If you ask me, Shawn Michaels is the greatest wrestler of all time. By the late noughties his hair was receding, it had been over a decade since his theme made any sense, not to mention he had become irritatingly religious. But the second he stepped through those ropes, it was clear that the man had returned. Like many reading, I only began watching wrestling in the late 90's and had only the vaguest of notions of who 'The Showstopper' was during his classic, if totally bonkers, comeback special street fight against Triple H at Summerslam 2002. I was impressed, but wondered if the gory spectacle of that match was a one off: fueled by a man desperate to have one last hurrah and with access to enough painkillers to domesticate a hippo. But month after month he kept delivering, rarely missing the mark during that entire eight year stretch, surpassing even his famed mid-90's peak as a headliner. Seeking out Michaels' earlier work was an awakening for me. It opened my mind to different eras, different promotions, different styles. He was my gateway wrestler and the reason I'm always trying to broaden my wrestling horizons, and I still haven't seen anyone better. The wealth of first class matches under 'The Heartbreak Kid's' belt is vast, especially considering the four year break Michaels took after losing his smile/lower back function. But we all know how the boyhood dream came true. We've seen the Hell in a Cell, the ladder match, the Iron Man, so what's left for hungry HBK fans? I hope to share with you some of the lesser known classics that have graced our screens over the years. Hold on one moment, he's just tuning up the band...
10. Shawn Michaels vs Shelton Benjamin - Raw, May 2nd, 2005
Shawn Michaels vs Shelton Benjamin I love me a good tournament. Nothing gets my wrestling trousers tightened more than eight to sixteen men going at it, all night long. By which of course I mean, I think it's a simple and exciting storytelling tool. For those of you who don't remember, this was a King of the Ring style tournament to determine the number one contender for Batista's newly acquired World Heavyweight Championship. The participants also included Kane, Christian, HHH, Edge, Jericho and Benoi....The Hurricane, I'm pretty sure it was the Hurricane. I liked everything about Gold Rush: it created compelling television where you felt anybody could win, except for Christian. But none of the matches came close to the 'blink and you'll miss it' quarter final cracker between Michaels and 'Kofi Kingston of 2005', Shelton Benjamin. The very opposite of a slow burner, this is 15 minutes of non-stop action dramatically halted when Benjamin takes a stiff kick to the jaw mid-air. It's a fitting end really. Both men played chicken until one of them crashed and burned. The beauty of this bout is in their ability to make everything seem believable while going full throttle. It would be easy for them to have sold nothing and just shoot through a bunch of impressive looking maneuvers. Instead the timing here feels perfect. Anything longer than 15 minutes and they would have had to slow down or risk becoming an indie-style spot fest. Benjamin looked incredible here. It's a shame he never found the personality to take his career to the next level. But much like his stand out MITB performances, he proved that given the right circumstances he could shine with the very best.
9. Shawn Michaels vs Bret Hart - Survivor Series 1992
It doesn't take a Damien Sandow to realise why people would overlook this early episode of one of wrestling's most famous rivalries. Their 1997 Survivors match sits alongside Andre vs Hogan as one of the most famous matches of all time for all the wrong reasons. If you have no idea what I'm talking about, you must be new to all this. Hello there, if I were you I'd start with Wrestlemania 17 and work around that. Enjoy the journey and don't let the IWC put you off too much. One thing that people tend to forget due to the Montreal nonsense, perhaps because Bret Hart never stops talking about it, is that their 1997 match wasn't very good. It wasn't terrible, but it's hard to imagine Hart/Michaels dropping below decent, even if Hart was mid-stroke and Michaels had just come off a three day bender with Scott Hall. Their '92 effort on the other hand was the type of slow, satisfying match Hart made his bread and butter. The kind you rarely see in WWE these days. Indeed, watching the first ten minutes will probably leave modern fans twitching their thumbs towards the fast-forward button for the chair shots that never arrive. But with patience comes great wrestling and this delivers in spades. For me though, this match will always be remembered as the first chapter in a flawed but brilliant world title trilogy between arguably the two greatest wrestlers of the 90's.
8. Shawn Michaels vs Chris Masters - Unforgiven 2005
A masterclass in how to put over a younger talent in defeat. So good was this match that I came away convinced that walking bicep Chris Masters was a future world champion. No seriously, I really did. The story of wily old veteran vs inexperienced young powerhouse is played to perfection, with Michaels bouncing around the ring like a ragdoll, before using his wits to overcome the much younger, stronger athlete. Despite a glowing performance from Michaels, it's Masters who really impresses in his big match debut . His offense never veers far from your usual power wrestler repertoire (torture rack, backbreaker, military press), but everything he does makes sense. It's a great example of storytelling and strategy: when done correctly less really is more in wrestling. The psychology here is built around Chris' unbreakable Masterlock (full-nelson) submission hold, which he mercilessly executes at every given opportunity, even going for Michaels before the bell in an attempt to make a name for himself. For his part, The Heartbreak Kid does everything he can to make this rather tame looking move seem like a world beater: elbowing, slinking and cheating his way out of harms way with increased desperation, before hitting a last second Superkick for the victory. Most importantly, Shawn never breaks the Masterlock. He merely avoids it. The move is not only protected, it looks more devastating than ever. This should have been a platform for Masters to rise through the ranks and become a main event player. Sadly, that wasn't meant to be, so this cracking contest will remain a document of wasted potential.
7. The Rockers vs The Orient Express - Royal Rumble 1991
While The Ultimate Warrior and Sgt. Slaughter sent the audience to sleep in the world title match two of the AWA's finest teams tore it up in the Rumble's best ever opener. Still impressive by today's standards, this type of thrilling fast-paced action was rarely seen at the time. Much like the famed ladder match, Shawn and co. don't do anything new here, rather they bring their own style to the mainstream. It's something that doesn't really happen nowadays, with even experienced wrestlers forced to 'learn to wrestle the WWE way', meaning that the thrill of seeing something new is weened out before it has a chance to hit our screens. The upshot of this is the WWE deliver a professional but predictable product, one which hits the mark more often than it misses, but also where surprises are few and far between. I wonder whether if an early 90's Vince (you know the guy, he sits on commentary saying rest holds are "un-be-lievable!") had the same mentality, we'd never have seen stereo crossbody blocks for fear they didn't fit in with the product. This match is filled with moves that were positively gasp worthy for the time: suicide dives, reverse flying cross chops, moonsaults. It's a thing of beauty now. You can just imagine kids in the audience going back to school and telling their friends about the amazing spectacle they saw that night. Which is no surprise, these guys had ungodly chemistry after dozens of matches in the AWA. Tag team wrestling doesn't get much better.
6. Stone Cold & Shawn Michaels vs Owen Hart & British Bulldog - Raw, May 26th, 1997
Lost in the sea of awesomeness that was the entire Stone Cold/Hart Foundation feud of 1997, this forgotten RAW classic lands us slap bang in the middle of one of the best times to be a wrestling fan. Shawn had just returned following a four month absence after his knee gave out due to the shock of being asked to job to Bret Hart. The story here is that although Stone Cold and Michaels don't get along, they hate Bret even more. Thus began the first of Russo's patented 'tag champs who need to work together but fight outside the ring' bit. It was quite entertaining at the time, but lost its value after it was used throughout the decade. Still, the audience don't know this yet so seem quite content with everything. Which they would, being from the past. In the ring things move as smoothly as you'd expect from three of the greatest of all time, not to mention a surprisingly motivated British Bulldog. The match manages to feel chaotic without ever going full clusterfuck. Best of all is the post match angle. After winning the titles The Hart Foundation jump Shawn, at which point Stone Cold decides that's not really his problem and beelines for Bret instead, who'd been stood watching the match like a dastardly Canadian general. The whole thing feels like a perfect moment in time: D Generation X, Montreal and the era of Stone Cold were just around the corner. The wrestling world would never be the same.
5. Shawn Michaels vs Triple H - Raw, December 29th, 2003
For a long time I didn't understand why this feud left me cold. For the most part I enjoyed their matches. They had great chemistry, the story suited and I'm a bigger HHH fan than most. But whenever I heard those names put together, I never felt the least bit excited. Around 40 minutes into their seemingly endless HIAC match at Bad Blood '04, I realised what it was. They were trying too hard. In an attempt to force this feud into the realm of classics, every one-on-one battle they had was overloaded with gimmicks and its importance pushed to exhausting levels by commentary. Their Armageddon bout in particular is overkill personified. This is perhaps why their Raw 2003 championship match stands so tall amongst their back catalogue. Stripped of excessive hype, gimmicks and the pressure of a headline PPV spot, the former DX members tear the house down with nearly 30 minutes of old-school rasslin'. Well, not quite. The match is still overbooked, complete with Flair interference and a Dusty finish. But everything that happens between the ropes until then is solid gold. Even HHH's usual "wear-down" sequence feels exciting in front of a red-hot San Antonio crowd, who go apeshit for every perfectly timed HBK comeback. The pop for Shawn's win is ear-splitting, only for Bischoff to take the belt away following a double-pin. I think they were trying to achieve something on par with Jericho's beautifully orchestrated 'phantom' title win in 2000, but it just came off as tedious. Crappy ending aside, this is one of the best Raw matches in history.
Advertisement
4. Shawn Michaels vs Ric Flair - Prime Time Wrestling, December 12th, 1991
Long before Michaels love-kicked Flair into temporary retirement the showstopper in the making was taking it to The Nature Boy, who was on his way towards his classic '92 rumble win. You would think on historical value alone, this would be one of the most famous matches in Shawn's early career. Actually, this battle between two bona-fide legends was first shown on RAW precursor Prime Time Wrestling and is only commercially available on weird compilation video Invasion '92. How weird you ask? Weird as balls. Weird enough to have part time commentator Sean Mooney present the thing through the least funny Star Trek parody ever. I suppose this was doomed to obscurity the second Vince set his phasers to retard. At only ten minutes long, this isn't quite up to the standard of their Wrestlemania 24 classic, but it's still great fun and well worth going out of your way to watch. The match features some great chain wrestling, with Michaels made to look every bit Flair's equal. For his part, The Nature Boy does all his signature spots and sells generously for the soon to be ex-Rocker, even allowing a few near falls for the rising singles star. The commentary here is just awful, made even worse by some awkward legal issues with Flair still carrying around the big gold belt and calling himself the "real world champion". Which led to WCW suing the bejesus out of everything Flair touched. So Lord Alfred and Spaceman Sean Mooney awkwardly skirt around the subject and at one point go completely silent for about nine seconds, while someone presumably gives them a bollocking over the headset. But that's pretty much the only bad thing I can say about this match, which is as good as could be expected for the timeslot. It's interesting to see Shawn in the position of being elevated by an established star. He got lucky in that respect. Arguably nobody is better than Flair at putting talent over. The end comes when Perfect pulls Flair out of harms way leading Michaels to get KO'd onto the guardrail. Party Marty then ran down to ringside and pushed his lifeless partner into the ring, presumably to give him chance to mount a comeback. Instead Flair pins him with his legs on the ropes: cheating even when his opponent is out cold. Classic Flair. Classic Michaels too, for that matter.
Advertisement
3. Shawn Michaels vs British Bulldog - One Night Only 1997
This was part of UK PPV One Night Only, which was so far off the hook you wouldn't even be able to throw your coat on it from where the show was stood. You would just have to put the coat down and deal with it later... or other, better hook related sentences. Honestly, I would give my left testicle to see a UK WWE show this good nowadays. Actually maybe not my left one, that's my favourite, but the right one as far as I'm concerned is ticket fodder. In a super classy move Shawn, who at this point was operating at maximum dickhead, had the match decision reversed to win the belt in Bulldog's home country. That's pretty bad, but to be expected from Michaels at this stage in his career. Not to mention this thing didn't even air in the US. Also the European belt was a trophy title and had little value around the waist of anyone other than Bulldog. Alright, that's petulant and childish even by Shawn's '97 standards. Oh, did we mention that Davey Boy had already dedicated his win to his cancer-ridden sister who was sat at ringside? Yeah... As horrible as the circumstances surrounding the match are, the action itself might be the best ever between these two, who had clashed multiple times throughout the decade. Davey Boy gives a powerful performance here and looks every bit the main event caliber power wrestler he was at his peak. Everything he does looks crisp, controlling things with the usual slams and clotheslines, before heating things up with a surfboard and electric chair drop. Michaels, to his credit, makes everything Davey does look fantastic. But things go south as D-Generation X make their way to the ring. Things turn when Rick Rude breaks up an O Conner Roll: the crowd is already hot and things are about to get a whole lot worse. Following a double KO spot, Hunter and co make their way to the ring and from there on out it's all D Generation-X. Bulldog is finally hit with a pedigree outside the ring before being thrown back into the assisted figure four. The crowd is absolutely nuclear at this point. They wouldn't, would they? Bulldog makes the ropes! But Rude nails him and he's blacked out! That's it?! Yes, that is actually it. Shawn continues being an absolute gent by dedicating the match to Diana, as she and Davey's dying sister sit dumbstruck at ringside. The crowd looks like it might actually riot and D-X wisely get the hell out of there. Wow, just wow. An uncomfortable, but fascinating match with some great wrestling to boot.
Advertisement
2. Shawn Michaels vs Jeff Jarrett - In Your House 2: The Lumberjacks
To say 1995 was a bad year for the WWE would be an understatement. This was a year we sat through Mabel winning King Of The Ring, then go on to face Diesel in the main event of Summerslam for ten damn minutes. It was bad. The only thing keeping the company from being 1999 WCW levels of unwatchable was the efforts of the mid-carders. In particular Shawn and Bret, who spent the year seeing who could have the best match with the worst possible opponent. Well that's not exactly fair on Jarrett, who has always been a solid mid-carder in his own right. But it's also fair to say the guy doesn't have a massive amount of four star plus matches under his belt. But lookee here, Jarrett is nudging a five star performance, while wearing a mad country singer costume? True Michaels magic. This was during that weird period of wrestling where everybody who wasn't a headliner seemed to have a second job: dentist, taxman, country singer. I suppose there were some lean years on the payroll after Hogan left. Silly outfits aside, this is a textbook example of old-school southern wrestling, with some WWE style bumps thrown in for good measure. Most hair-raising of all is Shawn going clear over the top rope onto the floor following a huge backdrop by Jarrett. It's a showcase of structure not to everybody's tastes: while Jarrett slows the pace, Michaels picks things up with high-impact moves. It all follows logically and makes the audience pop big for the face's offence. The spots are meticulously thought out and the ending, where the meddling Roadie costs Jarrett the match by grabbing the foot of the wrong guy, is a simple but effective feel good moment. Proof that sometimes the old ways are the best, this sits alongside the ladder match as Shawn's best IC title match.
Advertisement
1. The Rockers vs Doug Somers and Buddy Rose - AWA Brawl In St Paul, 1986
While most wrestling fans have heard of The Rockers, it's surprising how many have yet to see a single match from one of sports entertainment's finest tag teams. But before they made their way into the WWE, Michaels and Jannetty were already tearing it up in the declining AWA with top heel team "pretty boy" Doug Summers and "playboy" Buddy Rose. Both of whom were as cool as their names suggested. I was torn between this and their killer title match a few months earlier, but decided against it due to the lack of a satisfying finish. Having said that, almost every match in this feud was world class and could easily have been placed here instead. I strongly urge you to seek out as many matches between these four as you can. The teams had been fighting over the titles for several months, with The Rockers failing to get the job done when the belt was on the line. In their last bout, things descended into anarchy, leaving them to settle things in a steel cage. We're talking a good ol' fashioned blood feud. The cage has lost a lot of credibility due to overexposure in the 25 plus years since this match aired, but seeing it sold with this much gravitas, those doubts melt away and it soon feels like the spectacle it once was. Also helping the suspension of disbelief is Michaels pulling out a MAN-SIZED bladejob, leaving him helplessly wondering around the ring, before taking the low-road (pun intended), biting and crotch punching his way to safety. It's those moments that turn a good match into a great one: the face choosing to cheap shot his way to his corner in order to survive this brutal environment. Other highlights include Rose finding himself unable to stall in the cage and Michaels getting revenge by busting him open on the "galvanized steel". Which is just an awesome way of putting it. Well done AWA commentators, you've just invented one of my favourite ever wrestling phrases. Jannetty finally hits the hot tag and finishes things off with a battering ram. While this wouldn't be the conclusion of their feud, it very well may be the peak.