In the build up to this poorly anticipated WrestleMania, WhatCulture has been picking holes on the worst of wrestling's oldest and biggest PPV with 5 Matches That Had No Place on a WrestleMania PPV and the 5 Worst Main Events in WrestleMania History. Now comes the pièce de résistance - the 10 flat-out worst matches to grace the grand stage. Many of the popular choices that people love to hate (incidentally a lot of them are Triple H main events) won't be appearing as, although monumental letdowns, they are not the absolute worst matches. At this stage I'd be tempted to say this year's event will see no additions, especially due to the Inter-Continental Title recently being bumped to the pre-show! This list does not feature any matches from the women (or 'divas' as they're known now) as frankly the majority of them could make up a list entirely on their own. Although Trish Stratus and Mickie James may have had a cracker in 2006, virtually every other female match has been dire - whether it is down to time constraints or simply horrific wrestling. And let's be honest, nobody is hoping to see a dissection of the Playboy BunnyMania Lumberjill match. Well, except maybe Snoop Dogg/Lion. So which 10 horrors made their way onto the list? There was plenty of options out there (thanks Vince!), but these ten get the nod.
10. Jake Roberts vs. Rick Martel - WrestleMania VII
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=fXkpHpAByE8 Every blindfold match that has ever been done has always been terrible. And this is no exception. Now I'm not against fun matches with ridiculous stipulations that the kids will get kicks from, but there's a time and a place for them - and WrestleMania is certainly not one of them. The only thing going for it is that the gimmick fit the feud. Martel 'accidentally' sprayed Roberts in the eye with his cologne, blinding him and giving a severe handicap. To even the odds, a blindfold match was arranged so neither man had the ability to see. Or at least that's the illusion given to the audience. The match was purely made up of stumbling around, grasping at thin air and pointing in all corners. There was virtually no action, yet the crowd was amazingly immersed into the contest - yelling directions to Roberts and tittering at the two's disarray. He even got an exuberant cheer just for finding the opponent. It's hard to believe the "WWE Universe" could ever be as vocal in this absurdity nowadays. A list of moves featured in the match: scoop slam, backbreaker and Boston crab, before a quick out-of-nothing DDT won the match. That's 4 moves in a whole 8 minutes. How they got the crowd to like this atrocity as much as they did I'll never know, but I guess that's full credit to the charisma of the men involved.
9. Uncle Elmer vs Adrian Adonis - WrestleMania 2
http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x3zo70_wrestlemania-ii-p8-1986_news#.UVibflJXrKc WrestleMania 2 took place across 3 venues and unfortunately for Los Angeles, they drew the short straw by hosting this match. But what can you expect from a match between a cross dresser and a hillbilly? Many of those on this list are obvious big name candidates and ones likely everybody hates and have no qualms trashing till the end of time. This largely forgotten encounter (either because people never saw it or suppressed the memories) was geared as a harmless filler used to kill time - a very common occurrence in the early years of Mania. This was the worst of the lot. The match can be summed up by the very first move as Elmer throw an embarrassing punch and fell down backwards himself. Yes, you read that right. Adonis may have been past his physical prime here, having gained a lot of weight, yet he still carried the match against the hugely overweight farmer in his late 40s. Adonis' tremendous work and selling probably prevents this being even higher on the countdown. Adonis was simply an excellent bump taker. Lasting a bare 3 minutes, this contained zero entertainment value and accomplished nothing. Scarily though, this is a contender for best Uncle Elmer match and highlight of his career. That just about says it all.
8. Goldberg vs. Brock Lesnar - WrestleMania XX
Surely the most disappointing WrestleMania match in history, but is it the worst? No. Likely to be higher in many people's books, this 'contest' goes down as a smear in both men's careers due to their complete nonchalance and phoning it in on their last WWE match. Neither man wanted to be there. Goldberg's contract was coming to an end and Lesnar, the man who WWE had singled out the past two years as the poster boy to carry the company forward, was leaving for the NFL. The Madison Square Garden crowd got wind of this through internet speculation and boy, did they let Lesnar know about their new animosity towards him. To WWE's credit, the build for this inter-promotional match had been well done; dating back to a backstage tease at Survivor Series. Billed as one of the top matches on this historic card, nearly everyone was intrigued by a battle between the two dominant powerhouses - perhaps the pound-for-pound two strongest men the company have ever had in their acquisition. It had all the makings of an unmissable, potential classic affair. That is until the bell rang. Instead of exploding out the blocks, proving themselves to be the alpha male, both men..did nothing. It took 3 whole minutes of staring (the inspiration for Twilight perhaps?) before they finally locked up. The latter half to the encounter wasn't so bad, if a little formulaic in the trading of big impact moves but by this point the crowd had seen enough and there was no rescuing this one. The match has probably become most famous for its intense crowd reaction; opening chants of "you sold out" and boos for both men quickly turned to "this match sucks" and "boorring". Special referee Stone Cold Steve Austin could do little to spark the affair, but got the last laugh to the crowd's delight with Stunners to both men. Oh hell yeah.
7. The Undertaker vs. Giant Gonzales - WrestleMania IX
With over 20 years of WrestleMania experience under his belt, it was always likely the Undertaker would have a few duds along the way. Everybody knows Vince's apparent 'obsession' with big men and for many years of the streak, Undertaker was paired with these behemoths in a battle of the giants. This was no more evident than when he squared off with Giant Gonzales. The elephantine Argentinean was extremely limited in his ring ability, making even the Great Khali look as agile as a cat. While he came through his basketball career and then transition to wrestling with WCW well enough, by the time he came to the WWF he was majorly struggling with mobility and health. Standing a genuine 7 feet 7 inches tall, he towered over even the Undertaker, and wearing an awful body suit with painted on muscles and hair, he resembled something of a freak show. This special attraction match may have been appealing in theory, with Undertaker as the underdog for maybe the first time in his career, but it wasn't long before things became an eyesore. The crowd remained into it, but with Gonzales having one of the smallest movesets ever (only punches, chokes and rest holds) and controlling the majority of the match, it became an unbearably dull affair. Just when the Deadman was gaining the upper hand, Gonzales illegally used chloroform to knock Taker out. An 8-foot giant used chloroform to down his opponent. A heel he may be, but that still boggles the mind. Undertaker would win the match by disqualification, marking it as the sole blemish on his streak with this unnecessary unclean victory. To top it off, the two would actually go on to have a passable match at Summerslam, making this all the more excruciating.
6. Big Show vs. Akebono - WrestleMania 21
Before giving Big Show his 'big' WrestleMania moment last year (because apparently everyone needs one), Cody Rhodes reeled off the list of his embarrassing moments on the showcase of the immortals. One of these was a loss against Floyd Mayweather - a professsional boxer who was much shorter and lighter but resorted to using brass knuckles to get the victory. It was a highly enjoyable affair in one of the best examples of a celebrity match working to everyone's benefits. At the other end of the spectrum, however, was a 2005 sumo match against Akebono. I'm generally somebody who is largely against celebrity involvements in wrestling outside of being a valet or in someone's corner. A match featuring one can be written off as a dud before the bell even rings. The aforementioned exception with the Mayweather match drew much interest as one of the most famous and best pound-for-pound boxers on the planet went up against a giant. Akebono, on the other hand, didn't have that same mainstream appeal, seeing as how nearly every American was clueless to who he was. Even in Japan, where I assume the focus for attention here was, he was probably an unknown entity. The biggest problem for this match though, lied in the match type itself. Without meaning to disrespect the sport or Japanese culture, the Western world doesn't really 'get' sumo wrestling. Even as a WWE fan, seeing fat men wearing nothing but a mawashi does nothing to please the eyes. Akebono had already retired from sumo by this point and was actually wrestling in New Japan. So just why wasn't this a wrestling encounter for the fans that paid to see wrestling? The match lasted just over a mere minute. After much pushing and belly slapping, Akebono flung Show out of the dojo. Nothing pleasant, nothing special and the visuals of Big Show's pimply posterior is not a memory you want to cherish. Ever.
5. Sheamus vs. Daniel Bryan - WrestleMania XXVIII
There have been many short WrestleMania matches, particularly in the early years when squashes were prevalent in showcasing talent. Perhaps none has been more damaging and hated, however, than last year's World Heavyweight Championship match. In one corner you have Daniel Bryan, arguably the best technical wrestler in the world (never mind the company), who in over 3 years with the WWE so far has only this WrestleMania showing. In the other corner you have Sheamus, a 2-time WWE Champion, great brawler and personal favourite of WWE's Executive VP Triple H. And they were given..18 seconds. In a card that managed to find time for two mini-concerts and Brodus Clay dancing with his 'mother', these two were treated to a slap in the face in front of the watching world. To make matters worse, the previous year the two were bumped off the card entirely to make more time available for the loathsome Cole vs Lawler match (more on that later) and giving them a World title high-profile feud was going some way to correcting that. Give them over 10 minutes and you're guaranteed quality. But no - 18 seconds. You could argue that this has helped Bryan rather than hindered him in the long run, but rest assure this was never the intention.
4. Hulk Hogan vs. Yokozuna - WrestleMania IX
Time to revisit WrestleMania IX for one of the most shameless displays of politics in the history of the industry. After taking a long absence in 1992, Hogan returned for WrestleMania season to aid friend Brutus Beefcake in his feud with Money Inc. Yokozuna meanwhile, won the 1993 Royal Rumble to become the first winner to get a shot at the WWF Championship - then held by Bret Hart. Their paths never crossed in the build yet somehow, inexpicably, Hogan would wind up leaving WrestleMania as champion in the worst conclusion the event has ever had. Even though Beefcake & Hogan were disqualified in their tag team titles match, it ended with a happy ending and celebration as Money Inc. got their comeuppance. His re-emergence later on was unnecessary. For the evening's main event, Yokozuna cheated Bret out of the title to become the first heel to the leave Mania as champion. Or so we thought. Hogan came out to protest this injustice, and Yokozuna's manager Mr. Fuji challenged Hogan to a match on the spot (something heels just never do). Bret gave him the go ahead and the match was on! ..For a whole 22 seconds as Hogan embarrassed Yokozuna, Mr. Fuji and the entire paying public. It would be easier to stomach if Hogan dropped the belt to Bret at SummerSlam as intended, but due to Hart's size he refused to - losing instead uncleanly to Yokozuna, the very man he randomly beat for the title in half a minute. With so much backstage pull that it hurt the product, it's little wonder that was Hogan's last WWE PPV for 9 years. This match insulted Bret Hart, it hurt Yokozuna and it has forever tainted people's views on Hulk Hogan.
3. The Undertaker vs. Big Boss Man - WrestleMania XV
Undertaker's second appearance on this list is undoubtedly his worst WrestleMania match and many would argue the worst match of his entire career. This heel vs. heel battle - a rarity, especially for WrestleMania - featured the head of one heel faction going toe-to-toe with chief lackey (or 'head of security' as he was known) of another. It began at the start of the year, as Vince McMahon's Corporation wanted to prevent rebellion from the likes of Steve Austin, DX and eventually - the Ministry of Darkness. At the 'darkest' and most sinister stage of his career, Undertaker wanted to rid the company of the boss, so McMahon set up a Hell in a Cell match for his enforcer and the Phenom at WrestleMania. The storyline barely warranted using the revered structure. There was absolutely no chance of this matching the heights achieved in the first two Hell in a Cell matches - which begs the question why even bother? At this stage in his career, Boss Man was already well past his prime and on the decline, while Undertaker wasn't in good shape and would eventually need surgery by the end of the year. Gaining interest and some extra buys was all this could hope to achieve even if it meant hurting the reputation and aura the gimmick match had. The dull and lifeless battle lasted less than 10 minutes as the two staggered around the cell to the boredom of an indifferent crowd. Even WWE hate it so much that it's the only Hell In A Cell bout that didn't make it on the dedicated DVD. Even the Raw battles made it on the disc! The only thing from the match that people would remember was the imagery of Boss Man being hung post-match, something that has become a little awkward to watch following his death. Despite being at the peak of its popularity in the Attitude era, WWE served up a truly horrible WrestleMania in 1999 with little redeeming qualities - highlighted no more so than with this hell.
2. Bret Hart vs. Vince McMahon - WrestleMania XXVI
In 1997, the infamous Montreal screwjob took place when Vince McMahon screwed Bret Hart out of retaining the WWF Championship the day before he left for WCW. Fast-forward 13 years and Bret's return to the company, and you've got all the makings of a red hot feud between the two. And for the most part, it worked. The problem came in the match itself. People were expecting a brief 2 or 3 minute beatdown by Bret, finishing with a Sharpshooter. 13 years of torment put to rest in a feel good moment for everybody. And that's what we should have got. But somebody decided this bout between a 65-year old non-wrestler and a 53-year old stroke victim should last a whole 12 minutes, scandalously causing a fantastic bout between Rey Mysterio & CM Punk to last just a miserable 6 minutes. To make matters worse, we were treated to a completely pointless swerve where Vince paid and brought out the entire Hart dynasty to witness Bret's humiliation before realising they were siding with family. Seemingly everybody got in a shot at a helpless Vince before Bret reamed down with a slow, boring, never ending barrage of chair shots - even using the chair to take a respite in the middle. It resembled torture more than a wrestling match and after the unnecessary teasing of the Sharpshooter time and time again, Bret finally brought things to a close. Not with a bang but with a tiny whimper. The saving grace for this match is surely the WWE would learn their lesson and never book something this horrible and between two broken old men again. So did they learn? No, no they didn't.
1. Michael Cole vs. Jerry Lawler - WrestleMania XXVII
Just one year later, the WWE managed to out-do themselves and top just how abysmal Bret vs. Vince was. Given the longest build for WrestleMania XXVII (spanning back to the November) and featuring heavily in what seemed like every single broadcast, this match between two commentators was disgustingly the biggest grudge match and feud for the event. Although occassionally humourous with his outbursts on NXT, Michael Cole's heel persona in late 2010 and 2011 overshadowed everything else in the company, agonising to the point where I hit the mute button. Instead of calling the action, Cole and Lawler resorted to childish endless bickering that took all focus away from the real superstars. Starting with Cole's love for The Miz and costing Lawler the WWE Championship in a TLC match (something in itself beyond belief), things escalated to include deplorable insults about Lawler's late mother. When the inevitable was eventually made official, Stone Cold Steve Austin ruled himself as special referee. How ironic that this list of worsts contains two matches being officiated by the greatest. When the match itself came around, it was the stuff of nightmares. Worse than imagined. Somehow managing to last even longer than Bret/Vince, this match length took priority over two wrestlers in their prime in Bryan and Sheamus who got bumped to the dark match. Despite some early offence by "the King", a lot of the match was controlled by Cole. Let that sink in; a broadcast journalist with zero wrestling experience is controlling a match at WrestleMania. No wonder the crowd was up in arms. Just like Bret, Lawler flirted with the possibility of ending it 'early' before belatedly making Cole tap out to an Ankle Lock. But it didn't even stop there. The ridiculous 'anonymous GM' reversed the decision due to Austin interference, making the entire match utterly meaningless. Then we had a few Stunners, Spinaroonies and beer bashing in this unremitting pain. Every single second was torture. Michael Cole vs. Jerry Lawler is, without doubt, the worst match WrestleMania has ever seen. (Special mentions go to: Kane vs Great Khali, John Cena vs JBL, Bret Hart vs Bob Backlund, Lawrence Taylor vs Bam Bam, Mr T vs Roddy Piper and Boogeyman vs Booker T & Sharmell.)