Why WWE Has Lost 1 Million Viewers
This year's Raw after WrestleMania was a box office bomb.
Last week's Raw after WrestleMania viewing figures weren't a disaster for WWE, but they were an embarrassment.
The show scored a 2.02 from 2,924,000 viewers, making it the brand's most-watched show since 15 February, which drew an audience of only 2,000 fewer. One might look at the 10.7% increase on the previous week's numbers and consider this a minor success, but no. Last year's post-WrestleMania Raw attracted an audience of 3,903,000. That's a decline of over 25%, and it came on the back of a 'Show Of Shows' that most fans seemed to enjoy.
Some of the slump can be attributed to this year's Raw going head-to-head with the NCAA men's basketball tournament finals, which pulled 19,630,000. For comparison's sake, 2018's Raw after 'Mania, which didn't face NCAA competition, achieved a 14.4% increase on the previous year.
SmackDown fared even worse than the red brand, and did so without basketball as a convenient excuse. The Tuesday show slumped to 2,199,0000. This represents a 26% fall on the previous year and, unlike Raw, the viewership is largely in-line with what Team Blue has been doing all year. There was no post-WrestleMania bump for a show that is generally regarded as WWE's most consistent.
This is bad, bad news, particularly when considering what went down at WrestleMania 35.
CONT'd...
This year's 'Showcase Of The Immortals' was one of WWE's most fan-focused in years. Becky Lynch, Seth Rollins, and Kofi Kingston all walked out as babyface World Champions after major wins over pushed uber-heels. There were hometown (or hometown-adjacent) victories for Curt Hawkins and Zack Ryder, Carmella, and more. Sure, Kurt Angle got flattened on his way out, Triple H vs. Batista felt glacial, and the show was entirely too long, but its booking was largely calibrated for pops.
So why, then, have post-WrestleMania Raw and SmackDown ratings cratered in the aftermath of what should've been a re-energising show, even for the most cynical WWE Universe members?
Before we begin, a deconstruction of the counterarguments.
The first of these is that Raw's decline doesn't matter because it was still the number one rated cable show in the country. Choosing this hill to die on reeks of WWE apologism, because nobody within the promotion is comforted by news that they're outdoing sitcom repeats and late-night talk shows. Yes, TV ratings are sliding across the board, but the real story is that WWE have haemorrhaged 1 million viewers in a single year. Your competitors' inability to maintain a steady audience doesn't excuse your own, particularly when yours is demonstrably worse.
That cable numbers are slumping everywhere is another popular counterargument, but here's the thing about that one: WWE's are cratering at a faster rate than anything else.
CONT'd...
With thanks to the excellent Brandon Thurston of Wrestlenomics for sourcing the following graph from WWE's KPIs:-
This shows that WWE television performed significantly worse than everything else in Q4 2018, and the trend makes it hard to bet against similar numbers when the company's Q1 2019 financials come out on 25 April.
Similarly flimsy is the basketball argument. WWE drew almost 1 million more viewers the last time they went head-to-head with the NCAA (2017) in this slot, so while said competition can be used to excuse some of the lost viewers, it doesn't cover them all.
WWE still care dearly about their TV ratings, no matter how the internet responds whenever these figures come out. Television rights fees, advertising, and sponsorship accounted for $484.4 million of their $930.2 million in 2018. They're still dependent on it, and with reports that new network Fox will expect viewership figures of around 3.5m when SmackDown moves to Friday nights in October, boosting these numbers will be one of Vince McMahon's biggest challenges in 2019.
The Raw after WrestleMania used to be an easy home run that guaranteed a boosted audience; its palpable decline tells us much about the company's shrinking viewership as a whole.
CONT'd...
WWE's post-'Mania Raw is supposed to be special. It's one of the most anticipated shows of the year, not only because it marks the start of WWE's new "season" of programming and fresh starts for everyone after the previous night's shenanigans, but also for its surprises.
The 2003 edition brought Goldberg's long-awaited WWE debut and electric confrontation with his first opponent, The Rock. Fans were treated to one of the best Money In The Bank cash-ins ever ten years later, as Dolph Ziggler took Alberto Del Rio's World Heavyweight Championship. 2012 saw Brock Lesnar return for the first time in close to a decade, 2002 brought the brand extension's birth, and 2014 gave us Paige's shocking main roster call-up and Divas Title win.
In 2019, we got Lars Sullivan, Sami Zayn, a short Undertaker segment, and, err, a Chad Gable/Bobby Roode heel turn. Fun moments, but not what fans have been conditioned to expect from this show.
SmackDown was even duller, with Drew McIntyre and Braun Strowman's vacations from Raw the night's only eye-openers.
The audience can no longer rely on the Raw and SmackDown after WrestleMania to deliver its old promises. Now, the only thing these shows guarantee are victory laps for the likes of Rollins, Lynch, and Kingston, and a smattering of house show-calibre matches ahead of WWE's new post-'Mania priority: the Superstar Shake-Up.
Vince McMahon's bloated creative team can't even use these shows to establish new feuds and set wrestlers off in exciting new directions anymore, because everything changes the next week. What's the point in setting up Rollins' first Universal Title challenger when said opponent could be shifted to SmackDown seven days later? It doesn't work, and this is a huge reason behind the post-WrestleMania Raw's decline.
CONT'd...
In emphasising the Shake-Up over everything else, WWE are telling you that the Raw after 'Mania doesn't matter as much as it used to. A shame, but a potentially unavoidable shame.
WrestleMania's fallout is the operative time to hold this mini-draft because everybody should be looking for a fresh start after the 'Show Of Shows,' which remains WWE's season finale, and there's no better way to give a wrestler that than by having them move home. Hold it in May or June and WWE would be faced with an elongated version of the one currently faced by wrestlers in that week-long gap between 'Mania and the Shake-Up itself: performers would be left spinning their wheels in placeholder storylines because they could be on the move a few months later.
Such is life when your roster is split in two.
There's no obvious solution to this. Holding the Shake-Up on the post-'Mania Raw and SmackDown shows would be chaos. Scrapping the brand split outright isn't an option, as it would leave swathes of WWE Superstars stuck with nothing to do and destroy all parity between the company's two main roster shows. Going back to the days of big, game-changing surprises would certainly help, but how many big, game-changing surprises do WWE have left to deliver in 2019? There's no Goldberg or Lesnar to call on to return. The Rob Van Dams and f*cking Carlitos of the world are all that's left.
Indeed, the Superstar Shake-Up makes it nigh-on impossible for the Raw after WrestleMania to ever reclaim its lost lustre. WWE have adjusted their priorities, and while there are plenty of things they could've done to jazz this year's shows up (debuting the Undisputed Era, for one), their mystique is gone forever.
Shocking debuts and big call-ups are the past; beach balls and AEW chants are the future.
CONT'd...
The usual factors behind WWE's long-standing ratings crisis feed into this as well.
The key issue is that Vince McMahon is selling a product as cold as VHS tapes, Google+, and Doritos 3D. His audience is down to the hardcores. WrestleMania remains a destination event that attracts tens of thousands to whatever host city the Chairman chooses, but the zeitgeist moved on from professional wrestling decades ago. It isn't "cool" or "hip" anymore, and it'll never be that again.
WWE's propensity for spoiling surprises by advertising them ahead of time has destroyed the idea that "anything can happen." Raw's colossal runtime remains a valuable ad revenue money-spinner, but a weekly third-hour viewership drop-off shows that it still wears viewers out. Established flaws in the company's storytelling mechanisms, a dearth of star power, stale formulae, and a host of other problems also play roles.
This is a Vince McMahon problem. His company has a $1 billion TV deal on the horizon, and their new benefactors won't be happy if SmackDown can't improve on its weekly 2 million viewers. Vince must find ways not only to stop the rot, but to reverse it, boost his numbers by 50%, and deliver a return on Fox's investment.
Q4 2019 will tell us whether or not he is successful in what looks like a hopeless endeavour. If he is, it should go down as one of his career's greatest triumphs.