Perhaps the best WWE creation of the past two decades, the Hell in a Cell match debuted in 1997. Weighing over two tons and standing 16ft high (the new revised version is 20ft high and weighs 5 tons), the structure dwarfs nearly everything else around it. As the saying goes, men who enter it do not return the same. Careers are altered, lives changed, appearances disfigured. Even if it doesn't live up to this clichéd hyperbole anymore, there is a still a terror the unforgiving steel brings to superstars like nothing else can. The formation of the annual Hell In A Cell PPV has unfortunately diminished the entire purpose behind the gimmick, and the PG restrictions have proved detrimental to its barbarity. Nevertheless, the memories of the epic encounters from years gone by shall always remain embedded into our brains. This past Sunday's match between Ryback and CM Punk was the 26th inside the cell (although one of these bizarrely was a Raw dark match for the fans in attendance only). You won't be shocked to learn that neither of these will be featuring on the list. In fact, none of the matches from the Hell In A Cell PPV will be making an appearance, so you can already narrow down the possibilities to 17. But which of those made the top ten cut?
10. Kurt Angle vs. Triple H vs. The Rock vs. Steve Austin vs. The Undertaker vs. Rikishi - WWF Championship
When: Armageddon 2000 Where: Birmingham, Alabama Our countdown begins with the only match to feature six competitors. Seemingly the precursor to the Elimination Chamber, the match took six of the top superstars at the time and threw them all together into one hellacious main event. It is perhaps no surprise that the match was (kayfabe) orchestrated by the then Commissioner, Mick Foley. Deeming certain actions as going too far; the running down of Stone Cold and Triple H plunging from a fork lift truck to name but two, Foley sought to end it all at Armageddon in this unprecedented match. Fitting perhaps, that Carl Orff's O, Fortuna was used in the promotional video beforehand. Despite Vince McMahon's protests and Kurt Angle's whining of injustice, the bout was to go ahead. The best way to describe the match is simply mayhem. The initial brawling was between the pairs that feuded at the previous PPV and with essentially three singles matches happening simultaneously, it was near impossible to keep up with the action. Before too long, Vince McMahon arrived on a flatbed truck and threatened to tear the entire cell down. He would've succeeded too if it had not been for the emergence of Commissioner Foley and his security. But McMahon's damage had been done; the cell door had been torn off and an escape was possible. From here, the intensity increased with brawling all the way up the ramp and even on the scrap cars forming the staging area. The trails of blood, sweat and tears could be found in abundance all over the arena. And then they climbed. Of the six, only The Rock remained grounded. Triple H and Angle both found themselves in precarious positions, but it was Rikishi who ultimately perished by the hands of an Undertaker chokeslam. The 420-pounder crashed down into the truck with wood shavings scattering everywhere, much to the euphoria of the crowd. Not the most extreme stunt on this list, but this is a superheavyweight human being we are talking about. The ending itself came as a surprise and, after all that had preceded it, somewhat of an anti-climax with Angle seizing the opportunity to cover The Rock after a stunner. Against all the odds, Kurt Angle had survived.
9. The Undertaker vs. Randy Orton
When: Armageddon 2005 Where: Providence, Rhode Island Randy Orton has many accomplishments to his name: youngest world champion in WWE history, 9-time (as of writing) world champion, Royal Rumble winner. But back in 2005, his biggest boast was claiming the careers of legends. As the 'Legend Killer', Orton regained the momentum that went astray during his relatively short face run. The inaugural name on his list of legends: the Undertaker. Although narrowly coming up short at WrestleMania, Orton took revenge by winning in the rematch at SummerSlam before teaming with his father, 'Cowboy' Bob Orton, to bury Undertaker in a casket match - even going so far as lighting the coffin on fire. When the Undertaker made a typically classic return at Survivor Series, he had vengeance in mind and it would come at Armageddon - inside Hell in a Cell. In the weeks leading up, Taker's mind games terrorised Orton, but Randy managed to suppress all fears when he stepped in the squared circle. It was to be his most devastatingly vicious match since Backlash 2004 with Mick Foley. Undertaker dominated the early goings, using chairs and steel steps to mercilessly punish Orton's face. But, in a startling moment we're all too familiar with nowadays, Orton managed to hit an RKO out of nowhere and suddenly the momentum shifted. Orton hit a diving splash off the top rope onto Undertaker through a table was about as hardcore orientated as things got but skillful re-usage of past spots from previous matches in the series made the unfolding events a joy to watch. There was excellent counter sequences to behold that even included Orton mocking Taker with a Tombstone Piledriver of his own! The unrelenting action was back and forth and when it seemed Taker finally had victory in his sights, intervention from Bob Orton ensured the match would continue. A final Tombstone to both father & son would put the bedlam to bed. Definitely not as high risk or deadly as its predecessors (it played out more like a No Holds Barred encounter), a great story was told nonetheless. Randy Orton had given everything and proved he is able to go toe-to-toe with the finest WWE has to offer.
8. Batista vs. The Undertaker - World Heavyweight Championship
When: Survivor Series 2007 Where: Miami, Florida The road to this Survivor Series clash began back at the start of the year when the Undertaker won the Royal Rumble. It was the Deadman's first and only Rumble victory, despite competing in 9 of them. Batista went into their WrestleMania match with a genuine chance of breaking the streak, being unbeaten as World Heavyweight Champion since he won it two years earlier; only dropping it due to injury. The consequential Last Man Standing & steel cage matches proved to be stalemates until an ambush from Mark Henry & Edge put the Undertaker on the shelf. When Taker returned, Batista had once again risen to the summit and won his third world title. There was unfinished business between the pair and there was only one solitary way it could conclude. Of all his adversaries, Batista's best in-ring chemistry came with the Undertaker. Stealing the show once more, they traded impact moves: the spear to the big boot, the running powerslam followed by a spinebuster. Their bodies were being gradually worn down as this collision of behemoths escalated. When it looked like Taker was in complete control after a Last Ride and chokeslam, Batista desperately crawled back with another spinebuster. As blood trickled down his face, he could sense the impetus changing and hit his third spinebuster of the match. While the match wasn't a battle of wits, it thrived on painful spots and impossible near-falls. A Tombstone Piledriver couldn't finish things; neither could a Batista Bomb through a table. Finally, when it seemed impossible for Batista to kick out after a sickening Tombstone onto the steel steps - Edge interfered. In the guise of a cameraman, Edge (returning after his own 4 month lay-off) flattened Taker first with the camera, then with a vicious con-chair-to leave him helpless to the referee's 3-count. Edge had well and truly screwed the Undertaker, which leads us to the following..
7. The Undertaker vs. Edge
When: SummerSlam 2008 Where: Los Angeles, California By now you're probably realising The Undertaker is somewhat of a specialist when it comes to these matches. In all, he has participated in 12 of these monstrous matches in his illustrious career; considerably more than anybody else. After injuries to nearly every top star on Smackdown in 2007, things were starting to look up by the end of the year when Edge returned and cost the Undertaker his championship match with Batista. This gave Undertaker a second motive to be mad at Edge due to also losing the World Heavyweight title to him after a Money in the Bank cash-in. At Armageddon, in a triple threat between the aforementioned parties, Edge triumphed thanks to a little assistance from his new 'Edgeheads' (now known as Curt Hawkins and Zack Ryder). By beating Batista inside the Elimination Chamber to be no. 1 contender, he set-up a showdown with Edge for WrestleMania. As he is accustomed to, Undertaker reigned supreme in a fantastic affair, before meddling from Vickie Guerrero (Edge's liaison) caused Taker not only to lose his championship but his job as Edge came out on top in a TLC match. But when Vickie & Edge hit a rocky patch, there was only one method of revenge on Vickie's agenda; re-instating the Undertaker to face Edge inside Hell in a Cell. Both men gave it their all at SummerSlam. With Edge showing no nerves of his first Hell in a Cell, bringing in his more familiar arsenal of tables, ladders and chairs, he set about dismantling the Undertaker. Edge's character was at its superb best here; equal to anything he produced with Lita in 2006. He delivered two devastating spears, the first crashing through the cell wall and the second through the announce table. But as so often is the case, it wasn't enough to keep the Undertaker down - a Tombstone Piledriver finally cementing Edge's fate. As a final stamping point, Undertaker chokeslammed Edge off a ladder through the ring as flames engufled the torn canvas, effectively sending the Rated R Superstar straight to hell. Summer is often hot, but this SummerSlam match was a scorcher.
6. The Undertaker vs. Triple H
When: WrestleMania XXVIII Where: Miami, Florida The end of an era. That was what WWE billed it as two of the all time greats and the two masters of the Hell in a Cell came to blows at WrestleMania XXVIII. Between them, they have competed in no less than 70% of the total number of cell matches. In fact, until 2009, there had only been one match that featured neither man. After two previous WrestleMania bouts, the latter of which saw the Undertaker being carried out a battered and broken man, Triple H was ready to move on. Despite losing, in his mind he had destroyed and retired the Undertaker. But the Phenom wasn't done yet. One year later, the Undertaker returned and wanted his redemption. Initially refusing, Triple H (in his new corporate role) thought it bad for business to annihilate the last remaining relic the company had. If Triple H broke the streak, Undertaker would have nothing left, nothing to do but retire. Undertaker goaded his rival with unfavourable comparisons to his best friend Shawn Michaels, causing the Game to accept under the condition they go all the way - to Hell in a Cell. The stakes were increased even further when HBK himself was named special referee and by the time April 1st came around, expectations were high. Undertaker provided the first shock by showing his newly shaved head & mohawk. With a point to prove, he hastily started out the blocks, refusing to give Triple H the upper hand. When a chair was brought into play, the punishment was unrelenting. There were some stunning call backs to their earlier meetings as Triple H tried to combat a Hell's Gate submission by grabbing a sledgehammer again and yelled "stay down!" when Taker's perseverance and heart refused to die. The conflicted performance of Michaels was exceptional with the emotion driving this match into territory few dare to enter. He tried his best to prevent further anguish only to get shoved around by both participants. He insisted on calling for the bell after seeing the relentless hurting Taker was receiving but was put into Hell's Gate himself to keep the bout alive. One of the finest false finishers I've ever seen saw Taker kick out following a Sweet Chin Music & Pedigree combination - something no mortal has ever done. But from somewhere, Taker summoned all his strength in the final moments to hit a Tombstone and put an end to this epoch. Despite barely using the structure, it was still an incredible match. Standing at 20-0, Undertaker aided Michaels with picking up Triple H, as arm-in-arm they struggled up the ramp before one final look back at the audience they had captivated. A truly iconic image from three men who had been through not only physical, but emotional hell.
5. The Undertaker vs. Mankind
When: King Of The Ring 1998 Where: Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania Quite possibly the most famous match in wrestling history (though Hogan & Andre have a valid case), it's frankly perplexing to think this wasn't even the main event of the night. Unmatched in its spectacle, this was an unforgettable 15 minutes. After a heel turn as Cactus Jack and brief spell as Dude Love, Foley returned to his Mankind persona and re-ignited his feud with Taker. Matches between the two spelled back to 1996, competing in the first-ever Boiler Room Brawl and Buried Alive matches. They needed to go all out to top their previous classics and boy, did they ever. This wasn't about technical skills or pure wrestling; this was about carnage. Foley wasted no time, climbing the cell before the Undertaker had made his entrance and within seconds of the match starting, it had seemingly ended. In the most jaw-dropping moment wrestling has ever witnessed, Taker threw Foley off the cell roof, crashing into the announce table 16-feet below. A lesser man may have called it a day, apologised to the crowd and gone straight to receive medical attention. But the man dubbed the Hardcore Legend refused to give in, his broken body returning to ascend the cell once more. Depending on who you believe, the second fall wasn't planned. A chokeslam on the roof caused it to buckle and Foley fell again, this time into the ring and knocking him unconscious momentarily. Again the match continued, with Foley even managing to get in some offence of his own and bringing out his trademark thumbtacks/pins. By the end, Foley had suffered a ruptured spleen, a concussion, a broken tooth lodged into his nose and still insisted on walking out. This marmite match is heralded by some as the finest of all time, while others see it as no more than two big spots. What is undisputed, however, is just how memorable it is. For the 17,000 in attendance, they saw something that would live with them forever as Mick Foley literally put his life on the line.
4. Brock Lesnar vs. The Undertaker - WWE Championship
When: No Mercy 2002 Where: North Little Rock, Arkansas In his first year, Brock Lesnar tore through everybody the WWE could throw at him. Dominating like nobody else in history, he beat The Rock, Hulk Hogan, won the Royal Rumble, King of the Ring and even main evented WrestleMania. But in the middle of all this came a feud based on pure intensity like no other, a feud with the Undertaker. A double disqualification caused their Unforgiven match to end in a draw, so something more was needed - where there were no holds barred, no escape and disqualification was not an option - Hell in a Cell. Unlike every other match on this list, there was a distinct injury angle throughout. "The Next Big Thing" had 'broken' Taker's hand beforehand, meaning the American Bad Ass needed to wear a cast. Lesnar's dissection caused Undertaker to scream in pain, methodically directing attacks and submissions on the broken hand as every inch of the the closure was used for offence. Advantage Lesnar you would think, but unfortunately for him, the cast could also be used as a weapon as demonstrated by Taker's first offensive move in the contest and it took only 4 minutes for Lesnar to be busted open. Eventually Lesnar managed to strip the cast off and bare the flesh underneath. This cohesive story trumps what most other cell matches have attempted. It was a blood bath; not only were the two competitors bleeding buckets, but even Paul Heyman - and he wasn't even inside the confines of the cell! These two caged animals tore each other apart in a tremendous slugfest in its purest form. No kamikaze spots or escapes, just hard hitting and remorseless power. Not to mention the finish was excellent - Lesnar showing his amazing strength by reversing a Tombstone attempt into a F5. Brock Lesnar had reached the top of the mountain and was there to stay.
3. Batista vs. Triple H - World Heavyweight Championship
When: Vengeance 2005 Where: Las Vegas, Nevada In third place is the phenomenal contest between former Evolution cohorts as Triple H turned Batista into a bona fide star. Batista's breakaway from Evolution was wonderfully done, turning the man into a major face for years to come. While the first half of 2005 on Smackdown was Cena country, Batista dominated Raw with his feud with mentor Triple H. With matches at WrestleMania and Backlash, this final meeting at Vengeance saw 'The Game' bring 'The Animal' into uncharted territory. The traditional buddies-turned-rivals split was well received and while it's no secret that Batista isn't the best ring worker in the world, it wasn't evident in this excellent battle. Both men pushed the boundaries of physical endurance, withstanding torturous pain in their bid to win. The first weapon to come out was a chain, a rare appearance in this environment. Hunter whipped and choked Batista before 'Sin City' became sadistic city as a chair wrapped in barbed wire was driven into the bare back of Batista, tearing skin from body. (Why there happened to be barbed wire covered chair under the ring, I cannot imagine.) The chair would come into play again, as Batista smacked it into the Cerebral Assassin's face. It could make even the most twisted individual wince in anguish. Again and again they would use the chair to cries of disbelief from the crowd. Hunter's will would eventually give up after an incapacitating spinebuster onto the steel steps followed by a Batista Bomb. The war was over. They've had their critics for various reasons over the years, but on this night, Triple H & Batista earned the respect of the entire watching world.
2. Triple H vs. Cactus Jack - WWF Championship
When: No Way Out 2000 Where: Hartford, Connecticut Following their street fight at the Royal Rumble in Madison Square Garden, one of the finest and most brutal matches in history, there was a lot to live up to. So how do you go about trying to replicate greatness? Well, for Mick Foley, it was to follow the blueprint of his famous encounter with the Undertaker. Triple H & Foley first came to blows in 1997, as Triple H (then Hunter Hearst Helmsley) beat Mankind in the King of the Ring final. The feud would last several months, including the first-rate "three faces of Foley" promo where Cactus Jack debut in the company. By the time Triple H won the title at the start of 2000, the McMahon-Helmsley regime was working to humiliate and eliminate all competition, Mick Foley included - even being momentarily fired. But after a threatened walk off from the roster instigated by The Rock, Foley was re-hired and awarded a title match. Despite losing valiantly in the street fight, Foley would again get a title shot - this time in the unforgiving steel cell and on the condition Foley's career was on the line. It would be the first cell match where the title would be defended. Pulling out all the stops again, the wild brawl that followed would top even Foley's legendary match with Undertaker. Chairs and steel steps would be tossed around like toys, planted into skulls and faces would be painted crimson masks all over again. Foley had expressed his desire to fly off the top of the cell again and an ingenious spot saw the steps used to accidentally pry open a panel on the cell - Foley could finally work his way to the outside of the structure. The pair fought around the ringside area, until Foley found his holy grail: a 2x4 wrapped in barbed wire. Naturally, the Game ran a mile to his only safe haven: the top of the cell. Foley made the mistake of lowering his guard as he pursued, and Triple H took full advantage to send him straight back down through the Spanish announce table. As Triple H sought for respite up there, Foley countered with his 2x4..which he then set aflame and clocked Triple H's skull in front of the awestruck crowd. Just as he prepared to piledrive the Cerebral Assassin on the top of the cell, he was backdropped through the mesh and into the hard canvas below. His broken soul could not take much more and he ultimately succumbed to a Pedigree. Cactus Jack's (even if it proved not to be Foley's) farewell was passionate, poignant and most definitely painful.
1. Shawn Michaels vs. The Undertaker
When: Badd Blood: In Your House 1997 Where: St. Louis, Missouri You were expecting the Big Boss Man match, perhaps? The greatest Hell in a Cell match of all time is also the first Hell in a Cell match and what numerous people regard as the greatest match in wrestling history. Simply put: perfection has never been so ugly. At SummerSlam, Michaels played guest referee and inadvertently cost Undertaker the WWF Championship as he swung for long-time rival Bret Hart with a chair but caught the Deadman. Michaels claimed his innocence, but he would again strike Taker between the eyes with a chair in a tag match on Raw. In weeks to come, Michaels would continue to infuriate the Undertaker with hit-and-run tactics. This led to their first ever one-on-one contest at Ground Zero where Michaels would again play the coward to avoid confrontation at all costs before attacks on several officials ruled it a no contest. Nobody knew what to expect from the devil's playground. With the benefit of originality, they managed to tear the house down with both men on their absolute A-game with psychology, characterisation and storytelling off the charts. The Undertaker wanted nothing more than retribution against the cocky co-founder of DX, while Michaels used every trick in his playbook to survive; knowing he could not depend on assistance from his allies. Everything but the heart of the Heartbreak Kid was ostensibly broken, as he crashed through an announce table, hurled head first into the grating steel wall and received one of the most thunderous chair shots in history; echoing through time while on-lookers winced in agony. Blow after blow his body was shattered. There was innovation, drama and family affairs. Yes, this was the debut of the Undertaker's brother, Kane. As far as outstanding introductions to the wrestling world go, this is above and beyond anything else. Walking with purpose alongside father Paul Bearer, Kane literally ripped the door off the cell before confronting his visually worried Undertaker. Picking his half-brother up, Kane demonstrated his awesome power to the crowd before dropping the Phenom with his own patented Tombstone Piledriver. Wrestling would never be the same again. And if you don't believe me, look at the title match Shawn Michaels received for winning this duel.