Why WWE SUCKS At Debuting New Stars
Debut > Decomposition > Destruction.
Every year, it’s the same.
On the post-WrestleMania RAW, and recently SmackDown, WWE debuts a new influx of performers to an international, diehard fanbase intoxicated on the rush of WrestleMania Weekend. This crowd is made up of the most ardent fans on the planet. They would recognise and erupt at the sight of even the lowliest New Japan or Ring Of Honor midcard act, much less a performer with an established presence on the Network.
This year saw No Way Jose make his RAW bow, unannounced. That was somewhat excusable. No Way Jose is a one-dimensional undercard act there only to unglue a house show crowd; there is no real character to carefully introduce. Ember Moon followed. The New Orleans crowd, many of which watched her bravely lose to Shayna Baszler at TakeOver 48 days prior, received her with a warm welcome. WWE never indicated to its more casual audience what drives Ember Moon with a follow-up vignette highlighting her NXT achievements, nor defined her character. She simply ran through some moon-associated puns a week or so later.
The Authors of Pain followed, by which time it was already difficult to care about No Way Jose. This is the first issue with WWE’s dire debut process. No Way Jose, a pure novelty act in itself, was stripped of that fresh novelty within an hour.
The Authors demolished Heath Slater and Rhyno in what, nominally, was an eye-catching performance. Still, it could not register. Eyes always wander on the RAW After WrestleMania, and those eyes quickly wandered to Samoa Joe’s intense, thunderous promo at the expense of Roman Reigns. To the untrained eye - of which there are several not trained on NXT - Akam and Rezar were mute, twinned, diluted versions of the returning Samoan Submission Machine. Somewhere in the middle of all that, Bobby Lashley made a return decades in the making. That you cannot remember when, specifically, all but confirms that he is now an indistinct part of the furniture. The entire model satisfies greed. Naturally, the audience soon grows full.
24 hours later, the more casual audience was asked to recognise yet more names in a further deluge: SAnitY, Andrade ‘Cien’ Almas, the IIConics. On the same night, though truncated, we were also presented with a buzz-stealing first-time meeting in WWE between Daniel Bryan and AJ Styles. When the landscape settles, WWE literally Shakes it up once more. None of these new characters register because they are aged instantly.
CONT'D...
It’s an effective tactic in the short term, in that each act, to varying degrees, received a star reaction. But that is the problem, in micro, for a company that struggles in macro with long-term storytelling: WWE debuted these names to guarantee effortless pops from a receptive crowd. It is left to crowds not au fait with NXT to intuit that these acts are worthy of the reaction because, in addition to the instantaneous homogenisation, WWE often fails to define these characters in the subsequent weeks, let alone develop them - let alone book them, in the inevitable diminished return of the trend.
Inevitably, WWE’s abysmal creative staff is similarly bamboozled by this careless scattergun approach. The Authors of Pain weren’t even bestowed the dubious honour of a burial because they were not invited to the funeral. With too many moving parts to cram into the repetitive copy and paste formula, that formula won out, and spat out the moving parts. SAnitY aren’t “coming soon”. They are coming once there’s space to fit them in, which really should have been established before this chaotic threat was defamed as impotent.
Every year, it’s the same.
And every year, the tactic fails.
WWE relies on its audience to infer, which is a senseless, lazy, and counterproductive promotional tactic. The key concept is promotion: WWE resolutely fails to differentiate and promote these NXT promotees.
In order to create intrigue around a debuting star, WWE must think singularly. This intrigue will not (and does not) resonate when the act is immediately stripped of its unique selling point. The promise of something new stirs something within the wrestling fan, particularly in this era of content, content, content. Debut one star - a star with the credentials to change the game - into a game that hasn’t already changed or will change yet again within the hour - and thus preserve their special aura.
When WWE first introduced Razor Ramon, in 1992, he was not joined by a fleet of fellow WCW midcarders. His promise was not diluted. He was framed as a major deal because he alone was the guy who demanded your attention. He came, he was pushed, he conquered. Once established, the cycle began anew.
CONT'D...
Razor did not simply debut on WWF Superstars. He was promoted as a Superstar in the weeks prior via an almost failsafe system that, for reasons unfathomable, is another relic of wrestling’s successful past: the introductory vignette. In these vignettes, Razor built his sinister and cool character by terrifying the staff of a restaurant he refused to pay to eat in. He bragged about his ability to bag “chicas, meng.” Razor even spelled out that he was a big deal. “I am Razor Ramon. I am somebody important, meng,” he said. Even before he stepped through the curtain, you hated him. And, when he returned to the back, the WWF had reinforced the character with a sustained and consistent push. He did not miss TV tapings because the bookers didn’t know what to do with him. He didn’t fade in relevance as a result. He was an instant mainstay.
He was somebody important.
Even when WWE debuts a new face outside of the post-WrestleMania season, the system fails. Dolph Ziggler laughed off Bobby Roode as a mere entrance. The writing staff proved him right, as Roode entered 50/50 territory as an entrance. It’s perhaps too much for WWE to expect its casual audience to watch an NXT product without a television presence. It’s certainly not too much to expect its writing staff to watch the NXT product. It’s as likely to be a comprehension issue; Roode excelled in the heel role because he was maddeningly, hysterically arrogant with just enough viciousness to anchor the ludicrousness of it all. The sudden and stupid babyface switch in itself saw Roode balloon into the realm of the goofy, and his subsequent inconsistent booking reinforced this instantly wrong development.
This NXT to main roster disconnect is profound. It’s not even irreparable. There was never a connection; WWE has simply never grasped the process. The fans are acutely aware of this. Many - the majority - have come to shudder at the prospect of an act they adore in the NXT context debuting on the main roster. How WWE have conspired to make its audience dread the debut - the debut! Something once so bulletproof we actually anticipated the arrival of Hade Vansen! - is sobering. Depressing.
The problem is not limited to the debut process, but extends also into the environment into which these stars debut. Overstuffed and shackled, the roster, without any sort of tiered main event/midcard/undercard system, is awash with great talent treading water, coalescing into a sea of irrelevance.
Staggering the process is the first step. If Andrade Almas alone debuted on SmackDown, we may have been given reason to receive him as the next big thing. Instead, Andrade Almas on SmackDown is a thing that is happening.
“They haven’t f*cked him up yet” is not a sentiment with which we should approach the character arc of one of the best wrestlers on the planet.