Why WWE Is Making Its Biggest Long-Term Mistake Right Now

A WrestleMania X-Seven-sized heel turn.

By Michael Sidgwick /

WWE.com

You will read what is at its core a very reasonable take on Thursday mornings.

Advertisement

"Crazy concept, guys, but you can enjoy both shows!"

This, again, is very reasonable. Both AEW Dynamite and NXT, irrespective of which style of presentation one might prefer, boast objectively great qualities. AEW fans love Dynamite for its intricate long-term booking, traditional pro wrestling vibe, tonal range and creative expression. NXT fans love the product for its pulsating modern in-ring fare and its intersection of logical storytelling and slick, soothing WWE production, highlighted most recently by the stunning presentation of the sky-scraping Karrion Kross.

Advertisement

Both shows are exponentially better on an artistic level than the generic, formulaic and broad - all too often, that is a euphemism for punishingly lame - fare on WWE's main roster.

But the point is that this isn't some four-hour celebration of wrestling. This isn't, as has been made rather clear in 2020, some philosophical war waged between professional wrestling and sports entertainment. This isn't Wednesday Vs. Monday. This is WWE Vs. any other promotion that dares exist. Two of those hours exist to slowly suffocate the other two hours to death.

Advertisement

Party!

CONT'D...(1 of 6)

Advertisement
AEW (Ricky Havlik)

There is an incredibly basic babyface versus heel psychology to this "war" that does, in fact, make one show harder to enjoy than in years previous. WWE counter-programmed an AEW charity show well before NXT even made the move to Wednesday nights, for f*ck's sake. You're meant to cheer the babyfaces and boo the heels. Just because WWE warped that dynamic forever many years ago, doesn't mean it no longer applies.

Advertisement

Parallels are understandably drawn to the fabled Monday Night Wars. Both sides played dirty. The WWF buried WCW's roster as dinosaurs in defensive skits; WCW gave away the results of the taped Monday Night RAW. Triple H referred to AEW as a pissant company decades later; Cody broke his throne in response. The year 1997 is often cited as something incredible that would have been even more so, in retrospect, had tribalism not lessened what was a thrilling experience across both channels. Surely, the lessons imparted by WWE's subsequent monopoly inform the perspective we should all bring to this new war.

WCW lost the old war because it was multifariously, institutionally, and comically inept. The creative tipping point, however, arrived in 1999, at which point the company, bereft entirely of ideas, let go of its identity and attempted to react almost entirely to what the competition was doing.

Advertisement

Does this feel familiar?

CONT'D...(2 of 6)

Advertisement
WWE.com

How can you be aware of NXT UK and think that WWE's approach to NXT, post-October 2019, is remotely a good thing?

Advertisement

If NXT continues to win the battle for overall viewership - really, the Thursday fallout is at present an optics battle perceived as the loss that it is the by TV industry - it will represent a pyrrhic victory.

The greatest trick NXT pulled was convincing the world it wasn't a WWE show. And now that it so nakedly is, it is, yes, harder to enjoy. NXT once marketed itself, perfectly, as an alternative to WWE. It felt like Triple H was conspiring, in a secret we were all in on, to reimagine WWE's future without the knowledge of Vince McMahon.

Advertisement

NXT used to be the nice show as much as it was the good show. This is a key misconception. The rise of Bayley, Sami Zayn, American Alpha and #DIY illustrated the core appeal of the old NXT. It was a babyface promotion that told endearing and euphoric babyface stories through the medium of scintillating professional wrestling worked in a gear the main roster didn't. NXT was feel-good professional wrestling. This mutated into a dry quest for critical acclaim, around 2018, and what we are left with now is another quest entirely.

Now it's the show that functions exclusively and transparently to kill off the new nice and good show. NXT is harder to enjoy than ever because they've turned the f*cker heel. They have. Your writer doesn't like it any more than you do. But it's hard to "enjoy both" when one show exists now - crucially, to its detriment - as this reactive weapon.

Advertisement

CONT'D...(3 of 6)

WWE.com

Perhaps it's unfair to acknowledge the machinations of how the show comes together. Perhaps it's more fair to park it and just watch the show itself. The talent probably can't be bothered with this constant narrative, either, but NXT's defensive approach has infected the quality of the programme.

Advertisement

The general and fierce vibe of desperation is as much to blame as the canonically nonsensical and cynical main roster appearances. When was last time a RAW or SmackDown main event had limited commercial interruption?

The Great American Bash only happened in reaction to AEW Fyter Fest. The sudden, reactive marketing was as pathetic as it was ugly. The second night was headlined by Adam Cole Vs. Keith Lee in a Winner Take All match, and it was a very good if very NXT match in its tropes - wouldn't it be more of a huge shock if an NXT wrestler didn't kick out of a finish at this point? - but how much did it resonate as an earned, feel-good story, really? There was no struggle, no build, no organic peak. It was nice, and it was merited, but it wasn't truly life-affirming. It felt like a belated and synthetic emulation of that which NXT once excelled. This match was consistent with NXT's entire approach to the war. Adam Cole Vs. Matt Riddle - the NXT Champion Vs. NXT's most popular babyface - was a TakeOver-sized match, the TakeOver-sized match, looking at Cole's underwhelming run, and it was the very first segment that went head-to-head with AEW Dynamite. This NXT is no longer interested in telling stories on its own terms. It is driven entirely by what AEW does.

Advertisement

It is not at all dissimilar to 1999 WCW trying its hand at the sports entertainment of the WWF.

CONT'D...(4 of 6)

Advertisement
WWE.com

This is an extension of the "separating the art from the artist" debate that most fandoms struggle with. WWE is an horrific company on a moral basis. NXT, once this lovely fan service outlier, is now just another mechanism of its ugliness. It is petty and spiteful and the lack of true storytelling substance bears that out. AEW was meant to sharpen NXT - competition is great because it makes everything better - but NXT has regressed by reacting.

Advertisement

Ratings discourse is making online wrestling fandom a miserable experience. But if this thing all began in a bid to determine the best WWE main roster alternative (it didn't), one side is totally annihilating the other.

That's the lede here.

Advertisement

NXT is longer the alternative if, in fact, it ever was. Charlotte Flair's cynical run in NXT yielded more or less nothing. Io Shirai did not vanquish this great threat from the NXT of old. She beat Rhea Ripley, something she could have done had Charlotte Flair never returned to Full Sail. There was no definitive transition to prove that the modern scene had left the old division in the dust, and it took a lot of anticlimactic, weightless, screwy booking to get there. Dexter Lumis is a cartoonish outsize character who lacks the proper working finesse to fit into the brand. He is a main roster act, if there ever was one. Remember that vignette they ran of KUSHIDA, in which he was framed as NXT's next great babyface hope?

Few others do. Even before the ongoing global situation, he was relegated to also-ran in the Cruiserweight division.

Advertisement

CONT'D...(5 of 6)

WWE.com

Further disqualification finishes; main roster-style distractions; repetitive feuds that peter out with no definitive winner (Tegan Nox Vs. Dakota Kai): bad comedy segments (Robert Stone vomiting): NXT is no longer not your kind.

Advertisement

NXT represented the last connection the most ardent fans had to the WWE product. The aim, remember, was to make WWE the one-stop shop for all of professional wrestling. This unfocused, desperation hot-shot booking is slowly altering its perception. People still watch it, and love it, but a certain group of people have fallen out of love. This isn't good - it is far easier to lose fans than to win them back in wrestling - and those fans were once willing to suffer through Sundays to watch the Network on Saturdays. Without Network viewership data, there's a chance romance is being conflated here with true success, but without NXT, the NXT of 2014-2019, many loyalists will simply give up - if they haven't done so already. NXT was WWE's last great artistic achievement.

NXT represented the last chance WWE had of reaching the coveted younger audience. It used to be cool. NXT with its transparent attempts at oneupmanship is now the da with the bigger shed, and the da with the bigger shed, quite fittingly, watches NXT. NXT was once the soul of WWE, and in tiresome new world in which numbers are debated and spun and flung in all directions, the most important is 21.

Advertisement

That is the number of grams WWE is slowly losing.