Gimmicks have been a key factor in wrestling for decades and have had a major impact on attracting a global audience to the industry. Legacies have been born purely down to gimmicks being placed on talented wrestlers; The Undertaker and Kane have had twenty year careers thanks to characters that went over with the crowd. However, gimmicks don't always gather the same credit or longevity as those mentioned. Take the Gobbledy Gooker for instance, he was a man dressed up as a giant cartoon-like chicken that hatched out of a giant egg live on TV. Surprisingly, he didn't gain a great response from the crowd. Which is a shame really; The Undertaker Vs Gobbledy Gooker at WrestleMania could have been a huge draw for the WWE. There were also suggested gimmicks that almost ruined some of the greatest wrestlers the business has ever seen. The biggest instance being Stone Cold; when discussing a gimmick for the Texan, Austin suggesting he should have a cold blooded persona. The writing team came back with the name Chilly McFreeze to fit the gimmick. Could you imagine if that suggestion had materialised? We'd probably all be watching WCW right now. We all like to look back at the terrible gimmicks of the past and laugh, but it is a shame when they are wasted on truly talented wrestlers with great potential. This list is a collection of wrestlers that have been held back at some point in their career due to woeful gimmicks.
10. Dean Malenko
The WWE grabbed a steal when they picked up the misused gang of Malenko, Benoit, Guerrero and Saturn from WCW; each a great wrestlers in their own right. The gang arrived as a four man stable named The Radicalz and tore the roof off the arena on their debut, when they manhandled both members of The New Age Outlaws. Unfortunately whilst the success of Benoit and Guerrero is undeniable, Malenkos career in the WWE was less desirable. It is questionable whether giving the character a couple of prostitutes and then turning him into a ladies man was quite the right choice for a man who was previously known for his cold, wily demeanour; but hey, at least he didnt fall in love with a mop. Malenkos character would go on to develop a crush on Lita, naturally leading to the pair squaring off in a match; all men want to show the girl they fancy that they can beat her up. The bout came with stipulations and the ladies mans prize for winning the match was a date with the diva. Within the date she manipulated Malenko into admitting he was married before The Hardy Boys attacked him.
9. Max Moon
During his spell with the WWE, the man later dubbed as the Mexican Hulk Hogan was reduced to playing a character sent back in time from outer space. Max Moon would come down the ramp wearing a futuristic, fluorescent blue, cyborg outfit whilst shooting fireworks out of his arm. It was the 90s; he probably just looked like he was lost on the way to a rave. However, it becomes harder to feel sympathetic towards Carlos Moises, when made aware that he actually pitched the idea of this awful gimmick himself; the WWE quickly agreed that fireworks were a thing of the future and Max Moon was born. Moises soon bolted on the company and rookie Paul Diamond was left to pick up the pieces of this dreadful gimmick. Carols Moises talent was later to be established on WCW as Konnan, where he had a successful five year run. Unfortunately, the wrestlers performances started to decline and got sloppy once he cemented his position in the company. That said, whilst his consistency was questionable his ability was not.
8. Diamond Dallas Page
When DDP signed with the WWE he was renowned as one of the biggest babyface wresters WCW had to offer. Yes, he had also proven that he could play the heel; but did McMahon really have to make every wrestler he signed from his previous rivals an incompetent heel? He was so over in the WCW that he was known as the peoples champion; sound familiar? Whilst it doesnt require a rocket scientist to see the obvious potential for a DDP Vs The Rock feud, it does apparently take more than the minds of the WWE creative team. Instead, they chose to have Diamond Dallas Page stalk The Undertakers wife. Most WCW wrestlers brought into the WWE in the early 2000s were buried before being allowed any sort of impact, but DDP was misused and showed to be inferior more than most. Needless to say the wife stalker angle did very little for Pages WWE career and The Undertaker demolished him, he then got washed out to dry during the invasion angle.
7. Festus
Drew Hankinson has probably had the worst luck in wrestling history when it comes to being held back by a gimmick. Hankinson has had the misfortune of playing all the three of the following characters: Imposter Kane, Festus and Luke Gallows. Lets start with the first gimmick they shoved on Hankinson: Imposter Kane. In this role he would dress and act exactly as the original Kane previously did in his early years and attacked the Big Red Monster at random moments. Which developed into the pair squaring off at the 2006 Vengeance PPV; the match was like watching a computer game in which you and your mate have both chosen to battle as the same character. Strangely Imposter Kane picked up the win at the PPV, which gathered zero reaction from a confused crowd. The following night on Raw, Kane destroyed Imposter Kane, took his old mask back and threw the fake out the building; abruptly bringing an end to awful gimmick number one. Festus is arguably the worst of the three gimmicks that Hankinson was lumbered with. Here he was part of a hillbilly tag team with partner, Jesse. Festus appeared to be mentally challenged and Jesse would need to hold on to his arm as he walked him down the ring. The character would remain unresponsive with his mouth wide open and tongue sticking out, until the bell rang at which point he would morph into an aggressive powerhouse. Once the match was over he would turn back into the docile character that was previously ushered to the ring. Their final attempt at a character for Hankinson was Luke Gallows, a sidekick to a heel CM Punk. Unfortunately, all Gallows seemed to do was stand behind Punk and shake his head in agreement as Punk spat a promo. They had the occasional tag team match up, but once again the character didn't really go anywhere.
6. Isaac Yankem
Kane is one of the greatest characters the WWE has ever produced, and has gifted Glenn Jacobs a great career and several impressive accolades. That said, life wasn't always so rosy for the man behind the mask. Jacobs would have to grit his teeth and work his way through some awful gimmicks before eventually landing the role of The Big Red Monster. He debuted in the WWE as Jerry Lawlers dentist... Yep, not only can Jacobs boast about holding a variety of championships but he can also take the credit for Lawlers pearly whites. Though its hard to tell why The King paid for Dr. Isaac Yankems services, as he was both crazy and had the worst teeth ever seen on a dentist. After initially being thrown in the middle of a feud between Lawler and Bret Hart, Yankem soon turned into a jobber before disappearing from the show. What did they expect; he was a wrestling dental surgeon. Jacobs abruptly cut short a radio interview earlier this year when the DJ opened with the question is it Kane or are we talking to Isaac Yankem?. The dentist clearly remains a sore spot for the man we all know and love as Kane.
5. The Spirit Squad
When D-Generation X reunited in 2006 they needed a target, essentially people to prank and belittle to the joy of the crowd; who better than a stable of five goofy cheerleaders? The Spirit Squad were covered in slime, covered in crap and squeezed into a package addressed to Kentucky at the hands of HBK and HHH. In the ring the feud was also extremely one-sided and DX would win a few five-on-two handicap matches at PPV events, before they moved their attention elsewhere. Oddly, Squad members Kenny and Mickey were midway through a World Tag Team title reign when they were getting battered by DX. It was as if the company did not know whether to bury or push the gang, so attempted to do both at the same time. After the feud with DX, the group soon became jobbers and then finally split due to Kennys anger at the team continuously losing. The majority of the Spirit Squad disappeared and were sadly never repackaged into a sellable gimmick. Nicky on the other hand would become a World Heavyweight champion years down the line as new alias, Dolph Ziggler.
4. Perry Saturn
Whilst Dean Malenkos ladies man gimmick did not suit The Ice Mans cold, no-nonsense, tough guy character; he can at least be grateful that the writing team chose a different member of The Radicalz to become infatuated with a mop. Yep, the company decided the correct direction to push Perry Saturn was towards a cleaning product. The gimmick went as follows: Saturn received a concussion in a match that led to him losing a brain cell or two. He then started to make senseless, random statements such as "Did you know monkeys learn sign language to tell dolphins they love them?, before eventually going on to fall in love with a mop. The storyline started to get really intense, when Saturn was asked to choose between onscreen girlfriend, Terri Runnels and Moppy. He chose the mop and would have to go through the heartbreak of seeing his beloved mop being shredded by Raven. The scene produced more tears amongst viewers than the death of Bambis mum.
3. Paul Burchill
With the right gimmick and the correct feuds Paul Burchill could have been a major star in the WWE; he was an incredible technical wrestler, with an extensive set of moves. However his dreams were never going to be fulfilled dressed as a Pirates of the Caribbean rip-off. Whilst a wrestling pirate was pretty ridiculous in itself, it was the lazy back story of the character that ensured it would not be taken seriously. The WWE sold Burchills pirate as a descendant of Blackbeard, a man whose life ended in the 1500s. Yeah, ok. Perhaps, if we delve far enough into Mark Henrys family tree, well see that the worlds strongest man is actually a long lost relative of Hercules. Shockingly enough the gimmick soon faded away, and Paul was removed from our TV screens. He was repackaged and given a new character a few years later, but that gimmick also failed to go anywhere. What was the problem with his next gimmick? Oh, he only rejoined the brand as a man incestuously in love with his own sister. Poor Burchill never stood a chance.
2. Simon Dean
ECW was a company filled with talented wrestlers and Nova was up there with the best of them; he took high risks, could sell, was over with the crowd and had an extensive move set. At one point he hit a stunner, DDT and a leg drop on three different wrestlers in one movement; imagine that as a WrestleMania moment! Though the closest Nova got to performing at the grandest stage of them all was on a non-televised preshow battle royal at WrestleMania twenty two; not to mention he was the first eliminated within two seconds of the bout; ouch! However, he was of course appearing as Simon Dean rather than the infamous Super Nova. Simon Dean was a fitness expert, who would deliver tedious mock-infomercials promoting the Simon System which was selling dietary supplements and exercise programs. As a heel wrestler he would often insult the size of the hometown crowd to generate heat; he wasnt an enjoyable heel to watch though and instead just incredibly irritating, leading to him soon being demoted to jobbing and house shows.
1. Eugene
Believe it or not, there was a very proven wrestler behind the Eugene gimmick. Nick Dinsmore was very well respected amongst the underground circuit and was getting over on Ohio Valley Wrestling, both in a tag team and as a singles competitor. He was a great grappler with bags of potential, which was finally discovered by the WWE in 2004. Now to be fair to Dinsmore, as a hungry wrestler its probably hard to reject any gimmick put in front of you by the WWE. Im sure the two guys who had a tag team run on SmackDown as The Dicks werent exactly fist pumping at their new ring names. But being informed that you would be playing the role of Eric Bischoffs mentally challenged nephew must be more difficult to wrap your head around than most other gimmicks. Eugenes entire run in the WWE basically consisted of the babyface wrestlers looking out for him and the heel characters trying to take advantage of him. In one particular backstage segment, Vince and Shane McMahon offer a present to the bemused Eugene, before pouring green paint over his body and dunking his head down the toilet. Thankfully, the WWE created the be a STAR anti-bullying campaign many years later and all was forgiven. If you enjoyed the list and would like instant updates of future articles follow my Twitter page @Dragonstravel.