Why WWE Fans Love Michael Cole Now

Why are wrestling fans suddenly appreciating Cole's brilliance?

By Andrew Pollard /

With one quip at this year's SummerSlam, Michael Cole perfectly summed up the groundswell of fan support he's been receiving these days.

Advertisement

After Corey Graves proclaimed how he liked Cole better when he wasn't allowed to have an opinion, the 53-year-old immediately hit back with, "That's changed. A lot's changed". Yes, Michael, yes it has.

Having first arrived in the then-World Wrestling Federation back in 1997, the real-life Sean Michael Coulthard was handed the Michael Cole moniker and initially tasked with conducting backstage interviews. From there, he'd do voiceover work, host LiveWire, and would slowly start to cement himself as part of the company's commentary team. Throughout so much of the New York native's 25-year career with WWE, though, Cole has found himself lambasted and ridiculed by certain wrestling fans.

Here in 2022, the tide seems to have turned on that front. With each passing week, more and more people are pouring plentiful praise on Michael. In fact, coming out of the aforementioned SummerSlam show, one of the major talking points has been just how great a job Cole did on the call.

What's the reason for this change of heart amongst wrestling fans? Well, that's what we're here to discuss.

5. He's No Longer Viewed As Jim Ross' Replacement

For some, one of the main reasons why they didn't particularly care for Michael Cole and his work was, quite simply, because he was not Jim Ross.

Advertisement

Having been in the role of a full-time commentator as far back as 1977, good ol' JR is viewed by many as the greatest to ever do it. When thinking of favourite wrestling memories of yesteryear, Ross is the voice you so often hear over the action. Not just that, but the Oklahoma native added so much to such moments due to the words he chose and the way in which he delivered them.

So, when Cole was the one to step in and start filling in for Jim at times, that irked those who viewed JR as the voice of their childhood. To those people, Michael Cole could've delivered exemplary commentary during a broadcast, while performing brain surgery at the same time as he was splitting the atom and giving you the winning lottery numbers from the future... and the masses still wouldn't be happy.

The point is, no matter what Cole did or said, the hard truth is that he wasn't Jim Ross.

Of course, it's hugely unfair to compare Cole to Ross, and the former war correspondent should've always been judged on his own merit rather than being unfairly dumped on for being the man to replace the WWE Hall of Famer. That issue only obviously got worse when Michael Cole fully ousted Jim Ross to become the lead announcer on weekly programming and PPVs, but now it appears that fans have finally gotten over the fact that Cole took a spot that was Ross' for the longest time.

4. Jerry Lawler's On-Air Health Scare

10 September 2012 is a day that few wrestling fans will ever forget. There, on Monday Night Raw, Jerry Lawler suffered a heart attack on live television. Of course, at the King's side that night, was Michael Cole.

Advertisement

It may only be in recent months that the WWE audience has fully started to embrace Cole, but that on-air scene of near-tragedy is one that had even the biggest Michael Cole detractors feeling nothing but pure empathy for the man. There, the nowadays 53-year-old not only had to experience the sight of one of his close friends collapsing due to cardiac arrest, but he then had to stay at the announce desk, commentate on several more matches, and was tasked with providing fans with real-time updates on the status of Lawler.

In regards to that status, CPR was performed on Jerry, seven attempts were made to shock the WWE Hall of Famer's heart back into action, and that heart at one point didn't beat for 22 whole minutes.

While Cole did eventually sit in shocked silence throughout the final part of that Raw episode, that didn't take away from the trauma he went through on that Monday night. For that, even his biggest critics had to soften their stance on Michael Cole - even if just for one evening.

3. The Beast In The East

The Beast in the East was a 2015 WWE Network special which emanated from Ryƍgoku Sumo Hall in Tokyo, Japan. While the majority of matches on the card received plentiful praise - particularly Chris Jericho vs. Neville, and Kevin Owens vs. Finn Balor - one other element of the show that was warmly received was Michael Cole's commentary.

Advertisement

By this point in time, Cole had long been viewed as the generic WWE voice who battered audiences with Vince McMahon buzzwords and a sanitised commentary that rarely offered anything of genuine note to the in-ring action and instead was overflowing with plugs and recaps. For all accounts and purposes, the New York native was Vince's surrogate who spouted exactly what McMahon wanted the watching audience to hear.

So, when Vinny Mac opted against making the trip out to Tokyo for The Beast in the East, fans were left stunned by how darn impressive Michael Cole was. Without VKM constantly berating him down his ear, Cole produced a performance that felt more natural, more fresh and more stripped back. He and partner Byron Saxton left the wrestling to speak for itself at times, never being scared to sit out in silence if called for, rather than constantly filling the air and taking away from the grappling.

With this one show, fans started to realise that, despite their long-standing feelings, Michael Cole may not actually be all that bad. Rather than him, it was Vince McMahon who was the real problem for WWE commentary.

2. The Pat McAfee Effect

Right now, one could argue that Pat McAfee is the most entertaining act in the entire WWE. He may 'just' be a commentator - for the most part, at least - but McAfee brings an energy and passion to the product that is unmatched.

Advertisement

Along with that energy and passion, the former NFL star has also allowed Michael Cole to have, well, fun.

When watching SmackDown these days, you can absolutely tell that Cole is having a blast at the side of McAfee. Pat has the same sort of a vibe that a kid has when left to their own devices in a sweet shop; he is ecstatic to be where he is, he gets excited at everything he sees, and there's a genuineness and everyman charm prevalent that makes you immediately root for him.

Pat forces any commentary colleague to loosen the proverbial tie, to unbutton the proverbial top button. Even if Cole wanted to remain stoic and serious at all times, it would be impossible to do so when your partner in crime is gyrating on the announce desk and playing air guitar while Shinsuke Nakamura makes his way to the ring.

By accident or design, the presence of Pat McAfee has forced Michael Cole to be more natural and laid back, and two have become a legitimate highlight of weekly WWE programming.

1. The Prospect Of No More Vince McMahon

While the retirement of Vincent Kennedy McMahon offers up the chance for genuine change across a wide array of WWE matters, it also throws up the likelihood that Michael Cole is only going to remain a firm favourite amongst fans.

Advertisement

As part of the aforementioned double act with Pat McAfee, Cole was naturally not leaning as heavy in the Vince-isms so often associated with WWE commentary over the decades. This new attitude and approach for Michael has started to shine through across recent months with McMahon in charge, so one has to only think his energy and exuberance will only become even more prevalent now that Vince has been forced to walk away from WWE under a cloud of shame and controversy.

Already in the immediate aftermath of VKM's WWE exit, Cole has been quick to bandy around previously banned words like "wrestler" and "wrestling fans" on TV, and here's hoping that means no more "local medical facility" and an outright refusal to say "championship belt".

So, if you're loving what you've been seeing and hearing from Michael Cole lately, you should be extremely excited at what lies on the horizon for the veteran broadcaster.

Advertisement