Why WWE Is Hot And AEW Is Cold

Triple H is beating Tony Khan in 2023...but does Tony Khan *really* want to win?

By Michael Sidgwick /

WWE.com

WWE is hot.

Advertisement

The Bloodline saga is the primary driver behind the resurgence, though Cody Rhodes is doing great numbers at the box office and in the Nielsens on the Raw brand. Record gates are set every week. Arenas are quiet more often than not, and the dissonance is strange, but these people are buying tickets in staggeringly impressive all the same.

AEW, meanwhile, is cold.

Advertisement

The seat maps on multiple WrestleTix Twitter posts are heavy on blue. Last week's Dynamite slumped to the worst demo number in three years. Double Or Nothing, despite an electrifying last hour or so, was notable for its empty seats and comparatively flat atmosphere. Collision did a Rampage number three weeks in. A red-hot crowd is no longer a selling point of new alternative on the rise, a guaranteed weekly occurrence. PPV numbers are still fantastic, and late surges in ticket sales aren't uncommon where they were previously. Perhaps this reflects where AEW is at; the base connects with what has become an uneven product in a pattern as fitful as its quality output.

Dave Meltzer of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter has a theory, one supported by history. Whenever WWE gets hot, every other US promotion suffers. The more critically acclaimed Jim Crockett Promotions was ultimately mauled by the glitzy big time of Hulkamania, and by early 1999, the red-hot WWF turned the Monday Night Wars into a massacre.

Advertisement

Is it as simple as the promotion with more reach and visibility actually making use of its inherent advantage in the market, and AEW feeling smaller in comparison?

Production values and the optics of looking "big" matter a lot. Stars and stories are more important, as is the ability to strike the zeitgeist, but the big-time feeling matters. While Roman Reigns returning at SummerSlam helped, the introduction of the ThunderDome bolstered ratings on Raw as well. The idea that WWE belatedly looked as big as it could in the pandemic era boosted numbers in contrast to the über-bleak confines of the Performance Center. WWE feels big and is becoming bigger. AEW hasn't done many panoramic shots on TV very often in 2023 and feels in scope like the distant number two. The perception becomes reality truth is manifesting to a degree.

Advertisement

AEW however isn't just cold because WWE is hot.

CONT'D...(1 of 5)

Advertisement
WWE.com

That is a strong if all too simplistic argument, one that almost suggests that there's little the blameless AEW can do about it, and with Steve Austin and Goldberg on top, both the WWF and WCW were ultra-competitive for much of 1998.

Advertisement

WWE has clawed back the fans predisposed to enjoying the product by making the product better and more coherent. The Bloodline saga has earned back their trust; they believe the storyline is compelling, that it has a firm, unwavering trajectory that they cannot predict but wish to see unfold. Even if you find the ac-ting very broad, the cinema comparisons laughable, it is wildly successful and twist-heavy.

People want to enjoy the WWE product. Think about this: across the 2010s, Vince McMahon gave viewers multiple opportunities to run away. Many did, of course - so many that AEW became viable as an alternative - but it was so antagonistic at its worse and decelerated so much that were lucky to find a floor.

Advertisement

WWE is easier to watch. That might read as nonsense to some, given the nauseating camera cuts and hysterical commentary, but it isn't an ambitious product in which investment is difficult.

The Judgment Day are a productive unit; everybody involved has been elevated to a far stronger position than they were this time last year. Triple H's TV might be boring and repetitive and cheap a lot of the time, but he gets the basics right. Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn are the beloved cult favourites who made it big at last, in an echo of his best work at the helm of NXT. Watching several long title reigns isn't the most electrifying viewing experience week to week, but it all adds up to something more than three dry hours of Monday Night Raw. In going long with GUNTHER, Roman Reigns, and for a while there Bianca Belair, Triple H has conditioned his audience to take a handful of regular cast members seriously as winners and stars. This isn't remotely complicated, but it's demonstrably effective. The idea that these great champions, and Austin Theory, will one day be toppled is a fruitful one.

Advertisement

CONT'D...(2 of 5)

AEW

The Bloodline saga is enormously successful soap opera tacked onto wrestling, which at this point is secondary. The action is a backdrop to the storytelling in the Bloodline saga. The ref bump happens in every single Roman Reigns match, every single one, to enable the acting in the soap opera. The cinema comparisons are mocked in some circles because the story is very easy to understand. There is not a hint of ambiguity to it. It's mass-consumption stuff that has reached what passes for a mass wrestling audience in 2023. "Wrestling audience" is actually incorrect. With the unadulterated soap opera that is the Bloodline stuff, WWE has appealed to the WWE fans who like WWE first and wrestling second. There is no competition for that market, as TNA discovered in the 2000s. It is WWE's alone. AEW cannot crack it and show no signs of wanting to crack it.

Advertisement

WWE appeals to and seeks a massive audience. AEW does not, by design.

AEW is the alternative to the broad strokes of WWE, and uses a sprawling, rotating cast to tell more patient, wrestling-centric stories across the board. Many stories are advanced indirectly - as a somewhat recent example, consider the MJF Vs. Bryan Danielson feud. The challenger had to win a series of competitive challenges to earn a shot. As part of this arc, Danielson worked Timothy Thatcher, and with all due respect to a wrestler beloved by fans of the grapplef*ck style as a demigod, if AEW wanted to be number one, to appeal to the biggest possible audience, Tony Khan would not have booked that match.

Advertisement

Part of the AEW Vs. WWE story, that goes under-mentioned too often, is that Khan can't possibly mind being the steadily successful number two passion project. He'd have compromised his booking vision long ago, were that case. You don't win "ratings wars" with Timothy Thatcher. Khan knows this.

That said, AEW has lost some of its own audience for reasons that have little to do with WWE's success or his own bold hardcore fan-friendly approach. AEW can in theory tap into a bigger audience that enjoys pro wrestling first - they threatened to do precisely that in August of 2021 - but haven't done so in some time.

Advertisement

AEW is cold because, frankly, the promotion is not doing a good enough job.

CONT'D...(3 of 5)

Advertisement
AEW

Revolution was a huge sleeper hit of a PPV; as Meltzer pointed out, acclaim for the show and in particular the main event was so strong that people bought it well into the third and fourth week after it aired, which rarely happens. What followed next was not great.

Advertisement

MJF proved himself a worthy AEW World champion by drawing, but the Four Pillars storyline was a decided if noble failure. Fans did not buy Jack Perry and Sammy Guevara in main event slots. Guevara's promo work was weird, and while he wasn't a heel masquerading as a babyface - he was building his face turn and eventual programme with Chris Jericho in plain sight - the plotting was probably too ambitious. There was a narrative elegance to it all, in retrospect, but it was fussy. Busy. Bluntly, people would rather have watched a strong singles PPV challenger than watch what ultimately amounted to chapters in the long-term character arcs of Guevara and Perry. Too often this year, AEW has lost sight of immediate big match drama. It's no coincidence that Forbidden Door was the most anticipated show AEW has promoted all year. While this may read as counterintuitive for the episodic TV model, Tony Khan has spent too long wondering what is next, and as a result, a not inconsiderable portion of his TV viewership seems happy to miss out on what is happening now. The destination is too elusive, and AEW builds towards too many of them.

Elsewhere, the promotion is being carried by the Elite Vs. the Blackpool Combat Club storyline. Incredible between the ropes, as a larger story, something is missing. Again, it's too intricate for its own good. Somewhere along the way, between the mystery of who is aligned with whom and where Don Callis fit into everything, the all-important premise was forgotten. Why do these characters hate each other, and why should people care?

Advertisement

The core idea is too loose. Obviously, the BCC are surrogates for CM Punk and his perception of the Elite as "amateurs", but it never felt real coming out of Bryan Danielson's mouth. The programme has functioned as the latest backdrop for the ongoing Elite saga, and this is especially pronounced now that the Dark Order have crept into the narrative. Only the most forgiving Elite nerds care about that dangling plot thread, and even this one is exhausted by it.

Most of AEW's best stars have been consumed by a rivalry that felt like a political compromise from the off, and now that Jon Moxley is more preoccupied with Eddie Kingston than his supposed philosophical enemies, it feels like even less of a concern to the characters involved. AEW was once majestic at weaving various plot threads together.

Advertisement

CONT'D...(4 of 5)

WWE.com

Now, Mox cares more about Kingston than the Elite, Kenny Omega cares more about Don Callis than the Blackpool Combat Club, and all of this is happening weeks before the big blow-off at Blood & Guts. AEW's main event programme feels more convoluted and over-thought than layered and fascinating. Urgent, immediate animosity is lacking. It feels too clever and intricate for its own good.

Advertisement

It just isn't direct or urgent enough in 2023, AEW. Collision promises a more direct, simplified vision, but given the promotion's wider issues, was launched at the worst possible time.

This might read as WWE = direct and basic, AEW = too complicated for thickos, but that really isn't the argument being made here. AEW isn't high art; if it were, Matt Hardy wouldn't be messing about with his excruciating contract nonsense. AEW does reward a closer watch, but it's not so hard to follow that it's alienating. It is simply a wrestling-heavy promotion with a huge rotating cast that isn't presenting urgent, unmissable television with any one seminal storyline that is captivating the viewers who were enchanted by the product in the summer of 2021 - and now it is spreading itself thin, furthering deepening its niche. It's good, but it isn't Kenny Omega Vs. Hangman Page or CM Punk Vs. MJF good. When AEW rediscovers that level of brilliance, it might enter a new growth period.

Advertisement

A great product that promises to become better in the minds of the audience is the key. That's why AEW did such great business ahead of and shortly after All Out 2021. That's why WWE are on fire with the slow collapse of Roman Reigns. The fans love what they're watching and expect it to get better, and the better part is in sight. That last part is crucial - the idea that what follows next is as close as it is momentous. AEW fans are into what they're watching but feel like the product, for now at least, has peaked. To use a more historical example, the WWF in late 2000 started to stagnate before WrestleMania X-Seven, the poor build to which has been masked forever by a great sit-down interview and Limp Bizkit song. Steve Austin wasn't going to get any better.

One promotion is hot and the other is cold not because one is doing a better job of reaching the same available audience, but because one promotion is better serving their base than the other.

Advertisement