What If... Vince McMahon Booked AEW?!

What would Vince McMahon make of Orange Cassidy?!

By Michael Sidgwick /

AEW/BTE

This is a thought exercise penned for the purposes of comedy. If you like Vince McMahon, you won't like it. You're under no obligation to consume it; it's not three hours of Monday Night Raw.

Advertisement

Say All Elite Wrestling for whatever reason fails to catch fire in October 2019, and the Wall Street Journal investigates Vince McMahon's abhorrent historical sexual misconduct a few years earlier. Warner, panicked - there's hardly a surplus of people with a great history doing wrestling successfully - give an alleged abuser a time slot on a Wednesday night. It isn't out of the realms of possibility, and if you think that it is, you might need somebody to Power Slap some sense into your head.

Everything you love about AEW is of course dead now, with Vince at the helm. Consider the Elite's run in 2021, during which Kenny Omega and the Young Bucks descended into megalomania. It was incredible; they hid in limos to pretend that they were big shots, and not sh*t-scared of Jon Moxley and Eddie Kingston. Nick Jackson squealed as Michael Nakazawa mistakenly honked the horn, thinking he was under attack. Kenny Omega deadpanned "Did I explode?" to rescue the disaster that was the Exploding Barbed Wire Death match. In general - drawing countless subplots into its spiderweb, like the rise of Jurassic Express, the Jon Moxley and Eddie Kingston bromance, and the debut of Bryan Danielson and Adam Cole - the Elite's arc was piss funny, and the heel shenanigans were eventually thwarted with two classic babyface triumphs. The Lucha Bros. defeated the Young Bucks at All Out, and Hangman Page dethroned Omega at Full Gear. Entertaining episodic TV with a happy ending?

Advertisement

F*ck off, pal!

What's in place of all those things?

Advertisement

Kenny Omega and the Young Bucks: you're off the creative committee. This is Vince's show, and there's no need for anybody else beyond a fleet of writers whose job it is to pop him in a frightening game, the objective of which is to emerge unscathed from the horror of Vince McMahon. Think of this along the lines of a survival horror title - like the original Resident Evil for the PS1, only slightly less graphically sophisticated, looking at Vince these days.

CONT'D...(1 of 5)

Advertisement
AEW

Jon Moxley promised "glorious wrestling violence the likes of which the industry hasn't seen in decades" ahead of his match with Kenny Omega at Full Gear 2019, which was a richly detailed video nasty stuffed with as many easter eggs as weapons; before one was wrapped around his face in Baltimore, Omega joked ahead of the match on Dynamite: "What are you gonna do, Jon: chain-wrestle me?"

Advertisement

The match looks completely different with Vince at the helm. "You like Japanese sh*t, don't you Kenny? Here, have a kendo stick. Also, look shocked when the second One-Winged Angel doesn't cut it."

Dr. Britt Baker was the original choice to lead the women's division as babyface. She didn't get over as a babyface, and so, within months, AEW turned her heel. This wouldn't have happened under Vince. We know this from the Roman Reigns push. Vince would have told you that Dr. Britt Baker is a dentist more often under the belief that you didn't get it the first time.

Advertisement

"I was talking to Dr. Britt Baker earlier today," Excalibur would have said, in 2025, "and she told me that earlier than earlier that day, she extracted a decaying molar from a patient's mouth. Because she, you dumb f*cks, is a dentist in addition to a sports entertainer. "She" as in Dr. Britt Baker. My apologies for the pronoun. Even though it is very obvious to whom I'm referring, since I haven't referred to another women's wrestler since talking about her. Britt Baker. F*ck."

Hangman Page can't have been anxious. He's a babyface. He'd have to be a sh*tty stand-up comedian instead. Also: wear a big smile out there, Hanger. You might be despondent at the state of your career, which draws a disillusioned generation of millennial fans to your act, but you're only permitted to look sad when a heel beats you down for eight straight minutes.

Advertisement

Remember the incredible Taz Vs. Sabu-influenced Cody Vs. MJF feud, premised on the idea that the fans could not wait to see Cody get his hands on the little bastard and were willing to pay $50 to watch him get his comeuppance?

CONT'D...(2 of 5)

Advertisement
AEW

Well, forget it: Vince would wonder aloud where the rest of MJF is before Cody gets disqualified in a TV match for kicking his ass too much, thus delivering the exact antithesis of what fans actually wanted.

Advertisement

You liked "A little bit of the bubbly", too, right? It was great. But you see, you didn't get quite enough of it. Vince would create a video package highlighting every meme - after several days of it being explained to him what a meme actually is - and march Chris Jericho out to the ring, by which point everybody is over it, and instruct Jericho to say it over and over again. Vince would have Fandago-d Le Champion for a second consecutive time.

Who would Vince have went with as his top star? Cody? He didn't even go with Cody when Cody became the next John Cena. Mox? Every word out of his mouth would have ended up on an internal ban list. Omega? Not bloody likely. He keeps doing Buddy Murphy’s moves. Then again, Vince doesn't know who Buddy Murphy is, so Omega might have done OK.

Advertisement

Realistically, given what is known about the man, Vince probably would have went with Luchasaurus, if he was able to stay free of injury, and it wouldn't have been the worst thing in the world - that is until he had Luchasaurus welcome you all to AEW Dynamite and made him stop doing the stuff that got him over.

Wardlow is the obvious pick, but AEW fans gravitated towards him because he was a good dude in addition to being an ass-kicking macho prototype. There was more than one dimension to Wardlow. Vince however would have pushed him so hard down your throat that you'd choke harder than Triple H booking a woman.

Advertisement

Elsewhere, Vince would have taken one look at Joey Janela and ripped up the closest format sheet in his proximity in disgust. He'd have taken a single glance at Riho and, well, is not advisable to even joke about what he unquestionably would have thought. And how would he perceive Darby Allin?

CONT'D...(3 of 5)

Advertisement
AEW

Allin himself once joked that, had he signed with WWE, the company would have made him "a creepy figure hanging around a boiler room jacking off or something," but that's too on the nose. Allin would play Dexter Lumis in Vince's AEW. He wouldn't jack it, probably, but Darby almost certainly would have been told do none of the absolutely insane sh*t that nobody in their right mind would want to watch. And, after he was banned from his exquisite chain wrestling, Vince wouldn't have looked too kindly on his stunt work, either.

Advertisement

So Darby's bold and well-plotted trajectory to the top of the card wouldn't have happened. Does anybody grab the brass ring? What about Orange Cassidy? Does he get over in Vince's All Elite Wrestling?

This, away from the snark, is actually an interesting one to consider. Cassidy has a way of winning people over (with the exception, of course, of bad faith podcasters who need to bury him in order to live). Jim Ross and Chris Jericho have both spoken of how they didn't get Orange at first, to put it mildly, before realising that he is incredible at what he does and that over is over. The thing is, over isn't over in Vince McMahon's mind. Sometimes, being "over" is just the fans taking the piss (see: Rusev), so it's likely that Vince would have sat down, commiserated Orange, and told him to stick that thumb up properly so that everybody in the back row could see it. That way, the fans might stop patronising him.

Advertisement

You'd never have watched Yuji Nagata or Jeff Cobb or Tomohiro Ishii or Katsuyori Shibata or El Hijo del Vikingo or Hiroshi Tanahashi or Jun Akiyama or Minoru Suzuki or Will Ospreay perform on live television. Sure, they're all great, but plane tickets aren't cheap and none of them know where the hard camera is. Also, another wrestling promotion can't be good. You might start watching more than one if we admit that.

Eddie Kingston might have been hired...to ensure that Cezar Bononi could learn how to work. Kingston would have been on television as often as...erm, he is now.

Advertisement

CONT'D...(4 of 5)

AEW

Vince, a demented micro-manager, also would have regulated the commentary of Good Ol' JR (who's more Dirty Ol' Man Jr these days). On the December 9, 2022 Rampage, as the Bunny and Penelope Ford made their way to the ring, Tony Schiavone remarked "Those are two creepy gals right there, guys," to which Jim Ross replied "Well, that's one way of putting it. I might not put it that way. I kinda like 'em."

Advertisement

This is something that Ross actually said, and is not a joke made up for the purposes of this article.

This was also a euphemism for "They each are packing a whopping pair of breasts, about which I'm more enthusiastic than any AEW Trios match," and while Vince encouraged Jerry Lawler to reach the vinegar strokes in 1998, this is 2023, pal. You can only objectify women on your own time, when the networks aren't looking. Put it back in your pants, Pronoun Boy.

Advertisement

As for the Wellness Policy, standards and practises, things of that nature, Vince McMahon would have ensured the safety and wellbeing of his performers - chiefly Excalibur’s lung capacity, by not announcing a single f*cking thing in advance.

On the rankings system, Vince might not have abandoned it immediately, but, if the Wild Card Rule is any indication, there's a great chance that he'd have simply ignored the objective results and changed them to enable his whims under the belief that you wouldn't remember. No, you didn't see what you think you saw last week. If I don't care about, you don't either is basically Vince McMahon's entire modus operandi, which collides drastically with the real AEW's fan-service, let's bring wrestling back to the people philosophy.

Advertisement

As exaggerated as some of the above scenarios are - and some might even be too generous to the old, brain-fried despot - there's a pertinent point buried within the snark.

If somebody with Vince McMahon's ideas was given a TV deal and a lot of money today, with the only exception being that this person was starting from scratch, it would never work. The fan-loathing, inscrutable madness would not draw an audience. The thought would be inexplicable.

Advertisement

It is only because Vince McMahon is so entrenched within wrestling that he a fanbase exists to indulge his obnoxious stupidity. Judged on current form and not his past accomplishments, Vince is a complete f*ckwit.

Also: a terrible human being.

Advertisement