly Pay-Per-Views to only four of them a year which stops them from flooding the market with way too much for the fans to shell out for, something I wish WWE would take stock of themselves. Now they just need to learn how to build those shows much better, bring the right people into the company, listen to the right people who have the company at heart and maximise the talent they have instead of lining the pockets of faded heros.