Why AEW Were Right All Along

AEW is attempting to "restore the feeling" - and with VERY good reason...

By Michael Sidgwick /

AEW

All Elite Wrestling exploded into life more quickly than any other promotion ever. Funded by a connected super-fan billionaire and named after the branding of the act du jour, it sprinted out of the blocks with a revitalised Chris Jericho doing the best work of his career, Cody Rhodes' very astute grasp of the romantic underdog narrative, and the Elite's state-of-the-art fusion of exhilaration and layered melodrama. You might have personally deemed it corny, but it was red-hot. Transformative. It might not seem that way now - the worst time to put something over is when it just cycles out of fashion - but it was red-hot.

Advertisement

AEW had a vision to do what WWE refused to do or was incapable of doing. TV matches that were actually worked with lung-bursting effort. Creative freedom. Long-term, intricate stories. And, of paramount importance, wins and losses mattering. Lapsed WWE fans had watched on, for years, feeling patronised as Vince McMahon as toggled through his Rolodex of awful finishes. As New Japan Pro Wrestling rose to prominence, they longed for a mainstream US alternative with something in the way of a puro influence. Actually, they didn't. That was a totally naive pipe dream and they didn't bother. And then AEW actually materialised, the wild convergence of factors behind which should never be overlooked. It is a unicorn of a promotion that, beyond the odd, horrendous development - the orignal incarnation of the Dark Order, the Nightmare Collective, Matt Hardy - was as good if not better at its peak than the unprecedented level of hype promised.

Ironically, AEW's vision was so successful that this was proved to them when they began to fail by deviating from it.

Advertisement

The autumn 2023 period was inexplicable, and that was the worst thing about it. AEW was meant to be the switched-on promotion dialled into the pulse of the jaded, more discerning fandom. AEW was meant to be the promotion that had learned from the mistakes of WCW and TNA, which each entered death spirals after forging the competition. AEW was even incredibly smug about how much it knew better, once upon a time, which was as much a reassuring marketing tactic as anything else. And yet, they made a grave mistake. Whether inspired by the success of the Bloodline, frustrated by the lack of growth promised following the events of All Out 2021, or acquiescing to the demands of the wrong people - disingenuous online grifters or carnies within the company - AEW copied WWE's homework.

CONT'D...(1 of 5)

Advertisement
AEW

The slow-mo "comedy" vignettes, the TNA aesthetic trappings of the Devil, the Ole Anderson modulated voice of the Devil, the Devil hacking the broadcast feed complete with a light show that was just begging for Y'all Ready For This? from Space Jam to be played over the top of it: AEW didn't "feel" like AEW for a while there.

Advertisement

The Devil storyline was poor, but it wasn't the limit to AEW's problems. Something has felt off since Brawl Out even when AEW smashed the lingering, greyed cloud with excellent pay-per-views. Tony Khan also made the same mistakes virtually every one of his predecessors did. He introduced too many titles, undermining the very notion of achievement. Bad, tropey booking habits filtered through; the sheer level of interference that polluted the show reached a nadir of parody by Double Or Nothing, a show on which over half of the matches were blighted by outside activity. Much of it felt meaningless - and redundant, since Karen Jarrett had them all licked at drawing heat.

He signed too many wrestlers, filling a quagmire as much as a talent roster, from which it was difficult to escape. With so many great wrestlers in one promotion, Khan was bound to fail at least one of them. He failed several. The quagmire was deep. A lot sunk into it. Great talent, as a result of the wonky roster: TV time ratio, was often left to languish, and that Khan, an impulsive fella, quite liked throwing Gravity or Timothy Thatcher or even the worst ex-NXT wrestlers you've ever seen on his show did not help. Konosuke Takeashita, a phenomenal pro wrestler, barely wrestled in the back half of 2023 - even after defeating Kenny Omega twice in the space of a week.

Advertisement

The problems were exponential. Messes become more messy if they aren't cleaned up; that's what they do. If Take defeating Omega meant nothing, those supposed huge game-changing wins, what did that, in turn, say about Omega? He couldn't have been that big a star, a scalp, if defeating him cleanly didn't propel Takeshita further up the card. Just as they didn't in WWE in 2019 - the Hades-low bar AEW soared above - wins and losses increasingly meant little in AEW four years later. The programme, which lasted months, might as well have not happened.

CONT'D...(2 of 5)

Advertisement
AEW

Bad as that period was, AEW is still here. AEW is thriving, much as the perspective has been lost. The Collision attendances aren't fantastic most of the time, and the heat isn't what it was in 2021, but AEW is still in tremendous health.

Advertisement

In a weird way, AEW has followed the bizarre route WWE took in making its astonishing comeback (not that the popularity between each company is remotely comparable). WWE was essentially horrific for decades, plural, beyond some incredible, outlying top-level programmes. They are enjoying an incredible resurgence driven in no small part by contrast. A coherent, basics-forward product in which the promotion of the star acts is more impressive than the dry storytelling is drastically better than the faeces Vince McMahon called entertainment. "Drastically" isn't even an accurate synonym. Nothing can articulate how dismal WWE became between 2019 and 2021, and it was hardly great in 2009.

All Tony Khan had to do, it seemed, was deliver lame and antagonistic booking for two decades before making it make sense. If that reads as snarky, you'd probably be correct, but Khan experienced a mini version of that phenomenon over the last few months, as he launched a renaissance of a similar scale.

Advertisement

The Continental Classic did much to "restore the feeling". The wins mattered. Through the framing of the round-robin tournament - wins really mattered and were visually represented through the awarding of three points - winning a single match at the death over Brody King when he was already out of contention meant more for Daniel Garcia's career than Takeshita defeating a much bigger star twice. The agony of Eddie Kingston losing cleanly two times in a row drove his arc. He simply could not lose again, and this urgency drove his work. He button-bashed those chops against Daniel Garcia in a particularly excellent performance. That match, in addition to being awesome, was drenched in meaning. Eddie Kingston losing cleanly did significantly more to drive support for his character and for his overall career prospects than the dismal, laughable way in which he was "protected" in the Barbed Wire Everywhere post-match against Chris Jericho in 2022.

CONT'D...(3 of 5)

Advertisement
AEW

Funny how a wrestler with an authenticity and body type unwanted by WWE losing matches cleanly to drive support of his babyface character resonated with fans turned off by WWE. That's what AEW is, and it is not remotely coincidental that AEW fans gravitated towards that story. All the noise was rendered just that in December 2023: noise, made by obnoxious bad-faith actors, to which AEW should never have listened in the first place.

Advertisement

While it probably wasn't the best idea - Andrade el Idolo had wanted out for a while, and wound down his contract after Worlds End - he too was recharged throughout the Continental Classic. Countless AEW wrestlers won three matches on the spin throughout 2023, but Andrade's really seemed to count in the context of the tournament. He enjoyed his best spell by some distance in an AEW run defined by how fitful and uneven it was. He was supported, and elevated, by the sporting framework.

What follows is a list of achievements made by AEW since launching on January 1, 2019:

Advertisement

AEW has promoted 25 pay-per-views - a medium thought dead five years ago - two of which in conjunction with New Japan Pro Wrestling. Just one has dipped below 100,000 buys. AEW annihilated NXT in the Wednesday Night War that was launched to see them off.

AEW after over four years remains a huge cable TV success, and while cable TV itself is at its lowest ebb ever, AEW can do little about that. They can only beats what is put in front of them, and, as touted by WBD, they were top five in the key demo on no less than 50 occasions throughout 2023. The expansion of the pay-per-view schedule hasn't proved detrimental - at 134,000 buys, Worlds End was more successful than tentpole events Full Gear and Revolution - and that is because AEW has cultivated a very committed base of fans.

Advertisement

There's still a creeping sense that AEW isn't what it was, that the feeling isn't quite there, but it's not exactly reflected in the numbers.

CONT'D...(4 of 5)

Advertisement
AEW

The crazy thing is that these real, in many cases objective successes, don't register as such. So much obnoxious, deafening white noise drowns it all out. Yes, AEW arguably legitimately broke the all-time attendance record for pro wrestling, but Tony Khan will never make it in the big leagues by burying Jinder Mahal's booking on Twitter. That's small-time thinking!

Advertisement

What?

Tony Khan promoted All In: London! You'd have to actually build Paul Pfeiffer's viral one million-seater stadium design to do something more impressive than that.

Advertisement

B*llocks to these people. WWE's monopoly simply broke the minds of many people who had a coiled turd on top of their brain stem to begin with. What's become of pro wrestling conversation is the dismal, exhausting equivalent of fans of a popular music act angry that an alternative act has sold a few records. Why care. Why care. Why care. Alternatives exist everywhere. It's an indictment of the industry that this wasn't the case in US wrestling for so long.

The only people who matter are the fans, and AEW fans did in fact put their money where their mouths were - the C2 was a relative ratings triumph on Saturday nights - and it's time AEW continued to restore the feeling by bringing back the rankings system.

Advertisement

AEW was right all along to believe that the sought-after millennial demo was old enough to deal with their favourite characters losing clean within a sporting framework that didn't rely on cheap, carny tricks - and that vision is still true five years on.