While the WWF was prospering in the north, Jim Crockett Promotions was growing in the south. JCP boasted a talented roster better than McMahons in my opinion and it became the NWAs premier member, making it the WWFs main rival. It was decided in 1983 that the company would create a new super show at the Greensboro Coliseum JCP already had a tradition of holding shows there on Thanksgiving. Starrcade was a huge financial and critical success. Things went wrong in 1987. The WWF chose to run their own Thanksgiving show, Survivor Series, at the same time. Starrcade 1987 also marked the first time JCP entered the world of PPV, something the WWF had been doing since WrestleMania III. Vince McMahon threatened the cable companies, saying that if they showed Starrcade they would not be able to show Survivor Series and WrestleMania IV. The fact that Hulk Hogan was a mainstream celebrity, while JCPs main eventer, Ron Garvin, struggled to win over the promotions fans, must have had some influence. Starrcade struggled and JCP was sold to Ted Turner in 88. The first WCW years were very good. Sting, Vader, Flair, Steamboat and Lex Luger helped make WCW a better wrestling promotion, in terms of quality, than the WWF. Unfortunately, in a bid to attract more viewers, WCW got Hogan involved. At Hogans first Starrcade, The Nasty Boys, Mr T, Jim Duggan, Avalanche (WWFs Earthquake) and Brutus Beefcake who wrestled in the main event as The Butcher all featured it pays to be the Hulksters friend. There was an obvious dip in quality, from which WCW would never recover. The introduction of cruiserweights made the undercards exciting, with the likes of Misterio, Guerrero and Juventud lighting up otherwise boring PPVs, but the main events featuring Nash, Hogan, Piper and Goldberg were terrible. Starrcade 1998 saw Goldbergs winning streak come to an end as he was defeated by Kevin Nash for the WCW Championship Nash was the booker. Starrcade 2000, the last one, featured a main event of Scott Steiner vs. Sid Vicious a far cry from Flair vs. Race and it earned a dreadful 0.11 buyrate. It came as no surprise that WCW lost $62 million in 2000 and was sold to the WWF in 01. Starrcade was the super show before WrestleMania had even been thought up. Here are the ten best matches from the Granddaddy of them All...
10. Greg Valentine vs. Roddy Piper Starrcade: A Flare for the Gold
This was a grudge match Valentine was the US Champion but the belt was not on the line where both men wanted to beat each other down, and little else. A dog collar match doesnt sound like the greatest two men tied together by dog collars and a chain, but Valentine and Piper made it work with brutal action. Piper starts out the better man, but Valentine wraps the chain around his face. There is a rumour that Piper had damaged hearing, so the champion begins to attack it with the chain. Both men use the chain to choke each other and Valentine then locks in the Sleeper Hold. The Rowdy One fights out and beats him down with the chain, wraps his legs up for the pin and takes the win.
9. 3 Count vs. Jung Dragons vs. Jamie Noble and Evan Karagias Starrcade 2000
WCW was heading towards collapse at this point, with many of the big names jumping the sinking ship. This triple threat tag team ladder match was a reaction to the popular WWF matches, but, for some reason, the bookers decided to have the match start with just two men in the ring. There could only be one winner, despite it being a tag team bout, and the person would have a shot at the Cruiserweight Championship WCW booking at its best. Noble and Karagias have a ladder laid on top of them, with Kaz landing a springboard moonsault. Both of members of 3 Count, Karagias and Yang all perform dives to the outside. Noble tries to capitalise, but Kaz pushes the ladder over, sending him onto the four men at ring side. Karagias balances on a ladder and Yang tries to take him off with a springboard splash, but Evan counters it into a powerslam. Helms hits Noble with a neckbreaker from the ladder. Karagias then gets planted with a flip/powerbomb combination. The Dragons balance a ladder between two other ladders. The Dragons, Karagias and Noble all get pushed off the ladders, allowing 3 Count to collect the contract.
8. The Rock & Roll Express vs. Ole & Arn Anderson Starrcade: Night of the Skywalkers
The Rock & Roll Express were the most dominant team in wrestling at the time, while the Anderson brothers were hated due to their involvement in the Four Horsemen. The bout was held inside a cage to stop the other Horsemen interfering. This is one of the best traditional tag team matches, showing why the Andersons were two of the best ring psychologists. Ole and Arn focus on Gibsons arm and Mortons leg. Few teams have ever worked as well as the Andersons and the Rock & Roll Express, slowly building the crowds energy for the eventual hot tags. Morton is beaten to a bloody pulp. The crowd are willing him on but the Andersons wont let him make the tag. A brawl breaks out between the four and, as the referee is trying to regain control, Ole tries to slam Morton. Gibson plants Mortons back with a dropkick, pushing Ole over and allowing the Rock & Roll Express to steal the win.
7. Doom vs. Arn Anderson & Barry Windham Starrcade: Collision Course
Doom had become successful since losing their masks, dominating some of the best teams WCW had to offer. The Four Horsemen, annoyed with Simmons and Reeds progression, chose to battle Doom at Starrcade for the World Tag Team Championship. The street fight spills straight to the ramp, with Simmons lashing Anderson with a belt. Windham is the first to be cut open, before Anderson smacks Reed with a chair. A spinebuster gets a two count. Windham lands the superplex, but Simmons kicks out at two. Anderson kicks out of a chair shot, while Reed kicks out of the piledriver. Windham gets caught with a clothesline and Reed goes for the pin, but, at the same time, Anderson locks in a small package, with both pins getting a three count, meaning the match ends in a draw.
6. Ric Flair vs. Lex Luger Starrcade: True Gritt
Luger had joined the Horsemen in 87, but left a year later, feeling the group was holding him back. Barry Windham turned on The Total Package and joined the Horsemen, leading to a feud between Flair and Luger over the NWA Championship. The two met at the Great American Bash but the match was stopped due to Lugers excessive bleeding, which meant the Nature Boy retained the belt. This led to a rematch at Starrcade. Luger works Flairs arm, but the champion retaliates, taking aim at the challengers leg. Luger tries to lock in the Torture Rack but he struggles to get Flair up, allowing the Nature Boy to counter the submission into a roll-up, with Flair using the ropes for leverage as he stole the win. This was Luger at his unquestioned best, while Flair shows why he is regarded as one of the greatest.
5. Big Van Vader vs. Sting Starrcade: Battlebowl
The King of Cable tournament came down to Vader and Sting. Id argue that Vader was the best feud Sting had during his time with WCW, just shading the battles with Ric Flair, and this was one of the best matches the pair put on together. Vader mocks Sting with his power, slamming The Icon to the mat with ease. The crowd pop as Sting sends the big man to the mat with a spinning heel kick, before sending him over the top rope and landing a springboard splash. Vader blocks the Stinger Splash but Sting manages a superplex. Vader escapes the Scorpion Death Lock. Vader takes control, but fails to capitalise on his momentum. Sting counters a superplex attempt. A Samoan Drop and a top rope splash earn a two, before Sting reversed a top rope dive into a powerslam, pinning Vader to win the tournament.
4. Billy Kidman vs. Juventud vs. Rey Misterio Starrcade 1998
On the same evening Kevin Nash would end Goldbergs undefeated streak, it was the opening Cruiserweight Championship match which stole the show. Misterio had left the LWO, creating a feud between him, Guerrero and Juventud. Kidman and Misterio team up on Juventud, landing an impressive tilt-a-whirl backbreaker. The alliance starts to crack, with Juventud landing a double bulldog. The trio have some brilliant combinations. Juventud throws Misterio to the outside, then Kidman onto the Biggest Little Man, before landing a springboard splash. Kidman lifts Misterio onto his shoulders and Juventud hits a springboard hurricanrana. A huge springboard moonsault takes out both Kidman and Juventud. Misterio gets planted with the Juvi Driver, but Kidman breaks the pin. The champion lands a Shooting Star Press to the outside to take out both challengers. Guerrero comes out to massive heat and helps Juventud roll-up Kidman, but, the move is countered, with Kidman winning via pinfall and retaining his Cruiserweight Championship.
3. Vader vs. Ric Flair Starrcade 1993
Ric Flair had returned to WCW after his brief spell at the WWF, while Big Van Vader had held the WCW Championship for most of the year, only trading the title with Sting during a European tour. The Nature Boy promised to retire if he lost. The usual big man vs. little man arc was used, with Flair being the quicker veteran and Vader being the powerful beast and looking unbeatable. It was a brilliant story, like the retirement run from 07-08 but with Flair being at his classic best. Vader drags Flair around and wrecks the Hall of Famer for the opening ten minutes, with the challengers sporadic attacks having little effect on the big man. The Nature Boy begins to take aim at Vaders leg. Vader escapes the Figure Four, but misses the Vader Bomb. The big man misses the moonsault, before Flair catches his leg and rolls him up for the win.
2. Tully Blanchard vs. Magnum T.A. Starrcade: The Gathering
The NWA US Championship was up for grabs in this I Quit match. Magnum T.A was hugely popular and the closest thing in terms of popularity the NWA had to Hogan. Original plans had him winning the NWA Championship in the near future, but a car accident left T.A paralysed and unable to wrestle ever again. This is one of the most brutal matches from the eighties, long before ECW had influenced the business, and there are few matches that can match the sheer passion on display. Both men use the cage to cut the other open. Blanchard suffers a cut on his arm, only for Magnum to bite it, with the champion screaming in pain. Blanchard smacks the microphone into Magnums bloodied face, before Baby Doll throws a chair to the champion. Blanchard breaks the wooden chair, finds the sharpest piece and tries to stab Magnum in the eye. The wood hovers dangerously close over the eye, before the challenger escapes and drags another piece of wood into Blanchards head. The champion gives up and Magnum T.A becomes the TV Champion.
1. Harley Race vs. Ric Flair Starrcade: A Flare for the Gold
Race had won the NWA Championship from the Nature Boy and offered $25,000 to anyone who would stop Flair from wrestling. Bob Orton and Dick Slater assaulted Flair and hit him with a devastating piledriver, forcing The Dirtiest Player in the Game to retire. Flair returned, though, attacking Orton and Slater, setting up his rematch at Starrcade: A Flare for the Gold. Flair starts with a series of headlocks but Race takes charge, countering a powerslam and landing a big piledriver. Gordon Solie on commentary, talking about the comparisons between wrestling styles and backgrounds, makes me hate Michael Cole all the more. The champion smashes Flairs head against the cage, blood splattering over the camera. The Nature Boy turns the tide, slamming Races head against the cage and hitting the piledriver. Flair locks in the Figure Four this was when this was one of the most dangerous finishers in wrestling but Race manages to reach the ropes, to the shock of the crowd and Solie. The King of Wrestling regains control with a diving headbutt, before accidently knocking the referee to the mat. Flair goes up top and lands the cross body, Race tripping over the referee, allowing The Nature Boy to take the NWA Championship for a third time. The crowd loved the win, with all the face stars coming to the ring to congratulate to new champion. It didnt have the action of todays standard, but the emotion and intensity is superb. It was a true passing of the torch moment.